GAN plc: the difference between UK and US growth stock valuations
Gan (LON:GAN): I’ll remember this one for a while. Another addition to my ‘what could have been’ list.
The stock was chugging along very nicely on AIM, rising from around 50p in 2018, to the 100p–200p range last year. I jumped on at 132p and it quickly became pretty much my highest conviction stock.
Then coronavirus came along and I jettisoned my entire portfolio at the beginning of March. This saved me from some very nasty paper losses, which I’m sure I would have crystallised at lower levels, if I’d held on longer. GAN hit 69p, so getting out at 160p was a great move.
Still, those RNS announcements about a move to the Nasdaq exchange continued to trickle through. That’s bound to be good for the stock, I thought. The Americans love a growth company, and the story is great (GAN is at the forefront of the legalisation of gambling across the US). But I’m meant to be keeping my powder dry for now. I can buy back in later, when the markets are more settled.
Well.
The last recorded price for GAN’s UK listing on Stockopedia was 225p on 4 May. The StockReport from 2 May tells me it was valued at £200m. That was in itself a new all-time high: the average market cap being closer to £150m in the six months before delisting.
It opened on the Nasdaq at an IPO price of $8.50. UK shareholders were given 1 US share for every 4 UK shares they held. It closed that day at $11.40 and is now hitting $28, for a market cap of £650m.
Two months ago, the UK market valued this company at £200m.
Today, the US market values this same company at £650m.
It does make you wonder why growth companies would bother listing on the UK market, when the US or private equity backers may provide much higher valuations, and probably more in the way of fresh capital injections. We’re all aware of AIM stocks which come to market repeatedly, just to see their share prices ebb away to penny status.
I’m not sure whom it reflects more poorly on, however. GAN has revenue of around £25m, so a £650m valuation?! Seems almost nuts, to be frank.
Then again, I was on a webinar the other day, which showed the UK All-Share market has returned 65% since 2012, while the Nasdaq has returned 340%. So maybe we’re the daft ones for swimming in this stagnant pool?
Post Script
Having invested for the best part of a decade, I find the toughest thing to endure is narrowly missing out on these big winners. I’ve had stocks make big losses and the odd one go to zero, but nothing gnaws at me more than the stocks I should have bought, or should have held for longer, but didn’t – and missing out on the fabled multibagger as a result. Sure, I’ve been happy with my returns overall, but look what they could have been.
If a stock makes a loss, I was wrong; if a stock I like hits the stratosphere but I wasn’t along for the ride, it’s painful to think I should have been, and some minor decision got in the way…
I sold AB Dynamics in 2016 at 302p, thinking it had given me a good gain and it was now fully valued. The stock recently hit 2,800p! I never stopped liking the company, just decided to sell.
I’ve never looked at a stock as many times as BooHoo back in 2015, when it hovered just above the 20p mark and Paul was writing about it frequently in the SCVR. I thought it looked great, too. In fact, I looked at it so many times, I forgot I hadn’t actually bought any! Then it rose into the high 20s and I thought I’d wait for a pullback. Well, my attention turned elsewhere and the rest, as they say, is history. Ouch!
Tristel – sold in 2014 at 70p and recently hit 500p. But none as annoying as GAN – shaken out against my will, an instant multibagger swept from under my feet! And I did the right thing, I just didn’t get back in quickly enough.
I’ll hit on one of these stocks, one day!
Disclaimer
This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.
11 comments
Chris
If you read the book "Art of Execution" it might help you in your portfolio management , it help me to keep on to my winners and getting rid of my losers .
"UK All-Share market has returned 65% since 2012, while the Nasdaq has returned 340%"
With reference to you statement above, this has a lot to do with commodities companies being listed in the uk , and of historical reasons . and possible brexit reasons ..
if you looking for the growth companies at fair value ,have a look at european markets bigger markets, bigger opportunities, Have a look at my fantasy portofolio which reflect about 80% of my picks I have about 6 holding list in european markets.( DYOR)
Hi dustyie. Thanks for the comment. Yes I read Art of Execution back-to-back with Minervini’s book in March 2017. I have the date marked off because it represented a watershed moment for me and my returns improved instantly, from that point. I think both books are excellent and very complimentary.
I have no doubt execution / portfolio management is at least 50% of the ball game. But like all zero-sum games, it’s best to build from a sound defence. I like to keep the best sports teams in mind! So defence has been my focus.
I find I have no problem following the ‘assassin’ mentality outlined by Freeman-Shor. I’m very happy cutting losers if down 10-20% from entry, or immediately on a profit warning. I naturally find it very cathartic. When I analyse my past sell decisions, the vast majority have been right and saved me money.
Since I started in 2012 my annualised returns have been 13.06% with only 10.25% annualised volatility. This puts me on a similar footing to the Lindsell Train UK Equity Fund (13.76% pa with 11.52% annualised volatility). So I have to be happy with that, during my first eight years as an investor, where I’ve tried out various approaches and expanded on my learning year-on-year.
The next step in my development is to add a little more attacking flourish to this sound defence, by allowing myself the growth mindset to hold runaway stocks beyond the point it feels comfortable, on a valuation basis, probably banking the gains more slowly over time. I’m sure there’s a quote to this effect (maybe from Peter Lynch?) but I can’t seem to find it anywhere.
On the subject of other markets, I’ve also added the European subscription and have found myself more comfortable in that universe than the US. I bought Euronext earlier this year and was looking at Lleidanetworks last month, but unfortunately that one isn’t available on Hargreaves Lansdown.
I do find the European universe a bit hard to filter on Stocko: the filter by country function to remove UK stocks hasn’t been working for a few months now (logged with support), and a lot of the results are from exchanges such as Turkey and small Eastern-European countries, whose stocks are either unattractive or can’t be accessed on HL. I find the Scandinavian stocks are often most interesting.
I tried to look at your fantasy portfolio but I can’t for the life of me find the fantasy portfolio page anywhere on the site! I do remember creating one myself, but haven’t heard anything more about it since.
All the best,
Chris
Yes just check the the fantasy portofolio , it only accessible through the old stockopedia platform . (switch over to old web site under the profile tab ) . Yes you probably right to start with northern european countries first, as these markets are more mature and regulated , I find it easier to take up positions through my IG spread betting account , DFD(daily fund bet). if the spreads are wide it usually a sign that more caution is required
Nice post thanks Chris. I bought into GAN last year as well and when they started talking about a Nasdaq listing my thoughts were identical to yours - that US investors would place a higher premium on a business heavily focused on the US and riding a wave of legalisation.
Now I didn't expect US investors to take to the story quite so readily but full credit to any of them who bought in at the moment of listing. As for valuation well GAN is perfectly positioned to benefit from online gambling spreading from state to state and they are absolutely focused on this journey. I wouldn't bet against them.
Disclaimer: I do still hold GAN and haven't been tempted to sell - so far anyway!
Congratulations on the GAN holding Damian - I am duly jealous! All the best with it.
Interesting comments! What I so tear my hair out about is that so many intelligent Stocko subscribers give the impression that UK equities are the only asset class in town. Go to any modern professionally managed DC pension fund and you'll find that UK equities are a very small-bit player. Generally a UK equity fund (if offered at all) would be one of several a specific 'self-select' option, departing from their carefully constructed global equity options. DB consultants took their trustee clients down this route many years ago and DC funds followed not long after. Just one example - Nest is hardly the height of sophistication but you'll see from p. 4 of their latest quarterly investment report https://www.nestpensions.org.uk/schemeweb/nest/aboutnest/investment-approach/other-fund-choices/fund-factsheets.html that the top 10 holdings in their 2040 default fund includes not a single UK equity.
Even US investors are now waking up to their 'home country bias' and diversifying more.
Citya.m. today has yet another article explaining the dire performance of FTSE100 against global markets https://www.cityam.com/the-ftse-100-is-lagging-behind-soaring-global-markets-but-why/
I know it's fun to pick individual stocks - and some subscribers evidently are very successful - but to my mind you've got one leg tied behind your back if you're fishing in such a shallow pool as the UK. Wasn't there a Stocko article a few weeks ago about cyber-security businesses and how hard it was to find a decent example in the UK - perhaps demonstrates my point?
I agree the U.S is far more likely to put a much bigger valuation on a growth stock. Currently there is a profitable tech share forecast to grow earnings approx 100% this year and 35% in 2021. It's on a forward P/E of 20. If this was listed on the Nasdaq I would expect it to be 2-3 times the Mcap.
Hi
with reference to GAN "NUTS" valuation :-) , I have post a link below , which might go some way to justified it high valuation
At present GAN is market leader in it field (I think 30%) ... and has huge growth potential in the USA alone
https://calvinayre.com/2020/06/17/business/gan-poaches-tier-1-online-gambling-client/
P.S. As you probably guess by now .. yes .. I'm a shareholder :-)
I'm a newbie investor and your post is really interesting to me. I don't know anything about the stock you mention, but the interesting factor is this UK/US stock divide.
There seems a certain amount of sniffiness towards American stocks on this site and as an Englishman i'm not sure why. The argument seems to be that the US stocks are overvalued and investors will get their comeuppance. But when? We can all set stop losses these days and take profits. I am a noob so I would love someone to explain to me what i am missing.
The second thing i've noticed it how small beer the UK market is compared to US. We have bath mats, pasties and greeting cards and they have futurist technology. That's not meant to poo poo Dunelm, Greggs and Card Factory (all of which I own). But where are the English Crowdstrike, Tesla and.....?
My biggest UK winners so far have been highly speculative (Renold - up 50% and Amur Minerals -up 78%) but I bought tiny positions in them given their nature.
This post was not meant to be confrontational in anyway, just would like to understand why people prioritize the UK market over US.
Hi SHSlim, thanks for you post - I think my thoughts are exactly in line with yours actually.
Loved this comment: 'We have bath mats, pasties and greeting cards and they have futurist technology'!
Pretty much sums it up. If you compare the top FTSE 100 firms versus the top NYSE firms, one group is full of tech powerhouses and the other is full of ex-growth companies from yesteryear.
I do still struggle with the US valuations however. I added the US subscription to Stocko two or three years ago, but cancelled it after a few months, as I felt every stock I looked at seemed to be on too high a valuation. But that 'over-valuation' can last a long time and a tonne of money can be made riding the wave.
Tesla is probably the poster-child, with a market cap well in excess of most other traditional car companies combined, although it actually produces a very small number of cars at present and is barely profitable.
No stock will trade at a 40+ PE ratio in perpetuity. At some point in any company's life, growth slows to low single-digits at best (otherwise it would take over the whole economy). An ex-growth PE ratio may be 10-15 or as low as 5-8, depending on various factors. If a multiple contraction like that hits, any stock would suffer. It just depends when.
I do think the US markets are in bubble territory just now. Several classic signs: high private investor involvement / excitement levels (Robin Hood traders); narrow leadership (only the FAANGs are rising year-to-date, the rest of the market is down overall); and the ratio of stock market capitalisation to US GDP is at historical highs.
https://www.longtermtrends.net...
On the flip side, ultra-low bond yields do warrant high equity valuations, if the equity risk premium is kept stable.