Small Cap Report - SMWH, WYN, ZATT, SFR, FOUR, FIF, TTR, FDL

Wednesday, Jan 23 2013 by


Good morning. Interesting trading statement from W H Smith (SMWH). Despite reporting LFL sales down 5% for the 20 weeks to 20 Jan 2013 (which would normally be pretty disastrous for profits), they report a "good profit performance" (although not quantified in absolute, or relative terms).

This has been achieved by tightly controlling costs, and a planned strong increase in gross margin. This is pretty impressive, I've not heard of such a big (5%) drop in LFL sales being recouped through margin improvements & cost control before.

I still can't shake off the feeling that W H Smith is an accident waiting to happen - it's as old economy as you can get - books, greetings cards, travel, etc. Yet somehow it still manages to not only survive, but to apparently prosper. Perplexing.

Wynnstay (LON:WYN)

Wynnstay (WYN) is an agricultural products group, but reading their results (Finals to 31 Oct 2012), they also have a retail division, including 21 pet stores, so a potential roll-out story there perhaps?

They report record results, with revenue up 9% to £376m, and profit up 13% to £7.8m. Note the wafer-thin profit margin there. EPS is up 16% to 35p. That is ahead of forecast of 32.8p EPS, so looks good, but a share price of 468p means the PER is 13.4, not exactly a bargain.

The divi yield of 1.8% is unexciting too (total of 8.5p for the year). It has debt  of £13.8m (compared with a £79m mkt cap), so all in all this looks fully priced to me, so not of any interest.

£10m mkt cap computer games company Zattikka (ZATT) has disappointed in its short history as a Listed company, with the shares halving after a profits warning in Nov 2012. Their trading statement today indicates that things are not getting any worse, with trading in line with the expectations set out in Nov. I generally avoid this sector, after several bad experiences in the past. These companies constantly have to run to stand still, with frequent profits warnings if new releases (which have an extremely short shelf life, but up-front costs) flop, as inevitably they will from time to time.

However, the holy grail of gaming these days is to come up with something addictive online, where silly people pay money for imaginary objects through platforms such as Facebook, and waste vast amounts of time playing games.

Last week a new friend told me that Severfield-Rowen (SFR) looked like a good short, and I'll know to listen to him more carefully in future, as SFR has served up a nasty-sounding profits warning this morning. It's a structural steel maker, for buildings, etc. Cost over-runs on a project at 122 Leadenhall have triggered today's warning, and worryingly they don't seem to be on top of the figures either - with a review needed of its contract base. Clearly poor management, and the CEO has been kicked out.

Its funding position is also wobbly, discussions with Banks taking place over Covenants. This is the nightmare scenario, and is the reason now why I rarely touch any company with significant debt, relative to cashflows. "Gear today, gone tomorrow", as a wise man once told me (wish I'd listened more carefully!)

SFR shares are likely to be pole-axed today - halved maybe? I'm deploying my bargepole, and am not tempted to catch any falling knife where there's a risk of insolvency - been caught out too many times before.

4imprint (FOUR) puts out a "broadly in line" trading statement, so in other words slightly below. I do wish companies would stop using this trick, and just say "slightly below". It's a bit like charging £9.99 or £10 for an item. £10 is far more honest, and customers respect honesty. Although it's one of those situations where the first company to break ranks on this will probably regret it, as the market will probably over-react. But does it really matter what the short term share price is anyway? These things correct over time.

I like FOUR, it seems a steady growth company, but the price is now up with events in my opinion. Nice divi yield of over 4%, and a solid balance sheet with net cash, so it's my type of company, just not quite cheap enough for me to be a buyer now.

Finsbury Food (FIF) puts out a solid trading statement, although despite gradual reduction, there is still far too much debt for it to be of interest to me. I rarely (if ever) invest in food companies, as nearly all the profit is screwed out of them by the power of the big supermarkets.

32Red (TTR) is an online casino which has caught my eye in the past due to its very effective marketing strategy, and strong growth. Their trading update today shows continued growth with revenues up 28% for 2012. Profits are in line, so that puts them on a PER of just over 11, and a divi yield of 3.2%. Not bad for a growth company, although I don't like this sector, both for financial and ethical reasons.

Findel (FDL) issues an upbeat sounding trading statement. I don't like this one - accident-prone, and still has way too much debt. Low margins, and dreary, old-fashioned businesses. The valuation seems to already price in a trading recovery, so it doesn't interest me at all. There's no dividend either, so it ticks pretty much every box on my bargepole list.

Have a good day.

Regards, Paul.

(Paul does NOT hold shares in any companies mentioned today)

Filed Under: Smallcaps,

Get Paul Scott's Small Cap Value Report in your email inbox weekdays at 11am!


As per our Terms of Use, Stockopedia is a financial news & data site, discussion forum and content aggregator. Our site should be used for educational & informational purposes only. We do not provide investment advice, recommendations or views as to whether an investment or strategy is suited to the investment needs of a specific individual. You should make your own decisions and seek independent professional advice before doing so. Remember: Shares can go down as well as up. Past performance is not a guide to future performance & investors may not get back the amount invested.

Do you like this Post?
3 thumbs up
0 thumbs down
Share this post with friends

    WH Smith PLC is a United Kingdom-based retail company. The Company has two businesses divisions: Travel and High Street. The Company's Travel division sells a range of newspapers, magazines, books and impulse products for people on the move and a broader convenience range in hospitals and workplaces. The Company's High Street sells a wide range of stationery, books, newspapers, magazines and impulse products, as well as a small range of entertainment products.The Company’s subsidiaries include WH Smith PLC, WH Smith Retail Holdings Limited, WH Smith High Street Holdings Limited, WH Smith Travel Holdings Limited, WH Smith High Street Limited, WH Smith Travel Limited and WH Smith Hospitals Holdings Limited. more »

    Share Price (Full)
    8.0  0.7%
    P/E (fwd)
    Yield (fwd)
    Mkt Cap (£m)

    Wynnstay Group Plc manufactures and supplies agricultural products to farmers and the wider rural community in Wales, the Welsh border counties, the Midlands, Lancashire and Yorkshire. The Company operates in two divisions: Agricultural, which includes manufacturing and supply of animal feeds, fertilizer, seeds and associated agricultural products, and Specialist Retail, which include supplying of a range of specialist products to farmers, smallholders and pet owners. Agriculture division includes Feed Division, which operates two feed mills and one blending plant, offers a range of animal nutrition products to the agricultural market, and Arable Division, which supplies a range of products to arable and grassland farmers throughout the trading area. Its Specialist Retail division includes Wynnstay Stores, Just for Pets and Youngs Animal Feeds. In October 2013, it acquired all of the business and assets of Carmarthen and Pumsaint Farmers Limited except for its freehold properties. more »

    Share Price (AIM)
    0.5  0.1%
    P/E (fwd)
    Yield (fwd)
    Mkt Cap (£m)

    Zattikka plc is a games entertainment group. The Company is focused on developing Internet games development and publishing business. Its Internet properties are used in entertainment gameplay, such as social game play, mobile gameplay, browser-based gameplay, and with all forms of gameplay becoming a component of advertising budgets. It has its product pipelines across Social Network Games (SNG); browser games, mobile games; development of its SNAP analytics technology; acquiring licenses, such as Mr Bean and Monty Python. Building brands into game franchises; and creating product, including Hattrick, Fantasy Kingdoms, Vampire Legacy, Syfy Monster Island and Popmundo. more »

    Share Price ()
    0.0  0.0%
    P/E (fwd)
    Yield (fwd)
    Mkt Cap (£m)

      Is WH Smith fundamentally strong or weak? Find out More »

    1 Comment on this Article show/hide all

    behcet 23rd Jan '13 1 of 1

    WHSmith is not as old school as you might assume. They're working towards distributing Kobo ebook readers and ebooks, and have internet presence. Kobo is second only to Kindle globally.

    As far as I'm concerned you still need good old shops in trains stations and airports etc, as you can buy a bottle of water from the internet when are about to board on a plane. And you know and accept that you're being overcharged in these conditions.

    | Link | Share

    What's your view on this article? to Comment Now

    You are feeling neutral

    Use the £ sign in front of a ticker to turn £VOD into Vodafone PLC

    You can track all @StockoChat comments via Twitter

About Paul Scott

Paul Scott


Paul trained as a chartered accountant with Price Waterhouse. He then spent 8 years as FD for a clothing retail chain. "Retired" in 2002 to become an independent investor & analyst. more »

Stock Picking Tutorial Centre

Related Content

Stock Picking Simplified

Stockopedia takes your stock picking to the next level with cutting edge Stock Reports & Screening tools.

Get started
or Take a Tour to find out more.