Quick n dirty report: Trading platform relative satisfaction
On the 4th December, I invited the readers of the Small Cap Value report to share their experiences of the platform they use to trade. 123 investors responded and completed the brief online survey by 9am on the 5th December.
The summary findings are as follows:
1. Trading frequency
Perhaps unsurprisingly given they are readers of Paul and Graham's blog, the majority are 'frequent traders". For the trading platforms, this readership therefore is gold dust, as frequent traders represent the most attractive and profitable segment of the market.
"On average I trade" (123 respondents)
| Daily | 11% |
| Weekly | 41% |
| Monthly | 49% |
None traded less frequently than this.
2. Which trading platforms do you use mostly to trade?
- 17% iii/TD Direct
- 16% Hargreaves Lansdown
- 13% AJ Bell/Youinvest
- 10% Barclays
- 10% IG Index
- 7% Selftrade
- 7% i web
- 4% The share centre
- 3% i dealing
- 2% XO
- 2% Charles Stanley
- 2% Halifax
- 2% Lloyds
- 2% Alliance Trust
- 1% Internaxx International
- 1% Bank of Scotland
3. How long have you been using this platform as your primary trading platform?
The vast majority have been using their preferred platform for 3 years+.
- 74% 3 years +
- 19% 1-2 years
- 2% More than 6 months less than a year
- 4% Last 3-6months
- 1% Less than 3 months
4. Relative satisfaction and intention to switch (or not).
I asked five questions about how they rated the following: : Ease of use; Customer service, market information, market prices achieved and value for money. I then asked if they had considered leaving their provider recently.
There seem to be gripes about every supplier, often related to very specific issues. But there are clear patterns relating to individual providers.
- iii/TD Direct (17% of respondents), it scored the average for ease of use, customer service and value for money but below average for market information and prices achieved. Customers seem torn about whether to stay or leave after the recent acquisition of TD by iii with some 29% saying they'd leave but 38% saying they'd stay.
- Hargreaves Lansdown (16% of respondents) scored above average on four measures but was let down by its value for money. It was 1= for ease of use. The loyalty of its customers was extremely high with 70% saying they had not considered leaving and only 10% saying they had.
- AJ Bell/You invest (13% of respondents) also scored above average ratings for four measures but was let down by prices achieved. Its market information had the best score out of anyone.
- Barclays (10% of respondents) comes out worst across all 5 measures.. Compared to the others, customer service was appalling, ease of use not much better nor value for money. So not surprising that 75% of customers are considering leaving them and none saying they would stay! This is entirely because of the recent changes to the platform
- IG Index (10% of respondents) performed well for market information and value for money, average for customer service but below average for ease of use and prices achieved. 33% of customers said they were considering switching to another provider and 25% saying they would not.
- Selftrade (7% of respondents) is another platform which has recently changed its website to some poor customer reviews. Ease of use and customer service performed badly however market information and prices achieved performed well. Its customers seem to want to stay with them, 67% saying they had not considered leaving and 22% saying they had.
- iweb (7% of customers) scored above average on all 5 measures and was the best performer for value for money and prices achieved. This put it at the top of the leaderboard for the average score across all five measures. When asked if they had considered leaving, only 33% expressed an opinion, the lowest number to do so, which suggests their customers were not that interested in the question.
- The share centre (4% of respondents - NB small sample) scored the highest for customer service and was 1= for ease of use (alongside Hargreaves). It was third best for value for money and seemed to have the most loyal customers, with none saying they considered leaving. However market information and prices achieved were well below average.
- The sample sizes for the rest were too small to be able to report upon. However Lloyds and XO seemed popular.
5. If you did leave, which provider would you switch to? (115 respondents)
This is a hypothetical question and so the answers should be taken accordingly.
- 23% said they would move to Hargreaves Lansdown
- 16% to AJBell/You invest and 16% to IG Index
- 6% to iii/TD Direct
- 5% to i web and 5% to The Share centre.
- The sample sizes are too small for the rest but Charles Stanley, DeGiro and Spreadex were also mentioned by a few people.
I hope this is useful. Do please 'Like' this post if it is.
cheers
Francis
Declaration: I am currently with Selftrade and I have no commercial interest in any of the companies discussed above
Disclaimer
This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

82 comments
Don't know if this has been discussed before but I am concerned about security of any cash holdings in a broker account in the event of the broker or banks they hold funds in having problems.
Because I am a little nervous of the markets and of the possibility of a 2008 type scenario , I am 80% in cash in my interactive investor account . The cash held is well above the deposit protection scheme amount.
I wrote to interactive investor regrading the risk and this was their reply;
"The firm adopts a robust Treasury Management Policy and places client
money across a range of approved banks where they are held in trust within a
client money bank account. As the client money is pooled there is no way to
know where client A's money is. It may not be the same place as client B due
to the pooled nature when it is received.
Should one of the banks fail where client cash is held - say £20m,
this money would be assumed unrecoverable from a secondary pooling event and
each client who had deposited funds with the firm would share in this loss
pro-rata. However, these clients would be able toclaim via FSCA up to a
maximum of £85k "
Just wondering do most of you split your funds into several different broker accounts to try and mitigate this risk as I am now considering?
Hi
I do - probably unlikely but gives another level of safety - also means a bit of "testing of the market" every so often as detailed above.
Phil
On the basis of the UK government being more solvent that banks, I try to move cash into gilts. Gilts are very liquid so can be easily sold when the cash is required.
Quick update on some thoughts -
III/TD - this merger has now completed with III taking on TD's platform. Quarterly fees are up slightly and the FX charge is up from 1% to 1.5%. Most stocks below the FTSE 350 won't allow dividend reinvestment anymore. More international markets now and you can hold foreign currency in your account. On balance, though, I am surprised that the merger has resulted in lower service (less dividend reinvestment) in some areas and higher fees. III were one of the cheapest around. The III quarterly charge is also a trading credit. So if your trading costs came to the quarterly charge you would have no fees. This is a key difference with other platforms. However, this merger with TD doesn't really appear to have benefited clients versus the previous status quo.
Youinvest/AJ Bell - This does feel like a nice platform and you get shares magazine. FX charge for foreign dealing is 1% (not tiered). Offers lifetime ISAs. The mobile app and news service is very good in my view. Hargreaves Lansdown appear to contract out the news function or just link to other providers.
Hargreaves Lansdown - As has been noted a few times here you only have the 0.45% platform charge on funds. For stocks there is no ongoing charge. So actually Hargreaves may be a competitive platform. However, the trading costs are slightly higher than rivals.
Execution - this survey highlighted dealing executing (Price). I am not sure how this can really be measured from a survey? In reality I would have to have a few different accounts and do a trial order for something at the same time to see which platform could execute it for the best price. I wasn't really aware that some platforms can execute at better prices?
FX - what is surprising to me is that III is now more expensive than Hargreaves on FX. This is due to the tiered FX charge structure as they are both 1.5% from £0 to £25k. So from over £50k to £100k the charge from III is 1% while from Hargreaves it is 0.5%.
http://www.iii.co.uk/foreign-exchange
http://www.hl.co.uk/investment-services/fund-and-share-account/charges-and-interest-rates
The tiered structure means that Youinvest will be cheaper for small deals, below probably around £70k or something, but the others might be better for larger foreign share deals. Youinvest charges 1% for all amounts.
Test - cost to buy £100,000 foreign stock with Hargreaves is £875 in FX i.e. 0.8745%. Cost with Youinvest is £1k or 1% and cost with III is £1,187 i.e. 1.19%. Very surprised that III has made itself a very expensive option on FX. By comparison IG is 0.3% and so charges £300 while Degiro I think is 0.1% or £100. Its a great shame that the mainstream platforms make foreign stocks too expensive to deal in.
I think I will try Degiro and maybe open an account with Hargreaves to see what they are like. Losing a lot of money just to buy a foreign stock doesn't really make much sense. We also have an annual capital gains tax allowance of £11k and the capital gains tax rate is only 20% (not too onerous).
I think Hargreaves Lansdown has done a good job at offering an alternative to expensive wealth managers. But the company is ridiculously profitable. The operating profit margin is 68% and the return on capital is 85%. It seems to me that they are unwilling to pass on the economies of scale that their growth has generated onto their clients in areas like FX and trading fees.
I can understand why people choose Hargreaves though. If you have had issues with things like Barclays Stockbrokers you will want to switch to the safest and most reliable company there is. It is similar to people choosing to go with Apple products after buying cheap PCs from companies like Dell.
According to their website, HL have a 0.45% custody charge on shares in either an ISA or a SIPP (max £45 per annum). It's only the vanilla share dealing account where there is no share custody charge at all.
ISAallowance. Fair enough but the £45 cap is pretty low. So anything over £10,000 and your percentage fee is less than 0.45%. The III standing charge is £22.5 a quarter or £90 a year. Although that does give you trading credits for the period. Pretty complicated assessing all these different fee structures!!!
Not sure how safe Charles Schwab are long-term.Their debt seems to keep creeping up.
I recently completed the transfer of my ISA and my wife's ISA from Barclays to HL. I was told by four different members of Barclays staff that we could not buy nor sell throughout the time it took to complete the transfer which was something of the order of 12 weeks.
More on Charles Schwab- forgotten points:
1 You get an automatic margin facility based on the realisable value of the securities held i.e. you can invest more than the capital you lodged by borrowing against it . Useful if you want to increase the portfolio in the short term without funding Dollars. The interest rate is a bit heavy - it depends upon how much you borrow; 7.5% p.a. was my initial rate until I bargained them down.
2 You can short stocks if you self-certify as a knowledgeable investor: useful if you think the market or a stock will decline
3 Their options pricing is very clear and bid-offer quotes are very clear and available at a key strokes, as are various option strategies. You can also trade VIX options - useful if you think US market volatility will increase or decrease .
4 They do not permit Futures trading.
5 Their bond trading and research facilities are USD and US centric with no other possibilities. And the bonds are all or almost all Investment Grade so debarring the most interesting sectors e.g. Emerging Market Debt and Junk Bonds.
In case anyone has significant US trades, FYI I find Charles Schwab excellent. They have a London office.
I have used them since 199 ie. over 20 years with only a rare problem that was solved quickly and efficiently.
Everything is done via their system but if you need help there is a call centre accessible via a freephone number.
I am a great fan of ADRs which allows one to invest in major companies around the world with the only currency used being USD for investment and dividends.
Completing a W-8 reduces your withholding tax to 15% which can be used against your UK Tax
Commissions paid are $4.95 - $ 13 per sizeable.trade.
The best part is their research facilities which is excellent.
Hi Star8
Many thanks for your useful and clear description of Charles Schwab service.
I've heard several good reports about it and have been looking for a good service to increase my US-based investing.
Regards
Howard
If you invest $50,000 in your account you will get the first 50 trades free, this is such a saving over my broker, I calculated over £1,000.
Hi Herbie
Top tip, many thanks. A definite task for me over the next couple of weeks.
By the way, have you got a Euro-based account for your Euro-EU trades by any chance or do you do those in sterling via your platform (if I recall you are also HL, like me)?
Regards
Howard
No I'm still using HL for Euro stocks, have been thinking about IG but still undecided. Will wait until next tax year. Not keen on this new IG charge if it is correct, £25 per quarter.
Herbie
Ok, like you I'll carry on thinking about that then.
Thanks
Howard
Well I prefer to trade within an ISA but I don't want to move my ISA, so if I open a new ISA next April I can buy Euro ones within that and compare prices with HL. I think having several ISAs is probably a good idea rather than all with one broker.
Herbie
That's a useful idea, I had not thought it through like that. I like it.
I feel I have too much with HL and want more than a single platform as well as dollar and/or Euro accounts to build a more robust trading infrastructure for myself (Recalling Barclays issues, likely volatility of sterling-based assets and a desire to extend across markets).
Regards
Howard
I've moved my ISA's a few times XO to iWeb, XO to IG, IG to iWeb. Cash and stocks, so far without any problems, usually takes 4 to 6 weeks to complete. You can still trade your holdings up to a point when they actually move them. An obvious problem with this is that you lose your original book cost but I use a spreadsheet for this. So to anybody reading this, if you are having problems with a broker don't be afraid to move.
Having more than one ISA is a good idea as it acts a backup and also gives you the chance to try another provider.
Thanks for that, I have read some horror stories when people have moved from Barclays and HL. But I quite like the idea of 3 different platforms then I can choose the best one for each trade. I presume I can just move cash out of one into another?
With different platforms I can check live prices and compare. Is HL better than IG or AJ Bell? Are IG really that bad for Aim shares as some report?
When I did this first I wanted a second ISA so I moved some cash from XO to iWeb I then moved all cash and stock from XO to IG and then all cash and stock from IG to iWeb. You need to check what you can do with each broker and make sure they understand if you are just doing a partial move. What you don't want them to do is sell your holdings if you wanted them to move the holdings intact.
Yes I had that problem when I moved from Natwest to HL, I was informed they had to sell everything, it took ages and the information about the sales was a long time after the move and not at all clear. But anyway a fresh start at HL been there about 4 years now.
I'm strongly considering them for my US investments. But one question, can I transfer money in £ or do I need to send it in US$s?
I only transferred money once at the start of the account in 1996 and do not remember how it was done whether is USD or GBP - I suspect the former since we had substantial Dollars. Judging by the rest of their service I would guess it was at a reasonable rate and I am surevthey will accept Sterling.
However rather than guessing I suggest you contact them. Speak to the manager Mr Kully Samra
Address: 33 Ludgate Hill, London EC4M 7JN
Hours: Open today · 9am–6pm
Phone: 020 3795 2704
Regards
Michael
Hi Michael,
Thanks for all that info. I not looking to do it just yet maybe early next year, I don't work or live near London anymore. I will contact them about the transfer in due course.
I am also with HL but thanks to you are now considering Schwab for my USA portfolio.
As an addition to Herbies question if it is sterling is their exchange rate competitive? The only problem I have with HL is that the exchange rate on foreign trades is a rip off although they claim it is the marketmakers and not them. Presumably with Schwab dealing in dollars this could produce quite a saving?
Also do they send you an account tax statement at YE, HL do and very convenient for dealing with the Revenue.
Thanks.
I realise this isn't a suggestion thread, but still on topic... Is there any mileage in using the folios to cost/suggest the cheapest brokers. There are plenty of comparison sites around that will show you what various platforms will do based on putting in basic details about how many deals a year you do, fund amounts etc, but they can be taken with a pinch of salt. Price structures are usually way more complicated than basic numbers will allow for. They don't take into account regular dealing discounts for example, if your deals are done over a short time. It seems to me, being able to see your actual trading habits throughout the year, a better comparison could be done. Think "With today's pricing, it would have cost £x.xx less with this platform...". Something on the analysis page perhaps.
Of course it still doesn't take into account customer satisfaction or the features you might miss by moving, but this site is supposed to be an aid to doing your own research. Nothing wrong with wanting some more accurate stats to help with that. It could generate a bit of extra revenue for you guys from click-throughs if you put links on.
Are IG introducing a £24 quarterly custody fee?
I was about to switch one of my ISA broker accounts from to IG when I found this comment on the Monvator site ...
Can anyone confirm or add more info?
Have not seen that email, nothing today. The one on 11th Dec did not have anything about it either.
Re rumoured IG custody fee,
I've just signed up for a demo account so I could post in the support section. Unfortunately when I tried to do so I got a HTTP Status 500 error. I'll try again later.
Hi
Does anyone else use the Beaufort Securities platform? It's one of the brokers I use.
(Let me state that I'm not massively concerned about what I'm charged, within reason, so long as it does what I want. This is probably due to my memories of pre-big bang when the commission and spread was eye-watering compared to what it is now.)
Their new "improved" platform came in mid October - I find it awful. I can no longer withdraw money from my account online, I have to ring them. A couple of weeks ago I wanted to buy a share - I couldn't find a buy button anywhere. It took them several days to reply that I had to go into "Market data", select a share and then I'd get a buy button. (I'm used to having execution only platforms having buy/sell up front, not hidden). Contract notes take 2 days to appear ..................
Am I being unreasonable or do other users feel the same way?
Phil
Phil
My experience with the new Beaufort platform has been equally bad. I have usually had to ring them for one reason or another to execute a trade, and then they wanted to charge me £40 on one occasion. I just called back and got a different trader.
I have dealing and ISA accounts accounts with Beaufort and two other online brokers, iDealing and Jarvis (X-O) which are much better. I will not be putting any more money (e.g. annual ISA allowance) into Beaufort.
Richard
New III terms & pricing starts this Monday, 11th.
Monday 11th (tomorrow as I write) is the day my ex-TDW, now III account is transferred to the new charging structure and terms. I don't know if it is the same date for everyone, but assume so. After much contemplation over the last few weeks I've just sent a message to let them know I'll be moving to another provider. Would have done it earlier this weekend but the site has been close for maintenance. I thought I'd mention it as a reminder to anyone still on the fence up to the last minute.
Lion Tamer - I take it you are moving from TDW/III to IG? I was thinking of doing the same. On paper IG looks really good. However, the interface is a trading type interface. They have just used their spreadbet/cfd trading interface and applied it to share dealing. It is full of flashing red/green numbers etc. So I am not sure I am really a fan of the IG interface despite the great FX fees of 0.3% and low dealing costs.
I think the leading platforms are probably AJ Bell and III at the moment. Hargreaves is the best if you are willing to pay extra fees and wants managed open funds. AJ Bell has an FX fee of 1% versus 1.5% for III and Hargreaves. The platform fee for funds at AJ Bell is 0.25% versus 0.45% for Hargreaves.
I looked at AJ Bell platform, I was not that impressed seemed similar to HL, had a few more items but then had quite a few missing such as latest trades and the 1 day share price chart, is it different if you are signed in? HL is 0.45% for ISA but caped at £45, for share account it's free. But yes I agree that the 1.5% forex fee is too high but not sure it's worth moving just for that. The other thing comparing is the actual prices you can get, I have read several comments about poor prices on some platforms, it's all very well saving on commission but no good if you are paying more to buy and getting less when you sell. This is only something that has several platforms can answer.
Thanks RatioInvestor. Yes, moving from TDW/III to IG, as this (on paper) looks next best after IWeb & X-O, both which I've already got. I'm not too worried about platform features, but thought I'd check out the interface with a demo account (since I wanted to post a support question on the community site anyway). Unfortunately the demo login only supports Spread betting & CFD. :-(
My understanding is that brokers used to make a significant proportion of their money from interest on cash in nominee accounts and this evaporated with low interest rates. Maybe the rise in interest rates might help them increase their income and mean further rises in charges may not be necessary?
Interesting poll, another question worth asking may have been on shareholder rights (voting etc.)
Doug (another CREST fan)
Reading Merryn Somerset Webb's MoneyMorning email yesterday titled "Batten down the hatches: a Corbyn government could be on the way" the final paragraph suggested that investors may need to take more of a Buy and Hold view as McDonnell has "promised" that there will be new taxes on financial transactions which could get expensive for traders.
This made me wonder how this would affect online platforms as most of them appear to make their money out of dealing fees.
Besides moaning about one's online dealers and all the irritations they throw in your way by changing their websites or at times being generally unhelpful, I am very aware that the alternative (old fashioned brokers who charge a percentage of your account every year as a fee as well as a percentage on every deal you do) is so much more expensive that we have to make sure the online dealers survive. I am obviously speaking as someone who invests in shares and investment trusts rather than unit trusts.
For example, an article in Investor's Chronicle in July - link below - said that the FCA was doing an investigation into DIY investment platforms to ensure they offered value for money as their charges can be confusing and lack transparency. (Which is rather what we have been discussing above). HOWEVER, in my view, we do have to be careful that they don't end up throttling the online platform industry with rules and regulations which mean that the platforms cannot afford to operate and as I alluded to above, we end up with more of an old fashioned system and higher charges.
https://www.investorschronicle.co.uk/managing-your-money/2017/07/27/fca-launches-probe-into-diy-investment-platforms/
Hopefully I am being over sensitive, but just looking at the bigger picture I personally think we have to work with these platforms to ensure we don't loose them. Careful what you wish for and all that ...
Santa
I'm considering a Charles Schwab account for US shares, I see they offer 50 free trades if you deposit $50,000 into your account, I calculated that would be worth well over £1,000 compared to HL transactions, that is a considerable saving. HL charge £11.95 and 1.5% Forex fee. Even without the free transactions it will be still be around £1,000 as only $4.95 (£3.70). Charges should be coming down, IG have low charges and there are cheap online ones in Europe. HL profits are soaring, they also have picked a quite a few ex Barclays investors, I think you are being over sensitive. I think HL make a lot from funds as well.
Santa
You are right! As well as online accounts I have a Killik account. Charming service, but the dealing costs of 1.5% per stock (from memory) are a little eye-watering if you are selling an investment of, say, 20k.
Barclays site is a bit frustrating but a £6 charge for an identical transaction makes me tolerant!
So we must be careful what we wish for.
Regards
There seems to be a real opportunity for somebody to get serious about offering personal CREST accounts. It comes up a lot but maybe that is just the vocal minority of private investors which obviously would be visible on this site.
But why in an online age is this so difficult to offer? My Australian holdings in NABtrade give me everything through Computershare, what is the problem in the UK?
It is time for a low cost disruption company, can anyone in the industry tell us why this has not emerged here?
Maybe Ed and the Stockopedia group can get this going?
Had a quick look at Robin Hood. I can't see how they make any money out of ordinary clients trading US stocks alone. That's a pretty big barge pole to me! Either there are charges I'm not seeing and they are not making clear, or they are not sustainable, or they expect to raise cash from me in unforseen ways in the future.
My brokerage costs are a very small %age of my portfolio. I don't have a problem paying them if I feel I'm getting a decent service and decent security. I'd need a lot of convincing that something like Robin Hood was worth handing my investments over to.
Peter
Had a look at them and they say how they make money: "With Robinhood Gold, you get up to 2x your buying power and access to after hours trading for as little as $6 per month. This is the only product Robinhood charges you for, and is completely optional. Trading is still commission free.
Additionally, Robinhood earns revenue by collecting interest on the cash and securities in Robinhood accounts, much like a bank collects interest on cash deposits."
Trading in the USA is much cheaper than the UK, I looked at Charles Schwab bank and the dealing fee is only $4.95, most US brokers are $4-$10, which shows just how expensive some of the UK platforms are. I do agree that Robinhood maybe not that secure. Reviews are mixed and it's only available on a mobile device.
Surprised nobody has mentioned Robin Hood (especially those based in the US and Australia) which I read about briefly a while ago.
Anyone any experience or update on them coming to the UK/Europe?
Just before everyone gets bored to death!!!! Some things on Hargreaves have previously put me off. They wouldn't offer Fundsmith before as Fundsmith doesn't pay any shared commission to them. They have been forced to offer Fundsmith due to its popularity but Hargreaves come up with reasons to not recommend Fundsmith. At the Fundsmith AGM every year they make a joke about the latest reason Hargreaves have for not recommending the fund (AGM's are online). Hargreaves proposed putting extra platform fees on Investment Trusts at one point in order to push their investors into open ended funds where they get ongoing commissions from the managers. There was a rebellion against this and they backed down. I think that their fund analysis is probably ok. But they have seemed to have been personality driven with Hargreaves going for Anthony Bolton in China and then hyping Neil Woodford.
I have therefore personally found the way Hargreaves Lansdown operates as not fantastic. I.e. they appear to be biased towards investment areas where they will get the most ongoing commission. Having said that they are the largest operator and will probably be the most reliable.
My Charles Stanley trading account has one stand out feature. It is a CREST account which means that:
* I am on my shareholdings share registers in my own name
* I receive all shareholder correspondence directly from the companies
* I can vote / attend AGM's without having to organise this through my broker
* in summary, I really own the shares, as a against the normal nominee arrangement whereby the broker owns the shares and allows me a beneficial interest in them
I would highly recommend this account except for one thing - Charles Stanley have stopped offering CREST accounts. Why? I don't know. The system is computerised so it should not create much extra work for the broker. And it would be a great marketing plus compared to all the other nominee accounts out there. I wonder if Charles Stanley would relent if enough prospective customers asked for CREST accounts
I didn't know that thanks! I'm not sure if they offered that service for Charles Stanley Direct customers as I have never received any correspondence, but seemed a neat feature nonetheless. I've been with CSD for a while and I have no huge issues with them - decent customer service, reputable and okish website. The problem I have is that they don't have any standout features given they are not at the cheap end of the market (£11.50 trading fee) and buying international shares is expensive. I see a lot of horror stories about transfers, which has probably made me just take the path of least resistance and stay; even though I know it makes sense to move...
I have an X-O account for my non-ISA purchases and am a big fan. Cheap and cheerful, and surprisingly good customer service for the fees you pay (no admin and £5.95 a trade). The few times I have had a difficulty placing a trade, they have called up the relevant market maker and got me a decent price, while not charging me extra for doing so.
One of things I like about the Share Centre is they have never brought in initiatives which annoy me. No mean feat in user interface land. I am a satisfied customer.
Jon
IG charge 2 cents a share minimum $15 commission on US stock as well as the 0.3% FX.
0.1% on EU stock min 15 commission. Sorry don't know where the Euro key is.
Many thanks fwyburd for this survey. The survey and all the comments are really useful. And they really show how important this is to so many investors.
First my situation and then a few comments (trying as much as possible not to duplicate what has already been said above)
I have broking accounts with Barclays, AJ Bell, TD Direct, Hargreaves Lansdown, Charles Stanley. Yes it's an awful lot and makes things complicated. They are all there because at different times each had a major plus point for which it was worth opening an account.
Barclays is by far my biggest account. Until the recent move to "Smart Investor" Barclays were my favourites for everything except funds. Now ??? But the idea of being locked out and unable to trade for weeks / months makes me very nervous about moving. So I am going to stay for now:
* until they have proved that the new system is good enough
* or until the backlog has cleared and I can move relatively quickly
Achieved price - Barclays has always been very good on this (and still is). I often get prices well within the spread, sometimes even at mid price, often saving £20, £40 on a trade vs. the buy price. But it is almost impossible to compare achieved price savings between brokers. Just putting in one bid will affect the price offered when you try again on another platform
Fund pricing - I did a detailed comparison a couple of years ago (out of date now). The different brokers had different platform prices and also offered different fund classes for the same funds. And each fund class has a different management fee. Combining the platform and fund management fee, AJ Bell came out significantly cheaper than Barclays (as they were) and Hargreaves Lansdown
Confusion marketing - I think the technical term for the mix of different pricing bases is "confusion marketing". The overall result is that it is almost impossible to work out which platform is cheapest without a spreadsheet, a few spare days and lots of aspirin.
Recommended funds lists - I worry about the "recommended funds" offered now by many of the platforms (HL, Barclays Smart Investor...). Do they really know which funds are best? Do fund rebates from the fund supplier influence the choice. E.g. the Slater Growth fund was left out of lots of recommended funds lists despite consistent excellent performance
Research - We all use Stockopedia. Some of us use Sharepad too. We all read Paul Scott and Graham Neary. Given the quality of the information available to us I wonder whether the brokers own research provides anything of value. I would be interested to hear what anyone else gets from the brokers research pages
Drawdown - there is lots of (confusing) information about SIPP charges. But how easy is it to find out the costs of drawdown, Choosing a cheap SIPP provider would make no sense if the drawdown fees turn out to be extortionate
Again lots of appreciation for this fascinating thread.
Hi
Firstly, a big thank you to Francis for putting this together and to all the contributors.
I won't bore you with my platform experiences, but would just like to pick up on your comment near the bottom about research. It has always rather confused me that platforms work hard on touting that they provide research.
I came to doing my own investing by subscribing at various times to MoneyWeek, Investor's Chronicle, FT, Morningstar (Hemscott as it was), as well as using the Trustnet website and MOST IMPORTANTLY to Stockopedia.
Therefore, I agree so much with your comment questioning the value of the advice from the platforms themselves. I certainly don't use it and wonder how much of our fees are going on it.
... but that's just me!
Santa
This has been a most useful thread. Thank you Francis for running the surveys and setting it up. One thing that surprises me is that investors are prepared to pay the cost, esp. fx, of trading internationally through a UK account. I do a small amount of trading in the US markets and use a Charles Schwab account, which I can highly recommend to anyone inclined to take that approach.
Depends how trading you do in the USA but for many in UK they prefer to deal within an ISA then you don't have to worry about tax. But it's something I will consider if I trade more in US stocks. Charles Schwab dealing fee seems to $4.95 which shows just how expensive some of the UK platforms are.
These are the best value providers for what I do:
ISAs
iWeb -£5 a trade, no platform fees, no annual fees, free-to-hold funds
Jarvis's X-O- £5.95 a trade for UK shares, no fees
Clubfinance- £4.95 a trade for UK shares, funds possible but not best value, trade three times a quarter to avoid the quarterly charge of £15
LISA-
AJ Bell's Youinvest
SIPP-
X-O for UK shares, £5.95 a trade, no fees, perhaps not ideal when you go into drawdown due to fees at that point.
DeGiro and Saxo are cheap for European trading, but they don't do ISAs.
iii is worth a look if you need an extra account to hold UK funds, etc.-£10 a trade. (There is an annual charge of some small amount if you don't trade 9 times in a year.)
IG is probably the cheapest ISA provider for European trading.
I don't mind what the platform looks like, or what is on it as I get my information elsewhere. I've experienced many minor customer service failures with many brokers, but only one was serious enough for me to lose my temper and close the account (Barclays-don't ask).
Laurie - What you are saying is literally correct but can anyone be bothered to have six different accounts? I do think that in reality international stock dealing is off the table if you have to pay 1.5% FX to buy and sell. That is 3% lost just to get in and out excluding dealing charges. One thing from the III/TD merger is that the III FX charge has gone up from 1% to 1.5%. It is a shame none of the large brokers apart from IG offer reasonable FX charges.
Saxo do have an ISA, I have one for European trading. I don't particularly like the user interface, I find it particularly unintuitive, but it's a useful extension to the markets offered by Youinvest and the Interactive Investor (ex-TDW) accounts that I otherwise use, and am happy with.
timarr
As a final point to my previous post. I think that the charges for lots of these platforms follow their business models. Hargreaves Lansdown I think gets rebates on funds. So its charges are setup to encourage people into funds. Hence the 1.5% FX fee. It is a similar story at Youinvest. If you buy a fund with Youinvest the cost is £1.5 but if you buy a stock it is £10. It is only IG and Degiro that don't offered open ended funds and so offer very low fees on FX and stock buying. The reality is that Hargreaves Lansdown probably don't want you to buy individual stocks. They provide research on funds for a reason. The fee structure is about pushing clients to where it is most profitable for them. This is why there is all the complexity on fee structures.
Very interesting discussion. There are a few things I think might be considered here.
1) There are two general fee structures: flat and percentage of funds.
2) Comparing fees is actually quite complicated due to the different structures. If you have a large portfolio you can save a lot by moving to a flat fee company like III. Some companies take fees from your portfolio which isn't great if you have ISA's. Other companies will leave that pot unchanged and take fees from your bank account. I think Youinvest takes fees from your portfolio while III doesn't. I prefer flat fees as you know what you are paying.
2) There are two general fee structures: flat and percentage of funds.
3) III/TD Waterhouse combination has resulted in a new fee structure from 11 December.
http://www.iii.co.uk/sites/default/files/pdf/II_RATE_STND_PDF_OCT17.pdf
4) To give one example of the complexity III will charge a quarterly fee of £22.5. But this can be used for trading commission credits. So if your trading commissions come to £22.5 in a quarter you effectively pay no platform fee. This appears to be quite a competitive offering in my view.
5) FX fees are generally 1.5% (III and Hargreaves Lansdown) but Youinvest charges 1% and IG charges significantly less. Youinvest offers access to lots of global markets. III and Hargreaves Lansdown offer Europe and the US.
6) Youinvest perk - if you have over £4k with youinvest by value you get access to Shares magazine for free (£125 a year if subscribing). As far as I can tell the Youinvest platform (AJ Bell) is pretty slick.
7) Hargreaves Lansdown boast that they offset their platform charge of 0.45% with lower commissions on funds. I.e. they bulk buy so get their clients better deals on funds. Some funds won't cooperate such as Fundsmith.
8) As I understand a selling point of Hargreaves Lansdown is that they undertake research on funds in house. They also have lots of journals they write to give their customers. So these added value services may be worth it.
9) On the fees side IG launched its service a while ago and I think it has undercut nearly all of the industry. However, I don't think they offer funds. The FX fee is listed at 0.3% versus the next lowest, Selftrade, at 0.5%. This is significant as buying US$100,000 of a US stock with Hargreaves generates a US$1,500 FX commission versus US$300 with IG. Just doing my research and IG do offer a SIPP. IG don't offer all international markets only 7 at the moment:
https://www.ig.com/uk/investme...
https://www.ig.com/uk/investme...
It is amazing to me that buying an international share with IG could be cheaper than buying a normal share with Hargreaves Lansdown. I understand why many people would choose Hargreaves as there is no question that it will remain solvent. They also boast that they answer the phone quickly.
FX is a real bugbear of mine with it feeling like a ripoff. DeGiro appears to be at 0.1% so that could be worth considering too. They don't appear to offer things like ISAs and SIPPs though.
At the moment I am thinking III for the bulk of my investments and Youinvest for to get Shares magazine for free and the Lifetime ISA (not available on III). Hargreaves Lansdown appear to have an opaque structure on charges. Some charges they have, such as 1.5% for FX, seem to be taking the mick. For my mind Hargreaves have ridiculously high profit margins and are milking their market leading position. Youinvest is impressive on the international markets it offers.
A general view is that this reminds me of a point made at an investor presentation. Most private investors have no idea what their annual return is (due to money going in and out over a period etc). I would guess most investors would have no idea of the fees they are paying due to commissions and the complicated structures. There are lots of comparison websites though where you can enter in what you did in a particular year and work out which platform would have been cheaper.
Any thoughts let me know!!! It does appear that there isn't necessarily a platform that is best for everything. As a generalist platform with relatively low fees I think Youinvest (AJ Bell) is ok.
It is important to miss that most people invest in funds although probably not most stockopedia subscribers. So for most people Hargreaves Lansdown may be best for them.
Thanks for all that info. The comparison link really brings it home to me the HL high fx fees:
Total cost to you on a US share trade of $5000 IG £22.17 HL £64.25
If you did 50 trades in a year, of around that amount, it would about £2,100 difference.
Big thank you from me too for this survey.
I’d just consolidated wife’s and my ISA and share accounts into Barclays when they lobbed the grenade, and each of us have seven figure totals so their insane charges are relevant. We will get out when the dust settles, Ann also take our current account. If anyone writes a book on how to upset customers Barclays is an excellent example.
I’ve dipped my toes into iWeb so far which comes out of your survey quite well. Wonder though if we should pay to have a real stockbroker now, as other half might have problems when I pop off, however difficult to trust anybody. How about a comparison of personal brokers, or is that impossible?
I use Iweb, Share Centre & Alliance Trust for my own accounts and for accounts I run for my mum for IHT - so all in AIM.
IWeb
VERY cheap - £25 to open an account and £5 per trade; no annual fee. And that's it. But it's completely no frills. No backup telephone dealing service if you can't get a quote etc. There is a charge of £2 to set up a limit order - but refunded if the trade goes through. And Mum wasn't able to grant me dealing rights - "Get her to give you her login details" was the advice.......
Share Centre
Low, fixed charges - Dealing a/c £21.60 pa, ISA £57.60 pa. Dealing costs vary - with a frequent dealer option (£96 pa - per account holder, not per account), trades cost £7.50, or £5.75 if you hold a few share plc shares. Support is absolutely first rate.
Alliance Trust
More expensive & complicated, but good access to the dealers - and, if you contact them because there is no quote available, no telephone surcharge. On v useful feature is the ability to trade across several accounts simultaneously - my mum holds 6 accounts for her grandchildren which she wants to be absolutely identical. But it's expensive - and I may be referring them to the Ombudsman re their misleading literature.
Thanks for setting up the survey - v interesting!
Great information, many thanks Francis.
What I don't understand is why the more expensive brokers are so popular when the survey shows the cheaper brokers give an excellent service.
IWeb for example, apart from a modest joining fee there are no fees for trading or ISA accounts and trading is only £5 a time. This is the best of the brokers I've used in the past or currently.
X-O too small to report data in the survey but is also cheap; no fees for trading or ISA accounts and trading is only £5.95 a time. However the X-O platform is a bit basic.
IG looks good on paper too.
Disclosure: I currently have accounts with I-Web, X-O, and TDW/iii (for historical reasons but after the recent price hike I'm now going to drop, most likely in favour of IG).
Established brands can charge more because customers trust them more; smaller less well known or established firms, however good they are at what they do, for whatever price, are less trusted.
Thinking rationally, you would think that everyone would go for the cheapest. But we are not rational in our decision-making because there is risk in every purchase we make. And many purchase decisions involve mitigation of risk which helps people feel better about their decision.
So many people (not everyone, as we do not behave homogeneously) are prepared to pay a premium for a higher priced service which may not be as good as a cheaper one in the belief that the risk of something going wrong will be less (and if it does, it will get sorted).
So I was not at all surprised to see who the most popular providers are.
Francis
What I don't understand is why the more expensive brokers are so popular when the survey shows the cheaper brokers give an excellent service.
I didn't understand this either until I experienced a complete lack of response from customer service from my current broker; this is a repeated pattern for me - move for price, leave after repeated customer service issues - my conclusion is that maybe it is time to pay for customer service. This led me on a path to define what I wanted and a search to find out who could deliver it; customer service by now a slightly higher priority from when I had no need of it. For context I've been with my current broker (iDealing) since 2002 in addition to Comdirect, Selftrade (until Equiniti) through various incarnations and my wife is with Hargreaves Landown. I'm sure there were probably a few others I used occasionally that I now can't recall.
My criteria for a SIPP turned out to be:
Orders: Rising buys/stop buys and trailing stop loss
Markets: UK and Europe equities - funds nice to have but not important - so a tiebreaker
Currency: Hold in UK and local currency to avoid FX charges except when I choose to convert
Platform: Web and mobile - easy to use
Charges: Acceptable but not extortionate based on 0-50 trades per annum.
SIPP Administrator: prepared to move if broker requires.
I've gradually created a very short list of prospects* by striking through those that don't meet my needs and it is clear to me that if I want order types I use, customer service and separate currency in one account, I'll have to pay for them. Or having solved my customer service issue with one phone call (should have tried that first) I may stick with a reasonably cheap service.
*Currently Saxo bank or Interactive Brokers but a few others still to review. Suggestions / comments welcome.
@HumourMe - you have a good methodology, good luck with whoever you select.
Here are some comments on my first hand customer support experience with two brokers, in case this is helpful to anyone reading this...
I-Web
I used their support when helping my mother sort out APS ISA allowance after my father passed away, and they were excellent. Quick to answer each time, good advice, friendly, prompt to send documents in the post.
X-O
I used their support on a couple of occasions, to do with SIPP contributions not appearing in my account and to ask for a missing SIPP tax credit. Support was okay compared to long-since-defunct brokers I've used in the past. However I was disappointed I had to ask for support on these issues in the first place. My SIPP is the X-O Liberty one, not the same as the SIPP partner X-O currently use, so hopefully new SIPPs may be run more efficiently.
IG allow you to hold foreign currency in a local account so you can choose when you wish to convert back to sterling. Also aside from the mobile app they have an IG Academy app which is good fo learning.
I don't think you can do that with an ISA though. But yes it is good facility. My concern with IG is the limited markets and some people have mentioned poor prices.
Thanks for your efforts!
The three most surprising things for me (based on my own broker experiences) was that only 75% of Barclays customers are thinking of leaving (in light of the recent changes, which are quite frankly atrocious for customers). I can only assume the other 25% mis-clicked when completing the questionnaire.
Second thing was that HL scored so low on value for money. I recently transferred one of my accounts to them (have a wild guess from who), and HL don't charge any yearly fee for an ordinary share account and a cap of £45 pa on ISA fees. Which fee wise is about as cheap as you can get (or that I could find). And their dealing fees are about as industry standard as it gets.
Thirdly is that HL scored so highly for their platform. As it's really far from the greatest, and outright stupid in places. Such as not being able to switch from a regular trade to a limit trade without re-inputting all the data, which is a serious negative IMO, especially when time is of the essence (and I have never seen this before with any platform. Switching trade type should never require complete data re-entry). So two strange scores for me with HL. Especially the value for money since I don't know what more people could really want in relation to fees and dealing charges (unless they expect free stuff).
I'm with Barclays, and I'm remaining there.
It's perfectly true that they made a complete mess of the recent transitions - but I've been (and am still) with other brokers who made a mess of systems changes (none quite as bad as Barclays it's true), but it's pretty much par for the course in my experience. All brokers change systems at some time - either ownership changes or they think change is good for its own sake. Every time it happens it's a stressful and unpleasant experience. Against that the service over the past 15 years or so I've been with them has been generally good - they get good prices, they do administration (offers/letters of representation etc) efficiently (when not swamped by recent problems of their own making). They've been understandably slow to respond to complaints immediately after the change over, but now things have settled down they have responded reasonably.
The bottom line is that I don't see Barclays as fundamentally different than anyone else - in normal times they are better on some issues and worse on others - one of the reasons for having several brokers. It's certainly not worth the time and hassle to move and be locked out of my account for 6 weeks or so - even at good times.
Had the question been asked 9 months ago, or after the middle of next year I'd expect Barclays to have got a very different rating.
Peter
@peterg
Don't the new fees, for both ISA and Investor accounts, increase as the value increases? With the cap set at an insane £125 per month (£125 per month!!). I saw this as basically just a tax on successful investors and payable to Barclays (rather than to HMRC).
So interested to know/learn/understand what I might have missed that makes Barclays worth such extortionate fees. As you say:
"the bottom line is that I don't see Barclays as fundamentally different than anyone else"
but those new fees put Barclays well and truly in a league of their own (in regards to charging ridiculous fees).
Edit - Links to Barclay's ISA and Investment account fees (identical fees for both)
IA - https://www.smartinvestor.barc...
ISA - https://www.smartinvestor.barc...
For ex Barclays Stockbrokers customers fees are capped to £200pa for 3 years minimum. If they have any sense they will extend that in time, and to other customers.That is a significant increase, but trades costs have dropped by 50%, and everything else is now included - including any transfer out fees should I decide to move in the future. Given the amount I trade I will still pay more but it's much less than the headline increase, and as a proportion of my account it's tiny.
Peter
I can't recall seeing mention of the £200pa cap for existing customers before. Neither in the pack they sent out, nor in my conversations with them when I was tying to get some incentives from them not to transfer out. Plus while Barclays was delaying my two account transfers (Ordinary Share and ISA) they charged me £168 for the privilege of waiting (which were fees for two accounts for Sept, Oct, and ISA for Nov). If there is a (vastly reduced) cap of £200 for existing customers then that certainly softens the blow a lot. But IMO that still doesn't justify the huge (and unjustifiable) fees that new customers are going to be facing.
And trade costs haven't really dropped by 50% because they dropped by that amount previously if you traded regular enough as part of the sliding price scale (that HL and TDW/ii and several other brokers use). So you're only saving upto the point where trades would have reduced to £6 anyway Which was either 20 or 30 trades per quarter IIRC. And if I'm nitpicking here, then I'll point out that trading prices have actually increased because the price for frequent traders used to be £5.95 compared to the £6 it is now.
So after the point the previous frequent trader discount kicked in, you're actually paying more for trades now than you were before. And the new prices are not even good for infrequent trades because then the saving in trading costs (since you'd be unlikely to hit the full frequent trader discount) is far outweighed by the huge increase in account fees. So you need to trade more to take advantage of the reduced fees (which aren't real anyway) in order to compensate for the increased account fees. But that increased trading frequency would have led to the same (better!) discounted rate before anyway.
It was some months ago I calculated the figures, so I could be off here, but IIRC I worked out that you'd need to be placing something around 15 trades per quarter, and have <£50k in total account value across all accounts (and at all times, as if it goes up you're charged more) for the new prices to be in your favour. Anything above these and you're worse off now than before.
If you're happy with Barclays then that's cool, and best of luck with them (especially when the time comes to extend that cap). But AFAICT you have to be operating within a very narrow set of criteria to not be worse off (and maybe far worse off) in relation to fees and charges. Although I readily concede the abolition of transfers out fees is certainty in the customers favour, and the only single good thing about my recent transfer out experience (but then I was charged £168 in fees via another method, so no transfer out fees is another illusion because they'll still charge you account fees during the process, which they then drag out as long as possible).
I am with Barclays for ISA's despite not being happy and the anguish of having transferred my SIPP is stopping me moving at present. However, as far as fees are concerned the account cost is 0.1% of portfolio value so you would need well over £1M with them to incur £125 per month charges if you stick to shares.
The point isn't the value you'd need to hit the £125 cap, it's that the monthly cap is so unjustifiably high fullstop. I'd imagine most customers aren't going to get anywhere near the cap, but that's a very bad thing because it means there's plenty of scope underneath it for ever increasing customer account fees because fees will increase as the value of the portfolio increases, and entirely because the cap is so high.
For comparison HL's cap is £3.75 per month. So just pause and think about that for a moment. £125 vs £3.75.
That difference is simply criminal. And even if most people are nowhere near £125 and are paying say £30-40 a month, that's still a huge difference, and plenty of room for fee increases (if their portfolio value increases) precisely because the cap is £125 (rather than something less criminal like £25 per month).
"For comparison HL's cap is £3.75 per month. So just pause and think about that for a moment. £125 vs £3.75."
Yes it's £45 cap pa for ISAs. For share accounts it's free. As I said before though funds are not capped so if you have a lot of funds HL may not be the right platform for you. I don't know what Barclays charges. Is Barclays £200 cap per account, inc. funds?
Peterg is probably in a better position to answer this than me (and more knowledgeable about Barclay's current fees).
But (from my earlier link) Barclays charges double for funds what it does for shares (0.2%pa vs 0.1%pa). I assume that the cap (£125 per month) covers both shares and funds, but don't quote me on that (and please don't anyone rely on this for anything of any importance without checking first).
I had never heard of the £200 pa cap before Peterg mentioned it today (not even from Barclays during my talks with them). But that discounted rate is for existing customers only according to Peterg. As far as I can tell the yearly cap for new customers is £1,500.
Herbie,
The Barclays cap - for existing customers is £200pa, for all accounts.
Though it doesn't affect me, HL may be cheaper for stocks, but it is more expensive for funds, as you say. Barclays charges 0.2% pa for funds (with the somewhat high cap that has been mentioned). HL has no cap on fund holdings fees, and charges 0.45% up to £250,000, 0.25% up to £1m, so someone who holds largely funds would be paying a lot more with HL than Barclays (even if they are a new, uncapped, Barclays customer)
More generally, we have seen a number of management fee increases recently - and I'd be pretty sure we will see more. Execution only brokers have survived on a business model of trading commissions paying for a large part of their costs, and relying on at least some customers trading frequently. At times when PI trade frequencies drop they struggle. Others have low fees but tie customers in with high transfer out fees, and charge for things like letters of representation if you want to go to an AGM, which Barclays don't.
I think the relatively free ride that LTBH investors have had from execution only brokers is likely to be increasingly challenged in the future.
Peter
Well value for money is the trade costs, which are £11.95 per share deal, some brokers are much lower. Also the forex charge of 1.5% is too high, therefore I only gave them 3. Believe their fund charges are quite high also. Other issues are no trailing stop losses and no stop losses or auto bids on foreign shares. Other issue it defaults to the share account when dealing sometimes, so i have bought 2 shares that have ended up in up not in my ISA. There have been other issues recently such as some shares price charts only going back to May 2017 and incorrect prices being displayed. So for me to give them a higher value rating they need to cut the their share dealing fees and reduce the forex charges, that is why I considering switching.
Thanks for the reply herbie (this is regarding HL fees / value for money yes?)
HL's trading fees are comparable to TDW/ii (and Barclays before the recent changes), and reduce with frequency, which is a fairly common pricing structure I think. Other brokers do offer cheaper trading fees fullstop though. I rarely trade forex so certainly bow to your experience and views on that one.
I see the other points you raise as being about the platform more than the fees / value. Although I can't remember exactly how the questionnaire question was worded as to what was included in the definition of "value for money".
But I certainly agree with some of your points about the platform and research resources, and likely agree with them all once I encounter them for myself. I've only been using HL for just over a fortnight as the Barclays transfer took 4 months to complete due to their delays in crediting accounts with dividends. But from what I've seen so far the HL trading platform is pretty poor to say the least.
Which did surprise me since.it was rare to find any HL customer that wasn't universally singing their praises. And upon first using their platform I was led to expect as close to perfection as it gets. So the reality was certainly a let down. I even phoned them to inquire why they didn't allow limit orders based on value rather than number of shares and was told they'd never heard of such a thing?! So I'm starting to accept the likelihood of being disappointed with HL's platform rather than impressed by it over the coming months.
But I still see their fees as good value for money, but of course that goes down sharply if you include the quality of their platform as part of "value for money". Which I don't (but maybe I should).
Yes it's HL. I think on funds they charge 0.45% which is not limited, £100,000 will be £450 pa. £11.95 is not cheap and you have to trade more than 9 times a month to reduce that: 0 - 9 deals £11.95, 10 -19 deals £8.95, 20 or more deals £5.95. Quite a few brokers have lower fees. So for me value is only average if that. Yes some other points were to do with the platform. I'm considering opening new account with a different broker for foreign shares, HL is expensive and the spreads are not good either. I've had a few trading issues as well so HL certainly are not perfect. Just seen this: https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/www.hl.co.uk surprised how poor the reviews were.
I would agree that HL doesn't have a great platform, and on the fees point I'd agree they are generally quite low apart from FX fees which are way too high. Depends if you want to invest in foreign shares, but for me this was a big issue and basically the main reason why I left.
HL aren't the only broker to charge high FX fees (e.g. TD direct are high also), I find this quite annoying as it's basically money for nothing (although they may argue it covers some of the costs of offering foreign shares).
Wish DeGiro and Interactive Brokers would allow ISA's...
Very interesting - thanks for putting this together. Just need to point out that the spelling is Hargreaves Lansdown.
Thanks grb, I've amended the typos.