58
Archived articleThis is an archived article from 2020 - please note that any content within the article may be out of date.

Themes for a Long-Term Lockdowned Investor

Like most long-term investors I’ve been trying to see through the fog of war to figure out how I should be positioning my portfolio for the coming years. Frankly it’s not easy, these are unprecedented times and like everyone else I’m affected by the tragic events around us. Staying level-headed isn’t always easy even while staying safe at home.

Anyway, I thought a thread about the investment themes we might be following and ways of playing them would be interesting. In particular, assuming that we are looking at a recession, I mainly want to be invested in capital light businesses – companies that need to invest inflationary cash in depreciating assets will be running just to stand still.

In such uncertain times, it’s important to continually update beliefs and forecasts. Stocks here that I mention and hold I won’t hesitate to sell if new information becomes apparent. Only a fool commits themselves permanently at the best of times – and these times are not those.

Volatility

Uncertainty triggers volatility and there are a few companies that make money from this directly. The main beneficiaries are the spreadbetters. I held Ig Group (LON:IGG) and Cmc Markets (LON:CMCX) coming into the crisis and have topped up since. The other obvious investment here is Plus500 (LON:PLUS) – which has done fantastically well but which I avoid due to the Israeli connections. The management there are very good at timing purchases and sales.

The obvious question is whether these companies are making windfall profits which will fall away. The answer is – obviously – yes, but I don’t think that matters. They’re a valuable hedge against uncertainty and picking up stock when it’s cheap – as we’ve seen recently due to regulatory issues – is a smart move. The question now would be whether we’ve seen the majority of the immediate benefit?

The other stock in this area I’ve bought is Tp Icap (LON:TCAP) who ought to sail through these times without too much trouble, although they’re not as highly geared for volatility as the others.

Cybersecurity

The rapid rise in homeworking has forced lots of organisations into allowing home working. Those of us that can do it are the lucky ones. The issue, however, and this will grow, is that this opens up companies to cyberattack. Simple plays on this involving firewalls and VPNs are OK, but they’re purely windfall profits. What is more interesting is where there are longer term opportunities for companies to support and develop services around these security needs.

Here I’ve added to holdings in Ncc (LON:NCC) and L&G ISE CYBER SECURITY GO UCITS ETF (LON:ISPY) as well as retaining a holding in Avast (LON:AVST) . In the UK we’re not well served by quoted companies in this space – although both Bae Systems (LON:BA.) and £BT.A have cybersecurity operations hidden within their bowels. Generally companies in this area have already been bid up – it’s not rocket science to figure out how important this will be.

If anyone has other ideas from here or abroad that would be interesting.

Home working

More generally on the home working front there’s going to be a need for better communication services. We all know about Zoom and its much publicised failings but I think it’s worth noting that none of the other teleconferencing companies has had much scrutiny up until now and they probably all have security weaknesses. Zoom, at least, is getting the benefit of a lot of ethical attacks and is probably scaling up its security the fastest.

Here I’ve taken a small stake in Loopup (LON:LOOP) and retained my holding in Scottish Mortgage Investment Trust (LON:SMT) which holds both Zoom and Slack. Again we seem to have a dearth of companies in the UK offering remote working solutions and those in the US are very expensive.

Although there’s bound to be some reversion to normal working patterns I think it probable that there’ll be more home working and less commuting and business travel in future. That fits with a theme of protecting the environment so I expect a lot of this business to stick.

Home delivery

Stuck at home people need things delivered. Supermarkets are seeing a lot of additional business but I don’t expect this to carry on even if there’s more home delivery in future. Meanwhile most food delivery companies are expensive - Just Eat Takeaway.com Nv (LON:JET) for instance is on a PE of 100. That’s insane.

I’ve bought into Domino's Pizza (LON:DOM) despite some reservations about the business and the debt. However, it will trade through the downturn, and will continue to make money and the crisis is no doubt bringing home to its rebellious franchisees exactly how important the Domino’s brand is for them, as all around them competitors are struggling. Under the circumstances a PER of 17 doesn’t seem excessive.

Another possible way to play this would be through logistics companies. I’m not convinced - the barrier to entry isn’t that high and while they may make decent money now it’s hard to believe that won’t fall away later. But if anyone here has any insight into the sector that would be interesting.

Healthcare

I don’t think the fantastic rises and falls we’re seeing in companies promoting Covid-19 related fixes will stick. If someone finds drugs or a vaccine to solve the problem it will pretty much have to be given away and even if it isn’t it’s hard to see this a major source of revenue for years to come. And even if it is the odds of finding the one or two companies that benefit seem very long – there are too many imponderables there for me.

I’d much prefer to look at picks and shovels businesses, it’s impossible to believe we won’t see massive investments in healthcare and hygiene businesses going forward but as it’s an area I know little about I’m still in the research stage. All suggestions welcome.

Online platforms

Although there will be a lot of short term pain for some of these I think a lot of the online platforms will do OK. I held Rightmove (LON:RMV) coming into the downturn and I can’t say I’m particularly impressed with the way they’ve been treating their customers. But estate agents are going to go through a lot of pain in the coming months so they’re likely to gravitate to the platform able to invest the most. I can’t say I’m extremely confident – if anything the price looks high given some dim sector prospects, some active competitors and disgruntled customers.

More interesting, in my view, is Auto Trader (LON:AUTO). Obviously, the market for cars is dead right now and probably won’t look very good for a long time – new cars are the first things to go in a recession. However, they’re cashed up and have a capital light business model that will easily see them through the downturn. Meanwhile the economics of car dealerships are just awful – many of them won’t survive, even with government largesse and the backing of lots of assets – because many of those assets will not be realizable in a downturn. I’ve added some Auto Trader (LON:AUTO) as a last man standing play but I think it’ll be a long haul.

The same applies to On The Beach (LON:OTB) where I’m kicking myself for not investing before the recent run up. I think the runway to future profits is going to be hard but their capital light model is much more resilient than that of most of the travel industry. I think they’ll be a big winner – eventually – but there’ll probably be a better time to invest as the bad news seeps out.

Boohoo (LON:BOO) might be another winner – but a lot of fashion retailers are going to come into that space quickly as they have no other outlets. I don’t understand the fast fashion space well enough to take the risk. The online comparison sites Moneysupermarket.com (LON:MONY) (I hold) and Goco (LON:GOCO) will also survive but for now forecasting is difficult given a lot of moving parts – travel services are at zero but people have a lot of time on their hands to look for cheaper utilities, insurance, etc. As an aside, I wonder how the massive drop in car insurance claims is impacting insurers?

Home entertainment

If we’re all stuck at home we’ve got to figure out how to spend our time. In fact, the share price of companies like Netflix hasn’t moved much – but their valuations are ridiculous anyway, unless you assume infinite growth.

I bought Disney where about 25% of the current market cap is covered by Disney+ if you value subscribers there at the same level as those of Netflix. In fact, I think it probable that Disney+ subscribers will be more sticky than Netflix – can you imagine the screams of rage if young consumers are switched off? Of course, Disney’s theme parks are shut and films are stopped – but still, I think a drop in core value of around 40% is decent downside protection.

Home gaming is also booming and, again, some of that will stick. There was a real opportunity to buy Nintendo at the bottom of the market, and I’m still considering that even though the price has recovered. I did buy Codemasters Group (LON:CDM) and I’m thinking hard about what else to buy should the opportunity present itself.

One note on Codemasters Group (LON:CDM) though – their update this week made it clear that they’re seeing a shift from boxed retail to higher margin online delivery. It’s another sign of the looming pain for the High Street – not that we really need another one.

FANGs

I’ve bought Facebook and already owned Apple and Alphabet. Have never been able to persuade myself to pull the trigger on Amazon – I just don’t like the no-earnings model, even though I understand the rationale.

Clearly the other three will face issues – Apple will certainly see a drop in earnings but probably so will Google and Facebook as advertising drops off in the coming recession. Still, if I am paying for advertising I want to get my media in front of as many eyeballs as possible and they are still going to be the most effective at doing that. I’d expect them to end up with a larger portion of a smaller market and to come out the other side in an even stronger position, assuming the regulators don’t get there first.

And if the regulators do force break-ups – well, I’ll just own stakes in more highly successful companies. There’s not much of a downside here, especially if you consider the vast piles of cash on their balance sheets. Although – surely – they must pay more tax?

Payment companies

Most payment companies are going to have a hard time. A lot of them are on the hook for losses in the travel industry and I expect there to be some forced consolidation as regulators act to avoid systemic risk. The best plays here are the payment schemes Visa and Mastercard (who take no risk at all) plus the online payment companies – primarily Paypal. I held the latter coming into the downturn and wish I’d spotted the bottom in the market for the other two.

Typically a recession causes a drop in payments but countering this is the move away from cash (more card payments) and the general move to online (higher fees per transaction). These middlemen always win, although there may be some pain in the short term.

Others

I’m sure people can think of other areas – I’ve also bought FX companies (Record (LON:REC), £ARFX) - but they carry risk, asset managers (Schroders (LON:SDRC), M&g (LON:MNG)) - they'll survive but could easily go lower if the market tanks again - and cash rich behomeths (Berkshire Hathaway, Berkeley Group (LON:BKG)) as well as a few other things - Minds Machines (LON:MMX), Finsbury Growth & Income Trust (LON:FGT), Charles Stanley (LON:CAY) where I think there is good reason to believe that they’re undervalued (or at least they were when I bought them, 24 hours is a lifetime in trading terms at the moment).

On the other side I’ve sold anything related to retail, travel, property or which requires serious capital investment. I’ve made a few mistakes there – selling £KTL (duh) and Pearson (LON:PSON) (online education – another theme?) was almost certainly stupid. I also sold good companies like H & T (LON:HAT), Ramsdens Holdings (LON:RFX), Ten Entertainment (LON:TEG) and Hollywood Bowl (LON:BOWL) which went against nature but I don’t want to hold stocks where I can’t come up with any sensible valuations. I’d happily buy back at higher levels if the numbers start stacking up again.

Conclusions

I've been doing this investing lark since 1985 and it's never about getting all decisions correct, it’s about having a proper process and then trying to follow it while never, ever becoming so convinced that you’re correct that you fail to take on new information. If the facts change, change your mind and anyone who never does that isn't an investor, they're a gambler. Psychologically we like to follow people who are certain about things but the only certainty now is that nothing is really certain.

Thoughts, criticisms (polite ones, please!) and ideas all welcome. Good luck, and stay safe.

timarr

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

70 comments


Avatar for Adp 1

M&G is listed on here as a value trap, i'm curious to your view on that and if you think it's price is now too high for a sensible investment

1
Avatar for timarr

M&G is listed on here as a value trap, i'm curious to your view on that and if you think it's price is now too high for a sensible investment

I'm not sure my view is entirely worth having but I've bought M&g (LON:MNG) on the way down, at the bottom and on the way back up again. There's a bit of a discussion lower down about the pros and cons. It's now trading at over TBV so it's less of an obvious bargain.

I don't think the Stockranks or other ratings are working at the moment. Like all empirical tools they're based on past data and that doesn't work when whole economies get shut down. In addition M&g (LON:MNG) is only recently listed and without much data to work on they're not much of a guide.

To be fair, I don't anything could predict the last few months - but that's the one thing history teaches us. The unpredictable comes along with surprisingly predictable regularity :)

timarr

2
Avatar for AnonymousUser930783

Very Useful  analysis Tim. Thank you for your hints.

0
Avatar for timarr

Very Useful analysis Tim. Thank you for your hints.

Perhaps what I should have suggested is: wait for the markets to rise insanely, then buy a bunch of stuff that has zero earnings and little visibility, wait a couple of days for then to double, sell, rinse and repeat :)

We will presumably see a pullback here at some point, I'm virtually back to breakeven for the year, but it's hard to see current levels holding. Still, with lots of cheap money around and governments charging investors for the privilege of storing it for them it's also hard to see how markets can't do well, recession or no recession, once we're through the current crisis.

Personally I'd still rather buy companies with actual earnings and an element of growth but some of the direct consumer facing stuff we've seen rising was priced to go bust. There's a big advantage being on public markets right now, because raising funds is pretty straightforward even if the dilution is sometimes eyewatering (although not always). I expect we'll see a flood of IPOs when markets do open for business.

Couple of additional themes that have caught my eye - online delivery logistics and property rental. The former is pretty obvious - the figures coming out the likes of Tritax Eurobox (LON:BOXE) and Londonmetric Property (LON:LMP) show how little they're being affected by non-payment of rents - companies will obviously prioritise paying their dues on the earnings streams that are still working. The latter trend is less obvious but I was intrigued by the massive queues at IKEA last week. Usually a lot of the traffic there is driven by young people renting who need cheap furniture.

Leaving aside the societal issue of a younger generation that's permanently in flux it does suggest that the rental market is an area where there won't be much of a slowdown - in fact, coming out of lockdown you'd imagine a lot of people will be desperate to move. So maybe Property Franchise (LON:TPFG) and Belvoir (LON:BLV) will be beneficiaries: they both have attractive economics anyway, throwing off lots of cash with very low levels of capex and little or no debt.

The only other thing I've noted is that my dividend income stream has gone up significantly. Which is odd, because the only notice I take of dividends when investing is whether they're too great a proportion of free cash flow. Yet growth investors are seeing their incomes rise rapidly while income investors are seeing them collapse - I suppose that's markets being ironic :-/

timarr

0
Avatar for timarr

The key is to hold and add to winners while ruthlessly cutting mistakes. Overall about 45% of the stocks I pick are successful over a two year period - so I'm worse than a dart throwing chimp at picking stocks.

Me too. Thinking is often much overrated.

The main improvement in my performance over the last 30 years has been driven by a) spending less time doing initial research and b) cutting holdings that aren't working. The former means I end up with a larger sample set - doing endless amounts of research to understand companies is generally pointless: better to run through a high level checklist and, if they pass, buy a stake. Nothing like ownership to concentrate the mind.

The great thing about indiscriminate crashes is that they allow us to pick up quality stocks at a discount which means - temporarily - a much higher hit rate. But of my top ten holdings I've held eight for over five years, four for over ten. Momentum persists, particularly with companies that have an underlying moat so buying and holding winners and cutting losers drives outperformance.

FWIW my Eureka! moment came from Soros - who reckons he only gets one in three investment decisions right. But when he's convinced he bets big.

There's even a name for it: the Babe Ruth Effect.

timarr

2
Avatar for stegga1000000

Good to read your reply.
My Eureka! Moment only arrived last month when reading Mark Minervini’s book, he is a trader so I had avoided reading his books before, as I had never considered trading, but it was an eye opener, he has lots of gems to offer any type of investor.

He also says that out of 10 investments, you will only get 2 or 3 big winners so what do you do with the others, get rid of them. Also his key theme is making sure your losses are small.

He also had a small section on Time Value and the Power of Compounding:

Two 40% returns = 96% return
Four 20% returns = 107% return
Twelve 10% returns = 214% return

So achieving super performance doesn’t require you to find that elusive multibagger.

0
Avatar for Gutty

Which Mark Minervini book are you referring to please.

0
Avatar for stegga1000000

It’s Think & Trade like a Champion 

0
Avatar for stegga1000000

Thanks for the link to the Babe Ruth Effect.
I need to learn to apply it.

0
Avatar for timarr

Fasincating listening to Buffett last night. Highlight was Bill Murray turning up to ask a question.

He hasn't repurchased any Berkshire shares or made any big purchases because he prefers the optionality of cash - i.e. he expects markets to provide better opportunities. What he has done is sell all their airline shares (which given his previous comments on the airline industry were always an anomaly).

Berkshire is now sitting on $137 billion in cash. The headline loss is primarly investment losses, they actually made more money in the last year than the previous one.

Looking across the range of report from the US this week - Alphabet, Apple, Visa, Mastercard, Berkshire - the overwhelming impression is that things are bad, have got a little better, but no one really knows where this goes next. Investors, meanwhile, seem determined to believe that everything will go back to normal quite quickly and are budding up the prices of their favourite stocks.

Well, maybe. There was a quote in the FT yesterday that I thought was pertinent:

There are between three and five million people current furloughed in the UK. A lot of them are actually unemployed. They just don't know it yet.

Strange times.

timarr

2
Avatar for simoan

I don't bother following Berkshire any more but would wonder how the Insurance and Re-insurance businesses will fare in the current climate. Maybe he is needing to conserve cash to cover losses elsewhere? Did he mention how the insurance side was doing?

All the best, Si

0
Avatar for timarr

Did he mention how the insurance side was doing?

Insurance up about $350 million, re-insurance down about $450 million, insurance float delivered a $1 billion uplift. GEICO auto-insurance claims down which drove the whole insurance side to a profit.

There's a $230 million prospective hit in terms of Covid-19 claims. They expect an increase in claims going forward, but there's no obvious cause for concern. I'd be inclined to take him at his word - they're not buying because they expect better opportunities in future.

timarr

0
Avatar for Ashok Thakrar

Well explained. Wish I had had read it earlier. Will definitely for your ideas.Thanks

0
Avatar for timarr

Mastercard issued their Q1 results (ending March 31st) today and presently the shares have bounced 7% - obviously they beat analyst expectations. Which they did. But if you closely at the presentation that accompanies the results they include figures for April as well:

https://investor.mastercard.co...

Looking at slide 9 we can see that in April transaction volumes are down 20% to 25%. Cross border transactions, which is where most of the revenue is, were down 40/50% in the last three weeks. Remember this is payments volume so it's a rough proxy for economic activity - which if this is to be believed is falling at a startling rate.

I don't really understand how the market can reward an historical earnings beat in the face of current figures like this, although perhaps the view is that a few weeks aren't representative and everything will go back to normal.

There's a similar reaction to Alphabet's results last night - they've seen a sharp decline in ad revenue recently, but are cautioning that they can't yet extrapolate the last few weeks to the quarter. Again a big jump in share price, apparently discounting the immediate problems on the assumption that they're temporary.

Basically, if earnings don't start to revert to normal levels quickly there are going to be some nasty price drops ahead. And given the carnage we're seeing at the moment I don't quite see how we get back to normal quickly. Or I'm missing something completely.

But any other opinions would be very welcome because I'm wondering whether I'm completely missing the point.

timarr

3
Avatar for simoan

Basically, if earnings don't start to revert to normal levels quickly there are going to be some nasty price drops ahead. And given the carnage we're seeing at the moment I don't quite see how we get back to normal quickly. Or I'm missing something completely.

But any other opinions would be very welcome because I'm wondering whether I'm completely missing the point.

I'm sorry I can't be much help because your thoughts mirror my own. Given the severity of what has happened I find it inconceivable that I'm only 9% down YTD overall, and that my US portfolio is actually up 6% in GBP terms. This isn't supposed to be happening! Maybe we'll have to wait for the July reporting season to see a real setback? A full quarter of bad trading should do it. Shouldn't it?

Glad I don't have any chickens to count...

All the best, Si

3
Avatar for simoan

So we had Microsoft and Facebook reporting last night - two of my favourite companies to hold both directly and via Fundsmith. Interesting comment in the Microsoft release:

“We’ve seen two years’ worth of digital transformation in two months. From remote teamwork and learning, to sales and customer service, to critical cloud infrastructure and security – we are working alongside customers every day to help them adapt and stay open for business in a world of remote everything,” said Satya Nadella

Also an interesting update on the outlook on advertising revenue from Facebook:

We experienced a significant reduction in the demand for advertising, as well as a related decline in the pricing of our ads, over the last three weeks of the first quarter of 2020. Due to the increasing uncertainty in our business outlook, we are not providing specific revenue guidance for the second quarter or full-year 2020, but rather a snapshot on revenue performance in the second quarter thus far. After the initial steep decrease in advertising revenue in March, we have seen signs of stability reflected in the first three weeks of April, where advertising revenue has been approximately flat compared to the same period a year ago, down from the 17% year-over-year growth in the first quarter of 2020. The April trends reflect weakness across all of our user geographies as most of our major countries have had some sort of shelter-in-place guidelines in effect.

Facebook was up 9% in after hours trading so should open well in the blue today. One of my better recent decisions was upping my holding in Facebook earlier this month when it was on sale, unlike selling Boohoo (LON:BOO) pre-results at 250p :(

Interested to see what Apple have to say tonight.

All the best, Si

1
Avatar for timarr

Hi Si

“We’ve seen two years’ worth of digital transformation in two months. From remote teamwork and learning, to sales and customer service, to critical cloud infrastructure and security – we are working alongside customers every day to help them adapt and stay open for business in a world of remote everything,” said Satya Nadella

Yes, I'm seeing this a lot. What's remarkable is that the infrastructure has held up, which is testimony both to the resilient design of the internet and of the cloud service providers. Imagine how much worse things would be if the web had fallen over.

I bought Facebook near the bottom, wish I'd bought more but was put off by the stupid exchange rate. But even so neither they nor Alphabet are willing to put a figure on next quarter's numbers - the market rallies are taking an awful lot for granted (I'll stop saying that soon). But the FANGS, Microsoft, they will end up winning even if it takes a few years.

And in the real world there are good results too - Reckitt Benckiser (LON:RB.) (I hold) came out today with an excellent update powered by healthcare concerns. Jarvis Securities (LON:JIM) (also held) reported continuing high volumes of transactions. Compare this to the mess that is retail - John Lewis are suggesting that some of their stores will never reopen, while yet more have gone bust - and travel - looks like BA are shuttering Gatwick and Boeing are laying off 16,000: their CEO said it will be "years" before they pay another dividend. And these are the sector bellweathers.

Boohoo (LON:BOO) - not for me, I don't see how fast fashion can be sustainable going forward - but if you're going to hold a fashion retailer I suppose they're the one. If it got cheap enough I might buy Burberry (LON:BRBY) - I missed it at the market lows, but I'd want their moated brand and operating margins to reflect that to risk any capital here.

And yes, waiting for Apple and Visa updates tonight. Both purvey essentials, but Apple need to focus on their lower price offerings, iPhones are substitutable - high volume moats can be bridged if consumers end up short of cash.

timarr

1
Avatar for simoan

I bought Facebook near the bottom, wish I'd bought more but was put off by the stupid exchange rate. But even so neither they nor Alphabet are willing to put a figure on next quarter's numbers - the market rallies are taking an awful lot for granted (I'll stop saying that soon). But the FANGS, Microsoft, they will end up winning even if it takes a few years.

Do you not trade US shares in a USD account then? I'm always happy to hold a certain amount of cash in USD anyway, and have an account that allows me to trade US stocks without taking an exchange rate hit when buying and selling. I'm perfectly happy to hold Facebook and Microsoft through whatever happens next - talk about bullet-proof balance sheets!

I hold both Jarvis Securities (LON:JIM) and Burberry (LON:BRBY). I don't lose any sleep over either of them and they are long-term holdings. In due course, I will be buying more of both I suspect, particularly the latter. Boohoo (LON:BOO) - I'm less bothered about the sustainability of fast fashion, and in the short term more concerned that it is your average Boohoo (LON:BOO) customer who is likely to be most badly affected by the coming recession.

And yes, waiting for Apple and Visa updates tonight. Both purvey essentials, but Apple need to focus on their lower price offerings, iPhones are substitutable - high volume moats can be bridged if consumers end up short of cash.

I always used to think this way about Apple i.e. it's a product company. However, once I sussed that it's really a luxury brand it starts to look reasonably good value. Many people would rather die than be seen with a cheap phone (not me I might add!). I've never been convinced Apple products are as easily substituted by cheaper competitors as many people think and they have a brilliant ecosystem (sorry I hate that word but it's use is appropriate here). History would tend to back up this observation. But who knows... the future is unknown :-)

All the best, Si

 

0
Avatar for Sachiv Mehta

Ocado? (In hindsight, but there was a great article on them in mid - feb somewhere on Stockopedia)

0
Avatar for MH1

A great discussion thread and find myself nodding along with many of the ideas and themes.  I tend to look at investments currently as options and so the time value is important to me. Do I know how bad it will be-no. Do I know how long it will be-no.

Therefore my names have had similar characteristics, good balance sheets or asset light business models, a need to exist and ability to prosper post the ensuing mess.

I’ve struggled with the cyber security names and have been playing primarily in the US in Crowdstrike-it’s performed well but the issue is the crazy level of faith valuation, against that I’m not sure what truly exists over here.

Additionally in the US, Visa, MasterCard, Microsoft, Moodys, Msci- all effectively monopolistic type businesses, all in decent financial shape and all will come through. Timarr has already spoken about the first two but also the exposure to contactless that will be accelerated. Microsoft 3 stellar businesses and a cash machine, Moodys an oligopoly and exposed to the prodigious level of debt refinancing that we will see, Msci almost monopolistic now and probably the best play on the ESG theme. The problem with the US is that at best some of the valuations came down to near 20x, now they have raced ahead and I have started trimming as I feel this market will all take way longer.

In the UK . I too have Autotrader, but have held back on Rightmove though ultimately want to own it. I have been in and out of the house builders. Most are trading above NAV again and have extreme sensitivity to house prices so I prefer the safety of starting at sub NAV prices.  On the Beach I haven’t dealt yet but wonder if anchoring to the lows is stopping me pulling the trigger?! Amadeus is another name in Spain, it is the number 1 globally in the software ticketing systems that bring travel, hotels, carnrentals etc together. A more asset light way of playing the bounce when it comes-again I have been shy about pulling the trigger. Gym group, lowest cost operator, 22 months of cash, big free cash flow generator and the opportunity to still grow plus generally exposed to younger demographic. It’s dull post a 20% placing currently. I own both Codemasters and Frontier Dev and added to Codemasters in the meltdown. Worthy tiddlers-Getbusy, I continue to think this business is totally mispriced.  It’s loss making because it’s investing in a 3rd product-it will either succeed in that product or become a cash generating machine with a very sticky 90% recurring rev streams and growing.  E therapeutics-a former Woodford stock. An AI platform for drug discovery, I know the new chairman who created a lot of value at Silence Therapeutics. It’s had a huge run  but clearly more speculative.

In Europe I like STM, exposed to all the hottest areas of chip technology. It’s big and liquid so can be traded . I’m not currently in it but would buy it on weakness. I do own Dialog, not as sexy a name but has half its market cap in cash and much less automotive exposure.

I have generally cut anything that I feel I am gambling on but would go back if it was obvious the world had changed. Reach. Rockrose. Sosander.

Generally my cash weighting’s are still high. There is an optional it’s in cash that people underestimate ( maybe it’s generational). The Fed is trying to defy gravity so I think it could get messy again and if it isn’t so bad then there will be new opportunities in a new world.

 

3
Avatar for timarr

Hi MH1

I think if I had one statement to sum it up it would be: "go online".

There's a UK retail report out suggesting that post-crisis non-food retail will be over 50% of value, compared to 30% today. People who have never have bought online before have been forced to and have discovered it's not so hard. And with social distancing in force for some time to come then High Street shopping won't be much fun.

With that comes the transition away from cash - a YouGov survey has found that a third of people won't return to using cash after. Visa and Mastercard are guaranteed beneficiaries of that although online Paypal is just the most popular of a lot of alternative methods. Big question is if we have a recession will we see a fall in transactions - Visa announced a 4% fall to the end of March, and the crisis was only just unfolding. Both Visa and Mastercard are due to report last quarter's earnings this week, so that'll be a critical tell. But long term, they're a no brainer.

The rest of the US stocks you mention are about as safe as you can get, although they're all on heady prices. My baseline assumption is that we won't see the economy fully reopen until Q2 2021, once the flu season has passed and we have drug treatments to alleviate the worst of the virus symptoms - so there's plenty of time for all sorts of market action, with the odds to the downside barring a miracle vaccine discovery.

Getbusy (LON:GETB) is interesting, I was looking at them this week, but I'll take a closer look. Let's be honest, a company with the strapline "Work from Home" really ought to be interesting right now ... Gym (LON:GYM) I'm not so sure - in a recent survey on where people people would feel most comfortable visiting post lockdown gyms were bottom (garden centres were top). Perhaps that's personal bias - but my personal trainer and I will be working out in the fresh air once social distancing is relaxed.

All I did this week was top up Cerillion (LON:CER) after their results and buy Pearson (LON:PSON) before and after their (not particularly well received) trading update. The latter have been a lousy investment for a long time but they are now a pure play education company operating in an ideal market for their underlying online education business proposition. Most US quoted companies in this space are on a PER over 30, Pearson are languishing at 10. One of those is wrong.

I also still have high cash weightings. Too high, probably, but cash gives optionality in a market where that will be valuable. The challenge is to avoid staying in cash - in the recovery, whether that's in 3 months or 3 years, equities will be king.

timarr

1
Avatar for MH1

Good morning Timarr,

I understand the Gym Group reservations but most of the kids signing up wont be affording PTs:), I also think they'll see traffic from more expensive gyms. Weights and all sorts of exercise equipment is sold out online. As the low cost operator I think they'll thrive but it could be a longer road.However, this is what makes a market!

I will check out Pearson, I have only ever been short in the last 10 years and assumed it was still the same business. I have several investments in the online education space but they're all unlisted. 

Mike

1
Avatar for timarr

Hi Mike

I'm a Gym member, the PT's aren't so expensive ... my gym is a mixed clientel but definitely skewed to the young side and I can't see that crowd not going. Older people maybe not so much. Probably social distancing for a while. Pre lockdown that meant limits on numbers and no classes - which bring a lot of female custom - so they may struggle to both retain members and attract new ones.

On the other hand, the kit is hard to replicate at home and online workouts, although good, don't replace the gym experience.  I have looked at it, but put it in the too hard bucket - I'm sure they'll recover eventually, just don't know when eventually will come around.

Pearson ... hmm, well, what can we say, a horrible serial disappointer. But they've now flogged the last non-education bit and universities are struggling to mount online courses - my youngest is paying tuition fees for videos of last year's lectures. Slight concern is that UK universities are probably finding it hard to raise significant capital so I'd expect costs to be stretched over multiple years - but this is a global business, lots of money in the sector.  And if they can't make the business fly now they're a sitting duck for a takeover.

Nick Train has upped his stake again, but he's been doing that since 2012, so it's not the greatest buying signal ...

timarr

1
Avatar for Macro

I mentioned the SBIO.L Invesco NASDAQ Biotechnology ETF - See https://etf.invesco.com/gb/pri...

1
Avatar for Rusty2

OK thanks, that was probably it.

0
Avatar for shauniekent

Hi Timarr,
I had a couple of thoughts on this. The first was your assumption that we entering a recession. If this is the case, do you think we are a point where people fully realise the economic fallout from the lockdown and Covid19? I do not believe we are, I think many people comforted by the government furlough schemes etc are still wishful thinking that we leave our homes and things are more or less back to normal - certainly the people I work with and my family are hoping so. This leads me to believe the best time to be investing is some point in the future, rather than now - regardless of whether your rationale below is right. Your post didn't allude to the amount you may be holding in cash?

Furthermore, I think one can reasonably assume this is not only a recession but a possible depression.

Oil and gold were mentioned below. On the long term charts of stock markets versus either they both look extremely undervalued and in my view it doesn't take much insight to know that oil is not going to stay at $20 a barrel for too long (ie more than a year or 2 at most before going markedly higher).

Finally, i'll mention Bitcoin of which I am extremely bullish. I recently wrote an article on Stockopedia arguing that a rational investor should make a small portfolio allocation to Bitcoin. One thing i didn't write about what the correlation between central bank assets (which we know are currently sky rocketing with no end in sight) and the price of Bitcoin

https://twitter.com/TeddyVallee/status/1253330517061062656?s=19

All the best,

Shaun

1
Avatar for timarr

Hi shauniekent

Furthermore, I think one can reasonably assume this is not only a recession but a possible depression.

A depression is not just a big recession - it normally involves a collapse in credit availability and often deflation. Deflation is a real concern because if prices are falling then people hold off buying. I don't see either of those things happening.

A recession is quite likely - two quarters of economic contraction looks pretty much guaranteed from here, but that's already priced in. The question is how long it will take to recover - and that depends on the length and severity of a lockdown, the impact on confidence and how much unemployment there is. I weight the probabilities to longer rather than shorter, but nobody knows for sure.

On Bitcoin - well, recently it's correlated with other asset classes.  That's typical when crashes occur due to inherent uncertainty - supposedly uncorrelated assets suddenly start behaving in lockstep just when you want the opposite. The link is human nature, or course.

Although I'm no great fan of cryptocurrencies they are a hedge against political breakdown - we've seen Bitcoin used in Zimbabwe and Venezuela for instance. But you have to be really pessimistic to expect that to happen here. Ultimately Bitcoin is backed by people's belief in it - and for them to believe in it more than fiat currency then their faith in their government needs to have collapsed. 

Too volatile and too unlinked from the real economy for me. But, of course, for many that is exactly the attraction.

timarr

0
Avatar for jgunnsm2

Brilliant article. Thank you for sharing. Disney is really interesting but I don’t have Stockopedia for the US so cannot view the analysis and stock rank. I am guessing it cannot be relied on given the park closures. My belief with park closures at Disney is you get the visitors back and the ones who missed this year as for many visitors it’s a once in a lifetime to go to Disney so they will wait until next year. Disney has the opportunity to increase ticket prices more than ever to take advantage of the boom coming. I agree that Disney+ is difficult to lose once the kids and adults (I am a Star Wars fan) are hooked. 

Stay safe. 

0
Avatar for timarr

Hi jgunnsm2

My belief with park closures at Disney is you get the visitors back and the ones who missed this year as for many visitors it’s a once in a lifetime to go to Disney so they will wait until next year. Disney has the opportunity to increase ticket prices more than ever to take advantage of the boom coming.

I'm much more cautious than that. Firstly, though, theme park revenues are about 25% of Disney revenues, the rest come from streaming, films, owned networks, publishing, etc, etc. Not all of that 25% is lost but it's a big hit and Disney+ won't make up the shortfall. They'll also take a hit on film production, but I'd expect that to recover quite quickly. Going forward, even without the parks, Disney could still be very profitable if it reorganised.

Now, on to the pessimism ...

I don't think anyone listening to the CMO, Chris Whitty, at today's UK press conference could be under any illusions that the social distancing measures we're currently seeing will likely be with us, in some form, for a considerable time. Perhaps another18 months to 2 years in a worst case scenario. That's not the same as a lockdown, but it implies lots of care around venues where lots of people are in close contact and inclined to be less careful. Theme parks, festivals, bars would be obvious areas of concern - bars, for instance, are more or less the last things expected to be reopened.

A secondary factor is that people will be cautious, even when restrictions start to be lifted. Although many people will want to flock to these types of venues a lot won't, and I think you'll see a drop in demand. In this type of shock it usually takes about three years of normality to move back to a steady state.

My working assumption, therefore, is that the lost vistors are lost forever and that when parks reopen it will be with restricted numbers. Obviously the US may play this differently but the litigious nature of the society there will make companies cautious. For worst case estimates I expect to see Disney's theme parks running at 50% capacity when reopened for a couple of years before gradually returning to normal over four to five years.

As an aside - this is Disney, who have one of the strongest - maybe THE strongest - brands in the leisure industry, and who have huge resources that they can use to manage their way out. If this situation plays out as I suggest then weaker companies - which is to say, nearly all leisure related businesses - are going to be in a fight for survival. I admire investors brave enough to invest in the sector but it looks like a lottery to me. Even those that survive aren't going to be very profitable. But when the dust has settled Disney will still be standing.

I'd stress that this is my worst case scenario - but I do place a high probability on it. There seems to be a level of irrational optimism around that somehow when lockdown is lifted then things will go back to normal and company earnings will revert. Well, maybe - but I don't see any reason to risk my capital on it happening when there are obviously more straightforward places to invest.

Of course, the future makes fools of us all, and we may get a quick medical breakthough. In which case Disney returns to full profitability much more quickly. Either way, I won't mind.

timarr

1
Avatar for jonno

Good morning Timarr

I have been re-reading your article.  Your purchase of M&g (LON:MNG) piqued my interest.  It is unwanted like several other asset manager related stocks and as far as I can see as cheap as chips with a large dividend yield, which may or may not be paid.  Other than being familiar with the brand as a unit trust manager I am somewhat uniformed about the stock and so bearing in the caveat DYOR would be interested if you are able to share any  further thoughts you may.  I have started my research, but you are some way ahead of me.  I hope that you do not think me presumptuous or lazy in asking.

All the Best

Jonno

0
Avatar for timarr

Hi Jonno

M&g (LON:MNG) – hmm, well, yes, let me see … three lines of thought.

The first is that fund managers survive downturns. They may suffer drawdowns along the way, but they survive. So that ticks the first box, don’t want anything where the risk to my capital is 100% (and that means I’ll miss out on some big rises, happy with that).

The second is that they are very undervalued – I think when I bought my second tranche they were around 40% of book value and that was on a market that had fallen 30% plus. So there’s the second tick, there’s a massive margin of safety.

The third is that fund manager performance tends to mean revert. By and large they have absolutely no forecasting ability at all so performance is random. Of course they can carry on being very poor but at some point their luck will turn.

To that I’d add that there’s a reasonable chance of some M&A here. I think UK industrial stocks are off the table in terms of foreign takeovers, but M&G aren’t strategic to anyone, including themselves.

And, finally, with interest rates at near zero people with little investment knowledge will end up putting their money into markets via funds, and they’ll use the ones they’ve heard of. So on the upturn they’ll attract a reasonable amount of punter cash as people get excited about stocks.

Not exactly a glowing recommendation, I know, but I’d rather park my cash here than in a restaurant or airline. At least I know some of it will be there when I come back …

timarr

0
Avatar for Rusty2

Hi Timarr,

I believe you mentioned a Biotech ETF recently, I can't find it now, could you remind me which one it was, please.

0
Avatar for timarr

I believe you mentioned a Biotech ETF recently, I can't find it now, could you remind me which one it was, please.

Hi herbie

Sorry, but I don't recall that. I don't have any biotech ETFs - or any biotech stocks at the moment. The only ETFs I'm holding are Vanick Vectors eGaming and L&G Cyber Security.

timarr

0
Avatar for Rusty2

OK, sorry it must have been someone else.

0
Avatar for Bumpy

Hi Timarr

Why would you avoid Plus500 because of the Israeli connections?

0
Avatar for timarr

Why would you avoid Plus500 because of the Israeli connections?

Hi Peter

Three reasons, of different levels of specificity.

Firstly, I don't generally invest in overseas companies quoted in the UK. There've been far too many issues and when things go wrong there really is no possibility of gaining redress (although, to be fair, most UK quoted companies can get away with murder too, it seems).

Secondly, Israeli tech company culture is an old boys (and girls) network. Everyone was trained during National Service and everyone knows each other. As an outsider it's very difficult to understand what's really going on, and there have been plenty of cases where Israeli business culture differs from the standards we'd expect here.

Finally, on Plus500 (LON:PLUS) the directors have been remarkably good at timing purchases and sales.  If you're going to invest there it would pay to keep a careful eye on director dealings and follow their lead. And on that point, I'd note that they recently purchased signficant, multi-million, amounts of stock. Generally sales can indicate all sorts of things and the timing can be coincidence, but purchases - especially at volume and across multiple directors - are usually a strong sign of confidence.

Obviously, if I'd bought Plus500 when they issued their first positive trading update after the current crisis struck - somewhere around 650p - I'd have made a lot of money. So probably best not to follow my lead on this :)

timarr

1
Avatar for jonno

Hi Timarr

An excellent review and I agree with much of what you have said.

My take is slightly different. Regarding the FANGS and other still very highly rated, mainly American stocks, I can't bring myself to pay such rich valuations. I have therefore taken the approach of leaving this area to those with more skill and insight and have been buying funds/trusts such as Blue Whale Growth, Fundsmith Equity, Scottish Mortgage Investment Trust (LON:SMT) and £FGT.

I have yet to buy Disney and depending on price may well do so. It has a franchise and back catalogue to kill for.

Insofar as individual stocks are concerned my approach is generally is to avoid debt, have an eye to what are now historic investment metrics and what I think the intrinsic value of a company's assets are. I also ask myself will the company still be there when we emerge from the pandemic and pay close attention to the quality of management and their holdings and how they are dealing with the economic turmoil. Ability to pay dividends is a consideration, albeit relatively minor.

I have sold very little, but have added to or bought the following and try to buy when prices are depressed, but have not managed to buy at the bottom. Many of the stocks listed will not be everyone's cup of tea, but I think that I understand what they do and how they make, or should I say made a profit.

Fuller Smith & Turner (LON:FSTA) Good balance sheet after the sale of the brewing business and good quality, mainly freehold estate. The British pub will be here once this all passes.

Ryanair Holdings (LON:RYA) Whatever you think of his abrasive character, Michael O'Leary runs a tight ship and Ryanair is the best capitalised of all European airlines. Travel habits may change but people will still fly and go on holiday.

Itv (LON:ITV) I have banged the drum about Itv (LON:ITV) for a long time. The jewel in the crown is ITV studios. I am well down on my original purchase, but added a good amount at 59p.

Hollywood Bowl (LON:BOWL) I admire the management and their organic approach to expansion. The company's RNS announcements have in my view been exemplary in telling it how it is. I accept this business is very much in the front line but believe it will come through.

Premier Miton (LON:PMI) Again this goes against the current grain, but it is cash rich with several good funds in the stable and at some point the general public will start re-investing.

Strix (LON:KETL) Great cash flow and cash conversion. Global leader in kettle controls and is using its expertise to expand into water purification/filtration

Volex (LON:VLX) Again appears to weathered the downturn adeptly and has great potential in growth markets such electric cars, complex medical devices and date centres.

D4t4 Solutions (LON:D4T4) It is all about the data to quote the company. The ability to manage and integrate complex data is becoming increasingly important. The company is inexpensive for a software business, cash positive, is migrating to a Saas operating model and in general continues to trade well.

U And I (LON:UAI) Inexpensive in the extreme with management who have significant holdings.

All the best

2
Avatar for timarr

Hi jonno

Good post, and much to agree with. A few things come to mind.

Firstly if you look at Apple, Alphabet and Facebook you could have bought all of them in the past few weeks on a PER of around 20 before taking into account their cash piles. Given that they aren't going to go bust and are all likely to be major beneficiaries of a greater move to online that didn't look expensive. Amazon is another matter, but just look at that share price go ...

I bought Disney near the bottom (that and, bizarrely, M&g (LON:MNG)). I'm sure that will turn out well eventually but there's clearly some pain to come. However, they've raised $6 billion at an average rate of 2,9% at dates going out to 2050, so there's no immediate existential risk.

On the others I agree one way or another - I think it's possible to see a way through that will see restored earnings in 2 to 3 years so where they can be - or could have been - bought at lower prices if I think that will turn out very well eventually, notwithstanding there'll be some surprises along the way.

Personally, this week I bought Frp Advisory (LON:FRP) and Vaneck Vectors eSports, not hard to see where those thoughts come from. We have a lot of bad news to come, although I think there's a clear trend to re-opening for business which will get investors and markets excited in the short-term.

Whether that holds will depend not just on immediate earnings but whether the long-term prospects have been impacted too. I'm 60/40 that they have been, but I'm trying to focus on companies that can grow earnings anyway. As we get better visibility it'll be easier to make decisions on companies where there will be a short-term impact - but, obviously, if outlooks are better than expected then the big opportunity has already passed.

If so, I can live with that, especially as it implies we'll be getting back to something approximating to normal life sooner rather than later.

timarr

0
Avatar for abtan

Two things put me off Frp Advisory (LON:FRP) :

  1. Receivables is very high.
    >50%+ of revenue
    I don't understand why this is so high.
  2. Cash flow - members' drawings is massive, swings the FCF from very positive to very negative, so not as cash generative as first appears

With regards to 1. I'm sure there is an explanation. I'm just not sure what it is.

That aside, point 2. was the deal breaker for me. The income statement makes things seem quite rosy, but the drawings don't appear there and cash flow is actually quite poor.

If I have misunderstood how these things work please do let me know as there are a lot of positive comments on this company online so maybe I am missing something.

A

1
Avatar for timarr

Hi abtan

Fair points, as ever.

On the members drawings I think this is historical - partners previously (obviously) had significant control of how much they drew down. Going forward the Admission Document indicates that ex-partners' profit sharing will be equivalent to 25% of the earninsg before tax and and interest. A sweet deal we can agree, but it aligns the main fee earners with shareholders to the extent that I'm - well, not comfortable, but content under the current circumstances.

On receivables it's a good point. The Admission Document states:

In respect of the Group’s other business lines, the Group normally receives payment for the services it has provided once an engagement has been concluded and such payment may be in whole or part contingent upon a transaction or other given outcome having occurred. Whilst this is normal within the industry, it can lead to a lengthy period before payment is received and can expose the Group financially to a material degree to the risk of transactions not completing or other contingent outcomes not being achieved.

However, 'other business lines' are those not related to insolvency which is , supposedly, the main area of business. However, as most of this is unbilled revenue and that ought, presumably, to relate to insolvency I share your puzzlement. I'll dig some more.

timarr

1
Avatar for Richard Goodwin

'Whilst this is normal within the industry, it can lead to a lengthy period before payment is received and can expose the Group financially to a material degree to the risk of transactions not completing or other contingent outcomes not being achieved' which I guess why £mano 's services have proven popular.within the insolvency sector.

0
Avatar for jonesj

I still can't work out why the profit margins at Frp Advisory (LON:FRP) are so much higher than at Begbies Traynor (LON:BEG)
Which is a concern, as I have held Begbies for a few years.....

FRP list Begbies as their main competitor. FRP don't seem to explain income by segment, but 85% of their people allocated to a business segment seem to be doing insolvency. That's also Begbies main line of business,

Of course, Begbies margins were also higher after their flotation, in the early 2000s, but not at the level shown by FRP.

0
Avatar for Albertos

Its because the Frp Advisory (LON:FRP) figures disclosed do not include any fees/remuneration for the 50+ partners (as they were pre-flotation). These are the main fee earners.

The P&L figures on Stocko (from the admission document) are totally misleading.

1
Avatar for timarr

Its because the Frp Advisory (LON:FRP) figures disclosed do not include any fees/remuneration for the 50+ partners (as they were pre-flotation). These are the main fee earners.

Yep. Partners get 25% of earnings from here on in. I would ignore the Stockopedia numbers until we get reported figures. Peering through a glass darkly I think they're more profitable than Begbies Traynor (LON:BEG) - they certainly get bigger contracts - they've just been appointed administrators at Carluccios and Debenhams. But, let's face it, these companies are a bet on a grim short term for companies. At the very least they're likely to be resilient.

Even with government support if we assume leisure stocks face limited footfall for at least 9 months (and probably more) there's an awful lot of pain to come. In some ways this has just been artificially delayed - cheap money has kept a lot of relatively poor companies going over the last decade and now we've saved all the problems up for one short period.

Anyway, I've done here what I do frequently - buy small, watch carefully and then scale up if the figures make sense. At the very least it's a Keynesian beauty parade stock.

timarr

2
Avatar for aflash

On the Travel theme:

SPCE (Virgin Galactic holdings) rocketed up, came back to Earth and bounced. Future growth? Can get to Mars on cheap oil?

TRN (Trainline) added an FX loss to its operating loss. Capital Research Global investors bought in March as Merian Global investors sold, both before it settled at 200p. 

Both too high for me at the moment.

0
Avatar for RDHOWARTH

I would also caution investors of sell side research that will focus on the last recession. It rarely works like that. Good companies will come through this one, bu it may take a while. 

0
Avatar for RDHOWARTH

To cope with a bear market I have two simple rules: 

1. Do not sell bottoms. 

2. Do not chase the rallies.  

If you cant bring yourself to buy at a bottom, do nothing.  You cant devise a strategy for a bear market in a bear market. Only two things work, holding lots of cash ( or hedges) and defensive stocks. The latter change in each bear market but generally they are survivors and have strong balance sheets. Normally unfashionable. Fashionable shares are dangerous. In fact anything that was popular in the bull market is dangerous. 

For what follows be openminded and just concentrate on reducing defensives, cash, hedges during periods of weakness and re directing money to stocks getting killed that will survive and recover. Don't underestimate how long the bear will last. The recession will likely be 12 months and most people are ill prepared for the current environment. There will be great opportunities but we don't know what they are yet. 

Bear market rallies are brutal, but great opportunities to sell. In a bear the market will rise more days than it falls. So when you see the scary falls, just think, there will be a better time to sell. 

Im afraid im not much of a theme man, and prefer to have a highly concentrated portfolio. I would argue during the bear market its all about the stocks and balance sheets. Good management will get institutional backing in a fund raise, bad won't. 

8
Avatar for Bullsnbears

You mentioned you were cutting from retail. Any thoughts on the hospitality sector? JD Wetherspoon, Marstons. What are you thoughts if they can ride out the storm? Cheap?

0
Avatar for timarr

You mentioned you were cutting from retail. Any thoughts on the hospitality sector? JD Wetherspoon, Marstons. What are you thoughts if they can ride out the storm? Cheap?

Hi Bullsnbears

Way too soon for me. I'm sure most of them will survive but in what form is impossible to discern. If the lockdown is lifted in a month and they can generate enough cashflow to maintain operations without raising equity or significant debt then I'm sure they'll return to historical earnings levels in 2 to 3 years - and, yes, they'd be cheap now. But that's a big if and would probably mean you'd have to ride out some volatility along the way.

I still hold Young & Co's Brewery (LON:YNGN) - mainly out of sentiment - where the share price has (to me) inexplicably recovered. If I were buying in the sector now they would be my choice - in fact at under £6 at the bottom they were worth a punt, trading below NAV. Now - probably not.

To buy anything with zero earnings and no visibility takes a lot of guts - those who get it right will make a lot of money at the risk of losing everything. Personally I prefer to make less money with less risk of outright failure. The only stuff I'm interested in investing in with that profile would be companies with very low capex requirements that ought to be able to ride out the storm for a very long time - something like the online platforms of On The Beach (LON:OTB), Auto Trader (LON:AUTO), Rightmove (LON:RMV) or Purplebricks (LON:PURP).

In the end it's about our personal willingness to take on risk. I'm highly risk adverse - someone like Paul Scott is not - probably because he's a far better analyst of the sectors he understands than I am. Half the battle is knowing your own limits.

timarr

0
Avatar for abtan

Hi Timarr

From your penultimate paragraph here am I to understand that Purplebricks (LON:PURP) has piqued your interest? I must admit I wasn't expecting to see it listed alongside the likes the Auto Trader (LON:AUTO) and Rightmove (LON:RMV) .

Like you my biases kept me away from it until recently, so I am curious whether anyone else has looked into it and/or has any thoughts.

A

0
Avatar for timarr

Hi abtan

Yes, Purplebricks (LON:PURP) looks interesting although I've only had time to give it a cursory lookover. As you say, my biases led me to categorise it as an overvalued, overhyped story stock that had been found out - a sucker stock, basically.  But times move on, they now have a robust looking balance sheet and - crucially - a much lower cost run rate.

Mostly what I want to buy now are the sort of things I wanted to buy six weeks ago (is it only six weeks - how the world has changed) - companies with reliable earnings, net cash, low capex, good levels of free cashflow and evidence of some kind of moat in the form of operational margin or return on equity at a fair price. However, I think there's another category worth looking at - anything that has low capex and net cash that can easily keep running through the lockdown but whose competitors don't have the same advantages.

Purplebricks (LON:PURP) may fit that category - brick and mortar estate agents are going to struggle at the end of the lockdown because they're still weeks away from cashflow in what will be a difficult market.  I hold Property Franchise (LON:TPFG) for similar reasons. M Winkworth (LON:WINK) is another - although the price bounced yesterday after an update while I was still thinking about it. But this type of analysis is much harder than just buying shares in good companies.

I'll take a deeper look at the weekend, it looks like an interesting and low risk way of riding a recovery, even if we're talking a few years of patience.

timarr

1
Avatar for timarr

Hi abtan

RE: Purplebricks (LON:PURP): so if I understand what I'm seeing correctly we have a decently profitable UK business, a slightly lossmaking Canadian business, a stake in a German estate agent and US and Australian businesses in run-off - in fact, they ought to be closed by now. Given the nature of the business and the likely trajectory of home selling in wake of our current crisis it's very interesting.

However, I'm concerned by the continuing prodigious outflow of cash. Between the interim results on December 12th and the COVID-19 update on 31st March they managed to get through another £6.6 million. Some of that will be to do with shutting down the US and Australian operations, but not all - they projected a maximum cost of £14 million to do that and spent £11.7 million on them in the first half. The latest update didn't indicate that they'd finalised that process. Any thoughts on where the cash is going? Assuming they have control of their cashflow they should survive the lockdown with ease, but that's an important caveat.

Beyond that - yes, I can definitely see the attraction. A lot of small estate agents will struggle in the forthcoming downturn, assuming they survive the lockdown. If Purplebricks (LON:PURP) is well capitalised and well managed there is a definite opportunity. I also note the CFO has just left to be replaced by someone with a background in the industry having been the CFO of Zoopla's parent group. And the shareholder list is headed by Axel Springer, who are unlikely to let them go bust.

FWIW, I also take a lot of notice of CEO language. It was that which persuaded me to buy Games Workshop (LON:GAW) before the run-up and the director speak here is in the same mould - although the proof will be in action not words. However, investing in a company in recovery mode is different proposition that buying one in a stable state.

Broadly - if I was sure the cash haemorrhaging from the business was at an end I'd be a buyer. Without that assurance - well, probably still worth a small punt. If it survives and thrives then buying at double the current price (around 36p) would still be a good investment.

timarr

0
Avatar for abtan

Purplebricks (LON:PURP)

Hi Timarr

Pretty much spot on with your analysis:

  • UK doing well and still growing
  • Canada about break-even and growing
  • US + Oz shut down
  • Stake in German estate agent

To address your cash flow points:

  • Cash at 31st March was £35m
  • Extreme cash burn I estimate at c £2m per month. though I expect it will be lower than this, let's say £1m per month for a lower range if all staff are furloughed, zero marketing, and maybe some support for some agents.
  • (for reference there are c500 agents, so if the company provides any support, I am estimating 1k per agent per month = £0.5m per month - this would fall within my £2m cash burn estimate)
  • So the company has enough cash to survive 1.5 - 3 years as of the beginning of March 2020.

Results for H1 resulted in Adj EBITDA of £4.3m, or £3.1m excluding share based payments.

The UK by itself had Adj EBITDA of £5.5m, or £4.9m excluding share based payments.

The EV is currently £73m, so for a reasonably fast growing company, with a large cash safety net, this certainly looks cheap

306f2610fb6cf9048c1c2b3b880c06f7e27f8b4c1587302412.png
0
Avatar for aflash

What is missing here is Oil and Transport. 

There is Zero chance that people will stay at home permanently. 

Technology has developed time and space solutions that help mankind achieve so much more.

No hot tips or suggestions how to play it. 

The list is very long from Commodity and country Etfs to Airlines via Train companies, Cruise lines and small cap oilies. 

It is one area where you maybe  have some time. Demand has not finished dropping. Nevertheless traders have already anticipated what happens next.  

For my part I have traded RDSB, BP & XOM, actually aiming to reduce core holdings because their business models may be out of date and their dividends at risk. Traded CCL, and GOG, no position anymore. Anyone want my SGC? Too much debt. Traded Oil but aiming to build a larger position as the price hopefully drops more. Hold some Refiners, after all their margins stay the same, whatever the price of the 'entrant' commodity. There are lots of these from specialists HFC, VLO to large integrated oil companies. Missed DTG, hold AIR, thinking about AVAP. Hold some VTU. There is a podcast that reveals how the CEO is using technology to negotiate out of the crisis and how the used car market may develop. Plus freehold property. Want some TRCS but missed the low and since McArthur has gone do not want to chase it.

Sophisticated debt investors could do well stateside with fracking companies.

Larger airlines are toast but that may be reflected in the price.

Countries that import oil could do well, Turkey, India. Countries that export it maybe oversold.

TSLA over-discussed, time will tell.

Lots of 'may be' as far as prices are concerned but theme constant.

Anything I missed?

0
Avatar for timarr

Hi aflash

Travel, especially international, is likely to be the last sector to improve - the World Economic Forum reckons it'll take 10 months to get back to normal after the pandemic is over - and that's still months away:

https://www.weforum.org/agenda...

After 9/11 it took 3 years for air traffic levels to regain their former levels, it seems unlikely people will willingly be piling into densely populated planes, trains or buses in the near future - surely everyone will get in their cars? There will be permanent changes as well - a lot less business travel. If I wanted to invest here I think I'd need a very long timeframe and would only want the companies with the strongest balance sheets. Have held Air Partner (LON:AIR) in the past but no longer comfortable with the management after the accounting issues.

On car dealers - well, that's tricky. I did a bit of analysis on Lookers on Stockopedia (links to Stocko pages don't seem to work but easily found looking for discussions on Lookers (LON:LOOK)) and came to the conclusion that their assets would be rapidly shrinking while under lockdown. The car industry is the first to suffer in a recession, so the future doesn't look great either. The car manufacturers are increasingly looking at pay to drive as a model for the future and I can't see how the traditional dealer fits into that - maybe they still have a service / distributor role? But lots of capital employed and sod all return, they look like value traps to me. Be interested in a link to the Vertu podcast though.

Oil and gas - absolutely no idea, the complex interplay of supply, demand and geopolitics is beyond me. The undiscovered bright side of coronavirus maybe the positive impact on the environment? But that's probably wishful thinking rather than sensible financial analysis.

Tracsis (LON:TRCS) - yes, if the price came back. Rail maybe generally - the network's essentially nationalised so everyone's making some money. Trainline (LON:TRN) would be interesting but I don't understand the price.

Broadly - a lot of bad news to come, buying a portfolio of this stuff at bombed out prices would yield good returns, with a few wipeouts, but not really my thing. Time will come, though. If I had to pick one company in the vicinity it'd be Intercontinental Hotels (LON:IHG) - their franchise model protects them from a lot of pain and even if business travel drops off there'll still be decent domestic figures as people staycation at home.

timarr

1
Avatar for aflash

Tks TRN (Trainline) idea. I find their web site excellent. Indeed the share price is a conundrum.

As requested:

https://cardealermagazine.co.uk/publish/vertu-motors-boss-robert-forrester-car-dealer-live-midday-tuesday/189057

0
Avatar for john652

Hi Timar,

Air travel will be interesting and up until now I've thought at severe risk of mandated social distancing so say 1/3 of normal passengers allowed. But I read an interesting article by an aviation body offering planes to the government for excess NHS critical care beds - on the headline I thought, clutching at straws surely.

On reading it, take out the seats, put in beds, you have ready installed electric supply, oxygen delivery & importantly very high quality (HEPA) air filtering for the safety of the medical staff. Hmm, quite a good idea actually.

So, a thought, and this applies to the inventiveness of businesses everywhere that are desperately trying to think how to survive. Airlines could adapt the oxygen delivery to provide normal air for the whole flight. So passengers have to wear the mask (or a new more comfortable mask) for the duration. A pain sure, but would you not fly for this reason? This could remove one of the biggest hurdles for the industry post lockdown. Or you have your £5 instant C19 test before flying, or antibody test when it arrives, and cleared to fly. Obvious issues with this approach but maybe the airlines are not as bad as I've been thinking,



1
Avatar for timarr

Hi john652

Yep - we have a psychological tendency to extrapolate our current situation indefinitely into the future. But people and businesses are inventive, they don't just sit around waiting for the inevitable collapse, they innovate and try to figure out how to deal with the situations they find themselves in.

However, when this kind of systemic crisis occurs there are inevitably businesses that simply don't survive. Anything going into this with lots of debt and a poor business model is pretty much stuffed other than by luck. In the end we need to play the odds - buying well capitalised businesses that still retain earnings power at reduced prices is a better bet than buying debt ridden ones with no earnings at bargain ones. Of course, some of the latter may survive - and there will be people with deep knowledge who may be able to sort the wheat from the chaff, but I'm not one of them.

Talking of wheat, in amongst the carnage of what passed for the morning regulatory announcements was a positive one from Spirent Communications (LON:SPT) - 1st quarter revenue up 12%, $208 million on the books, an increased final dividend and continuing momentum as they help to build out 5G infrastructure. Even in these times there are gems if you look hard enough.

timarr

0
Avatar for simoan

Yep - we have a psychological tendency to extrapolate our current situation indefinitely into the future. But people and businesses are inventive, they don't just sit around waiting for the inevitable collapse, they innovate and try to figure out how to deal with the situations they find themselves in.

This is very true and a lot of investors miss this - good companies with quality management adapt and find new areas of business, sources of revenue etc. Good companies will come out of this crisis stronger and more dominant. Tbh I'm quite interested in looking out for completely new ideas which emerge from these tough times. 

As an example, I'm not blowing my own trumpet, but in the midst of the tech crash in 2000-01 our traditional line of work completely collapsed and so me and my colleague were forced to rethink and decided to completely change our business model by starting a complimentary business with much higher margins and a much easier way to make revenue. I'm not saying it was easy to start with, far from it, but we are still doing it 20 years later and it's the reason I obtained  financial independence way before my 60th birthday. Without the tech crash, things may have turned out very differently.

I believe some great companies will rise out of the ashes of this crisis. We just need to spot them and watch them grow. 

All the best, Si

2
Avatar for Rusty2

I don't know much about refiners but about their margins, if demand falls then their revenue will fall and their costs will increase proportionally, so margins will be hit? With airlines grounding planes and motor traffic reducing considerably then demand must have fallen significantly?

1
Avatar for aflash

Of course. 

That knowledge is widespread which is why the prices of the shares have dropped. 

However there will always be a need for the refining process. Do not forget all the by-products of Oil: chemicals and plastics.

Furthermore, statistically, the previous falls in the Oil price have been followed 2 to 3 years later by a significant rise. Increased demand, increased activity and costs savings on volume even if the base product is more expensive.

The title of this thread is 'Long Term Themes.'

The whole 'sea-change' in the development of solar and wind-power; the development of the LNG (Liquified Natural Gas) market, the ships to carry it; the environmental 'war' against plastic and the relative decline of the value of oil is relevant but beyond the scope of a 'comments' section.

'Get up early, work hard. strike oil...' may not have the impact as when Paul Getty said it but the commodity is still an important part of the economy.

0
Avatar for TangoDoc

Having just bought some more white metal 54mm Napoleonic figurines through ebay and begun to paint many more that I had undercoated but stashed away, I also snapped up some Games Workshop (LON:GAW) at a significant discount to the price they once were. We boys never really grow up, we never have enough soldiers to paint and, the joke in the hobby has always been that you're not allowed to die until all your unpainted figures are finished.

Any business capable of continuing, even growing, online that appeals to children of all ages, can survive even Covid. And, by the way, I just have myself. It has taken meover a month and the smell of coffee is heaven.

4
Avatar for timarr

(Your question provoked me to Google it! {Source World Steel Association})

Hi Phil

That's the point really ...

For superforecasters, beliefs are hypotheses to be tested, not treasures to be guarded.

Philip Tetlock, Superforecasters

Together we are better if we challenge each other. Respectfully, of course ...

So assume automotive and home construction halves. Maybe home construction is - say - 20% of all construction? So that removes 16% of demand. Perhaps another 3% off the rest. Is it plausible that government spending could cover that and more?

I'd suggest it can, but not with great confidence - maybe it's a 55% chance? Maybe?

Compare that - say - to the probability that governments will boost spending on healthcare. I'd be really confident there - say a 90% chance? But perhaps that's overconfidence on my part?

And in any case, healthcare companies are more expensive and construction companies are pretty cheap ...

I think I'd hedge my bets between the two without more data. But it's interesting, I'd never have considered iron as an investment without your suggestion.

timarr

0
Avatar for Metatron

Just a thought but before buying I would try to ask oneself (however crazy) whether the UK or USA govts might try to nationalise cash rich quality companies .
The British poltical class seem to regard the NHS as a religion and how far will they l go to justify funding it?
How far will Trump go to get re-elected?Is it unthinkable that Trump might try to acquire cash rich quality companies run by Democrat supporting CEO's or CEO's Trump has personal feuds with?

0
Avatar for Albertos

Although it hasn't been talked about much on Stocko in the past a major theme for me at the moment is Gold miners - with gold at an all time high in GBP terms and seemingly getting there in terms of USD as more and more monetary lossening takes place.

They have to be producing and paying dividends - not interested in exploration plays.

Polymetal International (LON:POLY) , Highland Gold Mining (LON:HGM) and Anglo Asian Mining (LON:AAZ) are the main ones I hold at the moment. (Dabble a bit in Centamin (LON:CEY) but this has had quite a few production problems in the recent past.) I'm sure there are some ETF's and Investment Trusts out there, but I don't look at these.

You have to comfortable with the geopolitical risk here.

There is a risk that the mines will be closed by lock-down (as has happened in the case of Hochschild Mining (LON:HOC) ) but lock-downs in Russia, Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan have not caused the closure of the mines yet (and I suspect won't given the knock their oil industries are taking).

Minor theme I'm exploring is Iron Ore. Currently prices are holding up well in the face of the global slowdown (aided by on-going problems at Vale) and I'm hoping China will boost infrastructure spending to restart its economy. So I'm starting to build a stake in Rio Tinto (LON:RIO) and have some in Ferrexpo (LON:FXPO) .

Following/thinking about many of the themes above . Entering the market with very small stakes with the idea of building from there as they rise (hopefully) and possibly as they fall if I consider the market is wrong. The idea is that I know I won't get the timing right but the market will come right in the end and I shouldn't be too badly scarred in the interim. Lets see if that works and if I have the "bottle" to carry it through if the market starts to fall again.

Phil

2
Avatar for timarr

Although it hasn't been talked about much on Stocko in the past a major theme for me at the moment is Gold miners - with gold at an all time high in GBP terms and seemingly getting there in terms of USD as more and more monetary lossening takes place.

Hi Phil

My advice on mining stocks is to closely follow what I do - and then do exactly the opposite. It's one of many sectors where I have no discernable skill level other than an impeccable ability to do precisely the wrong thing every time.

On gold I agree. Usually I adhere to Buffett's argument that it's an unproductive use of capital but in an environment with zero interest rates and governments printing money it's a hedge against future uncertainty. Due to my general incompetence in the area I prefer to use physical gold ETFs rather than trying to navigate the political risks and complexities of individual gold miners.

Infrastructure spending seems like another interesting area. I don't much like businesses that are dependent on discretionary government spending but surely we'll have a burst of Keynesian contracyclical investment as we emerge from the Covid-19 inspired slowdown? I think, though, my preferred approach would be to look at healthcare rather than fixed infrastructure - there I'd worry about the costs in an inflationary environment with fixed price contracts.

With iron isn't car making the second highest use, after construction? Would the increase in infrastructure investment outweigh a reduction in the automotive and housebuilding sectors?

timarr

2
Avatar for Albertos

Evidently the use is:-



Buildings and infrastructure, 51%
Mechanical equipment, 15%
Automotive, 12%
Metal products, 11%
Other transport, 5%
Domestic appliances, 3%
Electrical equipment, 3%

(Your question provoked me to Google it! {Source World Steel Association})

Personally, also, I think the West will have to do something to stimulate the automotive industry when they start emerging.

Iron ore is not by any means a certainty - but I think it has interesting possibilities.

Time will tell as always.

Phil

0
Avatar for abtan

Hi Timarr

Thanks for the post. Below are some thoughts of my own.

-----

My Position

It seems like you have taken many new positions over the last month or so. I hope you don't mind me asking, but do you usually have so many positions, or is it simply due to the current circumstances?


The reason I ask is that I am usually close to 90-95% invested with 20-25 holdings.
In the last month I am 85% invested with 40+ holdings - quite new territory for me and I wonder if I am spreading myself too thinly?

Incidentally, a few of my recent holdings mirror some of your choices and for the same reasons that you have alluded to.  These include:

IG Group (LON:IGG)
Moneysupermarket.Com (LON:MONY)
Goco (LON:GOCO)
$WALT
Minds Machines (LON:MMX)
Ten Entertainment (LON:TEG)

How the share prices will react in the next 6 months I have no idea, but I do believe that they will be back at their "normal" levels within the next 2-3 years, which is why I have bought them now.

---

You mentioned Home Working and Home Delivery companies (eg Domino's Pizza (LON:DOM) ).

I agree that short term profit increases are inevitable, though I personally have not found a company I would buy as I perceive other short term beneficiaries (such as IG Group (LON:IGG) or 888 Holdings (LON:888) ,) where share prices have fallen relatively deeper, are providing more value at the moment.

For the avoidance of doubt I do expect Domino's Pizza (LON:DOM) to be a good long term purchase and did consider buying over the last couple of weeks. I know HelloFresh is highly regarded and its price has risen in recent months, but again, it just looks too expensive, and my focus has been on share prices that have gone down.

---

I have also been tempted by some Game Developers (and made a small purchase of Electronic Arts at recent lows as it generates oodles of cash and has a relatively small CAPEX outlay), but I must admit that I haven't understood why so many other developers are so highly valued and continue to be "expensive" relative to their cash generation.

I know £TM17 is a favourite on these boards. Their main franchise that I am aware of is Worms, which I myself played a long long time ago. It has clearly lasted through the ages, but why is the company so well regarded now?

I also question what the impact of services like Google Stadia (Netflix for computer games) will have on the industry going forward. Surely there will be pricing pressures on the smaller game manufacturers in the medium term as these services become more popular?

For reference the other 2 games related companies I have looked at are Cliq Digital and G5EN.


---

Cyber Security - there are so many companies out there I just don't know where to start. 


----

Online Platforms

I personally would avoid Auto Trader (LON:AUTO) .

I have quite a detailed knowledge of the company and always thought they would never be dethroned. However, having seen the rapid rise of Cargurus in the USA, I am wary of Auto Trader (LON:AUTO) maintaining their lofty position in the long term.


---


Other  - Purplebricks (LON:PURP) - I have never been a fan of this company, but looking at the last results it is clear that there is a highly profitable company after removing the now discontinued US and Australian operations.  Competition I imagine will also reduce in the short term and the share price is very depressed at the moment, no doubt impacted by the current situation. 

My position is already quite large, and the only reason it is not larger is because Woodford's legacy position (via Link) remains unsold. 

I have bought into a few other companies not mentioned above, usually because I saw a material recovery within 2-3 years, but also as small "punts" that could multi-bag over a similar time period (eg Easyjet (LON:EZJ) ) With regards to the latter, my punts are very small positions.

As a final note, I have also been tempted to buy back into the house builders. People will still need homes in the coming years and I imagine a player like MJ Gleeson (LON:GLE) , which focuses on low price homes, will do well. I cannot imagine the government turning off Help To Buy in the current climate.


Interesting post again, thanks!

A

2
Avatar for timarr

Hi abtan

Interesting, I'll go back and look at Auto Trader (LON:AUTO) again. I'd not even considered Purplebricks (LON:PURP) which is bias on my part, I'll revisit. I've also been looking at Electronic Arts and will revisit that whole online gaming sector when I get the chance. On housebuilders I already hold Berkeley Group (LON:BKG) and Redrow (LON:RDW) and, on the whole, they're in good financial shape - but a recession is always brutal for them and will surely trump the "we need more homes" mantra?

I regularly operate on a portfolio of 50 to 100 positions - currently about mid way although still with an unusually high cash weighting of 40%. Obviously I'm aware of the portfolio sizing theories but I've managed a CAGR of around 12% for two decades with relatively low levels of volatility and sleeplessness.  The key is to hold and add to winners while ruthlessly cutting mistakes. Overall about 45% of the stocks I pick are successful over a two year period - so I'm worse than a dart throwing chimp at picking stocks.

The high cash balance is a consequence of cutting stocks where visibility has collapsed while buying smaller starter positions in a range of new ones, as detailed above, so it's in part an accidental consequence of the situation rather than a predetermined policy.  I doubt there'll be many weeks for the forseeable future where I won't be buying.

Thanks!

timarr

1
Avatar for stegga1000000

Hello Timarr,

The key is to hold and add to winners while ruthlessly cutting mistakes. Overall about 45% of the stocks I pick are successful over a two year period - so I'm worse than a dart throwing chimp at picking stocks.

Mark Minervini’s explanation of Risk/Reward in my understanding:

If I am prepared to risk a loss of £100 for £200 profit , ie 1:2 ratio, then if you get 1 out of 3 investments right then you won’t be any worse off. That is a success rate of 33%, he calls it the batting average. So having a success rate of 45% is a winning performance. I presume your risk/ reward ratio is better. Key is to keep your losses small.

Good luck with that success rate.

0
Get the free newsletter