28
Archived articleThis is an archived article from 2014 - please note that any content within the article may be out of date.

Small Cap Value Report (26 Jun 2014) - DTG, PTCM, CRAW, CHRT

Good morning! Final reminder for my Brighton ShareSoc investor evening tonight from 6pm. We could do with a few more people to attend, so if you would like to come along then please get in touch.


Dart (LON:DTG)

Shocker of the day is the profit warning from this airline & package holiday firm, operating the Jet2 brand. Their shares have plunged 26% to 187p this morning, which comes on top of previous falls from a 300p peak in April 2014.

Results for the year ended 31 Mar 2014 published this morning look good - turnover is a substantial £1.12bn, operating profit of £49.2m is up 30% against prior year, and EPS rose 14% to 24.7p. At the current share price of 187p that puts the company on a PER of just 7.6 times. That looks a bargain to me.

One fly in the ointment is the outlook statement, which is negative (although frustratingly it doesn't quantify how negative, which creates uncertainty);

In relation to the current financial year, we are finding demand for leisure travel, this summer, to the markets we serve, less buoyant than we would have hoped for and market pricing weak.  This may be due to the weather, the World Cup, or because the financial recovery hasn't yet taken hold in our home territory, the North of the UK.

Unfortunately, therefore, in view of the current visibility we have of our remaining summer 2014 forward bookings, we now expect the current year operating profit outturn to be lower than previous market expectations.

That doesn't sound too bad to me. They don't say substantially below, just below. So given that broker consensus for the year ended 31 Mar 2015 seems to be around 24p at the moment, then we might perhaps be looking at around 20p EPS for this year instead. I'd be surprised if it was any lower than that.

The reasons given for the profit shortfall sound like lack of demand, and competitive pressures, which are things that should be sorted as economic recovery develops over time. Therefore in my view this could be a good buying opportunity to get into a fundamentally sound business, which is having a blip in trading, at an attractive price.

53abee6303472Screenshot_062614_105608_AM

The other potential problem is a landmark legal ruling, from a customer called Ronald Huzar, who has sued Jet2.com for compensation after his flight was delayed 27 hours. As this was due to a technical fault, the airline refused compensation claiming it was not foreseeable. However, the Court of Appeal has ruled against Jet2.com, so this now potentially opens the floodgates for huge numbers of copycat claims. I can just imagine it now - all the usual ghastly ambulance chasing "legal services" firms will be advertising on TV - "Have YOU suffered inconvenience from a delayed flight? You may be entitled to compensation. Call 0858 triple three double two, double two, to find out how much YOU could claim....". Although the amounts involved are probably too small to make it worthwhile for the ambulance chasers to get involved.

Jet2.com are appealing to the Supreme Court, and possibly to the EU Court of Justice. Perhaps they will find a way in which paying compensation infringes their human rights?! That seems to be the standard get-out clause.

So in summary, at the current price of 187p Dart looks great value, assuming that soft current trading is just a blip, and that the legal case doesn't escalate. Here is an article about the legal case. So it's a question of weighing up these various factors, and making your decision. It's vital to DYOR, as always.


Porta Communications (LON:PTCM)

Shares in this rapidly growing PR group have taken a bath lately, dropping from a peak of 16.75p in Jan 2014 to just 9.75p today. I think that's partly due to a general sell-off in more speculative small caps, and also partly caused by the mixed messages coming from the company itself.

I'm a bit annoyed with management here actually, as I feel they over-promoted the shares in 2013, and exaggerated their trading performance. I accept that a PR company is almost obliged to demonstrate its skills in results and trading statements, by putting a favourable gloss on things (as virtually all companies do too). However, in this case I think they stretched things beyond what was reasonable.

In their trading update of 23 Jan 2014 the company claimed that it had operated at an annualised run rate of £4m EBITDA in Q4 of 2013. I rang the company, and asked if this was a one-off good quarter, and was told by a Director that no, that was how the company was trading, and the outlook was strong.

It became apparent from their 2013 results, published on 28 May 2014 that the EBITDA figure was being heavily flattered by defining "start up losses" as being two years trading from start up! I think that is ridiculous. A reasonable person might consider pre-opening costs as start-up losses, but once a business is trading, and making sales, then its profit or loss should be included within the main performance measure.

So I feel that investors have been misled by the company's very aggressive performance reporting in the past. Perhaps other shareholders have complained about this, because the reporting adopted today is completely different. They now talk about "EBITDA after all costs", as follows;

After five months of the current year, the performance of the Group remains on track, making substantial progress towards our goal of delivering positive EBITDA after all costs for the full year. Our growth trajectory continues with gross profit (fee income) growing by approximately 2.4 times to over £8 million and EBITDA, after all costs, increasing by approximately £1.6 million to approximately £0.8 million, when compared to the first five months of the prior year.

I think it's a good thing that a much more conservative basis is being used for reporting performance than before. Although the above quote seems to have rather mixed messages. The first bit I've bolded seems to be suggesting that they are loss-making, but with an improving trend. But the second bit I've bolded seems to be saying that they made an EBITDA profit of £0.8m in the first five months of this year. So rather confusing.

Notwithstanding these issues, my original reason for investing remains intact - i.e. that with a 2-3 year view, the highly experienced management here are rapidly building a PR group that could be worth multiples of the current valuation. Although they have certainly blotted their copy book by exaggerating performance to date. It shouldn't need me to tell them that good PR creates a favourable impression, without deviating from the truth. Financial PR in particular should be all about managing investor expectations, not hyping up those expectations to an exaggerated level, which is what Porta did last year, in my opinion.

Having said all that, the market has corrected the price down to 10.38p at the time of writing, which with 228.7m shares in issue, equates to a market cap of £23.7m. That looks an attractive price in my view, if you look forward a year or two when this is likely to be a bigger, and more profitable business. The beauty of people businesses like PR, is that they can grow organically very fast, just by hiring more people and winning more clients. There have been a lot of new companies IPO in the last year, so their pool of prospective clients that need financial PR to get onto investors' radar is growing all the time.

Management here have done it all before, so they have the experience and the contacts to do it all again. Therefore I'm happy to remain a holder for the next couple of years, and we'll see how it pans out.


Crawshaw (LON:CRAW)

I completely missed the upside potential of this share, where bulls have been proven spectacularly correct.

That a micro cap butchers chain from the North of England could be a 14-bagger in a year sounds ridiculous, but that's exactly what has happened, with shares rocketing from 4p to 59p.

The reason has been a step-change in performance, which bulls picked up on, and it has just got a lot more interesting today with the announcement of a national roll-out plan, to open stores across the UK.

How about this for a chart!

53ac0a61b11e4Screenshot_062614_125543_PM


Cohort (LON:CHRT)

Results today for the year ended 30 Apr 2014 look solid. Adjusted EPS came in at 19.2p, up 7% against last year, and that seems to be well ahead of broker consensus of 16.1p. The order book is slightly down at £82m, and it has a lovely Balance Sheet, with £16.3m in net cash. I would say that at least £10 m of the cash is surplus, and should be distributed to shareholders. On a market cap of around £82m (at 198p per share) that cash is a significant buffer, at about 20% of the valuation.

I don't understand why they keep renewing a £7.5m overdraft facility that isn't used, surely that is just a waste of money on the arrangement fees? Although reading the narrative today, it sounds as if they are seeking acquisitions, which could be a sensible use of the cash, if they buy the right things at the right price.

The outlook statement sounds vague, but OK;

All three Cohort businesses are on a sound operational footing and the management emphasis is now on maintaining and improving performance, whilst driving growth both organically and by acquisition, supported by a strong funding position.  Despite uncertainties in the wider Defence market, the Board considers that Cohort's order book and near term prospects provide a good base for future progress following the disposal of our Space activities.

So it looks a good value share, on a PER of about 10-12, with a great Balance Sheet, and it pays a dividend yield of about 2.5%.

My main reservation with this company is the large, lumpy orders, and being so dependent on Government decisions in the defence sector. So there will always be a heightened risk of a profit warning, that's just the nature of the business. Therefore I feel that a PER of around 10 is the right price.


Right I shall leave it there, and have a snooze before hosting this evenings Brighton ShareSoc investor evening. Should be a great laugh, as I've chosen a brasserie that serves lovely food, and has ice cold Peroni on draft. Therefore tomorrow morning's report might be slightly later than usual!

Regards, Paul.

(of the companies mentioned today, Paul has long positions in DTG, PTCM, and has no short positions)

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

22 comments


Avatar for Paul Scott

I try to respond to all comments, but must admit to being completely flummoxed by this one. Probably just a passing Globo or Quindell shareholder that hasn't been given their medication today!

2
Avatar for Fangorn

@Tony Drew,

1) Who's Crawford?
Do you mean lane Crawford? The company PP is musing about is CrawSHAW! Clearly you're having trouble reading.

2) First company PP is positive about?
Seriously? Two questions. Firstly do you read his blog every morning, secondly are you in fact SOBER when you do so?

3) Why bother scribbling such an unhelpful and factually incorrect post, and worse still not even getting the name of the company correct

F2

1
Avatar for Tony Drew

Crawford is the first company that has been given a favourable writeup since I started reading Paul Scott and that is six months ago! Whatever next.
Tony Drew

-10
Avatar for ericb

You dont read much then do you Tony Drew

6
Avatar for buyhard

My main concern here is the very low profit margin, around 4.4%. However, not unique to this airline but it does leave profits very vunerable to small downturns in turnover.

0
Avatar for valueman

Paul
I agree with your analysis on Dart -particularly not seeing earnings fall below 20p . It seems to have escaped most people's attention that forward holiday bookings as at the end of the year are 35% up on last year (as stated in the KPIs in the results). If that continues we should see another £5-6m in profit for the holiday business so I am not too worried.

0
Avatar for CliveBorg

Re: Crawshaw: Surely bulls should always steer clear of butchers? Nobbut seriously, do you think it could go still further with the national roll-out?

1
Avatar for MrContrarian

Report of Benchmark Holdings at ShareSco seminar
http://boards.fool.co.uk/sharesoc-seminar-a-flavour-13048993.aspx

1
Avatar for Gostevie

This Londoner was up in Huddersfield on business recently and being a shareholder I made a point of having a look in the Crawshaw (LON:CRAW) shop in the main shopping street.

Have to say I was well impressed. Encouragingly busy, spotlessly clean, and I can't think of any equivalent here in the south east. The best way I can describe it for fellow southerners is as a sort of a cross between a standard butcher, a decent sandwich bar doing hot and cold food to take away, and the bit in the supermarket that sells frozen ready-meals in plastic trays.

If - and it's always an if - the roll-out goes to plan I can see no reason why it shouldn't be a household name in years
to come, although I did top-slice my holding this morning to take some profit from the recent stellar rise.

Steve

4
Avatar for mustard

I hold Dart. There are two other things that worry me. First it has a distribution arm which seems to me to be totally different to an air line. Secondly there is the currency 'protection' that they took out that seems to have wiped out there cash takings. That looks to me like lazy management. I have not decided whether to sell or hold on as it now looks very cheap.

0
Avatar for MichaelFBS

Dart (LON:DTG) I should have listened to Buffet who once said:

'I have an 800 number I call when I get the urge to buy an airline stock. And I call them up at midnight and say my name is Warren and I'm an airholic and they talk me down. No more airlines!'

http://www.dailyspeculations.com/bear/buffett011905.htm


4
Avatar for cig

Thing is, it's now total market consensus that airlines are a bad punt and they tend to be on pretty low ratings, perhaps more than pricing in the sector's challenges?

(Never liked Dart myself, but I have positions in Lufthansa and Easyjet, and have been tempted by FlyBe.)

0
Avatar for it_trader

Didn't Buffet also reply at a conference when asked how you can become a millionaire - "Start as a billionaire and then buy an airline."

2
Avatar for MichaelFBS

Yes probably. The other one I like is "how do you make a small fortune from a vinyard? Start with with a large one (fortune that is)"!

0
Avatar for bsharman

Hi. I would be very interested to hear from anyone who attended the Sharesoc investor evening last night and can report back about the Benchmark Holdings (LON:BMK) presentation and Q&A. I'm intrigued because Neil Woodford has just bought 8.5m shares for his new fund.

0
Avatar for Edward Croft

I know that Mark Slater has a sizeable slug of Benchmark Holdings too. He picked them up at the original IPO.

0
Avatar for PhilipHanson

There are a number of sites that show aircraft fleet details, try http://www.planespotters.net/Airline/Jet2

The delivered date will show the date the aircraft was delivered to Jet2, most of their aircraft have flown for other airlines before so you need to click into each one to get an idea of when it was first delivered, e.g.:

http://www.planespotters.net/Production_List/Boeing/737/23525,G-CELH-Jet2.php

The old ones are the 31x 737-300's and the 11x 757-200's

1
Avatar for grumpy5

rageh
do you have any more data on their fleet?
If it were that crappy why would they win short haul airline of the year so regulalrly?

1
Avatar for cig

How relevant is the age of planes to the passenger experience? If the interior is refurbished every so often [dunno if this is the case here] most people probably couldn't tell the difference between a new and an older plane, but it will show up in fuel and maintenance costs for the operator, and future capital/lease expenditure if the old planes are paid up and amortised.

0
Avatar for PhilipHanson

The thing that worries me about Dart Group is the age of their aircraft fleet. Basically, they are flying round a load of old bangers - very old aircraft, many delivered in the late 1980's which are at the end of their useful economic lives. So I have regarded the company as running a very cash generative operation, but this ignores the impending capex and/or significantly increased lease commitments which will be required to replace their ageing fleet in the next few years.

4
Avatar for Edward Croft

Dart has been a top ranked and screened stock for a couple of years on the Stockopedia website and I'm sure a lot of subscribers may still hold it as a result - so this may be painful news for many.

David Stevenson first pointed the share out in January last year in his Adventurous Investor column in the FT when he mentioned it qualified for the Screen of Screens. At the time the stock was still around the £1 mark - it's had a huge run since then and I recently highlighted the share's performance in my recent webinar about the StockRanks.

The fall today reiterates the importance of diversification in any investment approach. A 25% fall is of course a lot in a single stock, but in a portfolio of 20 holdings it would only be a 1.25% drawdown. It also shows that the StockRanks should not be used in isolation when picking individual stocks - they are designed for use across diversified portfolios.

Dart Group has been ranked 99/100 for a long time on the Stockopedia system, I would anticipate that with brokers cutting numbers and the share price losing momentum that this will fall back somewhat now. On a QVM basis the stock will be ranked worse, though I anticipate on a QV basis the stock will be ranked more highly as it's got much cheaper as Paul has mentioned.

We've seen a lot more churn in the market in the last 6 months, in all rankings of stocks. Sweet Group and Space and People are two other well known 90+ ranked stock that have fallen hard, but they should be put in the context of many top ranked stocks that have done really well recently like Kentz, Staffline, Pressure Technologies, Cenkos, Trifast etc. 97+ ranked stocks on average have outperformed the All Share by 7% year to date.

Not putting all one's eggs in one basket is key to approaching the stock market. We have plans for another ebook guide all about portfolio management later this year (after one about the StockRanks). I think in the light of these kinds of events it's more important than ever that we get this work done.

13
Avatar for MichaelFBS

Gosh the investing thing is a roller coaster.

Thanks for the comment Ed. Unfortunately I am in Sweet Sweett (LON:CSG), Dart Dart (LON:DTG) and Spaceandpeople Spaceandpeople (LON:SAL). I have portfolio of 17 shares.

Funnily enough my best performing share is Prudential (LON:PRU) which is up 116% since I bought and is the lowest ranking stock I hold (well I hold Zanaga Iron Ore (LON:ZIOC) for a punt and Smart Metering Systems (LON:SMS) because a friend is a Non Exec).

Oh well. Now I have to decide whether to sit on these or get out an re-group.

Off for a run now to try and get rid of that pit in my stomach!!

3
Get the free newsletter