One year results for the Mechanical Bull Portfolio

Friday, May 30 2014 by
13

Please extend a warm welcome to the writings of the "Mechanical Bull" - a UK based private investor investing his portfolio with a purely systematic approach based upon Stockopedia data including the StockRanks and Screens.  

For an introduction to his method please do read his excellent introductory post "The Mechanical Bull Method".   We will be syndicating occasional articles from his blog to Stockopedia.


 

A First Birthday

On 24 May 2013, the Mechanical Bull portfolio was born. It wasn't called that in the beginning. It was just an idea that I had been thinking about for a while before I decided to put into action. I invested a hypothetical £30K to see where it would lead. It was a couple of months later when I gave it the present moniker.

So where are we a year later? Well according to stock prices on Google Finance, the MB portfolio is £42,779, which is an annual gain of 42.6 per cent. While this may seem impressive, it is important to see performance in perspective.

Comparative Analysis

First, we should look at the broader market. The FTSE 100 has been pretty flat over the past year. The FTSE 250 has done somewhat better overall with a rise of about 9 per cent, although it was up by a lot more earlier in 2014 with a big pull back in the last few months.

It is also useful to compare performance against other investment strategies. Stockopedia's "Screen of screens" gained by 25.6 per cent

The MB portfolio would have come 7th equal out of Stockopedia's 65 guru (long) strategies. However, three of those ahead have two or fewer stocks, and so the MB portfolio would have faired even better if these non-diversified strategies were excluded.

Although the MB portfolio has gone sideways for the past 3 months, it has actually held up quite well compared to other strategies and the broader market. Indeed, the MB strategy outperformed all these comparators on 3 month, 6 month and 1 year timescales as this table shows:

    Table 1: Portfolio performance up to 25 May 2014

 

It's Not All Good News

It all seems pretty positive so far. However, a closer look at the current state of the…

Unlock this article instantly by logging into your account

Don’t have an account? Register for free and we’ll get out your way

Disclaimer:  

As per our Terms of Use, Stockopedia is a financial news & data site, discussion forum and content aggregator. Our site should be used for educational & informational purposes only. We do not provide investment advice, recommendations or views as to whether an investment or strategy is suited to the investment needs of a specific individual. You should make your own decisions and seek independent professional advice before doing so. The author may own shares in any companies discussed, all opinions are his/her own & are general/impersonal. Remember: Shares can go down as well as up. Past performance is not a guide to future performance & investors may not get back the amount invested.


Do you like this Post?
Yes
No
14 thumbs up
1 thumb down
Share this post with friends



Staffline Group plc is a holding company, which is engaged in the provision of recruitment and outsourced human resource services to industry and services in the welfare to work arena and skills training. The Company has two segments: Staffing Services, which includes the provision of temporary staff to customers, and PeoplePlus, which includes the provision of welfare to work and other training services. Its Staffing Services focuses on providing complete labor solutions in agriculture, food processing, manufacturing, e-retail, driving and the logistics sectors. Its recruitment business operates from well over 300 locations in the United Kingdom, Eire and Poland. The Staffing brands include Staffline OnSite, based on clients' premises providing both blue and white collar, out-sourced, temporary workforces. Its Employability includes work program, prime contractor in over nine regions and sub-contracts in approximately five regions in England. more »

LSE Price
1270p
Change
-2.2%
Mkt Cap (£m)
362.7
P/E (fwd)
10.5
Yield (fwd)
2.2

Gattaca plc, formerly Matchtech Group plc, is a human capital resources business dealing with contract and permanent recruitment in the private and public sectors. The Company operates through two segments: Engineering and Technology. The Engineering segment comprises Barclay Meade and Alderwood recruitment consultancy brands. The Technology segment includes the Connectus recruitment consultancy brand. The Company is a provider of specialist recruitment services to the engineering and technology industries, both in the United Kingdom and internationally. The Company offers three core solutions: Contingent Workforce Solutions, Permanent Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO) and Total Workforce Solutions. more »

LSE Price
108p
Change
-0.2%
Mkt Cap (£m)
34.8
P/E (fwd)
4.5
Yield (fwd)
n/a

Dart Group PLC is a leisure travel and distribution, and logistics company. The Company is engaged in the provision of air travel organizer licensing (ATOL) licensed package holidays by its tour operator, Jet2holidays Limited, and scheduled leisure flights by its airline, Jet2.com Limited (Jet2.com). It distributes temperature-controlled and ambient products on behalf of retailers, processors, growers and importers in the United Kingdom. It operates through two segments: Leisure Travel, and Distribution & Logistics. The Leisure Travel business focuses on scheduled leisure flights by Jet2.com to holiday destinations in the Mediterranean, the Canary Islands and to European Leisure Cities. The Distribution & Logistics business includes the operations of Fowler Welch-Coolchain Limited, a distribution and logistics services provider. Its temperature-controlled operations are in Spalding in Lincolnshire, Teynham and Paddock Wood in Kent, and Hilsea near Portsmouth. more »

LSE Price
785p
Change
-2.6%
Mkt Cap (£m)
1,199
P/E (fwd)
9.2
Yield (fwd)
1.3



  Is LON:STAF fundamentally strong or weak? Find out More »


11 Comments on this Article show/hide all

Edward Croft 30th May '14 1 of 11
4

Mechanical Bull. Your study validates the results we've been seeing. The top 1% StockRank stocks have returned about 40% over the 13 months or so. We'll be releasing this data soon. The top 10% of StockRank stocks have returned about 35%. It's been quite eye-opening really.

Of course - past performance is no indicator of future results.  I'd be v. surprised if the next 12 months were the same - the stock market is rather unpredictable year to year.

 

| Link | Share
Blissgull 31st May '14 2 of 11
1

Those are impressive results.

Can you clarify what rules have been used for selling shares in the mechanical bull? Are they sold when the stockrank+guru screen formula falls below a threshold or when they no longer appear in the screen of screens etc?

Is the buying formula just to take the top 15 shares by stockrank and number of screens?

| Link | Share
mpat89 31st May '14 3 of 11
1

Thanks for posting this. Very useful. I have been using Stock Rank > 90 as one of my mechanical filters but your method is surely an enhancement to that. One thing that strikes me is that you have no rules regarding sectors. Would you not be concerned about becoming exposed to too much sector specific risk?

If we look at the current screen, there are 7 stocks with a spread of less than 5%, 5 of which are in Industrials. Any comments on mitigating that risk?

Professional Services: Web hosting
| Link | Share
pooledaniel 31st May '14 4 of 11
1

@ Bliss - the trading rules are set out on the blog.

See http://bullmechanic.blogspot.co.uk/2013/12/the-mechanical-bull-method.html

| Link | Share
Mechanical Bull 31st May '14 5 of 11
2

Blissgull - The sell trigger is when Stockrank+Screen of Screen count (MB score) falls below 90. The proceeds are then used to buy the stock with the highest MB score stock not already in the portfolio. This is a fairly arbitrary rule I have set just as way of being able to rotate the portfolio and maintain exposure to higher scoring stocks.

I have not done much detailed research into the effectiveness of this strategy. However, as part of my annual review, I made a comparison of the MB methodology as I've described with the performance of a portfolio of the 15 original MB stocks over the last year (i.e without any rotation). I think it is good idea to keep an eye on the rear view mirror to see how sold stocks have performed.

As it turned out, the performance was almost identical. So, maybe the current strategy is too cute and I would better off holding stocks for longer. Certainly it chimes with general warnings against over-trading. This is a theme I was going to write about a bit more in my next blog post.

Blog: Mechanical Bull Blog
| Link | Share
Mechanical Bull 31st May '14 6 of 11
2

mpat89 - You are right that the MB strategy over-weights certain sectors. Three of the current 15 MB stocks (Staffline, Harvey Nash, Matchtech) are in the recruitment sector. However, all three have all been stand out performers. So, I am aware of this issue, but I have not been excessively worried about it.

It would be interesting to go back and see how a more sector diversified strategy would have performed. That's given me a good idea for a future post. Thanks!

Blog: Mechanical Bull Blog
| Link | Share | 1 reply
Edward Croft 31st May '14 7 of 11
2

In reply to post #83720

MB - we do have plans to build out a rebalancing/portfolio building module that would sit on top of the screener. i.e. one could filter screening/ranking results to ensure sound sector diversification, set up periodic rebalancing schedules (quarterly, annual), liquidity filters (filter out wide spreads etc) and also desired weighting (equal weighting, value weighting, mkt cap weighting).

Indications are that enforcing max sector exposures reduces volatility and risk (e.g. banks in 2008) but at the expense of some upside performance. It's all a bit of a balance.

Anyone reading this should join the StockRanks webinar on Wednesday - I'll be showing the first year results of the StockRanks plus a few thoughts about how best to use them.  You can sign up here.

| Link | Share
mpat89 31st May '14 8 of 11
2

Will this webinar be recorded for us ordinary folks with day jobs?

Professional Services: Web hosting
| Link | Share | 1 reply
PhilH 31st May '14 9 of 11
2

Hi MB,

Thanks for your blog and posts.

Have you considered that the European Screen of Screens has a 1 year return of 47% whilst the Eurofirst 100 has returned ~ 12%. The challenge with the European stocks is that you are going to get the more obscure exchanges, such as Poland and Turkey, plus you might also be uncomfortable about particular countries e.g. Greece, Spain, etc. That said of the top 20 stocks in the European SoS I have have owned £NOLA_B (Stockholm), Dart (LON:DTG) (London), ST Ives (LON:SIV) (London) & £BAKKA (Oslo) and I still hold Veidekke ASA (OSL:VEI) (Oslo), Cegid SA (EPA:CGD) (Paris) & Salmar ASA (OSL:SALM) (Oslo).

Also I think one of the issues with using the SoS as a starting point is that you run the risk of missing the biggest gains. I've found that my best returns have come from stocks that I've screened that appear on few screens then as they've developed they creep into the Screen of Screens. In other words the SoS sort of validates my original selection and rather than jumping into the share at that point I'm monitoring them looking for a change in momentum to signal an exit.

That said the mechanical strategy you describe is straightforward to follow. It'll be interesting to see how it continues to perform.

Best of luck
Phil

Professional Services: Sunflower Counselling
| Link | Share
Edward Croft 31st May '14 10 of 11
1

In reply to post #83722

Hi mpat89 - yes of course - we'll record it and post it on Youtube.

| Link | Share
Mechanical Bull 1st Jun '14 11 of 11
4

PhilH

I have not looked at European stocks, partly because of the subscription costs, but mainly because my approach is a work in progress and for the moment, UK stocks are a big enough universe in which to test out these ideas

I tend to agree with your view on limitations on the SoS. Indeed, I think that screening in general has fundamental limitations. Basically, the more filters you apply, the fewer candidates you are left with so there is a practical limit on how many factors you can include. Also, a stock only has to fail on one criteria and it will disappear from the list. Screening is a blunt instrument.

The idea of StockRanks is much more accommodating. As there is no filtering, there is no practical limit on the number of measures that can be incorporated. The only question is which factors correlate with future performance and how these should be weighted.

The other thing I like is that StockRanks are a relative measure of how well a stock is fairing against all others. One of the problems with many of Stockpedia's guru screens is that they fluctuate over time and so some only have a 1 or 2 stocks, or even none. I think it is always better to think in relative rather than absolute terms and this is the essential difference between ranking and screening.

In future, I might look at ditching the screening element of the MB strategy completely. If Ed's comments about the performance of the top 1% StockRanks are anything to go by (i.e. 40% over the last year), then it may be that the SoS element is not actually adding that much.

MB

Blog: Mechanical Bull Blog
| Link | Share

What's your view on this article? Log In to Comment Now

You can track all @StockoChat comments via Twitter

 Are LON:STAF's fundamentals sound as an investment? Find out More »



About Mechanical Bull

Mechanical Bull

I am a private investor with an interest in mechanical and rules based investing for UK stocks

Follow



Stock Picking Tutorial Centre



Let’s get you setup so you get the most out of our service
Done, Let's add some stocks
Brilliant - You've created a folio! Now let's add some stocks to it.

  • Apple (AAPL)

  • Shell (RDSA)

  • Twitter (TWTR)

  • Volkswagon AG (VOK)

  • McDonalds (MCD)

  • Vodafone (VOD)

  • Barratt Homes (BDEV)

  • Microsoft (MSFT)

  • Tesco (TSCO)
Save and show me my analysis