Can you become a great investor, by choice?

Friday, Nov 16 2012 by

Like any activity where the results are affected by talent, some people are born to be great investors; but most are not.  Most private investors fail to match the returns of professional investors, and most professional investors fail to match the returns of a simple index tracking strategy.

However, great investors do exist and, although you cannot change your innate talent, there are many things you can do if greatness is what you aspire to.

Greatness is largely a matter of conscious choice, and discipline  

I’m a big fan of Jim Collins, the author of several outstanding business books including Great by Choice: How to Manage Through Chaos, and Good to Great: Why Some Companies Make the Leap and Others Don’t.  What I like most of all is the way he breaks down complex questions into a small number of critical behaviours, and then structures and frames them in a memorable way.

His books have been massively successful, far beyond their original business sphere because many of the ideas are applicable to life in general as well as business, and I think many of them apply to the world of investing too.

Here are some of the key ideas from Great by Choice which are paralleled by the actions of many great investors, and which can be learned and applied by those who aspire to be great investors themselves.

Clear Eyed and Stoic

“great [investors] accept, without complaint, that they face forces beyond their control, that they cannot accurately predict events, and that nothing is certain; yet they utterly reject the idea that luck, chaos, or any other external factor will determine whether they succeed or fail.”

The first lesson from Great by Choice is that the world is a harsh and uncertain place, and yet to be successful you must believe that you are responsible for your success or failure.

This is an especially difficult idea to apply in the world of investing, where in the short-term luck is as big a factor as skill.  Although luck may dominate the results of any individual investment (for example my investment in UTV Media returned over 40% in just 7 months which was as much luck as anything else), in the longer-term your ability to make the right decisions will be the most important factor.

Because of that, your long-term results are down to you, regardless of how uncertain the market may be.

Fanatic Discipline

“[Great investors] display extreme consistency of action—consistency with values, goals, performance standards, and methods. They are utterly relentless, monomaniacal, unbending in their focus on their quests.”

There are two lessons here.  The first is that great investors are usually extremely consistent in the way they apply their investment process.  Those two benchmarks of mainstream value investing, Warren Buffett and Neil Woodford, have both been doing more or less the same thing for decades – buying good businesses at good prices.  Over many years they have both applied themselves with relentless consistency, which takes great discipline.

The second lesson is that this consistency isn’t just applied to the methods and systems used to manage their funds.  The same consistency is applied to their goals, or as Collins puts it, their quests.

Consistent, disciplined action will massively increase the chances that any goal will be reached, but if the goal keeps changing, it will undermine your chances of achieving anything.

In the world of investing there is usually one goal which matters more than any other, and that is the goal of beating the market over the long-term.  Look at Warren Buffett’s annual letter to shareholders and the first thing you will see is the company’s long-term results compared to the S&P500 (including reinvested dividends).

The table of results goes back to 1965 and shows the results for each year, the total compound rate of return to date (19.8% for Berkshire and 9.2% for the S&P500 as at 2011), and the total return in that time (513,055% for Berkshire, 6,397% for the S&P500).

To say that Buffett has a relentless, monomaniacal focus on his quest of beating the market is perhaps an understatement.

The 20-mile march

However, at the same time Buffett has avoided over extending himself and his company during good times, an approach that Collins calls the 20-mile march.

The 20-mile march is an approach to consistently achieving goals which focuses as much on not over-achieving as it does on never under-achieving.  Without this discipline, companies, investors and people often over-extend themselves in the pursuit of ever greater gains.

In the world of investing this mostly relates to using debt to increase returns.  As we’ve just found out with the housing bubble and the banking crisis, investment returns can be massively increased by borrowing money to invest.

But the downside is that if things turn against you while you’re over-extended – you’re dead, and once you’re dead you can never come back.

Empirical Creativity

“When faced with uncertainty, [great investors] do not look primarily to other people, conventional wisdom, authority figures, or peers for direction; they look primarily to empirical evidence. They rely upon direct observation, practical experimentation, and direct engagement with tangible evidence.”

Next to Lemmings, investors are perhaps the worst group you’d want to follow.  They have a terrible habit of finding the biggest cliff and jumping straight off it.  There is only one reliable antidote to the madness of this particular crowd, and it is to be found in the disciplined application of hard evidence and research which has been conducted over the best part of a century.

In effect, when you manage a portfolio of stocks you are conducting one long research study into how good you are as an investor.

Collins uses the term “Fire bullets, then cannonballs” to describe an approach to taking small learning steps before committing fully.  In other words, take many small, low-risk steps to find out what works, and only then go in with conviction.

In the same way, investors can learn as they go by firing “investment bullets” – small bets on investment ideas which allow them to learn about investing while having real money at stake; an important psychological factor that cannot be replicated with virtual trading accounts.

And the learning never ends.  In my opinion one of the benefits of holding 20 or 30 companies instead of 5 or 10 is that the number of opportunities to learn is so much greater, and the risks of each lesson are so much smaller.

I still follow this approach today.  With a target of 30 holdings in the UKVI model portfolio it’s highly unlikely that any one stock will reach even 10% of the total amount.  This means that I have more “experiments” running at the same time, giving more opportunity to learn more lessons with less risk than if the portfolio were more concentrated.

Productive Paranoia

“[Great investors] maintain hyper-vigilance, staying highly attuned to threats and changes in their environment. Even when – especially when – all is going well. They assume conditions will turn against them, at perhaps the worst possible moment. They channel their fear and worry into action – preparing, developing contingency plans, building buffers, and maintaining large margins of safety.”

The future is uncertain, but what we can be certain about is that at some point things are going to get very ugly.  That’s easy to say in 2012 as we’re five years into the biggest slump since the 1930’s.  In 2006 such concerns would likely have fallen on deaf ears because Gordon Brown had, apparently, broken the cycle of boom and bust.

The world is a cyclical place; it’s just a fact, and because it’s a fact we should hope for the best and prepare for the worst.

The first step in risk reduction in the stock market is to diversify enough so that a total collapse of any one holding won’t be enough to scare you out of the market.  I prefer to be diversified enough so that a 100% loss in any one holding will probably be replaced in a single year by the dividend income from all the other holdings.

When an economic crisis occurs, it’s often geographic in nature, affecting one country or region of the world more than others.  The obvious response is to use diversification to reduce the risk; to have a portfolio which generates cash from around the world.

Sometimes a crisis can occur in one industry, such as the music industry.  Again, the obvious response is to diversify into many different industries, as unrelated as mining and music.

Sometimes everything takes a beating.  In some market environments like March 2009, every stock drops by a huge amount, regardless of its industry or where it operates in the world.  This risk can be offset by using cash as a buffer, and holding enough cash so that you can ride out a colossal market crash, avoiding the worst of all possible mistakes: selling at the bottom.

The death line

Having a highly concentrated, high risk portfolio  is akin to investing near what Collins calls “the death line”; the point at which one small mistake, or piece of bad luck, can send you spiralling into the grave.

For investors the grave is replaced by the act of selling at the bottom which, although not quite as bad as death, is still a traumatic event for many, and it’s something that few can come back from.

Never come anywhere near the death line.  In a few years the economy may look fine and you think that your portfolio is safe, but things could turn bad again very quickly, and most people will only realise they’re carrying too much risk when it’s too late and they cannot stop themselves from pressing the sell button.

My personal approach to productive paranoia is to mix aggressive diversification with quality holdings; only owning companies that are highly successful market leaders, with outstanding track records of success, combined with strong balance sheets, all bought at low valuations.

Think risk first, returns second.

By accepting that the future will be very unpleasant at some point, you can take proactive measures to ensure that you are in it for the long haul, and in a position to reap the rewards of being greedy when others are fearful.

Consistent, disciplined, researched, cautious action towards a consistent long-term goal

These principles can help to form the foundation for any investor who wants to beat the market and go on to become a great investor.

Without this foundation, beating the market is simply a game of luck in which the odds of success are tiny.  With them, the task becomes achievable and within the investor’s control.

About the Author's Newsletter

UK Value Investor Profile Image Promotional
UK Value Investor

UK Value Investor is a monthly investment newsletter for defensive and income-focused value investors. Each issue includes a FTSE 100 valuation and projection, a unique defensive value stock screen and a detailed review of a 30-stock model portfolio, including any buy or sell decisions that have been made that month. … more or visit website »


This article is for information and discussion purposes only and nothing in it should be construed as a recommendation to invest or otherwise. The value of an investment may fall and an investor may lose all their money. Any investments referred to in this article may not be suitable for all investors.  Investors should always seek advice from a qualified investment adviser.

Do you like this Post?
6 thumbs up
0 thumbs down
Share this post with friends

UTV Media plc is the United Kingdom-based media company engaged in broadcasting and digital media assets across radio and television divisions. The Company operates in three divisions Radio GB, Radio Ireland, UTV Television. The Company's Radio GB division operates talkSPORT, a sports radio station; Sport magazine, a sports magazine; 13 independent local radio (ILR) stations, including Juice FM, The Pulse 1 and 2, Signal 1 and 2, Swansea Sound and The Wave, and others, in England and Wales, as well as a number of digital radio multiplexes throughout Great Britain. Its Radio Ireland division is a local radio operator in Ireland with around seven stations broadcasting from Belfast, Cork, Limerick, Dublin and Drogheda and an advertising sales house based in Dublin. The Company's Television division operates the Channel 3 public service broadcast license for Northern Ireland. Its Television division also includes Simply Zesty and Tibus, digital media businesses. more »

Share Price (Full)
Mkt Cap (£m)
P/E (fwd)
Yield (fwd)

  Is UTV Media fundamentally strong or weak? Find out More »

1 Comment on this Article show/hide all

Diggerriggers 18th Nov '12 1 of 1

This is the best written article on this subject I have read to date.

| Link | Share

What's your view on this article? Log In to Comment Now

You can track all @StockoChat comments via Twitter

About UK Value Investor

UK Value Investor

My name is John Kingham and I'm the editor of UK Value Investor, an investment newsletter for defensive and income-focused value investors. That means I write about buying large, successful companies with long track records of profitable dividend growth, and buying their shares at low valuations and with high yields. My website includes a unique stock screen and a model portfolio which is managed using a checklist-based investment strategy.  The goal of the strategy is to produce a portfolio which combines a high yield and good capital growth with low risk, and which is easy to maintain in just a few hours each month. more »


Stock Picking Tutorial Centre

Let’s get you setup so you get the most out of our service
Done, Let's add some stocks
Brilliant - You've created a folio! Now let's add some stocks to it.

  • Apple (AAPL)

  • Shell (RDSA)

  • Twitter (TWTR)

  • Volkswagon AG (VOK)

  • McDonalds (MCD)

  • Vodafone (VOD)

  • Barratt Homes (BDEV)

  • Microsoft (MSFT)

  • Tesco (TSCO)
Save and show me my analysis