5
Archived articleThis is an archived article from 2018 - please note that any content within the article may be out of date.

Inheritance tax query from a novice

My very elderly widowed mother has been advised by a well-meaning relative to invest most of the proceeds from the proposed sale of her quite substantial family home into Business Property Relief (BPR) schemes in order to reduce inheritance tax, because these investments would fall outside her estate if she lives for another 2 years. While I know nothing about BPR schemes, it strikes me that this introduces a high level of risk to her capital, because presumably the investments into the BPR schemes can fall as well as rise. Yet the friend has said to her that investment into 'developers' outside AIM (so presumably unquoted companies eligible for BPR?) are very low risk. I'd be grateful for any thoughts on whether investing a large amount of cash in this way at my mother's advanced age is a good idea.

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

77 comments


Avatar for GrahamF

Perhaps I didn’t make my point clear. I’m talking about leaving the amount above the nil rate band to charity not the entire estate. So, where a married couple have children that means 2 lots of standard nil rate band £650k plus the residential NRB, potentially 2 lots of £175k, on top of that. So potentially £1m tax free in a couple of years’ time.

Unless there are an unusually large number of children in the family this still gives each of them a very substantial sum of money to help them pay off their mortgage, university debts, or whatever. So, leaving the surplus above the NRB and RNRB to charity is not depriving the children of considerable financial help.

Not sure I get the point about the amount of IHT being raised being insignificant for the government. It is more than £5bn. You could increase the amount being spent on transport by 15% with that.

2
Avatar for timarr

Hi Graham

Well, I understood the point.

The IHT raised by the state has to be viewed in context. It's a bit like the discussion around the EU budget payments - it's a terribly big number out of context, but if you look at government spending as a whole it's really not.

The UK budget for 2018 was £800 billion. IHT is less than 1% of that and I would argue that's insignificant in the context of government spending. Worse, IHT is a regressive tax - the richest people don't pay it, because they have good and entirely legitimate estate planning. It's a rough rule of thumb that any tax that means richer people pay less tax proportionately than poorer people is a bad one. For more context - raising income tax by 1% would raise the same amount of money as IHT and would be far less regressive.

But if people wish to leave their estates to the government because they feel an obligation to help fund it then there's nothing to stop them doing so.

My broader point, however, was that it's far better to give away the inheritance before death. If the typical UK person dies at around 85 and they were on average about 30 when they had children those children will inherit in their mid to late 50's. Frankly, by that point they should already have sorted out their finances, no matter how great a struggle it was. Given the inter-generational wealth dispersion it would be better if people gave their children a part of their inheritance twenty years before that. And if we do that then a lot of the IHT discussions are moot.

timarr

1
Avatar for potter12

Some very good contributions to this thread. Can I add to timarr’s post above?

As someone who is 70+ I agree with the suggestion of giving away substantial amounts while you can.

If you plan to become a successful investor and you are in your forties or fifties it is worth considering how you are going to dispose of your success. Let’s say you are in the position of aiming to have an estate worth more than a couple of million as in the example above. One way of solving some of the IHT problem is to give a substantial portion away. Because most people don’t need multi millions when they reach my age.

Giving to one’s children is best done early, especially if they may become wealthy too. As has been said, it’s much better to financially help when your children have a young family or earlier.

And, if one is lucky enough to be able to give substantial sums to charities the rewards can be much more enjoyable looking back than the most expensive holidays or fastest cars. And so much better than building up a large IHT liability. Researching the charities which are most worthwhile from a personal view and then following up with a targeted gift programme can lead to some very interesting experiences. It also makes investing successfully much more enjoyable. And, if you choose wisely it can lead to meetings with some really interesting people.

Good investors who have done their research during their build-up phase should have the skills to choose really worthwhile charitable projects.

Sadly when you are in your seventies you come across people who spent too long accumulating and who leave problems of surplus wealth when they die. They could have had fun with it if only they had made different decisions when they were younger.

regards

Potter

2
Avatar for Michael Ridyard

My view is that Jonathan's parents will have more than likely been higher rate tax payers and will have paid their fair share of income tax already on their assets and savings. The issue of fairness is more to do with the capital gain treatment on assets like homes which have increased in value over many years of ownership. I am classed as one of the baby boomers and possibly have become the last generation to prosper more than their parents. I say that even though my children have had a better education than I have had. When you look for the reason why it all comes down to the average cost of purchasing a home to the average salary. Average house prices are roughly 8 x the average UK salary and only 5 x when i purchase my first home. The bank of Mum and Dad is becoming essential to help youngsters onto the property ladder and inheritance benefit has also become far more important. timarr raises an important point regarding University fees which did not apply when I went to university. Only 4% of my generation went to university whereas around 40% go today. It has been estimated 75% of university students will not pay off their student loans which can be as much as £70K. The target salary is £25K. What a tragic state of affairs. There's no doubt education is important but it needs to be targeted at a more vocational level as it was in my generation. Anyway we are stuck with the problem now so i would suggest most people will want to pass on any wealth accumulated to their children to help them raise their families.

2
Avatar for GrahamF

Peterg, absolutely agree that we should all be paying a fair share of tax to provide public services. It is a personal choice as to whether one feels that the public purse rather than a specific charity is the best way to help others.

JohnEustace, that’s a good point.  Some charities seem more intent on expounding a one sided political view and are too involved in political lobbying and some are simply poorly run.  Choosing carefully is important.  My main charity is my local hospice as I feel it provides the community with vital support, regardless of people’s background, and the alternative would often otherwise be taking up space in scarce hospital beds.

1
Avatar for timarr

Well, to posit an alternative view ... the changes in our economy have led to an intergenerational imbalance in wealth. Older people have benefited from huge rises in property prices, largely as a result of low interest rates - pensioner property values are in excess of a trillion pounds. At the same time the younger generation are virtually being forced to go to university and take on student debt, which then acts as a drag on their ability to save for mortgages on inflated house prices - and which means they have to rent, often from older buy-to-let investors.

That imbalance could - and perhaps should - change by the old downsizing and passing their savings onto their children or even grandchildren prior to death. If you argue that a large part of estates are a result of an accidental transfer of wealth from the young to the old then it makes sense to reverse that flow, while avoiding IHT and resolving some of that imbalance.  Frankly the money is of more use to our children in their 30s and 40s than it will be in their 50s and 60s when most us will finally shuffle off our mortal coils.

As for the government needing the money to invest, overall IHT is a tiny part of the government's income - the government this week has already set aside the equivalent of almost all of the IHT income for next year on no-deal planning.  If we want to help the government raise taxes then giving money to our children so that they can spend it on houses, home improvements and raising future taxpayers is likely to raise far more money for the Exchequer in the long run.

timarr
1
Avatar for JohnEustace

It's not easy to know which charities will make good use of a bequest. Some are very poorly run.
GiveWell does thorough research to find the ones that deliver the most benefit from their income.
https://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

A fascinatingly different perspective. I'd be interested to learn what others think.

0
Avatar for timarr

The decision to leave money to charity as opposed to family or friends is a personal one, each of us has to make our own choices.

However, if you do go down this route make sure your mother gets proper professional advice over her will. I know of at least two examples of badly drafted wills that ended up in court with the charity suing the family to maximize their part of the legacy.

In one case the deceased had left a fixed sum to charity and the, at the time, considerable, residue to the family but sadly by his death the value of his estate had decreased to the point where liquid funds didn't cover the charitable bequest. Family members ended up taking out mortgages to pay the charity off rather than being forced into a property sale at a depressed price.

In my limited experience charities are extremely aggressive in pursuing estates for their share of the funds. As is often the case when a well organised institution takes on an individual the odds are stacked in favour of the institution.

This is no reason not to give money to charity, but it does highlight the need to make sure it's done properly.  This Money Advice Service page is a useful guide to the advantages of doing so:

https://www.moneyadviceservice...

timarr

2
Avatar for GrahamF

Or give everything above the nil rate band to charity in the will and there’s nothing to pay the tax man at all, no complicated calculations involving IFAs, no stressing over risk in AIM portfolios, and still a very handsome amount for beneficiaries within the nil rate band.

The deceased no longer has a need for that money after they have passed away, so unless the family really needs more than the NRB......., can any of us say we really need more than the NRB,.....the charity option makes a lot of sense.

We generally are concerned to manage our affairs to avoid (legitimately) paying unnecessary taxes on our income. That can make us focus on what the tax man is getting from IHT, when the easy way out is simply to give the extra wealth above the NRB to charity instead.

2
Avatar for peterg

I agree with a lot of what you say, Graham, but while I will make some limited charitable donations on my death, I'm not making any special arrangements to avoid IHT. I'm more than happy for my estate to pay its share. Tax revenues are essential for the running of the country and the services we all expect - NHS, defence, education, social services - all of which are currently underfunded. So while I will choose to pass a part of my estate on directly to a small charities that I have a particular interest in, they will be a small part of it. At present I regard the IHT exemptions limits as far too high, and there are very few cases in which families need to be protected from IHT on estates to anything like the current levels.

3
Avatar for Jonathan777

My understanding is that if you gift the money from the sale of the isa away there will not be any CTG liability.

Thanks, Michael. Not sure if I've understood you correctly here, but timarr is saying that gifting the money from the sale of the ISA does in fact trigger CGT.

0
Avatar for timarr

Thanks, Michael. Not sure if I've understood you correctly here, but timarr is saying that gifting the money from the sale of the ISA does in fact trigger CGT.

I was saying that, but I'm wrong. As there's no CGT liability on the shares as they're sold out of the ISA the CGT "buy" price is effectively the price at which they're transferred out. Michael is correct - as long as you manage the sale of the ISA and transfer of the monies correctly - i.e. virtually simultaneously - then there'd be no CGT liability.

Apologies - although I'd argue that just proves my point that you need a proper advisor :)

timarr

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

Brilliant. That's great to know. Thanks.

0
Avatar for Michael Ridyard

Jonathan,
timarr is quite right you can't gift an isa to a child for example and anything sold and transferred out of the isa would be CGT free. Providing your mother lives for 7yrs then the money will not be subject to IHT. My understanding is that if you gift the money from the sale of the isa away there will not be any CTG liability.

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

You can't gift the ISA, that's a personal thing, so in order to transfer an ISA to you your mother will either need to transfer the shares out (CGT free) or sell the shares in the ISA and transfer the cash out (CGT free) and then transfer the shares or cash to you - triggering CGT.

Most helpful, thanks. I guess the sensible approach is not to run the risk of paying tax twice – CGT and IHT. Something to discuss with the adviser. Perhaps best for my mother to hang on to her share portfolio.
0
Avatar for Michael Ridyard

Jonathan,
Just one point, make sure your mother puts together a Gift Letter to each recipient, which should state:
I hereby certify the following:
- Details of the gift and value and name of recipient.
No repayment of this gift is expected or implied from the recipients in cash or services.
- Date the gift was made
- Recipients address
- Donor Name & Address
-Donors Signature and printed name
- Recipients Signature and printed name

You can do this yourself or get a solicitor involved.

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

Will do. Thank you.

0
Avatar for GrahamF

Jonathan

Please also see if there are some charities that your mother would like to support as many very worthwhile charities depend on legacies from people with substantial estates like your mother’s. If she leaves 10% of the net estate to charity the IHT rate reduces from 40% to 36%.

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

We will certainly look at this. Thanks.

0
Avatar for timarr

Hi Jonathan

Presumably the gift-of-shares issue timarr has kindly identified applies equally to shares both inside and outside of any ISA?

The issue doesn't arise. You can't gift the ISA, that's a personal thing, so in order to transfer an ISA to you your mother will either need to transfer the shares out (CGT free) or sell the shares in the ISA and transfer the cash out (CGT free) and then transfer the shares or cash to you - triggering CGT.

Basically anything we can spot the taxman has already covered.

timarr

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

Thanks so much to everyone for their input into this thread. I’ve learned a great deal. I’ve arranged to meet with a financial adviser soon along with my mother and my brother and my sister. And, keeping things very simple, we’ve come up with a possible plan of action to put to the adviser for his consideration and comment...

Mother’s Situation

My mother is 88 years old. She’s quite frail, but she remains active and in reasonably good health. The family home she intends to sell next year should fetch in excess of £2M. In addition, she has a share portfolio worth about £1.5M and a pension income of about £19K (£10K state pension and £9K from my deceased father's private pension). My father’s full nil rate band for IHT passed over to my mother, and she has a life-insurance policy that will be worth about £350K when she dies.  

My mother wishes to move in with my sister at some point after the family home has been sold. My sister has a quite large house in London that she and her husband both live in and rent out to two tenants. One or possibly both tenants would move out when my mother moves in. Though my mother is fine going up and down stairs, my sister’s house is fitted with a lift because my brother-in-law is in a wheelchair, so the lift could prove helpful should my mother become less mobile than she is now. And should my mother ever need additional outside care, my sister could ‘bolt on’ a care package to the existing one that is already in operation for my brother-in-law.  

Possible plan

Having thought about the very helpful comments given here regarding capital risk, we’re not planning on going down the AIM route discussed earlier in the thread, and even though it’s also been very helpfully explained that the peer-to-peer lending option qualifying for BPR is lower risk than investing on AIM, the assets on which the loans are secured could presumably drop significantly in a crisis, so perhaps we should rule this out as well. So here’s what we’re planning to discuss with the financial adviser:

  1. My mother sells the family home and gives the cash to the beneficiaries of her will, who are her three children.
  2. My mother gives my sister a cash lump sum up front to compensate her for lost rent over a specified number of years relating to the tenant or tenants who’ve moved out. (If my mother gives the lump sum instead of herself paying rent, it rules out my sister having to pay income tax.)
  3. My mother retains £500K in her share portfolio and divides the rest (about £1M) between her three children. (Presumably, it’s good if any of the children want to accept shares in specie, as that will prevent triggering capital gains tax outside her ISA?)
  4. My mother has no outside care needs at the moment, but if/when they do arise, she can pay for these herself out of income (£16K pension plus approx £15K from the £500K portfolio = £31K). She can also spend capital from the £500K if she wishes, though that will of course reduce the income she’s able to receive from it.
  5. My sister has said it might be possible for our mother, as sole beneficiary, to vary the will of my father, who died in April 2016, in order to pass some assets direct to the children from that date and so reduce the length of time before these assets no longer qualify for IHT. 

Any thoughts are very welcome. The more we've reflected on things before going into the meeting with the financial adviser the better. Many thanks!

 

0
Avatar for timarr

Hi Jonathan

I'm not really qualified to comment on most of that but one point:

My mother retains £500K in her share portfolio and divides the rest (about £1M) between her three children. (Presumably, it’s good if any of the children want to accept shares in specie, as that will prevent triggering capital gains tax outside her ISA?)

If your mother is transferring shares to family members then that's deemed a disposal at the market price and CGT arises on the transfer - i.e. your mother pays the CGT on the difference between the buying price and the market price at the time of the transfer.

timarr

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

If your mother is transferring shares to family members then that's deemed a disposal at the market price and CGT arises on the transfer - i.e. your mother pays the CGT on the difference between the buying price and the market price at the time of the transfer.

Thank you for this info. There are some significant gains on shares that have been held for decades, so perhaps this is an argument for my mother holding on to the shares, so as to avoid paying tax twice – for CGT and IHT. 

0
Avatar for Luthrin

There are some problems with the plan you've outlined (the gift of shares for example, as timarr notes), but since time is of the essence here, can I ask whether your father had an ISA (or multiple ISAs), and if so, has your mother made use of the Additional Permitted Subscription (APS) allowance? (This assumes that your mother and father were not separated at the time of your father's death.)

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

There are some problems with the plan you've outlined (the gift of shares for example, as timarr notes), but since time is of the essence here, can I ask whether your father had an ISA (or multiple ISAs), and if so, has your mother made use of the Additional Permitted Subscription (APS) allowance? (This assumes that your mother and father were not separated at the time of your father's death.)

My father did indeed have an ISA that he subscribed to every year. Thanks for letting me know about the Additional Permitted Subscription (APS) allowance.  I don't know if my mother has been making use of it, but I will check. 

Presumably the gift-of-shares issue timarr has kindly identified applies equally to shares both inside and outside of any ISA?

0
Avatar for StuartPrice1

One area that is often over looked and can and will reduce IHT liability over the medium to long term is the regular gift exemption. This is unlimited as long as its can be proved was paid out of Income and not Capital and was a paid on a regular basis (A Direct Debit).

Assuming the owner has children, grand children, great grand children etc then £7140 can be paid annually into JISA and Pension for those under 18. This is great way of re-distributing wealth to family whilst the owner is still alive. A regular payment into an adults ISA or pension would also be possible. If its regular and out of Income then it will not be caught by £3000 exemtion rule or 7 year rule. This also will give the owner some gratification of the financial legacy being passed on whist being alive to see it.

1
Avatar for Michael Ridyard

This has been a very interesting thread which as timarr has suggested may impact other persons reading this thread with wealthy relative estates >£2M. One point that has not been raised however is the Gift of a home or a 50% Gift in a home to a relative to reduce the estate value below the £2M threshold. This only works of course if the owner liver for 7yrs after the gift is made. If the elderly person continues to live in the property after the gift of the home they must pay the going rate of rent and the bills. If you only gift 50% of the property both you and the new owners need to live in the property for 7yrs, but you do not need to pay rent. This will then mitigate the IHT position for wealthy estates, but it goes without saving there must be enough of the estate put at one side to cover care home costs. If you get dementia the average care costs should cover at least 7yrs.

2
Avatar for Asagi

Hi timarr,

Good points but....

there are less than 200 stocks on AIM with a market capitalisation of more than £100 million and many of those wouldn't be suitable for a BPR portfolio,

I'd have it the other way round, that few AIM shares of that profile would not qualify for Business Property Relief and IHT immunity.

Asagi

0
Avatar for timarr

Hi Asagi

I said "suitable", not "qualify" ... :-)

But you're probably right anyway. Most of those 200 will qualify and will be suitable - the obvious exceptions are investment companies, which don't qualify, and some resources stocks (some of which are probably dual listed and don't qualify either).

timarr

1
Avatar for StuartPrice1

As a solution utlilising the reliefs a few companies offer a collective. the OCF is usually a little high but the risk is lowered. Have a look at the Unicorn AIM ISA among others, a firm called the Wealth Club offer good brokerage services towards this type of product. I have no connection and have not used them, however would be a lower risk option than direct equity investment in unquoted stock.

1
Avatar for Luthrin

For an experienced investor who is fairly confident of producing market tracking returns from a well-diversified portfolio of, say, forty AIM stocks (and my impression is that there are plenty of such individuals subscribing to Stockopedia), I think the lower risk option is to self-manage the portfolio rather than entrust the task to one of these wealth management companies.

First, as you point out, such AIM portfolio services carry a hefty cost, and this creates an immediate headwind that will materially lower performance. Second, the weight of funds from these managers into what they regard as bulletproof companies creates an 'IHT premium' in the share price. Consequently, if Business Relief (as it's now called) from investing in qualifying AIM shares is ever removed then the valuations of these favoured stocks will likely drop considerably (in all likelihood most AIM stocks would be affected to some extent, but some much more than others in my view).

Examples that come to mind are James Halstead (LON:JHD) and Nichols (LON:NICL) , where Octopus Investments, one of the largest AIM portfolio managers, has substantial holdings via its nominee company. Both these stocks have very similar current StockRanks and factor breakdowns: SR86/Q96/V21/M90 for Halstead and SR87/Q95/V22/M93 for Nichols, and that low Value factor is at least partially reflective of individual investors and professional portfolio managers herding into what is perceived as a high-quality, low-risk AIM investment for IHT minimisation.

We saw how such perceptions can come unstuck a couple of months ago - Patisserie Holdings (LON:CAKE) had much the same characteristics just before the shares were suspended on 10th October (SR82/Q98/V17/M88). This was another large Octopus holding, with its nominee company owning 8.34m shares, a stake of over 6%.

5
Avatar for timarr

For anyone browsing this thread in future it might be worth restating that putting an old person into a portfolio of AIM shares isn't a sensible approach. Seeking to protect the capital value of an estate by putting that capital value at risk in shares of any kind would be crazy, if only because the actual point at which IHT is triggered is completely out of the control of everyone.

However, the point that Luthrin is making about AIM BPR qualifying stocks looking like a crowded trade is correct. Aside from Octopus, whom he mentions, there are other funds run by Downing, Unicorn, Puma, Stella, Blankston Sington and Investec. There may well be more, those are just the ones I've run across. Almost by definition these funds are chasing the same shares - there are less than 200 stocks on AIM with a market capitalisation of more than £100 million and many of those wouldn't be suitable for a BPR portfolio,

Even some of the larger AIM stocks would be impacted by the removal of BPR - James Halstead (LON:JHD) for instance has Octopus (4.12%), Investec (2.54%) and Unicorn (1.63%) among its significant shareholders. I assume not all of those shares are in IHT funds but you'd still see some impact. I actually sold most of my AIM holdings early this year judging that the prices were too high relative to the market, that that was partially due to a BPR based crowded trade and that the risk of BPR removal meant that the risks were to the downside.

timarr

4
Avatar for dmjram

Very well put - as well as the inherent risk of investing on the AiM market in a crowded trade, you have a layer of political risk on top in the form of BPR availability decisions by the government in power at any given time.
Simply not a good risk-reward pay off for for an elderly investor.

1
Avatar for Wimbledonsprinter

“For anyone browsing this thread in future it might be worth restating that putting an old person into a portfolio of AIM shares isn't a sensible approach.”

Timarr. I hesitate to add anything to the excellent points you have already made on this thread, from which I have learnt a lot, but on the point above, I could imagine an (admittedly rare) case where:

1) the “old person” is very wealthy and in any plausible scenario would have enough cash to cover possible care costs etc, and would still likely leave an estate in excess of the IHT threshholds, AND

2). the intended beneficiaries are also in the fortunate position of being independently wealthy and they would likely use any funds received to augment an already existing inventment portfolio.

If both these two conditions were met, I could personally see some logic in putting a smallish part of the excess (after any plausible care cost scenario, remembering people can live a long time, and the IHT thresshhold) into AIM stocks, particularly given the current IHT status of AIM stocks.

The above is going to be a very rare scenario. But, I think it highlights a broader point, that before thinking what is the right investment, people should think what are they trying to achieve. My limited experience (and I am not a financial adviser) is that people do not think enough about what they want realistically to achieve. Jonathan seems to be in a position where he might have a good insight into what the financial situation and goals are not only of his mother but the intended beneficiaries of the will and I would recommend that he has thought about that as well before meeting the IFA.

4
Avatar for timarr

But, I think it highlights a broader point, that before thinking what is the right investment, people should think what are they trying to achieve. My limited experience (and I am not a financial adviser) is that people do not think enough about what they want realistically to achieve.

Wimbledonsprinter, couldn't agree more.

But I suspect the situation outlined in this thread is one that many of us are likely to encounter in the next few years - an aged relative in their 80's downsizing a house that's gained a huge amount in value and suddenly being faced with a potentially large IHT bill (note that the IHT exposure exists anyway, but while it's locked up in bricks and mortar it's hard to mitigate).

The requirements here seem to be (1) find a way of mitigating the impact of IHT, (2) ensure some kind of reasonable income and (3) avoid the risk of an outright capital loss. An AIM BPR portfolio meets (1), might meet (2) but can't meet (3).

In fact even as a wealthy investor you'd need to think carefully about using AIM BPR. The only credible long-term plan that I would consider would be one in which the shares are sheltered inside an ISA. Remember the qualifying status of AIM shares for BPR varies - larger stocks, in particular, are likely at some point to move to a full market listing. Outside of an ISA you're then exposed to CGT as you'll have to sell the shares to move them into another BPR qualifying stock.

I think we can safely say it's tricky. But I'd agree with the main thrust of your point - people need to be realistic about their financial goals and plan for them. In particular, if we have the knowledge to do so, we need to be making IHT plans in our 60's, not our 80's.

But I think it's a particularly difficult time to be planning these things. Aside from the IHT review underway I think we can be fairly sure that CGT will be targeted by governments looking to raise cash. And if we do get a Labour administration I wouldn't be entirely confident that the favourable treatment of ISAs would continue, although you'd at least hope that any changes wouldn't be retrospective.

timarr

2
Avatar for Laughton

Jonathan's not the only one learning something new.

All very interesting and helpful information - prompting further investigations.

2
Avatar for Armorduck

What about the somewhat radical advice that your mother should not try to avoid inheritance tax but instead be happy redistribute her excess wealth to the more needy in our society?

3
Avatar for John

Yup. Great idea if the more needy in our society were French farmers, or Indian space programmes!

-2
Avatar for timarr

Yup. Great idea if the more needy in our society were French farmers, or Indian space programmes!

Are you suggesting that any extra income raised by Jonathan's mother declining to take advantage of legitimate IHT reliefs would be automatically funneled to French farmers and Indian rockets?  If so, that seems very odd.

Personally I'd have thought that the budgets for those things would be fixed so that any additional taxation could be used as additional funding for the NHS, or nuclear weapons, or redistributed to the needy poor or spent on ridiculous vanity projects like HS2. But what do I know?

In fact IHT appears to be regressive once you get beyond the immediate IHT reliefs - i.e. larger estates pay less proportionately. This is one of the findings in the OTS initial report. Basically richer people with larger estates have better - and completely legitimate - tax planning and are able to effectively mitigate IHT.  This is counter to any properly designed taxation system where wealthier people should pay proportionately more - or at least shouldn't be paying less.

At a guess Jonathan's mother would fall into the category of people normally caught by IHT with an estate a bit larger than the standard allowance. While I'm probably in a minority here in favouring a more redistributive tax system I certainly don't think we should support a tax that penalises people simply because they're not aware of the tax breaks available. She should definitely seek to minimise her estate's exposure.

The OTS response points to looking to simplify the IHT reliefs to ensure that you don't need to have access to clever financial planning to take advantage of them. Quite how they'll do that I have no idea, but you'd probably expect the Office of Tax Simplification to probably try to, err ... simplify the tax in some way.

timarr

2
Avatar for John

My original remark was of course half fun and whole earnest - there was no intention to offend anyone! But since you ask........
"Are you suggesting that any extra income raised by Jonathan's mother declining to take advantage of legitimate IHT reliefs would be automatically funneled to French farmers and Indian rockets?"
It is my understanding that a proportion of the UK's total tax take is automatically funneled to French farmers (as part of our annual contribution to EU funds) and to Indian rockets (as part of our foreign aid programme).
"Personally I'd have thought that the budgets for those things would be fixed"
I could of course be wrong, but thought budgets for these things would vary as a proportion of GDP.

Joe

1
Avatar for timarr

Hi Joe

I did realise that the comment was tongue in cheek, but it does rather encapsulate a certain section of society's view on the relation between taxation and government spending - and indeed what we should be spending it on. So ...

The Overseas Aid budget is fixed each year and is generally used as an extension of soft power - i.e. by spending money on aid we (and every other country in the world) look to create economic opportunities. Arguably money sent to India is now misdirected given economic development there, but it's unlikely we're spending simply to be humanitarian. And of course we don't spend any money directly on Indian rockets.

The EU budget is broadly dependent on Gross National Income in comparison with other EU states - so it varies a bit. But there's no direct relationship between GNI and taxation, so paying a bit more IHT won't make any difference to our EU contribution.  And of course we don't spend any money directly on French farmers. In fact as the French contribution to the EU budget is greater than the UK's it would be more accurate to say that the French are spending money on English farmers.

And really IHT is a drop in the ocean - we raised £5.2 billion from IHT last year, sent roughly £9.4 billion to the EU and had total public spending of £817 billion. Most wastage in government spending is within our own borders, however tempting it is to raise a few poster boy examples of overseas spending stupidity.

timarr

5
Avatar for John

Hi Timarr
Joe obviously have a better understanding of these matters than I do, so Ill stop digging myself any deeper into this hole!
Joe

1
Avatar for timarr

Hi Joe

That's a very kind way of saying I should get out more ... :-)

timarr

4
Avatar for JohnEustace

I'm beginning to think jonathan is just setting us tests here but I'll bite one last time:

"The additional nil-rate band will also be available when a person downsizes or ceases to own a home on or after 8 July 2015 and assets of an equivalent value, up to the value of the additional nil-rate band, are passed on death to direct descendants.

There will be a tapered withdrawal of the additional nil-rate band for estates with a net value of more than £2 million. This will be at a withdrawal rate of £1 for every £2 over this threshold."

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

I'm beginning to think jonathan is just setting us tests here but I'll bite one last time:


You've been extremely helpful and patient. Thank you!

0
Avatar for Luthrin

Hi Jonathan,

I suggest you get a copy of 'How to Save Inheritance Tax 2018/19' by Carl Bayley. It explains the various exemptions, reliefs and mainstream strategies for IHT minimisation well and avoids the often overwhelming detail of a professional practitioner's text such as Ray & McLaughlin's 'Practical Inheritance Tax Planning' or Tolley's 'Inheritance Tax' (both of which sit on my bookshelf and cost over £100 a pop).

4
Avatar for JohnEustace

The main residence nil rate band is £325k, transferable to spouses on death. There is an additional nil rate allowance, currently £125k, rising to £150k next tax year, for property left to direct descendants. That additional allowance is for estates less than £2m. It reduces by £1 for every £2 of estate value above that.

It is all on the HMRC site I linked to earlier...

2
Avatar for Jonathan777

The main residence nil rate band is £325k, transferable to spouses on death. There is an additional nil rate allowance, currently £125k, rising to £150k next tax year, for property left to direct descendants. That additional allowance is for estates less than £2m. It reduces by £1 for every £2 of estate value above that.

Thank you. I will check the link out again, but your succinct explanation is so helpful. So from what you're saying here, this additional nil rate band only applies to property and not shares or cash... if the property is not left to the children, but is given to us in cash, does this mean the additional nil rate allowance of 125K does not apply? And finally, if my mother were to reach 250k (125x2) above the £2m, does that mean every pound of the additional nil rate allowance would be withdrawn and so this additional relief would not apply? Thanks again.

0
Avatar for Jonathan777

Would be very grateful for someone to explain how nil rate bands work and why it would be beneficial to reduce my mother's estate to under £2m in order to benefit from full allowances available under these nil rate bands. Thanks and much appreciated. (Will definitely talk to an IFA, but am learning a lot from the great community here before having that conversation.)

0
Avatar for Michael Ridyard

My view is don't put all your eggs in one basket and certainly don't get involved in anything you don't fully understand the risk.
I would strongly recommend you get Power of Attorney over your mothers welfare and finances. It costs about £300 from any decent solicitor. You mother needs to be be of sound mind to sign it and if she wishes she can transfer all powers over to you now. If she's a very independent, financial powers can be transferred if she becomes unwell and has limited mental capacity.
Many elderly people become very ill late in life and they may need 24 hr nursing care at a care home. If you have assets such as a home these will need to be used to pay the care home fees which are around £900/week. You have to be very careful that you have not deliberately deprived your mother of capital. If deemed so the local council in which the care home resided will peruse any beneficiary for care home costs.
£700K IHT free is not bad.

2
Avatar for John

Probably I've missed something here, but where does £700K IHT free come from?
Joe

0
Avatar for timarr

Agreed, Jonathan, but of course this could happen if the market drops like a stone anyway. Also cash and property can drop like a stone too. Not sure but I think the market has the best record of all three over the years!

Not quite sure how cash can drop like a stone? But the point here is to find ways of mitigating IHT while maintaining capital - there's no point in doing the former and losing a ton of money by putting yourself in risky assets which go wrong.

Taking on the excess risk of AIM shares in order to try to mitigate IHT exposure for a very old person would be a very strange and extremely questionable decision. If I was a family member deprived of a substantial part of my inheritance because of such a choice I would be looking very seriously at legal action against whoever made that decision.

Probably I've missed something here, but where does £700K IHT free come from?

Presumably the £350K IHT allowance for his mother and an assumption that his father's IHT allowance was unused and passed to his mother.

timarr

3
Avatar for Jonathan777

Presumably the £350K IHT allowance for his mother and an assumption that his father's IHT allowance was unused and passed to his mother.

Yes, I can confirm that my deceased father's unused IHT allowance has passed over to my mother. So the assumption here is indeed correct.
0
Avatar for Asagi

We also know that the Association of Accounting Technicians has specifically called for the relief to be scrapped

that's excellent information timarr - thank you.

On another note, I'd say that there is the risk of trying to time the market with a portfolio AIM investment. Investments do not have to be liquidated on inheritance and one hopes that heirs do not have pressing plans for the money. A well managed AIM portfolio should produce a decent income and when held for the long term, hopefully deliver the textbook growth of 8% a year (or whatever it is) that equities are supposed to.

Then, of course, there are trusts:

https://www.moneyadviceservice.org.uk/en/articles/using-a-trust-to-cut-your-inheritance-tax

Asagi

1
Avatar for Asagi

Does anyone have EPA over your mother? You said she was very elderly. Even if she paid for advice, if she in a position to be able to make a judgement over its merit?

timarr wrote:
there's a government IHT review underway at the moment, there are likely to be changes to the whole approach next year. Removing BPR on AIM shares is one of the ideas that's been floated.

I disagree. People may be second guessing the result of the review when they say that this could be the outcome but I've not heard anyone in office or industry saying that this should happen. Indeed we are only a few years on from Lord Heseltine's review of govenment support from SMEs, are we really ready to start removing supports?

My understanding, from speaking with one professional previously (yes, a 'tax expert', the one thing people normally tell us they are not!) is that if things are tightened up/changed in the IHT investing space, it will likely be the more 'contrived' lending schemes. Here is an example:

https://www.mattioliwoods.com/...
Mattioli Woods Progression, which is aimed at high-net-worth investors, operates by establishing one or more trading companies where the client is the sole shareholder. The company’s funds are invested in a range of trading activities that qualify for Business Property Relief (BPR). Targeting a dividend of 5% per annum after all charges, the service enables clients to receive an income from their BPR qualifying investment or, if not required, profits can be retained within the Mattioli Woods Progression company.

so, a company is created that invests (don't know if they mean equity or lending) in BPR qualifying businesses and tries to deliver an income of 5%. That's a very helpful income.

I think that a characterisation of this type of investment as 'insane' would be a bit OTT!

I'd expect that this is the type of scheme that Money Marketing is talking about. I've had some past professional dealings with Mattioli Woods (but no ongoing arrangements) so that is how I know about their offering. If it helps, I also know timarr in real life, indeed he is one of the experts I contact from time-to-time for a second opinion.

Asagi

2
Avatar for timarr

Hi Asagi

I disagree. People may be second guessing the result of the review when they say that this could be the outcome but I've not heard anyone in office or industry saying that this should happen. Indeed we are only a few years on from Lord Heseltine's review of govenment support from SMEs, are we really ready to start removing supports?

Well, we know that BPR on AIM shares was included in the OTS review of IGT because it was specifically mentioned in the original call for evidence (https://assets.publishing.serv...).

We also know that the Association of Accounting Technicians has specifically called for the relief to be scrapped (https://www.aat.org.uk/prod/s3...) and that the Treasury has declined to commit to keeping the IHT relief (https://www.ftadviser.com/inve...).

As to what will actually happen - who knows?  But I think pointing out that there's an ongoing review of IHT and AIM BPR on a thread about using AIM BPR to mitigate IHT isn't unreasonable ... :-/

I think that a characterisation of this type of investment as 'insane' would be a bit OTT!

To be fair, the context in which the word "insane" was used was about the advisability of putting someone in extreme old age into AIM shares in order to try and mitigate IHT! I would stand by that comment.  But I agree that using managed BPR schemes is different and how suitable they are is entirely dependent on individual circumstances.

timarr

2
Avatar for peterg

My understanding, from speaking with one professional previously (yes, a 'tax expert', the one thing people normally tell us they are not!) is that if things are tightened up/changed in the IHT investing space, it will likely be the more 'contrived' lending schemes

I'm certainly no expert on this, but I would agree that clearly the motivation is to eliminate the misuse of IHT reliefs that are primarily intended to protect small family owned firms. It would be possible to make a case (a good one, I'd think) that anything with a public listing does not qualify as such. And quite clearly, the conversation we are having here has nothing to do with protecting an SME from IHT, which tends to illustrate the point. So removal of IHT from all AIM shares seems perfectly logical and supportable. That doesn't mean it will happen, but it certainly might.

2
Avatar for John

The point is always made that investing in the market is high risk and that the value of investments can go down as well as up. Bear in mind that if your mother could survive for two years having invested in high quality AIM companies which qualify for IHT relief, the “going down” part would have to be in excess of 40% before her estate would be worse off than it is just now. I hope I’ve explained this properly!
Joe

1
Avatar for Jonathan777

"the “going down” part would have to be in excess of 40% before her estate would be worse off than it is just now."

Thanks for your message, Joe. Great point. But as I've also learned on here, this is true unless the IHT breaks are withdrawn under the current review – in which case any loss my mother makes puts her in a worse position than if she'd stayed in cash.

0
Avatar for John

Agreed, Jonathan, but of course this could happen if the market drops like a stone anyway. Also cash and property can drop like a stone too. Not sure but I think the market has the best record of all three over the years!

0
Avatar for Rusty2

How can cash drop like a stone?

1
Avatar for John

"It does not mean that the pound here in Britain, in your pocket or purse or in your bank, has been devalued."
Famous last words - Harold Wilson!
Just for fun.

1
Avatar for peterg

Bear in mind that if your mother could survive for two years having invested in high quality AIM companies which qualify for IHT relief, the “going down” part would have to be in excess of 40% before her estate would be worse off than it is just now.

Not quite true. It will depend on the size and placing of the estate. For an estate of less than £325k (£750k if the spouse's allowance was unused) there will be no benefit. Only if the estate is either very large or only the excess above the IHT allowance is invested in IHT exempt investments will the benefit approach 40%

3
Avatar for peterg

Yes, absolutely, my mother will get professional advice; it’s just great for me to learn a little bit more here in advance, so that hopefully I can have a more informed discussion if/when I get involved in any dialogue with the adviser. 

Exactly the right approach. While I certainly agree that your mother should be getting professional advice on this, the harsh reality is that not all IFAs are equal. The better informed you are to start with, and the clearer you are about what you are looking for, the better the odds of you getting good advice and a good outcome.

4
Avatar for JohnEustace

Do get professional advice. It’s impossible for us without knowing all of your circumstances and we are just random(ish) strangers on the Internet.

This is a starting point on finding an IFA.
https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/savings/best-financial-advisers/

And this is the IHT rules relating to properties on the HMRC site.
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/inheritance-tax-residence-nil-rate-band

4
Avatar for Jonathan777

Thanks for the links, John. I hear you. It would be good to know if it's possible to engage an IFA who charges a flat rate as opposed to one who stands to gain a percentage by converting the cash from the house sale into BPR schemes.

0
Avatar for skinner66

if you gift money . property etc,, if they die within 7 years then liable for tax..hence ill put my house in kids name before that, unless im struck dead at age 52 lol,,assets and cash in bank all count,,my mother in law pays for all, caring , worked for years she has to pay out her small pension but has money over 12k in bank.. if was less caring would be free,, so 12k in bank is costing her about 6k per year extra for carrears,, i did say but some dont listen,, until all gone,,

-2
Avatar for Laughton

"hence ill put my house in kids name before that,"

Bear in  in though, that this won't work if you gift them the house but then continue to live in it without also paying them a market rent.

2
Avatar for dmjram

The over riding rule is never let the tax tail wag the investment dog, especially when the investments are in AiM/unquoted assets which may not even qualify for the relief in 2 years time. Add in your mothers age and potential need to access the funds for care etc. and it becomes even more important to follow it!

Talk to an expert and look at all the options e.g. if your mother has sold her principal private residence, there is main residence relief she may well qualify for without the time lags.

5
Avatar for Jonathan777

Thank you, dmjram. And yes, I think this is 100% a case of the tax tail wagging the investment dog! So really that's perhaps all that needs to be said.

But I'd really appreciate any thoughts on the Money Marketing quote mentioned to timarr: "it is possible to invest in BPR qualifying investments outside Aim in IHT services where the business is to lend money to other companies. This is a form of secured lending and lower risk than Aim. The portfolios are managed for capital preservation, in keeping with the needs of elderly clients." https://www.moneymarketing.co.uk/iht-planning-balancing-bpr-and-investment-risk/

Does the apparent emphasis on capital preservation and being lower risk than AIM make any difference?

And in relation to your final point, my mother hasn't yet sold, but will be selling her principal private residence next year. As I understand it, the main residence relief means she won't have to pay any capital gains tax, but there is no bearing on inheritance tax. If I've got that wrong, please let me know.

0
Avatar for timarr

It's an insane idea, don't let her do this without getting proper financial advice.

Firstly, you're quite correct, it introduces significant capital risk. Over a long period of time it could be a reasonably safe approach but assuming that your mother's lifespan may be relatively short then the level of investment risk alone rules this out as a sensible approach. In the past two months, for instance. we've seen drops of 50% in some AIM favourites.

Secondly, AIM BPR is really tricky - figuring out if companies qualify can be difficult and the qualification status can change without anyone knowing. For instance, if the company decides to get a quote on another market it loses its eligibility for BBR.

Thirdly, there's a government IHT review underway at the moment, there are likely to be changes to the whole approach next year. Removing BPR on AIM shares is one of the ideas that's been floated. BPR relief was introduced originally to ensure that family owned businesses wouldn't be forced into selling up when the original owners died - AIM shares accidentally inherited (sic) this relief, but there's a very strong case for removing it.

And finally, putting someone of an advanced age into unquoted investments of unknown pedigree is highly risky and I don't believe any trusted advisor would recommend this. For a start, how do you get your money back?

But please don't take the word of an anonymous poster for this. If this is a substantial amount of money the family needs to take professional advice. There are legitimate ways of minimising IHT on estates, and the earlier action is taken the better.

timarr

17
Avatar for Jonathan777

Thank you, Timarr, for your thoughtful and comprehensive reply.

I hear you 100% on the AIM shares.

And I also hear you on the unquoted investments of unknown pedigree...

I have found a reference on-line to what is probably being referred to in relation to the investment in unquoted companies. It's an article in Money Marketing that includes a mention that "it is possible to invest in BPR qualifying investments outside Aim in IHT services where the business is to lend money to other companies. This is a form of secured lending and lower risk than Aim. The portfolios are managed for capital preservation, in keeping with the needs of elderly clients." https://www.moneymarketing.co.uk/iht-planning-balancing-bpr-and-investment-risk/

Have you heard of these BPR qualifying IHT services outside AIM that lend money to other companies? And what do you make of the statement that it’s apparently lower risk than AIM and the portfolios are managed for capital preservation? Is this of any comfort? Or should I be just as concerned as before? I’d be very grateful for any thoughts.

0
Avatar for timarr

Hi Jonathan

As it happens I do have a vague acquaintance with this kind of scheme. At base it's a form of peer to peer lending - you have a small business and need short term funding that banks aren't interested in, or you simply don't like banks, while I have some spare capital I'd like to invest. The intermediary negotiates the interest rate and secures the capital on assets - usually property.

I assume this could be scaled up to larger businesses if the intermediary was able to access enough aggregated funds.  If the intermediary is any good this is a relatively safe way of investing funds - basically the capital and interest should be secured, and the loans would normally be short-term, so the actual risk is lowish. Managed properly it would be far less risky than an AIM based scheme.

It's obviously a fairly sophisticated scheme, so you still need advice. I'd also remain concerned that this type of scheme might be caught under new IHT legislation. It obviously wasn't the purpose of BPR to allow wealthy individuals with no direct connection to the underlying business to avoid IHT.

On the other hand, anything that allows small businesses to access funds really ought to be be viewed as a positive development. But we live in strange times.

On your IHT / CGT question - yes, the family residence is CGT free but it, or its released value, are part of your mother's overall estate for IHT purposes where there's a £350,000 allowance before IHT is applied. Note that  when a spouse dies their unused IHT allowance is passed to the remaining partner.  So, for instance, if your father predeceased your mother and left everything to her she would have an IHT allowance of £700,000.

There are also some additional exemptions if the family home is left to a relative. It's very complicated and if your mother's estate is of significant value you must get professional advice. Trying to save a few thousand in professional fees now will cost far, far more later on.

timarr

5
Avatar for Jonathan777

Hi timarr,

Thanks again for your fantastic response.

Yes, absolutely, my mother will get professional advice; it’s just great for me to learn a little bit more here in advance, so that hopefully I can have a more informed discussion if/when I get involved in any dialogue with the adviser. On this note, it strikes me that there are potential conflicts of interest... A financial adviser earning a percentage on any investments made as a result of his advice would, even if only unconsciously, be motivated to push BPR schemes as opposed to recommending my mother stay in cash after the house sale. Does that make sense? Or am I being unduly cynical here...? Are there any IFAs who charge a flat fee and therefore have nothing materially to gain from the client moving out of cash and into one of these peer-to-peer lending schemes?

There are a couple of other things that strike me regarding your very helpful answer. (1) Is it a red flag for a small business to go to a peer-to-peer lender rather than to a bank? Does this smack of desperation? And (2), while the loans are secured to assets/property, it would presumably still be possible to lose a lot of money if the value of the assets plummets in the event that the business fails or the economy deteriorates significantly?

Jonathan

1
Avatar for dmjram

"A financial adviser earning a percentage on any investments made as a result of his advice would, even if only unconsciously, be motivated to push BPR schemes as opposed to recommending my mother stay in cash after the house sale. Does that make sense?"

Which is why the FSA changed the rules with the Retail Distribution Review and financial advice is now predominantly fee based - you pay an hourly rate rather than a % of the sum invested in commission from the product recommended.

You need to check which products the FSA you choose to see is looking at and advising on for you - many offer a restricted range and don't cover the whole market. 

2
Avatar for timarr

All IFAs are now fee based, I believe. I'd anticipate this type of scheme would be quite expensive, but potentially the IHT savings are enormous on a large estate.

Small businesses have many reasons for seeking alternative funding lines - those may include desperation, but bank lending policies are hemmed in with all sorts of restrictions, plus the tendency to withdraw cover when most needed. Many small business owners don't trust the banks, and there is a legitimate and thriving market in alternative lending approaches. I doubt that directly lending to small businesses is the appropriate approach here, it's more likely to be a collective model. However, I have no experience to offer on that, it would be a discussion via the advisor.

And, yes, of course it's possible the assets won't cover the debt. There are no free lunches. However, you'd want a margin of safety - you wouldn't want to be lending up to 100% of the underlying asset value.

timarr

2
Get the free newsletter