The five best stocks from 1994

Thursday, Dec 06 2012 by
5
The five best stocks from 1994

Active fund managers argue that they can beat the market by picking stocks that do better than the average. Risk and liquidity issues are important factors to consider here but, as an exercise to test this thesis, it is interesting to look back and see what stocks now in the FTSE 100 were the best picks 16-years ago on a total returns basis, i.e. with dividends reinvested.

Since September 1994 the best performer was Capita, a support services company. Second was Tullow, an oil exploration company, third was Sage, a software company, fourth was Antofagasta, a mining company and fifth was Next, a retailer.

The results shed light on the growth versus income argument. Traditional investors argue that the reinvestment of dividends is the key to long-term performance. This is supported by the Barclays Equity Gilts Study which shows that £100 invested in 1899 would now be worth £160 in real terms, but £22,239 if dividends had been reinvested. The performance of Capita illustrates this. In capital terms £100 grew to £3,620. Reinvesting dividends over the 18 years would have yielded an extra 36% (giving £4,911). A similar uplift is evident for Sage and Antofagasta, whilst for Next the uplift from reinvesting its dividends almost doubled total returns over the period to £2,356.

These data also demonstrate the power of compound interest. A seemingly small difference in annualised returns can lead to a vastly different final sum over a long period. Capita’s capital return is only a couple of percentage points lower than the total return (22.1% p.a. and 24.2% p.a. respectively) but by the end of 18 years of reinvesting dividends the outcome is almost £1,300 more.

Returns for Tullow, by contrast, have little to do with dividend flows and are all about growth. Oil explorers reinvest cash-flows boosted by occasional windfalls such as those experienced by Cairn in Rajasthan. (Ironically Cairn would have been in the top five, but payment of its last special dividend in March 2012 knocked Cairn out of the FTSE 100). The dividend yield for Tullow has remained very low since 2003 when the company first paid a small dividend, though it has risen since.

If dividends are that important shouldn’t investors just concentrate on high yielding stocks, where dividends are high in relation to the share price? The danger here is that a high yield is signalling that dividends are about to be cut, leading to a collapse in the share price and grief all around.

In time companies with growing dividends, like these five, will overtake such bond-like (i.e. almost fixed income) investments. Longer term outperformance clearly derives from two sources. Firstly a growing dividend should eventually catch up with a high, but stationary dividend. The benefit of a relatively higher dividend for reinvestment will thus fade. Secondly, share prices tend to follow earnings and dividend growth. Capita, for example, has seen its dividend grow from close to zero in 1994 to 22p per share in 2011. Over the last 10 years the dividend has grown at an average of almost 24% p.a. and with no re-rating of the shares over this period (i.e. the dividend yield remains the same) this would lead to a similar average annual share price return.

Sage has produced an even more impressive dividend growth rate of 36% compound over the same 10 year period. Thus dividend growth has been the main driver of outperformance here, rather than a re-rating (as evidenced by the dividend yield rising over the last ten years for both). Dividend reinvestment has been less important for both, as reflected in the fact that the average dividend yield for Capita and Sage has been 1.5% and 1.75% respectively over 10 years. By contrast, returns from Next have had more assistance from the reinvestment of dividends. The average dividend yield over 10 years, at 3.3%, is close to double that of Capita and Sage. This is reflected in a wider gap between share price (capital) returns and total returns (14.9% ‘v’ 19.2% compound p.a.). The contribution to total returns from dividends is smaller for Tullow and Antofagasta, and harder to generalise. Tullow only started paying dividends in 2003, whilst Antofagasta has paid small dividends, apart from three large special dividends paid since 2007.

Could these returns have been predicted back in 1994? There is certainly very little to connect the five stocks as they come from five completely different sectors. An expert in one sector could have picked the winner in that group. But it is hard to believe a generalist would have selected the best in each. Picking the right stocks can give fantastic returns, but looking at this eclectic bunch it is hard to avoid the conclusion that it comes close to a lottery. How easy was it to predict these businesses would prove classic growth stories with expanding income streams rewarding investors with rising dividends and share prices? Isn’t it easier to just buy the whole market, accept the rough with the smooth and experience less risk and greater liquidity?

Results (end value of £100 invested in each stock on 6th September 1994, dividends reinvested, source Bloomberg): - Capita (£4,911); Tullow (£3,818); Sage (£3,366) Antofagasta (£3,302); Next (£2,356)


About the Author's Fund Management

Rob Davies Profile Image Promotional
VT Maven Smart Dividend UK Fund

The VT Maven Smart Dividend UK Fund, formerly The Munro Dividend Fund seeks to buy the UK market in proportion to the forecast dividend of its constituents and in this way provide the returns of the asset class at lower volatility. ...read more or visit website »


Disclaimer:  

Past performance is not a guide to future returns. The value of investments and the income from them may go down as well as up and is not guaranteed. An investor may not get back the amount originally invested. For risks relating to specific products, please refer to the relevant documentation for that product.


Do you like this Post?
Yes
No
5 thumbs up
0 thumbs down
Share this post with friends



Capita PLC is a United Kingdom-based provider of business process management and integrated professional support service solutions. The Company's operates in sectors, including health, property services, general insurance, investor and banking, services, integrated services, information technology (IT) services and consulting, life and pensions services, professional services and workplace services. The Company offers services, such as administration and business support, customer remediation, business process management, consultancy and change management, customer management, financial services, software solutions and travel and events, among others. The Company operates across the United Kingdom, Europe, South Africa and India. more »

Share Price (Full)
1252p
Change
-0.8%
Mkt Cap (£m)
8,314
P/E (fwd)
17.1
Yield (fwd)
2.6

Tullow Oil plc (Tullow) is an independent oil and gas exploration and production company. The Company is engaged in oil and gas exploration, development and production and the sale of hydrocarbons and related activities. It operates in three geographical segments: Europe, South America and Asia; West and North Africa and South and East Africa. The Company has had significant exploration success in Uganda's Lake Albert Rift Basin, offshore Ghana and most recently in Kenya’s South Lokichar Rift Basin opening three new hydrocarbon basins. In Uganda, Tullow has drilled over 70 wells and discovered 1.7 billion barrels of oil around Lake Albert with the potential to produce over 200,000 boepd. more »

Share Price (Full)
395.1p
Change
1.0%
Mkt Cap (£m)
3,600
P/E (fwd)
28.8
Yield (fwd)
0.6

The Sage Group plc is a United Kingdom-based company which provides small and medium sized companies with a range of easy to use business management software and services including accounting and payroll, enterprise resource planning (ERP), customer relationship management and payments. Its developed tools include online accounting service, Sage One which is written in jargon-free language and comes with a simple wizard to help you import all data.  Payroll software improve business efficiency by giving control over payroll process and sensitive employee data, ensuring people are paid correctly and on time. Whereas HR solutions can help people become more productive by managing recruitment, training, development and performance. Sage ERP X3, integrates business processes into one common system, accessed via a simple user interface. Sage Pay helps to take payments online, in person or over the phone, backed by 24 hour customer support. more »

Share Price (Full)
568.5p
Change
-1.6%
Mkt Cap (£m)
6,125
P/E (fwd)
21.7
Yield (fwd)
2.4



  Is Capita fundamentally strong or weak? Find out More »


What's your view on this article? Log In to Comment Now

You can track all @StockoChat comments via Twitter


About Rob Davies

Rob Davies

Rob Davies is the Fund Manager of VT Maven Smart Dividend UK Fund, formerly The Munro Fund.. He worked as a professional geologist in Antarctica and Australia before joining the City as a mining analyst.  From 1999 to 2001 he was a writer at The Motley Fool and in 2002 he joined the Private Client Department of Clydesdale Bank as Senior Investment Analyst where he was responsible for writing and maintaining investment policy, selecting securities and portfolio creation. His experience of the stock market as an equity research analyst, personal finance writer and portfolio construction manager has given him a unique background to draw on in crafting this investment process which he now runs at VT Maven Smart Dividend UK Fund, previously known as The Munro Fund. more »

Follow



Stock Picking Tutorial Centre



Stock Picking Simplified

Stockopedia takes your stock picking to the next level with cutting edge Stock Reports & Screening tools.


Get started
or Take a Tour to find out more.
Let’s get you setup so you get the most out of our service
Done, Let's add some stocks
Brilliant - You've created a folio! Now let's add some stocks to it.

  • Apple (AAPL)

  • Shell (RDSA)

  • Twitter (TWTR)

  • Volkswagon AG (VOK)

  • McDonalds (MCD)

  • Vodafone (VOD)

  • Barratt Homes (BDEV)

  • Microsoft (MSFT)

  • Tesco (TSCO)
Save and show me my analysis
Foliobuilder