68
Archived articleThis is an archived article from 2018 - please note that any content within the article may be out of date.

Stable stock ideas for volatile markets

I don’t know about you, but the recent market correction has rearranged my portfolio with all the subtlety of a bull in a china shop. I imagine I’m not the only investor sweeping up broken crockery right now.

As I write, the FTSE 100 has found a degree of resistance at the 7,000 level (down from 7,877 in May earlier this year). Macro fears abound: Brexit, trade wars, increasing debts, weakening underwriting standards and the gradual normalisation of interest rates, to name a few. The days are also getting shorter, but my colleagues assure me this happens every year.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, 2018 has been a volatile year. We are more than nine years into a bull market and pretty much in uncharted territory. If the UK stock market was an ‘X’ on an old pirate’s map, it would be scrawled right next to a ‘Here Be Monsters’ sign in the middle of the ocean.

The nature of this bull market deserves a book in its own right, propped up as it has been by the most massive bout of global quantitative easing in human history. There have been some unprecedented monetary policies enacted in the past decade by central banks, which makes second-guessing this market especially tricky. One thing is for sure: we may be in the middle of this bull run or we might be nearing the end, but we are certainly not at the start.

The risks are skewed to the downside but if you are not quite ready to start storing cash under your mattress just yet, it might at least be prudent to consider a couple of stocks with defensive characteristics.

With this in mind, I went to ‘Browse Sectors’ in Stockopedia's drop-down ‘Home’ menu, opened up the ‘Consumer Defensives’ sector, sorted its constituent companies in descending order of StockRank, and picked the top three UK-listed stocks to have a look at. (Click here for a shortcut)

Wynnstay (WYN)
Share price: 440p
Market cap: £86.9m
StockRank: 98

I was surprised to see Wynnstay pop up. I invested in this company because it is very boring, operates in the countryside away from the London hype machine, and has been around forever (well, since 1918). WYN began life as a farmers’ co-operative but grew steadily over the ensuing decades and, via a series of mergers and acquisitions (the latest being the acquisition of eight stores from Countrywide Farmers in April of this year), has morphed into a major supplier and retailer to the UK agricultural industry with an £80m market cap.

It does not appear to attract much analysis or share chatter, and yet here it is, at the top of the Consumer Defensives sector with a StockRank of 98. The group has a strong dividend record and a history of profitable, acquisitive growth in a relatively unexciting (ie. overlooked) area of the economy.

A glance at WYN’s five-year financial summary on the group’s Stockopedia page throws up a couple of issues, however. The biggest in terms of the theme of this article is apparent in the volatility of Wynnstay’s revenue over time. This volatility is down to the fact that, while WYN is in the Consumer Defensives sector, it is prone to cyclical factors.

The group’s sales and profit are linked to cyclical farm gate prices -- hardly a characteristic of a resilient, defensive stock. Another mark against it is the group’s current operating profit margin, with the ratio for 2017 coming in at an underwhelming 1.95%. While this is factored into the share price, which is valued at 0.21 times sales and 13.4 times 2017 earnings, the fact remains that there is not much of a cushion should Wynnstay experience a drop in revenue.

An aside: while exposure to farm gate prices might restrict the group’s control over sales and profit growth, they do act as a profitable tailwind when the going is good. It is worth noting that these prices have begun to normalise after a period of underperformance and could lead to slightly more favourable margins. Once the direction of travel pivots, this new trend can remain in place for years, and Wynnstay stands to benefit through operational gearing.

The group’s chief exec said in its recent half-year trading statement: ‘Wynnstay's interim results are encouraging, with the Group's stronger performance reflecting the long-awaited upturn for the agricultural sector, which started to come through in 2017. The continuing improvement in farmgate prices has boosted farmer confidence, and demand across most product categories was higher year-on-year. Demand for feed also benefited from the prolonged winter.’

In conclusion I feel that Wynnstay is more cyclical than defensive, however.

Tate & Lyle (TATE)
Share price: 660p
Market cap: £2.98bn
StockRank: 97

Tate was established as a sugar refiner in 1859. It merged with Abram Lyle & Sons in 1921 to become -- you’ve guessed it -- Tate & Lyle. Boring names are good, and a business that can trace its roots back more than 150 years (hopefully) won’t go bust anytime soon.

The group was at one point responsible for refining around 50% of the UK’s sugar, but it sold this part of its business to American Sugar Refining, Inc. in 2010. Today, the group focuses on using innovative technology to turn raw materials like corn, tapioca and oats into ingredients that add taste, texture, nutrients and increased functionality to food and beverages. It has scale, it is multinational, and it has barriers to entry in the form of its proprietary food tech.

TATE’s five-year revenue history, much like Wynnstay’s, flags up some questions though. Primarily, why the dip in sales between 2014-16?

In 2015, TATE experienced weather-related supply chain disruption, which ‘significantly’ impacted business, leading to lost sales and £20m of additional costs. Its bad luck continued with the temporary closure of one of its plants in Singapore following an industrial accident. A tricky year, then.

Stuff happens. Perhaps more important is the fact that TATE appears to have rebounded encouragingly. Again using the Financial Summary section we can calculate its six-year average operating profit margin to be around 7.6%. If you strip out the 2015 and 2016 figures to approximate an underlying average margin, this increases to 9.6%.

The group does have net debt of £392m but with a net debt to EBITDA ratio of 0.8x and interest covered 14.6 times as of FY 18, this is hardly a problem.

Ideally we would see profits rising each year but this is not the case with TATE, given the operational issues in FY15. A return on capital figure of 13.4% is encouraging though -- as is TATE’s ability to recover from supply chain and factory disruption. On the surface of it, there is a lot to like about Tate & Lyle as an investment. Perhaps in future we will look back on its April share price of 526p as an attractive buying opportunity.

Carr’s (CARR)
Share price: 154p
Market cap: £137.1m
StockRank: 95

Carr’s is a business I have not come across, although I should have, considering one of its two divisions is in more or less the same agricultural space as Wynnstay. Come to think about it, it is a great example of how the StockRanks system continues to introduce me to interesting research opportunities!

Carr’s agricultural business is more international in scope than Wynnstay’s. It has a presence in the UK, Europe, New Zealand and the US. FY17 revenue in the division was £315.9m and underlying operating profit £8.6m, giving an underlying operating profit margin of 2.7% -- some way ahead of Wynnstay’s. Carr’s is also linked to the same farm gate cycle. The group’s management confirms as much in its 2017 full year accounts:

‘Farmer confidence has returned during the year as a result of the increase in farmgate milk prices and improved revenues from beef and sheep leading to a recovery in farm incomes. We expect farm incomes to continue to improve throughout the current financial year.’

Carr’s other operating division is its engineering segment, which ‘includes the design and manufacture of bespoke equipment for use in nuclear, oil and gas, and petrochemical industries’ -- so farmers looking to expand into the nuclear power plant business need look no further.

Approaching this share for the first time, its high StockRank of 95 is perplexing given the group’s patchy recent track record of revenue and profits:

In FY17 operating profit in the Agriculture division fell 17.2% to £8.6m, while operating profit collapsed by 74.2% to £0.7m (mainly due to a large contract getting delayed in the UK). Assuming this recovers next year to 2016 levels of c£1m and taking into account the more favourable conditions in its agriculture business, perhaps Carr’s will enjoy some profitable tailwinds heading in the months and years ahead?

The above companies all have their merits and perhaps warrant further investigation. Wynnstay and Carr’s stand to benefit from an upturn in farming incomes and could enjoy meaningful increases in profit over the next couple of years. It is this cyclicality that arguably compromises them as defensive stock candidates, however. Tate & Lyle has scale and proprietary food technology. It appears to have developed a competitive moat and enjoys higher returns on capital and equity than either Carr’s or Wynnstay. The resilience of its stock price over the past month suggests it may also be worthy of more in-depth research as a defensive stock.

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

23 comments


Avatar for John Gibson

Ed,
"so farmers looking to expand into the nuclear power plant business need look no further."

Great sentence, thank you!

0
Avatar for 1James1n1

Hi Jack,

Whilst the first port of call after some market choppiness might be to look at Defensives, have you considered Begbies Traynor (LON:BEG), which is at heart an insolvency specialist? If we get a sustained downturn, this is one company who could stand to profit in such circumstances. I have previously held Begbies Traynor (LON:BEG) and they have spend recent years seeking to broaden its range of activities so as to avoid cyclical impacts and doing quite well as a look at the stock page might suggest.

The other thing I have been looking at it Pharma companies (although have not looked at back-test data at this point) as I would anticipate that these may be less susceptible to a down-turn, although comments on this line of thought are very welcome!

0
Avatar for Beginner

The recent sharp falls have left most REITs unaffected; insurance has seen little volatility, and tobacco has seemed quite resilient. Alternatively, should income seekers think about shifting into preference shares to guard their dividends?

If a rising tide lifts all boats, surely the ebb tide will bring them all down too? To really squeeze the metaphor, ships laying aground can lay no lower. This suggests a decent place for your cash might be in companies/sectors that have already taken a hammering? The latter might include Flowtech Fluidpower (LON:FLO) , Walker Greenbank (LON:WGB) , Playtech (LON:PTEC) , Centrica (LON:CNA) and Cenkos Securities (LON:CNKS). None of the latter seem in danger of busting, they all have ample room for expansion, each has some form of moat, and they all display a proven track record of profitability.  During the most recent flap none of these shifted that much, so there may be stability here, or futility.  Perhaps not so much bottom fishing as sifting through the mud!

1
Avatar for Jack Brumby

Beginner -- not stocks I’m too familiar with, but that’s quite the extended metaphor in any case. Here’s to plain sailing!

1
Avatar for fletty

i looked at the top 25 in the same sector out of curiosity and immediately excluded 9 of them including WYN and CARR, based on very high spreads (5 or 6% in some cases) and low volumes/thin trading. TATE looks OK though

2
Avatar for Hear here

If fear you don’t know Tate and Lyle very well. It still has significant commodity businesses that make up over half the earnings, they like to talk about the added value stuff but there is a lot more to the business. The Singapore plant wasn’t closed temporarily it was closed permanently due to huge pricing pressures in Sucralose

3
Avatar for Jack Brumby

Hi cmills93,

No I don’t know Tate & Lyle’s business very well -- I hoped this article might throw up some new research candidates and that's what happened!

I see you’re right re. the Singapore factory, thanks. When I was writing this up I went to the FY15 accounts and found a reference to an ‘extended shutdown of the Singapore plant following the accident in April 2014,’ but missed the wider, permanent restructuring, apologies.

0
Avatar for vik2001

i just noticed in the US Russell 2000 the 50 day MA is about to cross down over the 150 MA. which is a signal of a bear market in this small cap space.

0
Avatar for Howard Marx

It's getting close.

If you sell on this so called 'death-cross', which techncal trigger do you use to re-enter? When the 50d crosses above the 150d again?


5bcefc715c44arut_2018_50dsma_150dsma.jpg


2
Avatar for Benson212

Hi Howard Marx

Yes, you re-enter on the "Golden Cross" which is when the 50 DMA moves sharply above the 200 DMA (or 150 DMA in your case). You can find Golden Cross examples under Tools >>> Chart Signals if you're interested in applying this to individual stocks.

The ratio between the 50 DMA and 200 DMA is considered an important part of momentum. In fact, emperical studies suggest it's predictive of excess market returns if the 50 DMA is above its 200 DMA (the higher the better) and it forms part of the Stockopedia Momentum Rank.

Trading the Golden Cross can be an excellent trading strategy in itself, but you must be careful of "false signals" - they're numerous. Therefore, combining this with fundamental analysis such as upward analyst earning revisions, improved market sentiment etc. will help you find winners.

2
Avatar for dfs12

Another vote for Tate & Lyle (LON:TATE). For me it is a goldilocks share... good value but not worryingly cheap (V=67), good dividend (Yield 4.6%) but sustainable and good cover (1.79), a bit of debt but not too much (gearing of 13%), momentum rank is high (91) and has been improving over the last few months (+29 in the last 3 months), balance sheet ok (Price to tangible book 3.3), not expensive on price to sales (1.1) especially when one looks at a good net margin (9.78%). The other thing I like about it is that it probably has a "image problem". Most people associate Tate & Lyle (LON:TATE) with sugar production at a time when sugar is the new evil, even though they are now a company who helps companies reduce the sugar content of their products having sold the sugar business years ago.

1
Avatar for donald pond

if you want a truly defensive sector I would have thought Infrastructure was a good place to start: HICL Infrastructure (LON:HICL), BBGI SICAV SA (LON:BBGI) etc. Big dividend players, assets that are resilient throughout market cycle.

2
Avatar for TangoDoc

The strategy I favour is to select stocks that have always paid a reasonable div and make money whatever anyone thinks of their value and hold them while they continue to perform that way. I am not clever nor lucky as a trader so rely on being a farmer since I have no need to sell any stock at any time.That's not to say I ignore market movements but I certainly don't feel gloomy while the human race still has to eat, drink, dispose of waste, bank, travel and replenish. In that sense, Tate & Lyle (LON:TATE) is certainly in my portfolio.

3
Avatar for brianbathgate

Thanks for that Jack, as a relative newcomer to Stocko I am still learning to crank the handles. Like you I have recently been looking for "resilient" stocks for the next 3 to 6 months. My only recent purchase popped up top using your shortcut on another sector, it would be good to get some of our experienced experts view on resilience factors.

Are you presenting one of your stocks to Stock slam next Wednesday? I'll be a very interested member of the audience.

1
Avatar for Jack Brumby

Hi Brian, I will be at the Stock Slam but I'm not sure if I am presenting yet. Look forward to seeing you there in any case!

0
Avatar for Mechanical Bull

A word of warning - in the current market conditions, UK Consumer Defensives as a group have not proved very resilient. They are 5.7% down over the month (about the same for the market as a whole) and 9% down for the year (a little bit worse than the overall market). Investors shouldn't be lured into thinking that this sector label necessarily provides protection against a market correction.

11
Avatar for Howard Marx

Agreed, during the last bear market (2007-09), Defensive sectors in the US (Utilities, Healthcare,  Consumer Staples) did better than either the Cyclical sectors or the broader indicies, yet still managed to fall by 45%, 40% & 31% respectively. 

Holding cash was the only place to hide last time around.

5bcc88f0760cf2007-09_by_sector.jpg


7
Avatar for timarr

Holding cash was the only place to hide last time around.

I know what you mean, but not quite. AAA bonds returned about 5% and Gold and Managed Futures about 16%. I love this graphic from Visual Capitalist, which looks at what's worked in the US in the 5 major crises we've had in the last 25 years:

Every situation is unique, but generally the types of asset classes that protect investors in times of crisis are not necessarily the same as those during a bull run. Therefore, it’s worth taking a look at five previous periods of distress to see the returns of conventional and alternative asset classes.
http://www.visualcapitalist.co...

Worst three performers out of all asset classes over all 5 crashes ... small cap stocks, large cap stocks and international stocks. Basically just avoid stocks.

timarr

5
Avatar for Jack Brumby

Sounds like wise advice, Mechanical Bull. Did you get the sector performance from Stockopedia or somewhere else? It's useful context. I was surprised to see that two of the three companies that came up have cyclical characteristics -- I wouldn't instinctively classify them as defensive...

Valuation is also key. On the link below I think the right-hand side of the sector table deserves a mention -- the consumer defensive sector is more expensive than some of the others and this should be taken into account.

0
Avatar for cafcash49

Thanks for this; I sold everything about a week ago and will stay out for a while. I couldn't take any more weeks showing a loss. After two good years I am gradually giving it back which is not good. I am now reviewing my strategies and I think safety has to be key for a while. As you say boring companies that keep producing a profit have a lot to offer in this sort of market. I'm not at home at the moment but will explore these 3 on my return. Good luck and thanks for the article and for bringing these companies to my attention.
Charles

2
Avatar for Jack Brumby

No worries Charles, of the three it seems to me like TATE has the more defensive characteristics. WYN and CARR actually strike me as more cyclical, and both have low margins. They may have their merits and might both be good companies, but they're not quite what I was expecting to pop up! DYOR, of course.

Good luck to you too!

Jack

0
Avatar for casper1240

Me too have kept NAT.GRID UNITED UTILITIES,PLP.DS SMITH AND GLENCORE Sold my other holdings at a loss /could have made a good profit on Bodycote PLP. and Rolls r but i held my shares with Beaufort who went bankrupt so couldnt sell any till they were transfered to my new broker .

0
Avatar for Catstycam

Good very late evening cafcash49.

I agree largely with what you are saying. I too sold out of the market totally about 2 weeks ago due to the market conditions. There is little reason for any optimism at present and some major black clouds around. Of course we have seen it all before and (over time) have pulled through. This may be part of a market correction or something much more like the end of a long and now very tiring bull market and the start of a bear market. There are many investors who over the last 9 years have only known a bull market with the occasional correction, but far fewer who have experienced a bear market which can last not weeks, or months but a year or more.

This evening I did an interesting exercise. I looked back at my trades since January 2016. Out of around 24 trades bought only 4 are currently above what I sold out at, despite many of them trading higher at some time after I sold out. I find that particularly worrying. Had I kept all the holdings I would be significantly worse off. Some luck, some good judgement - we need both. I would have been far better off had I not held onto shares which had at one time been in profit only to sell them only once they had fallen back into a loss.

Regards and good lucik

CM

0
Get the free newsletter