44
Archived articleThis is an archived article from 2022 - please note that any content within the article may be out of date.

Stock Pitch - Royal Mail Group (LON:RMG)

While many investors sleuth around in the relatively uncharted waters of the AIM market, it is the FTSE 100 that has been leading the way in recent months, supported by a host of listed giants trading at relatively attractive valuations.

Yd2WcYAJyubidsLO-a27ouVSYgaU1NQVEusxeC6OYMijHxc4KSgLJuXjFdTgTqFx2xvZMofoBXQV2oALoRlQecyD7OTsedhA1gNmz5x_I7wE2tuBBUvBOD6wRYDQiHPfMHXx4w34

Royal Mail (LON:RMG) is one such company. The UK’s universal services provider delivers letters and parcels to 31 million UK addresses six days a week. This obligation results in a large fixed cost base but also a highly trusted brand (ranked in the top 10 of YouGov’s Best Brands 2021).

Despite its standing, the shares trade at 7.2x forecast rolling earnings, 5x trailing twelve month free cash flow, and just above 1x tangible book value. Pick a metric, and Royal Mail Group looks cheap.

But there are risks. That large cost base is a concern in an inflationary environment and, as one of the nation’s largest employers, wage inflation is a threat. Its privileged position as USP invites government scrutiny, and the group must keep workforce unions onside. It has its fair share of stakeholders.

Still, the new management team is confident in Royal Mail Group’s prospects and the strength of its balance sheet - so much so that it recently announced the return of some £400m to shareholders in the form of special dividends and share buybacks. That’s close to 10% of the current market cap.

This combined with a more than 5% forecast dividend yield, a Value Rank of 95, and a significant valuation discount to US peers such as Fedex and UPS begs the question of whether or not the shares are simply too cheap.

Royal Mail was pitched to the Stockopedia Investment Club on Tuesday the 18th of January at 496.5p.

01Qk2lXHS_a1Ihy6xJNvZNvIij3n_Ja1CxJcztCJavI9ZnZ2qyANO-Uaerchy1Piwfjv8VyTd4Qm_pZX1-nXnY27LyH1Irzd6lt57Yk_oL6_i1cv_hGYfhHfUKm5RepY6Mye_9HV


Profile

About the Stock:

Royal Mail Group (LON:RMG) operates in the Industrials sector, and is a part of the Freight & Logistics Services industry group.

Its shares currently trade 441.4p on the LSE Main Market. There are some 995,296,793 shares in issue and it’s nearly 100% free float, so the stock is extremely liquid.

The StockRanks are uniformly favourable for Royal Mail and the group is classified as an Adventurous Large Cap Super Stock. From a factor perspective, the group brings a lot to the table.

vk3XmuVhLATPp_54MtZPLRSJsVxQ-FockUlP99NRt-g29v-89cuoOGUNEIvO3ONmzDlSHXdHpz08vbps2JgGAe8ejB_Nn2ZwcWqAqTD9O3shpsw0gHELHcD1us33GRy2udkTKKZF

About the Opportunity:

Royal Mail shares are cheap relative to a lot of other stocks across multiple metrics.

XFkFdouQICnAmzdWH53xyKjgYTlO3tGGTqtA6CCTIpXcyeTB6krlXiUzGEFDaH_EQjjk1rzOp351q9gAI4_Udcv2d8Zd8QvAg20vBS6YUsf0IuvF3Qbrj67pIPt-swJKpkNqY-B_

If the group can generate revenue growth and realise the benefits of operational gearing, then its shares could materially rerate. Royal Mail reported its highest rate of revenue growth since IPO over the course of the pandemic, and its large fixed cost base (around 65% of costs) means further growth could have a large positive impact on profits.

The group is investing heavily to position itself at the forefront of a structural growth opportunity in international parcel delivery (driven primarily by ecommerce). The scale and duration of this shift remains hard to quantify, but even before Covid, the parcels market was growing at 3-5% per annum. Over the past two years, domestic parcels have grown at 15%pa.

On the other hand, increasing costs (if not mitigated by cost savings and productivity initiatives, as has been the case so far) have the potential to seriously dent profitability. People costs and fuel expenses are of particular concern given the inflation seen in these areas.

voLFw3j07rI3pcsXomHMepAaUq08wH1iY2WRu78uCIU5v6Z3xYQYtRPLN6_daj7UPrr7ZPmdLitutxM5T3DkORzv93unmcoLymVY-Vw9BEYX89ERQf-IJ1BnUwyBT0OrY17mFns3


Business & Model

What is the company history?

  • 1516 - established as a government department before being made available to the public in 1635.
  • 1840 - the Uniform Penny Post introduced, whereby a single rate for delivery anywhere in Great Britain and Ireland was pre-paid by the sender.

VuOsrjzoSBRU29nOeNRb7hERN7rw56YADUrjVQ83nxfcnZqI06sVos1F1vWiBWdMP6I_WCbAKfhHyCg-09RTvBQD5N0hDj0TtxSuJor1-f5kl3nUi0zJ1fhEmVfyO77nTDdnmVKq

Royal Mail Post Office Regulations handbill giving details of the Uniform Penny Post, dated 7 January 1840

  • 1968 - two-class postal system introduced, using first-class and second-class services.
  • 1969 - changed from government department to statutory corporation known as the Post Office.
  • 1971 - national postal strike over pay.
  • 1980 - British Telecom separated from the Post Office. Girobank sold to Alliance & Leicester in 1990. Royal Mail Parcels rebranded as Parcelforce.
  • 1988 - national strike over bonuses paid to recruit new workers in London and the South East.
  • 2013 - Royal Mail to be floated on the London Stock Exchange at 330p.
  • 2013 - the CWU confirms strike action in response to the privatisation. Resolved via settlement.
  • 2015 - the government announces it will sell its remaining 30% stake.

What are the key business segments?

The Royal Mail of today has two main business segments: Royal Mail and GLS.

Royal Mail is the UK’s universal service provider, delivering parcels and letters to 31m UK addresses 6 days a week. Its Parcelforce division offers express parcel delivery. This segment is responsible for the bulk of group revenue but tends to be low margin.

3wO0938z3lno7pU2ae7b8ChJw-m5FGQXhDgamPcwBxGHsKsu_P13x75CIl2Vcu_iHS8Rz9simXxDaU1F6RbCd0dWkMlqp8ahEWtPKgBnzQJWCnWVwdZiMYqpuQuKlTZnRlypB2eo

It employs some 137,300 workers, of which 85,000 are postmen and women. Add to that around 50,800 vehicles, 37 mail centres, an 11,100 strong local collection network and two big new parcel distribution hubs soon to come online, and the scale of this enterprise is clear to see.

General Logistics Systems (GLS) is run autonomously as the group’s international operations. It has historically been higher margin than the UK operations.

xnx7UOb5KNlNMrC4Q_ZWQa41UeSI2WpcC5bfiJ4lq9_F3CkcAEsf5ylnN9E4MaMTFuCUTpnw5v6t6n35C8M01UUgE2zAb4R6FChmKX7_gSjeRDzlBb7ulN8mFjHT7unpKbwXhfVC

The difference in margins is due to people costs. These trend at around 66.4% of Royal Mail revenue, compared to 22.3% for GLS, so it’s a material difference.

That’s because GLS employs more contractors in line with peers, whereas Royal Mail is unusual by industry standards for its higher levels of job security and compensation.

These are two different businesses with different strategies; GLS is very much run autonomously. There has been speculation in the past that the group might sell GLS, but management has recently said it intends to keep them together.

What is the business model? How does it make money?

Royal Mail collects, sorts and delivers letters and parcels.

As the UK’s sole designated Universal Service Provider, it delivers a ‘one-price-goes-anywhere’ service on a range of letters and parcels and has an ‘unparalleled’ network in terms of scale and shape.

Parcelforce, meanwhile, is a leading provider of express parcel delivery services.

62_xuNQ3FbnRRM0XXz1r8yvFY_deud1KJ5DdQiWVa2-kEIXJkLM-hSOLZVj7EtH8VB6rnLr0tyBW8ipOJZW6Lhh5ZFe83E7ICKvWW2oPLASUu6SV7a7f1ulox0yuVnouyB73BycH

GLS collects, sorts and delivers parcels. It is one of the largest ground-based deferred parcel operators in Europe. It has a growing presence in North America and a wide network of partners across the world. A recent acquisition strengthens its position in Canada.


Market & Competition

What is the state & size of the company's market?

Statista reports that revenue generated from parcel services in the UK experienced continuous growth between 2013 and 2021, with about £9.4bn of domestic parcel revenue in 20/21. Europe generated 38.8bn euros in 2019. This is an increase of around 7.5 billion euros from 2015.

Who are the company's key competitors?

DPD Group - an international parcel delivery service based in France, generating c11bn euros in annual revenue.

Hermes - a multinational delivery company headquartered in Hamburg, Germany.

DHL - an international logistics company, which is a division of Deutsche Post.

JtkpCIB0IIe4GTyBCh713xeX1cB60a_7I-abXnP9bIo1SOPsKBz_1sVIpULSfhgB0El9XpCfIMJQFP5zcmSGdbqaMpZkw7cLgiMV6_cZ3AMFgaqdj2MHQnF02tdyaUms10oc1oLI

Statista - market share of the leading courier service providers in the UK in 2020

0b55eDecc0HzTm-ZVbR-u0NBzZwPYcUVx23K2FMkv8X2tMagaENzxi_32r8YBgsU3iV6utLqaETt1mSiZKIQyi4cNZiZtwhfz5PAfNHei8o3D_vAWHccvvChHtsUKHoc1_tiFxtC

‘Which parcel delivery provider do you prefer?’ - Statista survey of 1,741 respondents in 2019

These are competitors in the UK. GLS has many more rivals across its 40 markets, with the closest competitor being DPD.

There are also a couple of US-listed companies which trade on significantly higher relative valuations than Royal Mail, namely Fedex (11.4x forecast PER and 8.64x trailing twelve month EV/EBITDA) and UPS (18.1x forecast PER and 13.51x TTM EV/EBITDA).

What is the company's strategy?

We are transforming from a UK-focused letters business that delivers parcels, to a parcels-led, international business, delivering letters in the UK

Royal Mail is investing in its network to handle more parcels. This includes the construction of two substantial new distribution hubs, including the Midlands Parcel Hub in Daventry. This is a significant milestone that will play a key role in the future direction of Royal Mail.

The midlands site is the larger of the two, and will be able to process more than one million items per day when it opens in 2023. It will supplement the North West Hub in Warrington, which is scheduled to be fully operational in this spring.

Automation

We are continuing to increase the number of parcels that are sorted through automation across our operation. The number of parcels successfully sorted at least once grew significantly from 356m in 2019-20 to 652m in 2020-21 – an 83% increase. However, our percentage of parcels sorted by machine was unchanged year on year by 33%. The industry benchmark is 90%.

GLS - has its own ‘Accelerate’ plan to generate an 8% operating margin. This could be at risk depending on how long and to what degree wage inflation plays a role.

The key strategic ambitions here are:

  • By FY2024-25 it plans to outgrow the cross-border deferred parcel market growth rate of around 9% and hopes to generate around a quarter of its revenue in this segment.
  • By FY2024-25 GLS plans to outgrow the business to consumer (B2C) market growth rate of around 10% and deliver a 17% CAGR in volume terms from FY2019-20.
  • Launch innovative digital and sustainable solutions that are centred around customer needs and provide the best ‘delivery experience’.

How does it derive its competitive advantage (if any), is it durable and is there evidence of one in the financials?

This is a competitive sector with some very good operators. Royal Mail does have a few points in its favour, including:

  • International scale,
  • Brand and heritage,
  • Market position,
  • Balance sheet strength.

Financials & Ownership

What is the record of growth & profitability?

Revenues have increased but net income has fallen. This has changed recently, but the degree to which this is a temporary boost from lockdown dynamics remains to be seen. The group does generate solid free cash flows though, while being able to pay out dividends and reinvest at the same time.

9SO5iBaLp1f0SgbgWDPD6h3lZm2FlGqn7R39f6NmTvpApPmhPIM6IUSEoExqmfC_JcFYXKpQtGdOKmAM5wWlU97D113zkB-S_a6v-t8Li5WQErfDJM9ysEcrXD5qlZN4-6g9afN2

BhtlEy1q3gqhzY5iU0eW3xDSanuoLJU12zDI3kulFCQw6Ne881eYdUCHUwtPR2KshKjH0eTif90ganwV2R_VjLQCwWFXMOn9K52QuzZr_UdHnhFczq4iTZK4pG1M07OpXkq-wel5

What is the state of the balance sheet? (debt/cash etc)

The balance sheet is strong and management has signalled it will return cash to shareholders as it goes back to being net cash neutral. Management is optimistic that both Royal Mail and GLS can be self-funding in the years ahead.

WO8F0Q_7JjtOI-8oBbbstCUFdWbvFHeEF9erOAGmaDa4uw6vQn8jTQJ1pMmizng3gQDv2Y9DpJircd96ZWCWZLNnoU6dckBQPfvPjlpx9yb7TLJFOtGHwdLoF8orTW79tfrCW2I1

Is there evidence of historic share dilution or buy backs?

The number of shares in issue has remained broadly stable, and should come down as a result of recently announced buybacks.

2nETklEcwh5N1iRfYIxq8FSZ1bQGarfXa4ah-bmjGZ2aGj-sBjIaxhF4tgC0sGGZ2GZm2BPOI8EUUrJmh6XD8L2uqgXhkdXxE9_H9If4A6MQBarTJZoCWkeHqf_Ltnj5qJ2oGsnI


Valuation

How does the relative valuation compare versus industry and sector?

The key thrust of the stock pitch boils down to one simple point: by almost every available metric, Royal Mail shares look cheap. Particularly when you compare it to peers.

hDNuAfD8dqHQpFBitBFi2-8mll8tHGySwT3ukfmc1BrAn-zXUqWrzECX3Bmbb8x-Zv_cPbzq6u9ajg8fPU4BXBksTh7WOqrgCdlnjiwtpSV5agE_A1lSakdKoDTrSfDJN8Xgw6l1


Trends & Catalysts

Are there any catalysts could drive a rerating in the medium term?

  • Ongoing parcel delivery growth,
  • New hubs bringing more capacity and automation,
  • Transformation initiatives and operational efficiencies,
  • Better scheduling and route optimisation; shift to 24/7 delivery,
  • Distributions to shareholders via buybacks, dividends, and special dividends,
  • Ongoing growth capex,
  • Additional acquisitions at GL

Risks, Threats & Hurdles

What are the biggest risks, threats or hurdles that the business may face?

Cost headwinds - Royal Mail’s USP status means it has a large cost base. With wage inflation and increasing energy prices, managing this is a key risk and is likely the reason the share price looks so cheap.

Royal Mail staff are relatively well paid, but even small percentage increases here could have a big impact on profits.The group has said any wage increases will be funded through productivity initiatives and gains.

Wage inflation is more of a risk for GLS, which is seeing inflation across all countries.

Shift to parcels - this is an opportunity, but is lower margin than letters (as more letters can fit in a van) and presents operational issues such as a broader range of shapes, weights, and sizes.

Unions - the relationship here is the best it’s ever been, but the unions still represent a stakeholder with which Royal Mail must collaborate in order to push through transformation changes.

Competition in logistics has also stepped up as the role it plays in supply chains and customer deliveries grows in importance. Other large operators include Amazon and DPD in the UK, with many other overseas operators.

Covid - presents a couple of risks. Royal Mail has suffered recently from higher than average worker absences. As such a large employer, Covid waves could continue to impact its operations. Additionally, there is the risk that forecast parcel growth has been flattered by lockdown-related ordering of products.

Brexit - The new UK-EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement complicates this picture. The deal has at least temporarily introduced costs to consumers and businesses. This adds another barrier to international parcel volumes and leaves couriers more dependent on domestic parcels, which is a fiercely contested market.

There is a pension fund, which is in surplus.


Recent Trading & News

Summarise the most recent trading statements and comment on them

Trading update for Q3 to December 2021

  • Royal Mail Q3 domestic parcel revenue +43.9% vs. Q3 2019-20, and -4.9% year on year,
  • Royal Mail Q3 domestic parcel volumes +33% vs. Q3 2019-20, and -7% year on year, ‘at least maintaining our market share’,
  • GLS Q3 revenue +35.2% vs. Q3 2019-20, and +4.5% year on year.

Profits forecast in the UK arm cut from £500m to £430m after announcing a move to shed 700 managerial jobs as part of reorganisation plans. This will cost £70m in redundancies. Savings from the redundancy programme will amount to £40m annually. Accounting for this £70m hit, trading remains in line.

GLS is on course for operating profits of €400m.


Sentiment

What do the brokers currently think?

After multiple upgrades, consensus EPS forecasts have been nudged down slightly on the back of the recent update (but still value the shares on a single-digit PER).

L8eVElluw3k6a0Wvjaf3QBFG7lKHwgCUNDbm0-mfU9IO96UnvNOwHOieWL_zfabO6cnPYzXlpNxwvZFYxZ7CiyB_z_ZsuW20RdnJ8i9uvpRtpRMVEALKjrFLsU3qIcM448DAkApu

What is private investor sentiment at the moment?

Royal Mail is one of the most widely held stocks out there in the retail investor community. Some institutions have been showing interest recently as well, namely Vesa, which took its stake above 20% in January, and BlackRock (see Major Shareholders).

aox7BHlqDEYjl5Iznv287XM14RQn13jY5zfXSNmINEMnAYfMgZAu2nSKRw6DgcMSvBRS0gVRpXX7zTfgAqg9pLnF8msj5fVNkPpLZ2lTnpxRXtXDZi6m7RvRD3sZRgrV0PCigrN0

What would the person selling to us be thinking and who are they?

  • Cost pressures could hit profits,
  • Revenue growth from shift to parcels may be less than anticipated,
  • Relationship with unions deteriorates,
  • Competition intensifies, impacting either market share or margins.

Conclusion

Royal Mail Group generates strong cash flows, is investing for future growth and operational efficiencies, and is a trusted domestic brand with a growing international logistics business.

If the group can grow revenues while keeping a handle on costs, then profits could increase quite quickly. But therein also lies the risk - should anything go wrong, then profits could disappear just as rapidly.

After deliberation, the Club opted to buy Royal Mail shares at £4.40 per share.

40OMjaapAjem8Qf4nA3pGF4Q-VBiygS0ylzrMuKCR502eUNQZj4Hxm3vAcXvkW6t79NCEpgV2J0q53mnagENLYpNf4ulC73mgxO7-78nZ-rTbv3pXRVXMf7HSKXLvjFilAhuGsjs

There’s no doubt the shares look cheap. Is the market correct to discount the share price due to the group’s large costs, or could there be an opportunity here for Royal Mail to grow revenues and rerate?

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

36 comments


Avatar for turbo

Would be interested to hear on views of how Royal Mail (LON:RMG) will weather in the current economic climate. Can't decide if it a) is a safe place to put some cash medium term, and b) has it fallen far enough making it an attarctive proposition?

Momentum ranks on Stocko is currently very low at  2. How do we factor in the effect of Royal Mail being demoted from the FTSE 100 on the share price?

Other factors to consider include falling post-pandemic parcel numbers, rising stamp prices and rising labour costs.

2
Avatar for Sheru The Vegan Westie

hmmmm …. but has this all now been priced into the current stock price? :-)
To me it still seems to be a good dividend paying value stock … worth holding onto for a few months if not a year (to see it rebound)

1
Avatar for Paul2148

turbo, my view is this is falling into classic value territory but it may not be an easy ride back up.  Personally I would pound cost average in ( which is what I am doing). To offset any further downturn.  My reasons for saying this are;


1) still a good level of short interest and whilst this has decreased I imagine it could increase with further headwinds.

2) GLS still looking profitable with further growth but will be affected by any recession across the Eurozone.  It’s North American operations may offset this very slightly dependant on the economy there, however the risk of not meeting expectations is present.

3) RMG is the main drag on current valuation from my point of view;

a)The managers union are balloting for industrial action  after a badly received re-org has soured relations like never before.  I believe the last time this union balloted was around 40 years ago.

b) the CWU (frontline union that represents the majority of the employees) is currently going through the disagreement process leading to them being able to take industrial action if the issues are not resolved.   This is around a pay claim in which they want 5% no strings.  RMG has offered a tiered 5% based on working Sundays and local productivity schemes, amongst other issues being resolved.

c) parcel volumes are likely to drop this year - nationally due to economic slowdown and international following Brexit changes (which started last year).

d) competition is stepping up in the domestic market with other carriers improving their cost base and service. 


Whilst a lot of this could be baked into the current price, should negotiations with the CWU breakdown this will lead to other carriers being very predatory with nervous customers who just want to guarantee service,  in the past this has lead them to  lock in customers on 12 month contracts.  Should this happen I think the sp has further to fall.


All of the above is the bear case.  To counter this I would suggest watching the analyst presentation on the RMG investors page.

The CEO has a clear vision of where he wants to take the company and should he be successful I think it will unlock huge value for shareholders.



3
Avatar for Sheru The Vegan Westie

I bought lots of Royal Mail shares yesterday as a lot of my checks shown below now show that this stock may now rebound upwards:

215bedf01ea91550fed0d53486df47c952059cb51653171745.jpegf43d17c5476ffc987fae951a13ff6dad3e2ca1991653171745.jpeg8f39f1a7eb0d16280b51abf2a6f3248e9f6af7631653171745.jpeg91d59f1b4c9420ec1a408e954d321031413c3d091653171745.jpeg7f07bcd6598afd9ca1308a1386b0251b45ed542d1653171745.jpeg9f8016a91d0a482708386e446a564903136ac5c41653171745.jpegc48b0f91602110ade5f2c87528ffac79a56e4be31653171745.jpeg
4
Avatar for Arturo82

Now 279p. A protracted fight with the union over wage demands is not fully priced in.

0
Avatar for Paul2148

The SP continues to drop and I now think RMG is facing some serious headwinds - at least over the next 12 months.

Inflationary pressure from fuel, heating, NI are all set to increase and I notice today the CWU have tabled a pay claim (there is a video on their Twitter account).  Whilst no specific number is mentioned, what is mentioned is "cost of living" and "high inflation" so I anticipate this claim to be around 7%.

Looking at 19/20 wages (£4267m) for UK (not GLS) that would equal a further circa £250m in wage costs (not all wages costs are CWU grade employees), on top of the aforementioned increase in fuel (largest fleet in UK) , heating (a very large property portfolio) and NI contribution increase.

RMG has stated a progressive dividend policy, so another circa £230m cost and I can't see the CWU being happy with this amount being handed to shareholders whilst a claim for a similar amount for their members is not met.   Cost of living is likely to be a very emotive issue amongst their employees.

This CEO has so far only enjoyed cordial relations with the CWU.  He has yet to deal with them with a strike mandate behind them, which always unsettles customers, many of who switch to competitors during such times.

I'm also lead to believe the proposed managerial reduction isn't going as planned and whilst Unite/CMA do not have a history of industrial action, I am told this is a possibility given this is the second managerial cut in 12 months. 

Cost pressures isn't something that can be managed by raising prices - all of their customers will have the same increase in costs squeezing them.   RMG pricing power isn't great, the market is very competitive so customers can easily switch carriers and RMG costs are higher than their competitors which places a pretty hard floor on RMG prices that I guess many of their competitors can beat.  

EV roll out wont be fast enough to offset rising fuel costs and parcel automation will value add so long as parcel volume remains high - if not all the company has done is create surplus capacity.

Whilst a tad Bearish I do think this is relatively short term and could provide good entry points.  I've held have since floated, topping up when the price dropped into the low £2 and then through the Covid drop so my average SP is excellent and this is now my largest position.  I intend to hold LT (10yrs+) as I do believe the company is a good LT hold.


1
Avatar for Robert Fellowes

"There’s no doubt the shares look cheap",  but they may get even cheaper over the next few weeks. The charts are showing an emerging "death cross"  and, if it develops it may be possible to buy at around 380p in a  few weeks time. The 200 day SMA on my chart looks weak and the Bollinger has a very nasty looking bulge. At today's price I think it's a reasonable 12 month bet, although the current sentiment is clearly very bearish. I own a small number of RMG, but would buy more at a better price.

3
Avatar for Wilbraham

Couple of thoughts:

1.  I had coffee last week with  a lady that's just quit her delivery role at RM.  They made no attempt to persuade her to stay, despite staff shortages.  She was appalled at the manipulation of overtime/shifts/sick-days etc which apparently is rife amongst the workforce.  That can't be a positive for productivity.

2.  Totally agree that 'mail' as such must dwindle.  I insist on hard copy current account statement and one utility bill - everything else is online.  Most 'mail' I receive is junk  that's binned unopened.  (Some is 'leaflets' not in an addressed envelope that I assume RM is paid a modest fee to deliver.)  If 'mail' for documents didn't exist surely no one would invent it now?  Sure, RM can raise stamp prices at CPI++ but this just accelerates the decline.  A few years ago I'd have suggested they deliver mail only every other day but I guess this would be redundant now that packages/parcels (ie anything physical that can't be transmitted electronically) take up much of their capacity and people want next-day, thanks to Amazon lead.

3.  eBay etc have made it much easier to send parcels with ready-to-print labels and drop-offs at local convenience stores/garages with no need to wait in a virus-laden PO queue.

4.  It does sound a fiercely competitive industry for all players.   Yes there's an element of 'captive market' but as the oldies die off so will their inherent loyalty to RM.

5.  Beware there's a huge DB pension liability.  Yes the funds may be in surplus currently but unless the trustees have substantially de-risked (I haven't checked their statements) they could still swing back to deficit in adverse conditions.  Again I haven't checked, but if RM are continuing to offer DB accrual to current staff (and maybe even new entrants) that's a competitive disadvantage.

6.  I'm not sure that comparisons against PEs etc of international players necessarily imply 'cheap'.  US-owned businesses I suspect have long been rated more highly than similar UK players.  Even if there's no fundamental reason for this it just seems to persist and I don't see a compelling driver for PEs to converge within a reasonable timeframe.   Remember, your return as a shareholder is driven significantly by the difference in PE from buying to selling (+ EPS growth and dividends).  Possibly the competitors are more focused on automation - I don't know.  

Despite these cautions, I see some attractions in RM though sustainability of dividends as others have pointed out sounds a risk.

3
Avatar for rmillaree

5. Beware there's a huge DB pension liability. Yes the funds may be in surplus currently but unless the trustees have substantially de-risked (I haven't checked their statements) they could still swing back to deficit in adverse conditions. Again I haven't checked, but if RM are continuing to offer DB accrual to current staff (and maybe even new entrants) that's a competitive disadvantage.

Ok i cant be bothered to check and i am making assumptions that are wrong and could easily have been excluded - cheers (apologies for blunt tone here but it would only have taken 2 minutes to check ref db accruals )

Agreed DB pension liability is huge no doubting that  - would be interested to get anyones viewpoints who can do an actual review here and add useful comment rather than just saying this could be a massive issue without adding any context. Note  taking the time to look at the annual report page 187 it appears the largest scheme is in surplus by over £2 billion   (3.6 bill before witholding tax which i guess only applies if there is surplus??) - ok there are two different calcs ref pension defecits and surplus but the numbers look ok to my untrained eye. 3.6 bill surplus pre witholding tax on largest scheme with liabilities being £8.1 bill.  I cannot say whether these figures are good / bad or indifferent  but they do look more ok than bad to my untrained eye.

but if RM are continuing to offer DB accrual to current staff (and maybe even new entrants) that's a competitive disadvantage.

They closed that scheme  for future accruals in 2018 as basic google search shows.

Note i would say its highly likely Royal mail will be much more generous with regard to pension provisions for staff than your average low cost courier operator despite the closure  of the defined beenfit scheme to future accruals - so i do agree that they could be at a  somewhat disadvantage in that regard - perhaps though employees look at teh whole  package they get when taking employment so perhaps they don't have to offer quite as high a salary as competitors if the pension perks mean that the whole remuneration package is equivalent to competitors.

Must admit the whole pension thing is certainly worth pointing out and is a mini red flag in a similar manner as the prior union relations issues they have had. Much rather have fresh new startup with no mention of defined benefit anything.

3
Avatar for Dragon

"3. eBay etc have made it much easier to send parcels with ready-to-print labels and drop-offs at local convenience stores/garages with no need to wait in a virus-laden PO queue."

Royal Mail do a collection service from your home. You can also buy and print postage stamps online.

1
Avatar for khmkii

In the long run, the contribution from a change in PE to total return is assumed to be negligible in every model I can think of.

0
Avatar for MGerard

not sure here, as has been pointed out was much cheaper a few years back (revenue flat but share price doubled!). The few letters I continue to receive are where I have forgotten to switch to paperless statements. Oh and lots of insurance and other renewal docs more of which are switching online. I can only see market size and potentially share going down over time. Then there is the longer term prospect of drone delivery. And finally the postman who keeps dropping elastic bands near my front door. 

0
Avatar for rmillaree

MGerad

I can only see market size and potentially share going down over time.

Have you even bothered to read the latest trading update  ? - i suspect not .

Royal mail letters make of only £2.8 bill of the £9.6 bill revenues ytd . If you had made the effort to read the latest trading date you would have seen the increased parcel volume is more than making up for any stuctural decline in letters volumes. It was expected that parcel volumes would subside somewhat due to large increases over covid but thankfully levels are remaining well above pre covid levels - up 43% compared to same period pre covid lets ignore that tasty number though shall we?

Per most recent update 

Confident there has been a structural shift in parcel volumes since the start of theCOVID-19pandemic;

▪ 439 million parcels handled during the quarter;▪ 

Q3 domestic parcel3revenue grew by 43.9% vs. Q3 2019-20, and declined by4.9% year on year;▪ 

Q3 domestic parcel3volumes grew by 33% vs. Q3 2019-20, and declined by7% year on year; at least maintaining our market share;

Then there is the longer term prospect of drone delivery.

any reason that drone deliveries would not be fulfilled by royal mail when they work practicably speaking ?- none that i can think of.

as has been pointed out was much cheaper a few years back (revenue flat but share price doubled!).

What a bizzare statement  - have you checked the level of profits this company is churning out now compared to a few years back £600 mill per year net profit 2021 , 2022 and 2023. And you are comparing low prior share price to years when company made 259 , 141 and 161 net profit - practicably speaking its a different company back then. Revenue for vanity profits for sanity as they say. As for your assertion that revenue if flat thats just factually incorrect sorry. 2018-2020 revenue was 10 bill odd per year 2021 and 2022 over 12.5 bill with 2023 is expected to exceed £13 bill.

I would concede the company is not without potential margin issues etc and i dont have high conviction that they will remain this profitible long term - but management are confident ref next year and pe here is only 7 so its not exactly a premium price we are paying - possibly even cheaper than 7 if you look at operating cashflow.  

2
Avatar for Wimbledonsprinter

Jack - thanks for your very interesting write-up.

One thing I would point out is the relationship with the unions on the Royal Mail side. While the relationship with the CWU (posties and sorting staff) is, as you say, the best it has been for years, the same can not be said for Unite (managers).

Unite is angry at the proposed 700 management jobs being cut and is talking about possible industrial action.

https://www.unitetheunion.org/...

2
Avatar for muscleriot

A lot of profits have been made from Covid test deliveries. Just looking at the figures, B/S they look great, but then you realise... they were at £2 pre-pandamic with no inflation 2 years ago. A covid cyclical? Decent management - but a workforce who will strike at will. And now they have a real decent moral reason to strike - the evil of inflation. I am not getting in front of that frieght train...

“Here lies the body of Postman Sid: he could not exist on fourteen quid!”

https://www.cwu.org/1971

2
Avatar for Bouden54

Dont see why this needs to end up in strike action. The unions will be in a strong position to push for pay rises, but Royal Mail will likewise be in a strong position to put up prices as their competitors will be facing the same pressures. 

0
Avatar for Dragon

Yes this is a PLC not a state run monopoly from the 70's. The price of the stamp can be easily be increased to cover wage inflation. The dividend is covered 2.4 times by profits, so can be afforded. Some Posties are still shareholders as well.

1
Avatar for muscleriot

https://www.cwu.org/news/messa...

"there’s growing anger over how our members’ pay has fallen behind the cost of living in real terms over the past two years....

with inflation rising higher – everyone’s talking about higher bills for gas and electric, food prices etc – and they’re telling us that there’s got to be substantial progress on wages to compensate." CWU union Feb 2022.

Wages increases at 1% settled in April 2021 by Royal Mail Plc? Will some RMG stock dividends quell the deserved anger? The average employee share holding on floatation is 613 shares. Now worth about 4.5K with 3% dividend or a extra 180 quid a year. Not a hard question....!!!

UNIONISATION....!!

You can't have 7% inflation without massive pay increases being re-negociated and strikes if they don't! I just don't get why this inflation is not ripping through the market values of companies with large workforces...

Lets look at a 5% pay increase across the board and estimate its impact!

No. of Employees158,592
(£millions) 2021
Revenue 12,638
Cost of Revenue 6,470
Gross Profit 6,168
Selling / General / Administrative Expenses 3,483

Revenue/Employee = £79,688

(a) Cost of Revenue/Employee = £40,796

(b) Selling / General / Administrative Expenses per Employee = £21,962

(a) + (b) = £62,758/Employee (9,953 m) x 5% = £497.65m extra cost.

Net Income 2021 = 620m

Basically anything for shareholders will be wiped out - if these workers are paid enough to compensate for CPI inflation.

I have to laugh at the supposed 2.4 x dividend cover! All of this is based on the PAST - the rearview mirror!

2
Avatar for Dragon

Surely if the pay increase is 5% you don't multiple all the revenue costs by 5%. The wage bill is only part of that. If there is inflation won't that be applied to the cost of postage, increasing the revenue. Can you factor in some price increases into your laughter.

First class 85p x 5% = 89.25p

Revenue 12638 x 5% price increase = £632m increase in revenue.

1
Avatar for muscleriot

A 2% pay cut with a 5% wage rise. Inflation is at 7%. PPI output prices are around 10%  for Dec. 

Fairer would have been ALL COSTS to rise by 5%. Not just those loosely based on wages. 

Assuming 3% yield. Why would a buyer not want a REAL return, not want a 7% yeild? for a 0% return?  Not today - but some day not too far away....

I know TINA means the current 3% i.e. -4% after 7.5% RPI inflation is 'a bargain' compared to the subway mugger in chief Andrew Bailey giving savers a -7% return.  But one day that will change. 

This whole ballgame of chasing the least negative real return depends if you think inflation is transitory - I don't think it is. 

And if it isn't, huge changes are coming and RERATING will hover over the SP. 

1
Avatar for Dragon

I just think that you have to apply inflation to both sides of the P&L account. Below I quoted an increase in a first class stamp of 5% = 4.25p. In 2020 RMG increased the price by 9p with inflation below 2%.

1
Avatar for muscleriot

Even if the company was inflation proof - it doesn't mean the yield you lock in is inflation proof....Stop staring at the tree and look at the forest burning down. 

0
Avatar for rmillaree

Basically anything for shareholders will be wiped out - if these workers are paid enough to compensate for CPI inflation.

I have to laugh at the supposed 2.4 x dividend cover! All of this is based on the PAST - the rearview mirror!

Why are you completely ignoring the fact that when companies costs go up they generally increase prices to cover their increased costs and keep margins similar ?

I won't argue that it is possible that they may be adversely hit but to do calcs on the basis that they will not recoup any of the costs increases (that presumably dont exist yet) seems nonsensical unless you have some reason for backing up your assertions - eg if broker covering royal mail  indicates it will be such. Must admit royal mail are not a high conviction play for me as i do concede the point the profits could be squeezed out of existence and i may end up with egg on my face but as of today the directors of the company still believe they will make £600 mill profit this year and £600 mill profit next year.



2
Avatar for muscleriot

And what price say you, is a -4% real return worth in the future? Is it the price you have locked in based on a nominal 3% dividend a great deal? You may indeed think it is compared to the nightly rape of -7% going on with the prudent savers next door while they are asleep and unconcious.

But now inflation is knocking at thy window with a princely 7% rise in fuel, food and essentials. You have to sell the stock to pay for draught excluders and secondhand thermal underwear.

You offer -if everything works out business wise - a minus 4% real return on your market stall full of Royal Mail (LON:RMG) certificates. Are you sure the next buyer will be eager for a negative real return? Do you think at any point a real return - or a less negative real return - means you must markdown the price? And what price will that be?

If inflation is -7% and the real return accepted is now -2% not -4% doeth that not make a -50% markdown for each RMG cerficate?

0
Avatar for Bouden54

All this may be true, except that RMG would then put prices up to offset higher wage costs. Overall profit impact = neutral

1
Avatar for Doug2b

Royal Mail - if you add together the falling net tangible equity over the past 4 years and then allow for the share issuing over the same period, the average annual net fall in tangible equity is just over 1.4% pa.

This of course means that the 5.47% dividend is not affordable and Royal Mail's management are reckless to pay such a dividend. A dividend of about 2% is all that Royal Mail can afford at the moment. Royal Mail issues a few more shares each year and erode some equity each year as well, all to keep those who don't look beyond the dividend happy. 

6
Avatar for rmillaree

cheers for that doug - I am hoping they will become a reformed character this year and next - note there are some positive signs here eg they have recently spent 200 mill buying back shares and paid a tidy special divi - so I have hope their sins of the past will not be sins of the future and higher earnings truly will show up in your  numbers in a year or two feel free to call me out in 18 months after 2023 numbers are updated .

1
Avatar for davidallen77

I think.it was Paul that said a small increase in staff costs wipes out profits here?! Such a labour intensive business risk of fste100 exit also like the qr codes

0
Avatar for iain1234

Great write up. I sell a lot of stuff on eBay after a house clearance and unfortunately Royal Mail is usually my least favourite delivery method. They are by far the most expensive and  the hardest to use - usually involve queuing at a post office.  The competition are way cheaper and you can easily dump parcels in these automated drop off boxes that most supermarkets now have. 

4
Avatar for Fegger

i suggest that you study the Royal Mail services available .i use click and drop . it takes sales off my ebay and my bespoke website on the woocommerce platform and collates them . i print the labels at home and drop off in a bag into the Post Office wth no queuing. if you are a larger business you can pay for a collection service from your home.

1
Avatar for bohenie

Thanks Jack for sharing this - a lot to take in, and great to see a major company like this with a pension not in deficit - a big plus for me. Its antiquated Yes, but that only means it should be better/more profitable as it eventually modernises. These new postage stamps coming soon with QR codes is one example - but surely one of the biggest hurdles will be to integrate delivery and collection. At present one van delivers and another comes round later to collect from postboxes - waste of resources, especially in rural areas.

0
Avatar for Logical David

Yes bohenie, the new QR stamps are due to be launched by the Post Office this year.  The existing traditional ordinary stamps currently in use will no longer be valid after 31st January 2023.  After this date you won't be able to use the tradition stamps to post a letter but you can swap them at the Post Office for the new QR stamps.

2
Avatar for rmillaree

Must admit i have had a punt here - despite thinking this would certainly be an uninvestible  business due to militant unionisation - i have been swayed over to the viewpoint that it is worth a point.

2 semi red flags

1 past history of militant unionisation would have convinced me to steer well clear. Must admit i still have a red flag here despite the current situation seeming to be mostly amicable at present. I could understand anyone who stays clear on thisd basis.

2 they seem very old fashioned - in recent update they semde dproud they had just stopped manual sign in procedures - how any buisness could not have swapped to automated swipe system years ago i know not (unions agaisnt tis move)?

3 will they face reversal of covid tailwinds and margin pressures - that has to be a big conern.

 the good bits

would would GLS be worth as a standalone busines without being tarred with teh royal mail brush - give that business a pe of 15 and what is the  rotal mail side valued at - not  alot.

Balance sheet looks great.

On freecashflow measure of ebita measure it looks cheap as chips.

I would guess if doug were to run his magical numbers on this year and last he would be impressed. 

 Certainly surprised myself with my purchase here if nothing else.

3
Avatar for Doug2b

I will have a close look later. I am fixing external lights while the daylight remains. At the end of the day, it will come down to whether this business generates tangible shareholder wealth at a suffcient rate relative to what you are paying, as always.

1
Avatar for Wimbledonsprinter

I agree, by putting GLS alone on a similar multiple to Deutsche Post or UPS, I can get ear the current market cap of the combined group.  The current management structure, with no group CEO but separate CEOs of Royal Mail and GLS would seem designed to facilitate a split.      I have also heard management say that both businesses are now self-financing - so there is no need for GLS to cross-subsidize the Capex needs at Royal Mail.  A split would also seem to unlock a lot of value.

But Jack says in his write-up that:

“There has been speculation in the past that the group might sell GLS, but management has recently said it intends to keep them together.”

I had not seen this management statement saying the two businesses would not be separated.   If anyone could point me in the right direction that would be appreciated.

0
Avatar for JohnEustace

Yes, if management have said that about GLS I also missed it. The largest shareholder is Daniel Kretinsky’s Vesa group with 20.2%. Looking at their other holdings, e.g. Post NL,  I have to think their interest is in the international business. 

0
Get the free newsletter