Pittards (PTD): Turnaround questions

Thursday, Feb 07 2013 by
2

Pittards (LON:PTD) is a 'premium leather and leather products' brand, based partially in the UK and partially in Ethiopia. They seem to make a pretty broad range of products, with 'technically advanced'  leathers being a common phrase in their annual report. That said, first thoughts are that it sounds like a commodity business; as the board quite reasonably puts it:

"The leather industry is a global business: wherever countries have meat and dairy industries then hides and skins are produced as by-products."

And while I'm not an expert on the industry, or any industry for that matter, I would imagine the economics of having relatively dispersed raw materials would lend itself to having a relatively dispersed market structure. Pittards is by no means a particularly big company, which might lend weight to this theory. The attraction isn't as immediately evident as it sometimes is, then; we don't have an obviously defensible market position, a leading company in a niche or similar.

The eternal temper

The attractive factor is the usual - the price. It's trading at a decent discount to the assets in the business, and it's profitable, too. Those two factors aren't always particularly easy to find together. At this point it's probably wise to note the bid/ask spread, though, since in this case it is particularly relevant to any discussion of the 'price' - iii quote the bid at 1.75p and the ask at 2.25p. This is an enormous difference. I usually use the midprice in my calculations, out of habit more than anything, but it should be noted that spreads this wide can be a significant dampener on returns.

Anyway, as always, I've stated the hypothesis - that Pittards is cheap because it is trading at less than the value of its assets as a profitable business, something which loosely shouldn't really happen if flows of capital are free and transactional costs are minimal (though we've already disputed that). More importantly to us and much more solidly, low PTBV values and low P/E figures, though imperfect, are also correlated with higher future returns. There. Easy! 

The wrecking ball

It's never that easy, of course, and the first question we have to ask is immediately obvious from the graph in the top right - what happened? Pittards was shoveling money out of the window in what were, frankly, the good times - and since '05, they seem to be going from strength to strength. The answers in the annual reports were rather unsatisfying - the '05 chairman's statement, for instance, basically blames bad macroeconomic conditions. This might well be the case, but it leaves us rather uneasy as investors. Macroeonomic swings happen. That the company makes such enormous losses when they happen is worrying. I suppose we can reasonably identify '06 as the turning point - the point where they rationalised their UK operations, focused more on their Ethiopian partnership, and stepped into Asia with a sub-contractor. It's also the point revenue started to tumble, since they moved out of one processing step of the vertical supply chain. Revenue falling for a reason like that, since margins are increasing with it, is hardly a worry. It's a sign of more focus.

Here we have our first question; we can identify lots of differences between now and 2005. Is the company fundamentally different, or are circumstances simply better? The implications of that question on the value of the business can't really be overstated. Consider the graph:

 Special Offer: Invest like Buffett, Slater and Greenblatt. Click here for details »

Returns on capital are what we care about. We want a company which makes returns consistently above its cost of capital. This makes growth valuable to the business, and therefore us as investors. It's also easy to understand from the perspective of the price to tangible book value we were talking about before - if a company is perennially earning below its cost of capital, it may well deserve to trade at a discount to the value of those assets. In essence, those assets just aren't worth as much in the hands of the business they're with.

My gut feeling is that a corner has been turned with Pittards. There has been some sweeping changes, with that fledgling Ethiopian paternship I was talking about earlier having grown into full on ownership, giving Pittards a lower cost production area which may genuinely have some value above the book value - by the sounds of it, it took time, energy and cash to get things up to scratch.

There is one thing I remain a little unsure about, though; exchange rate implications and currency movements. 72% of the group's revenue is in US dollars, and while the group does publish a figure for the impact of currency movements, it's not a figure that's particularly useful to me - it basically just shows the impact of the reduced value of receivables and dollars held in cash. More fundamentally, I'm interested to know what operational impact it has. Just how global is the leather industry? Is it local enough so that even small currency swings mean a switch from local to international sources? I'm not sure how I'd go about finding this out. Frankly, the best solution would be to take a cycle average of returns and profits for Pittards - something which is rather hindered by the fact that I don't think it's really had much of a cycle in its current state. It is fundamentally changed.

The lowdown

I'm running out of space and it's an interesting company - so do your research - but my conclusion is that it's one for the shortlist. I naturally have less faith in returns figures over a shorter time period, like the 4 years here, and the bid/ask spread is prohibitive because it raises effective cost. It's very volatile, though, so if it dips I might be tempted - it's probably risky, but there's something about it I like. I sense there might be value in the way they've restructured to do business.


About the Author's Blog

ExpectingValue Profile Image Promotional
expectingvalue.com

Expecting Value is a value investing blog which publishes regularly on different topics. Generally, the coverage will focus on specific shares and feature a discussion and analysis of its potential, but also includes some 'bigger picture' concepts. ...read more or visit website »


Disclaimer:  

As per our Terms of Use, Stockopedia is a financial news & data site, discussion forum and content aggregator. Our site should be used for educational & informational purposes only. We do not provide investment advice, recommendations or views as to whether an investment or strategy is suited to the investment needs of a specific individual. You should make your own decisions and seek independent professional advice before doing so. The author may own shares in any companies discussed, all opinions are his/her own & are general/impersonal. Remember: Shares can go down as well as up. Past performance is not a guide to future performance & investors may not get back the amount invested.


Do you like this Post?
Yes
No
2 thumbs up
0 thumbs down
Share this post with friends



Pittards plc is a United Kingdom-based company engaged in the leather production. The Company is engaged in the design, production and procurement of leather for sale to manufacturers and distributors of shoes, gloves, luxury leathergoods and sports equipment, the provision of consultancy services within the global leather industry and the retail of leather, leathergoods and leather garments. The principal activities of its subsidiaries are the production of leather, leathergoods, leather garments and gloves. The Company operating segments include Skins, Hides, Ethiopia and other. Its geographical segments include United Kingdom, Europe, and North America. more »

Share Price (AIM)
172.5p
Change
0.0  0.0%
P/E (fwd)
7.4
Yield (fwd)
n/a
Mkt Cap (£m)
15.5



  Is Pittards fundamentally strong or weak? Find out More »


What's your view on this article? to Comment Now

 
 
You are feeling neutral

Use the £ sign in front of a ticker to turn £VOD into Vodafone PLC

You can track all @StockoChat comments via Twitter


About ExpectingValue

ExpectingValue

Follow

I'm a private investor looking to broaden my horizons and constantly develop as a stock picker. I run expectingvalue.com to help me better track and understand my own performance, and open my decisions up to discussion. I focus mainly on small - mid caps; I'd say my usual target band is from £10m - £800m, but there are obviously exceptions to this. more »



Stock Picking Tutorial Centre



Stock Picking Simplified

Stockopedia takes your stock picking to the next level with cutting edge Stock Reports & Screening tools.


Get started
or Take a Tour to find out more.