23
Archived articleThis is an archived article from 2018 - please note that any content within the article may be out of date.

SCS: Sofa so good baby

The end is nigh!

You know this right? Particularly if you sell soft furnishings to beleaguered lower income Brits. No brainer...to think otherwise makes you fo shiz a few tablespoons short of a teaspoon. Well baton down and button up...

SCS (LON:SCS) is a great stock and company. Yes, I mean Tony the Tiger grrrrrreat! Its not in the most glam sector and it ain't going to blow the bleeding doors off like a hot cakes online retailer (though many of those will burn up or fade away burning your capital for the journey). But is priced like it can't deliver anything whereas the reality is it will deliver more than enough. Whereas how many moonbeams are there for the online girls and boys to collect? And even moonbeams have a terminal growth rate....which cold dished reality could feel like a bit let down.

So, come on down and get your bargain SCS (LON:SCS) now. Okay, there is a the trading update for Christmas and key new year sales period to come at the end of the month. I don't have any good foresight on this however my guessestimate is further deterioration in the HoF based franchised outlets as HoF had a tough time whilst holding the LFL previously reported in SCS stores steady-ish at 3.6% as reported in AGM statement in Nov (that figure included 6.4% LFL decline in HoF stores which represents 6.2% of total order intake).

Worst case scenario is that there is a private equity take out or management lead LBO (that won't happen whilst current long standing CEO is there but could happen with the replacement).

Stockopedia does a good job on the financials as a summary as this is real straightforward crisp and clean stock from an accounting perspective. Net cash for FY 2017 is about £10m over stated as a result of timing differences in working capital so EV/EBITDA is more like 3.4x rather than 2.9x.

I've held the stock for about 18-24 mths now, read the historic reports and had a call with the CFO last Friday to improve my understanding of some things. It reassured me that this is a well run business by guys that know their customer and how to run the business.

There's a 40% stock overhang from private equity investor Sun Capital. On Friday the company bought 1.29% of mkt cap from Sun to place in employee benefit trust for future bonuses. I don't know the corporate finance ins and outs but SCS definitely has the cash pile and ongoing cash generation to buy all the remaining Sun stake back (approx £33m at today's price) over next few years whilst maintaining dividend and even opening more stores.

Operating margin at 3.6% is not astronomical and they can't reach peaks that DFS does, however the defensiveness of this margin and ability to avoid excess downside in it is important (all bets off if we have armageddon...but hey I'd look at some other stocks too for that problem). Defensiveness comes from 1) they are already servicing the less affluent Ds and Cs segment outside SE England which has felt the pinch since 2008, 2) Cash holding and negative working capital model, 3) suppliers are required to share the pain on pricing when costs tightens as it did after Brexit GBP fun (think Toyota industry chain management), 4) they'll cheapen materials to keep prices fixed (I assume particularly at the low price end of their offering) 5) no debt, 6) low basic wages with good bonus for sales, 7) low recurring investment needs, 8) extremely disciplined capital allocation from management.

Cash has outperformed earning recently and it is earning that will head towards cash as depreciation decreases. Relatively high depreciation relates to big burst of 39 long lease stores 2005-2007 (ahead of delisting to £1 buyout in 2008 as they got caught by financial crisis on technicalities of credit insurance...that is a lesson well and truly learned and influencing conservatism of management).

Some have worried about the 0% APR finance they offer. 46-49% of sales are financed. It costs them £17.5m a year to pay for this. So pulling out of 0% finance would hit headline sales....however with EBITDA at £17.5m there is a trade off here whereby the loss in top line does not necessarily damage bottom line. That said I haven't worked out the crossover point yet.

What really doesn't make sense for a stock like this is not to allow private investors to participate fully in investor and analyst presentations. Theses guys need a following from private investors given the size of the company. The institutional guys are a waste of time! Hey, SCS! Wise up and let us in on the info with the awful and lethargic 'big boys'....who couldn't give a damn about you by the way.

lavinit aka mojomogoz out
xxx

(there's more to say but out of time...ciao)

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

10 comments


Avatar for Blissgull

Looks about right to me. This is what Barclays offers business customers.

https://www.barclays.co.uk/business-banking/accounts/compare-accounts/

Remember the SCS figures cover a period prior to recent rate rises.

3
Avatar for abtan

Thanks for that. Very interesting and I had no idea.

Looks like their bank is Lloyds, who provided an interest rate of 0.05% for most of 2017-2018, which leads me now to question how they received so much interest!

On c£44m cash balance, a 0.05% interest rate works out at £22k for the year, rather than £220k reported.

https://commercialbanking.lloydsbank.com/commercial-terms/interest-rates-and-charges/interest-rates/

0
Avatar for abtan

I just took a look at the FY results released a few weeks ago by SCS (LON:SCS)

Everything looks almost too good to be true, even when factoring in:
- customer deposits of £12.2m (which was stagnant vs prior year ie YOY cash increase is a "real" cash profit)
- the possibility of losing HOF concessions

So in light of recent fraudulent accounts from a certain cake shop, I thought I would take a look at interest received in the year:

£205k interest on cash balances of c.£44m = 0.45%

Surely a company with such a high cash balance would get a better rate than I get at my local Nationwide? Does anyone else think this looks odd?

0
Avatar for mojomogoz

SCS (LON:SCS) is too good to be true...but it is true ;)

They went under in 2008 crisis. They were caught out by terms of a financial product and it being pulled on them by financial partner under duress (credit insurance I think) which then unstuck their financial offering with customers. This came on top of tough (but survivable in isolation I think) trading. They had also expanded too quickly opening a lot of shops a couple of years beforehand. Perfect storm and out they went bought for nothing by Sun Capital.

Sun refloated them a few years back. Same management in place and same sort of product but with an improved 'negative working capital' operating model. Sun also did Bonmarche Holdings (LON:BON). Interestingly, both companies were IPO'd well IMO. BON looks interesting too but I prefer SCS believing it to have a more durable and defensible against competitors business model.

They sold cheap sofas (I jest council estate chic) then and they do the same now. Most investors have some money and "aspiration", be they professional or private, and they probably just don't vibe the cheap necessity of SCS.

What will it take for market to give SCS a bit of love? Dunno. They have been executing very well in tough environment and get no attention. Obvs they could use the cash pile...and they will at some point. I see using the cash as a drive to double earnings. Then they have self generated growth on top of that both LFL and 30 target areas they want the right site (based on their analysis of their customer profile).

All in, I think I can get a triple without multiple expansion with much lower downside risk than most other stocks. What about the next half year performance? Well there's got to be a chance that earnings are flat or down after a good run in a tough environment. Consensus has them down 2.5% for FY19. Perhaps the stock will get cheaper as a result. This would be an unbelievable gift and I'd probably break my weighting limits to go for more.

Or I may just be deluded :)

2
Avatar for abtan

Interesting thoughts.

Are you concerned by the potential loss of HoF concessions?

By my rough calculations, and all else being equal, a loss of 7.1% of the top-line would lead to £3m PBT for the FY, or maybe closer to £5m without the £2m in performance-related bonuses that were paid out in 2017/18.

Still worth a buy rating IMHO, but the SP would probably drop on negative news.



0
Avatar for mojomogoz

I'd like a bit more info from them on HoF concessions in general. It made positive EBITDA contribution in 2016 for first time (2014 being initial development) and with c.10% growth in 2017 from HoF that went more positive. So the 10% step back in 2018 suggests back down closer to breakeven (going backwards is always more painful).

Costs of HoF have been expensed and then ongoing profit sharing agreement. As it stands they lose much more revenue than profits from reversal in HoF as they can cut relatively painlessly. I think mgt are very focused at SCS and will not let the cost of this drift too much...that said, HoF concessions were good idea (different demographic and location from retail park stores) so its possible they hold out on them with a bit of pain for a bit of time.

Note, that H2 2018 saw a slow down in negative sales pattern from HoF compared to H1 2018. Doesn't mean much but means not accelerating bad at the moment.

PS when I said triple I meant on a 3-5 years horizon factoring in cash generation and dividend. SCS isn't a moonbeam stock so not likely to suddenly catch fire although announcement on cash would move things a lot.

2
Avatar for mojomogoz

PPS despite my positivity on stock - I like to try and be longish horizon and not worry short term (I'm not a good trader on sustainable basis) - there's a decent chance of disappoint for H1 19 results due to tough comparison, tough UK retail and HoF. If you want your patisserie and eat it then you may get a great buying opportunity in next 6ish months

0
Avatar for matylda

Sure thing

0
Avatar for matylda

FinnCap have initiated coverage here today but as yet have not issued a note.

1
Avatar for mojomogoz

Groovy. If you read give us the highlights (I hardly ever read broker notes, maybe I should!).

A speculative bit of me wonders if this coverage is initiated by forthcoming corporate action with their cash pile that...hopefully nothing hubristic and more a huge buyback program. Like I said...speculative, not informed.

0
Get the free newsletter