(The following statement was released by the rating agency)
Fitch Ratings-London-January 24: Retailer distress, a Brexit-related consumer
confidence downturn, legacy oversupply of space and increased e-commerce exposed
cost inefficiencies of physical stores in the UK, Fitch Ratings says. These
factors contributed towards UK leading property companies' shopping centre
values declining by around 20% in 2018-2019. In the rest of Europe, comparable
factors are less prevalent, which was reflected in benign changes (between -2%
and +2%) of shopping centre valuations and in broadly positive rental growth.
In the UK, Company Voluntary Arrangements (CVAs) allowed distressed retailers
(and their peers) to rebase some of their costs quickly, including property
rents. This informed UK property valuations that rental growth prospects are
poor, and retail property value declines now reflect this.
The UK's CVA mechanism of re-setting retailers' rents is not available across
the rest of Europe. Like-for-like rent growth (usually inflation-indexed) in
continental Europe (including the Nordics) has been positive and occupancy rates
are holding up. Several years of unfettered UK rental growth, pushed by
landlords and over-competitive retailers, is being re-tethered. Europe's indexed
rental agreements with shorter lease lengths seemingly have acted as a good
discipline for market participants.