A Scottish Tracker would be lumpy and bumpy

Friday, Nov 09 2012 by
A Scottish Tracker would be lumpy and bumpy

The prospect of Scottish independence raises a number of issues, one of which would be the merits of a passive fund to track Scottish companies. There are many uncertainties to be resolved affecting Scottish companies such as currency, banking supervision and regulatory regime. Nonetheless, working on the premise that existing listed Scottish companies (as defined by the Scotsman’s Scottish Share Index) retain their domicile in Scotland post-independence, what would the index look like? And does it represent an attractive investment proposition and a means of gaining exposure to traditional strengths such as whisky, financial services and the energy sector?

From the outset the index, calculated using market capitalisation and valued at £64bn, would suffer from overexposure to a limited number of companies because the universe of 33 stocks is quite small. Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) would presently represent 40% of the index weighted by market value. This is despite the fact the share price has fallen 95% or so from its peak. Adding Standard Life (9% of the index), Aberdeen Asset Management (5%) and Alliance Trust (3%) and F&C (1%) would further increase the dominance of the financial sector to almost half the index. The next biggest would be SSE, the gas and electricity utility, at 18%, followed by the engineering companies Aggreko and Weir, at 7% and 5% respectively. Replicating such an index through an OEIC would be impossible given the constraints on the maximum holdings size to limit concentration.

Given the dominance of a handful of companies in the Scottish index, a passive fund tracking the index would have given a very volatile ride. FTIM carried out some simple back-testing on the index over a 10 year period, rebalancing the index by market value at the beginning of every year. From the start of 2002 to the start of 2012 the index would have fallen 30%, dragged down by the performance of HBoS and RBS which made up over two-thirds of the index for the first 6 years. This year it would have staged a bit of a recovery as RBS has risen sharply, jumping 24% by the beginning of November.

Using market capitalisation to track markets has a number of problems so a fundamental process may be better with a relatively small collection of stocks. Indeed, this seems to be case. Using dividends gave a better capital return of 7% over the same 10 years. One of the main reasons for this is that the dividend-weighted index would have held no RBS from the start of 2009 once it was clear no dividends were to be paid. The dividend version of the index would have held no Cairn throughout this period and would have finished the period with an ever-increasing weight in SSE, a stock that has maintained steady dividend growth throughout the period. SSE would now be close to half the index. In addition this version would offer a much higher historic yield at around 4.9% against 2.1% for the market value based index. That in turn would make it less volatile.

Would this index in any way reflect the relative contributions of various sectors of the economy to Scotland’s GDP? Cairn (at 3%) is the only oil and gas representative in the index, yet this is a major employer in Scotland, though according to the Scottish Government 2007 figures for domestic output, Oil & Gas Extraction only represented 1.7% of total supply, whilst Banking was just 4.2%. Meanwhile the biggest contributors (ignoring Public Administration at 5%) were Construction (7.9%) and Health & Veterinary Services (4.5%), neither of which have any representation in the Scottish index.

This exercise illustrates the difficulty of finding a means to track any particular country. The FTSE 100 index has long since lost any serious connection with the underlying UK economy. A rough rule of thumb seems to be that profits for over 70% of the index are earned overseas. Oil and Gas represents 18% of the index and Mining 10.5% yet these companies operate mainly overseas with many recent recruits coming from the old Soviet bloc.

Digging down into the detail of individual companies shows how difficult it is to allocate economic activity to any particular country. Weir Group as a global engineering company reports its revenues on the basis of the location to which its product is shipped. In 2011 this led to the UK accounting for only 4% of group revenues. This fails to reveal how much of the revenue derived from UK operations, or more precisely, how much of the “value-added” was created in the UK, let alone in Scotland.

So it seems a Scottish index would not be a fair representation of the Scottish economy and represents an extreme case of the inability of a tracker to mirror the underlying economy of any single country. Volatility would be high although a dividend weighted index would have reduced this. A UK tracker might be better seen as a short-cut to a truly global tracker. Indeed the correlation between the UK market and a world index has recently been as high as 95%. A Scottish index would certainly not show anything like the same correlation.

Filed Under: Scotland, Indices, ETFs,

About the Author's Fund Management

Rob Davies Profile Image Promotional
VT Maven Smart Dividend UK Fund

The VT Maven Smart Dividend UK Fund, formerly The Munro Dividend Fund seeks to buy the UK market in proportion to the forecast dividend of its constituents and in this way provide the returns of the asset class at lower volatility. ...read more or visit website »


Past performance is not a guide to future returns. The value of investments and the income from them may go down as well as up and is not guaranteed. An investor may not get back the amount originally invested. For risks relating to specific products, please refer to the relevant documentation for that product.

Do you like this Post?
3 thumbs up
0 thumbs down
Share this post with friends

The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc (RBSG) is a holding company. The Company operates through its banking and financial services subsidiaries, including The Royal Bank of Scotland plc (RBS) and National Westminster Bank Plc (NatWest). The Company’s operations are conducted through various divisions, including UK Retail, UK Corporate, Wealth, International Banking, Ulster Bank, and US Retail & Commercial, Markets and Non-Core Division. UK Retail offers a range of banking products and related financial services to the personal market. UK Corporate is a provider of banking, finance and risk management services. The Wealth division provides private banking and investment services. International Banking serves the companies with a client proposition. Ulster Bank is a retail and commercial bank. The US Retail & Commercial division provides financial services. Markets is an origination, sales and trading business. The Non-Core Division manages various assets of the Company. more »

Share Price (Full)
-7.2  -2.1%
P/E (fwd)
Yield (fwd)
Mkt Cap (£m)

The Weir Group PLC is a United Kingdom-based company engaged in engineering businesses. The Company’s products and services are used in many industries, including water and wastewater, chemicals and fertilizers, agriculture, food and beverage, pharmaceutical, pulp and paper and steel and marine engineering. The Company operates in three business segments: minerals, oil and gas, and power and industrial markets. Minerals operate in the global minerals processing sector. The equipment and services are applied across the mill circuit, the process by which rock ores are broken down into end commodities such as copper, gold and iron ore. Oil and Gas operates in the conventional and unconventional upstream oil and gas markets. Power and Industrial operates in the conventional, nuclear and renewables power generation, industrial and mid and downstream oil and gas markets. more »

Share Price (Full)
-63.0  -3.5%
P/E (fwd)
Yield (fwd)
Mkt Cap (£m)

Standard Life plc is a United Kingdom-based long term savings and investments company. The Company operates in Asia Pacific, Europe, Middle East, North America and United Kingdom. In India, HDFC Life Limited (HDFC SL), a joint venture with Housing Development Finance Corporation Limited sells a range of savings, pensions, protection and group term assurance products. In China, the Company sells a range of savings, investment and protection products in Tianjin through intermediaries such as banc assurance partners and financial consultants. It offers a range of investment and pension products to individual and corporate customers. The Company sells investment-linked savings products through financial advisers and brokers throughout the Middle East. It offers a range of savings, insurance, mutual funds and portfolio management products and services in Canada. It sells a range of savings and investment products to customers, employers and through intermediaries like financial advisers. more »

Share Price (Full)
1.0  0.2%
P/E (fwd)
Yield (fwd)
Mkt Cap (£m)

  Is Royal Bank of Scotland fundamentally strong or weak? Find out More »

1 Comment on this Article show/hide all

What's your view on this article? to Comment Now

You are feeling neutral

Use the £ sign in front of a ticker to turn £VOD into Vodafone PLC

You can track all @StockoChat comments via Twitter

About Rob Davies

Rob Davies


Rob Davies is the Fund Manager of VT Maven Smart Dividend UK Fund, formerly The Munro Fund.. He worked as a professional geologist in Antarctica and Australia before joining the City as a mining analyst.  From 1999 to 2001 he was a writer at The Motley Fool and in 2002 he joined the Private Client Department of Clydesdale Bank as Senior Investment Analyst where he was responsible for writing and maintaining investment policy, selecting securities and portfolio creation. His experience of the stock market as an equity research analyst, personal finance writer and portfolio construction manager has given him a unique background to draw on in crafting this investment process which he now runs at VT Maven Smart Dividend UK Fund, previously known as The Munro Fund. more »

Stock Picking Tutorial Centre

Stock Picking Simplified

Stockopedia takes your stock picking to the next level with cutting edge Stock Reports & Screening tools.

Get started
or Take a Tour to find out more.