46
Archived articleThis is an archived article from 2018 - please note that any content within the article may be out of date.

How falling markets present tough questions to investors

Share prices have fallen across the board in October, and it’s a reminder of just how quickly fear spreads when stocks start tumbling. My colleague Jack wrote this week about the sense of foreboding that’s hanging in the air at the moment. There’s almost a sense of inevitability that some kind of correction is past due. Knowing how to react to that kind of prospect is difficult.

Ten years into a bull run, and faced with various signs of trouble (in various parts of the world), it’s not hard to piece together a pretty gloomy narrative. While October has been unpleasant, some of the main UK indices - certainly the small and mid-caps - have been trending down since early summer. So for some investors, this experience has been less of a suckerpunch correction and more of a protracted beating.

This week the FTSE 250 has been flirting with correction territory, with the index currently down by just over nine percent for the month. As usual, the UK indices are taking at least some of their cues from price action in the United States. That’s been translating into some sharp and unpredictable intraday moves - days that start well but end up finishing on yet another low.

Profit warnings and bad news

In recent weeks the sharpest falls on the FTSE 250 have been exacerbated by bad news and profit warnings. Among the biggest fallers have been stocks like Keller, ConvaTec, Superdry, Indivior, Inchcape and Victrex. In terms of relative price strength, they’ve all undershot the All-Share index by more than 20 percent.

There are similar war stories over on the AIM All-Share, where Fevertree Drinks - a stock that, size-wise, has more in common with the FTSE 100, has seen more than a billion pounds wiped off its value since the end of the summer. It’s down from £4.23bn in early September to £3.18bn currently.

But it isn’t necessarily all bad news. It’s fair to say that some stocks (a minority) are holding up reasonably well under the conditions. But it’s also the case that investors with at least half an eye on value have been crying out for a meaningful correction for several years. For many, what we’ve seen so far won’t be anywhere near enough. As a result, we’ve got a melting pot of emotions. There are those selling up at the prospect of mounting losses and uncertainty. There are others prepared to stay invested and sit out the turmoil. And there are others readying themselves for the chance of some bargain hunting.

Deciding which position to take is a personal choice. But it’s worth bearing in mind the human instincts that can be an influence...

Fear of loss

One of the most recognised behavioural challenges in investing is loss aversion. It’s a concept closely associated with prospect theory, which was developed by the psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky.  

The idea behind loss aversion is that the pain of a loss is a much stronger emotion than the joy of a gain. So investors go to greater lengths to avoid losses, even though it might not make sense. More specifically, the urge to avoid losses by selling up when markets are falling - even though understandable - can end up being costly without a solid strategy for getting back in. That’s because acting on emotions to avoid losses can arguably mean missing a market rebound.

Loss aversion can also lead to being too risk-averse and forgetting that, as an asset class, stocks will always encounter periods of volatility. Even so, they still tend to outperform other assets over the long term.

This problem gets worse when you mix loss aversion with the other well known emotional tendency of constantly watching portfolio performance. When that happens you’re at risk of myopic loss aversion. The more you look, the worse it gets before, ultimately, you become paralysed by fear and make costly decisions.

Research by Schroders earlier this year came up with some pretty startling numbers when it comes to the costs of mistiming the market. Investing £1,000 in the FTSE 250 in 1987 and leaving it for 30 years would have have seen the pot grow to £24,686. But trading in and out of the market and missing out on the index’s best 30 days would have left you with just £6,878. It’s an extreme example, but the point is that time out of the market might limit the downside, but it also risks missing out on the upside.

Deciding to get out of the market in the face of mounting losses is a personal choice. But if preserving sanity means selling up then it’s worth having a strategy for getting back in again. The advice for staying in the market through highs and lows really hinges on the idea that, psychologically, it can be difficult to time the re-entry. That unintended consequence could end up end up being even more costly than just sitting tight and weathering the storm.

Either way, in times of stress it’s handy to call on a classic quote from Warren Buffett - a man not easily shaken by price swings - to try and get things into perspective:

“If you expect to be a net saver during the next 5 years, should you hope for a higher or lower stock market during that period? Many investors get this one wrong. Even though they are going to be net buyers of stocks for many years to come, they are elated when stock prices rise and depressed when they fall. This reaction makes no sense. Only those who will be sellers of equities in the near future should be happy at seeing stocks rise. Prospective purchasers should much prefer sinking prices.”




Photo by Brendan Church on Unsplash

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

75 comments


Avatar for Carey Blunt

I'm bumping this thread because I think it is one of the best threads on Stockopedia about determining when a macro event (such as Corona Virus) might be something that we can just ignore or when we might be able to determine that it is turning into something more serious that might cause us to take a different action.

We are talking here about using stats and data on the market to change the course of our thinking rather than rumor or opinion and I think that's an approach that is always worth considering.

Its not always appreciated but the process of us tipping into a recession or bear market actually happens relatively slowly and the principle in this thread is trying to work out if that really is the happening right now or not.

@PhilH I think the next days/weeks are going to interesting to see if the markets trigger your exit rules.

0
Avatar for PhilHofGrowYourDough

With the FTSE, even after the recent rally it is still Bearish. My exit strategy is two fold. I'll exit either when ...

  • Blue TenkanSen (fast MA) crosses Red KijunSen (Slow MA)
  • Flourescent green stop loss is broken by price action. The stop loss is the KijunSen displaced.
5c66db1f08f9dukx.png


The DAX weekly chart is still very bearish. Same exit rules apply


5c66dcb4e418fdax.png

This is very much my own strategy so please do your own research. It's quite likely that I'll lose money on the shorts but that'll mean that the market has rallied and my other investments should do well. In the meantime I have an insurance policy against something very ugly.

0
Avatar for finchy

Phil,

Where are you sitting now a couple of months on?

0
Avatar for Carey Blunt

Hi PhilH,

Would be interested in knowing if your exit rules are now triggered in this latest Corona Virus market drop? If you are using weekly periodicity then I think using your original criteria of the lagging line going under the cloud for 2 weeks then your exit rules have not triggered. If you are using the rules in this post then I think they probably have triggered.

I would be interested in your thinking this time around.

cheers

Carey

0
Avatar for PhilHofGrowYourDough

btw my preference was that the US market held out until march time before capitulating as entering a short position at that time would mean that my other investments wouldn't have been eroded by a wider market collapse,

i.e. it's a bigger drop from Decembers SPX chikou (value appears in May in the charts as it lags) to the bottom of the Kumo (for two consecutive weeks) compared to Mar's SPX chikou to the bottom of the Kumo.

I've tried to highlight that below in Orange


5c66d700b4cd2spx.png


0
Avatar for PhilHofGrowYourDough

I'm still sat on my shorts for DAX and FTSE. With everything that is going on I'm in no hurry to close them. March is looking interesting both in terms of Brexit and US/China trade negotiations. Given that Trump has had to cave on the wall legislation and that he'll face legal pressure if he tries to invoke emergency procedures I'd suggest that he'd be looking for a good result regarding the US/China talks. I think he'll want to appear tough. But aside from that the shorts hedge my portfolio at present and although the performance of my investments has been flatish, I have a good insurance policy against some very real headwinds.

Best of luck
Phil

1
Avatar for PhilHofGrowYourDough

The US charts are starting to look hairy now ...

S & P 500

5c181ebc254e3sp500.png


Last week's price action close below the cloud and this week's price action is pushing into new 9 months lows and the lagging Chikou is wandering into the cloud. The moving averages that form the cloud are poised to cross turning the cloud Bearish. Even if the price action consolidates at this level it'll be 5 weeks before the lagging line falls out of the bottom of the cloud. Closes below 2500 don't look that far fetched over the coming weeks and that's going to take the lagging line below the cloud and if that happens for two consecutive weeks that'll be my signal to go short on the US market.

S & P 600 Small Cap

5c18231e48569sp600.png

Today's lows were a 14 month record and the lagging line is sitting in the middle of a thin cloud (limited support). The cloud is about to turn bearish too.

Be careful out there!

Phil

3
Avatar for Carey Blunt

Hi PhilH,
Did you ever get to the point of shorting the US markets?
Carey

0
Avatar for PhilHofGrowYourDough

Hi Carey,

I've come close to pulling the trigger. I'm looking for the blue lagging line to close below the cloud for two consecutive weeks.

5c334608d1849spx.png


I think the outcome of the China trade talks are going to push it one way or another but I can't decide which way it'll go at present.

Best of luck
Phil

1
Avatar for finchy

Phil,

Curious on where your sitting now with your UKX market short given recent "recovery". Additionally what approach / instrument do you use for shorting? If ETF does the daily rebalancing negate the "true" expected return?

0
Avatar for Rusty2

Just as well you did not short it, S&P is up 17% since Dec 24. Even the FTSE100 is up 10%. I think it is difficult to predict which way the markets will go but I'm still quite negative on the UK in the next few months, I'm more in cash now.

1
Avatar for Ramridge

The mathematician Sir Isaac Newton invested heavily in the South Sea Company and lost in today's terms around £3m.

Apparently, the great scientist took a philosophical view of his losses. He said ruefully, “I can calculate the movement of the stars, but not the madness of men.”

Of course the notion of behavioural investing came a lot later.

2
Avatar for timarr

Of course the notion of behavioural investing came a lot later.

Earlier, actually.  Joseph de la Vega wrote Confusion de Confusiones in 1688, 30 years before the South Sea Bubble.

People follow gurus without thinking:

“There are times in which the powerful investor is followed by many, even at the cost of losing money”

People seek confirmation from others (and, of course, often react violently when opposing views are offered):

“It is not important that the basic value of the shares be practically nothing as long as there are other people willing to close their eyes and support those contradictions”

People will trade for no obvious reason other than their own overconfidence:

“They will sell without knowing the motive; and they will buy without reason. They will find what is right and they will err for fault of their own.”

De Vega came up with four principles of investment that are as true today as they were then:

  1. Don’t advise anyone to buy or sell shares.
  2. Accept your profits and your regrets without looking back.
  3.  Profit in the stockmarket is transitory.
  4.  To succeed you need money and patience.

True 330 years ago, true now and, no doubt, true in another 330 years.

timarr

9
Avatar for goodgoff

My view on this article? I am now even more unsettled. Should I be like the ostrich, stay invested and then see what's left in a year or so? Maybe wealth preservation should be my priority at 79 years so shove what's left in a gold ETF.

0
Avatar for Tradertimes82

Just read this article this morning (31/10/18), it couldn't be more apt! As a self taught (not a good idea, but who do you trust? ) novice who has largely traded in the AIM market and two years into trading, this last couple of days has seen my portfolio and my frame of mind hit rock bottom, it's ironic this should appear in my inbox today. Read this, take it in and remember it folks. I guess trading isn't for me.

0
Avatar for Bonitabeach

Hello Tradertimes82,

"Trading" isn't for most of us. Try "investing" instead. The AIM market is particularly risky with only a little wheat amongst the chaff.

Who do you trust? Only yourself. There are some good fund managers if you want funds but not that many. There are some good managers and management teams in companies, but the median will be disappointingly poor.

In respect of this UK market sell-off we were here before as recently as April! The "value" orientated stocks I hold have been hit too but my dividend expectations remain undiminished. I think the shares I avoided as "over-valued" have been hit hardest along with the fundamentally poor business models and the over indebted.

Sometimes it's about avoiding the losers rather than picking the winners. Investing with a longer-term outlook is much easier and more rewarding than trading short-term. I bought LON:(RDSB) at £14, I see no reason to sell at £25 while they pay me 10.75% on my investment cost. Chase shares that could double in 12 months, not today thank you; I have learned to be grateful for the 10.75% and the share price will bob up and down with the market.

Bonitabeach

5
Avatar for Tradertimes82

Thanks for this, another great reply. Yes I am strongly considering whether investing is for me. I thing I need a rest as Markj777 suggested and I take on board both your comments as I attempt to stumble forward.
Thanks again for taking the time to reply.

0
Avatar for mmarkkj777

Hi Tradertimes82

Firstly commiserations on your losses, but I guess not many were completely unscathed (funds have gone down too).

I turned to cash, but not before the fall before many my stop losses were triggered, so still down around 7%, but now that I feel it was a mere correction, not an impending crash, I am missing some upside as the markets spring back (which of course doesn't mean a major fall wont happen, but nobody knows), as I start to carefully reinvest, with the inevitable dealing costs and stamp duty, etc.

Don't let the recent correction cause lasting damage to your frame of mind (your portfolio will fix itself if you are patient enough!). Its all learning and nothing should be catastrophic. One thing is to think about risk management as you rebuild. What is the worst thing that could happen? It's a phase and will pass. Strategy (stay in or get out for a while). Tactics e.g. stop losses. Maybe using a temporary short of the market as a counterbalance (then selling it again when the correction has finished). The fund £SUK2 shorts the FTSE100 to the power of 2 and can be used as a counterbalance to your long investments and you only need half the capital to have the same effect ( short term fix only, though). Look at the Stocko conservative stocks, maybe, while we are in these volatile times.

Finally, Its great learning. Robbie Burns, Jim Slater and many other fantastic investors (let alone us mortals) served an apprenticeship and lost money in their early days and everyone has spells when they lose from time to time. Its about making more on the roundabouts than you lose on the swings.

The most important thing is to be patient and not overreach. Think as much about minimising your potential losses as maximising your potential gains. Stocko tools help with this. Invest with risk management in mind and do whatever it takes to preserve a good mental attitude, or this will surely affect your investing and decision process.

If necessary, step back, take a break, have a rethink, then, if you chose, come back with a stronger strategy.

Cheers,

Mark.

1
Avatar for Tradertimes82

Thank you for this advice, believe me it is much appreciated, I certainly needed to read another perspective.
Thanks again for taking the time to reply.

0
Avatar for mmarkkj777

I guess, regardless of the theory and who defined it, we are essentially talking about market sentiment, collective behaviour of share holders, rather than intrinsic economic value. Who was it who said they will 'revert to the mean' eventually.

I honestly don't know whether I am acting or re-acting. All I know is that I feel better in my self for being mainly out of the market at the moment, which is probably a good thing for decision making overall. It also means I have the capital to reinvest when I think the time is right. The big question is, will my opportunity loss (if I get the timing wrong) be greater than the loss I would have incurred by remaining fully invested. Only time will tell.

I'm sure there are many more with the same situation.

3
Avatar for mmarkkj777

Great post and interesting replies.

I'm 95% in cash now. I didn't need to make the decision. All my stop losses triggered (bar a couple) over the last 3 weeks. Mostly auto, but manually controlled on my American stocks. I now just hold 3 large blue chips that I have had for years and will probably stick with. I need to time my re-entry so as not to miss the upside, as mentioned in posts above. Time will tell if this was the better approach or not (last time I stayed in). I'll probably go for Value showing early momentum, as opposed to growth, when I initially start to go back in.

2
Avatar for aflash

'Where I do think I excel is in recognizing my mistakes...that is the secret to my success'

Why the inverted commas? George Soros wrote it, not me.

'I came to the conclusion that basically all our views of the world are somehow flawed or distorted and I then concentrated on the importance of this distortion in shaping events'

'The big difference between Jim Rogers and me was that Jim thought that the prevailing view was always wrong, whereas I thought that we may be wrong also.'

Who acknowledges that they are fallible while buy and selling? I do. Soros does.

This is a good thread. If we get on to reflexivity it will be an excellent one. Here is Soros again:

'Only the first part of my argument - that the prevailing bias affects market prices - seems to have registered. The second part - that the prevailing bias can, in certain circumstancs, also affect the so called fundamentals and changes in market prices cause changes in market prices- seems to have gone unnoticed.


Not by me. How about you?

4
Avatar for timarr

This is a good thread. If we get on to reflexivity it will be an excellent one.

Something like this: Soros' Economic Reflexivity?
So [in standard economics] if a security falls in price below its fundamental value then traders will purchase it and bid its price up until it reaches the equilibrium point again. With economic reflexivity this may not happen: if traders believe markets are about to fall they’ll sell – and markets will fall. Sometimes lots of traders will do this, become convinced they're right and carry on selling (or buying). Standard economics calls this irrational, Soros thinks it's reflexivity in action because the act of selling, or buying, changes the mental expectations of people.
Basically, markets can become irrational for long periods, even though the behaviour of investors is perfectly rational by their own standards.

timarr

4
Avatar for gus 1065

... and sadly, as JM Keynes pointed out, the markets can remain irrational for longer than many of us can remain solvent (especially if using leverage).

Gus.

2
Avatar for timarr

and sadly, as JM Keynes pointed out, the markets can remain irrational for longer than many of us can remain solvent (especially if using leverage)

Apparently he didn't say that - at least no one can find the source of the quote. But he did create the concept of the beauty contest as applied to investing in which everyone bets on the person they think everyone else will want to win, rather than the person they think is the most handsome.

There's a really interesting paper by David Chambers and Elroy Dimson that charts Keynes' evolution from an unsuccessful top down macro-economic led investor to a successful bottom up fundamentals led one. It mirrors the experience of many people and the research which suggests that more experienced investors are less biased and trade less:

Keynes the Stockmarket Investor

timarr

1
Avatar for gus 1065

Hi timer.

Fair comment. JMK said a lot of things but in this case it’s hard to stick that particular tail on the donkey. The attached link attempts to explain the attribution.

https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/08/09/remain-solvent/

Gus.

1
Avatar for skinner66

hot socks, sorry disagree i sold my other house after renting it out, for what i spent to maintain i still was big profit, or why would i rent it out,, then i sold at 100k profit,,

-3
Avatar for Hot Socks

which bit did you disagree with?

0
Avatar for daverawc

apologies my typing and grammar are terrible

1
Avatar for daverawc

As for the buy and hold argument, if you had bought the FTSE 100 in late 1999 early 2000 you would have suffered 18 years of negative returns up to today.

3
Avatar for Rusty2

I don't think so because that ignores dividends, but why cite just the FTSE 100, there are many other shares to buy. The FTSE 250 has done better. Anyway you just looking the average ex. dividends. I believe the FTSE 100 average is about 8% pa inc. dividends, not great but not negative.

1
Avatar for Rusty2

I don't think so because that ignores dividends, but why cite just the FTSE 100, there are many other shares to buy. The FTSE 250 has done better. Anyway you just looking the average ex. dividends. I believe the FTSE 100 average is about 8% pa inc. dividends, not great but not negative.

0
Avatar for PhilHofGrowYourDough

Here's where I'm at.
My approach blends a high QM screen with technical analysis (specifically Ichimoku Clouds) to buy and sell. I invest in the UK, Europe & US with mostly smaller companies although I do buy some bigger companies too that match my criteria.

My strategy in market bumps has been to wait a while to let the dust settle before doing anything. In the past I've been fortunate that the market has rallied quite quickly and I was able to sell the stocks that didn't rally with it. But for me this time it feels a little different. 

I've been using weekly charts with Ichimoku Clouds to monitor each region. The logic for doing this is based upon noticing that the Chikou (or the blue lagging line) interaction with the Icchimoku Cloud (or Kumo) could be a good bull/bear indicator on a weekly S&P 500 chart. I've highlighted this with red circles below.

5bd43e0becbecsp500at.png


I use the same principle to monitor other indices using weekly charts


UK

FTSE 100 - Weekly Chart

5bd43c71e3631ftse100.png

The blue lagging line has broken below the cloud (historic price action). The actual close on Friday was 6949 so the updated weekly chart will look more bearish still.  For me this chart reads Bearish and would be strongly bearish if the price closes below the previous low in the spring of 2018.


FTSE All Share - Weekly Chart

5bd43edeaf548ftseas.png

Again the blue lagging line has broken through the cloud and the friday close was 3808 which again would make the weekly chart more bearish. For me this chart reads Bearish and would be strongly bearish if the price closes below the previous low in the spring of 2018.

FTSE Small Cap - Weekly Chart

5bd43f853cca2ftsesmc.png

The blue lagging line is stuck in the cloud and the cloud is thick as there has been consolidation and uncertainty over the proceeding weeks. The theory is that it is harder for the price action or lagging line to penetrate a thicker cloud as this indicates that there has been a big battle between the bulls and the bears and so the price tends to bounced off the cloud. In the end the price sank through the cloud as it thinned. Will the lagging line bounce of the bottom of the cloud as the price rallies or will it sink through the cloud. For me this chart is Neutral and I'd label this chart as consolidating. The actual Friday close was 5393 so the lagging line is still just about contained within the cloud but it's looking ominous.

Decision:  Close all UK stocks that have Q < 80 or M < 80 or having negative EPS upgrade estimates for FY or FY + 1 and I've opened a super short on the FTSE.


Europe

Dax - Weekly chart

5bd442a844c3bdax.png

Blue lagging line has convincingly broken down through the cloud and recent price action has closed below the lows in the Spring of 2018. Price close as of Friday was 11159 so the updated chart will be more bearish. For me the is a Strong Bearish chart.

FTSE Eurofirst 300 Excluding UK

5bd443805b4baeuro300exuk.png

Blue lagging line has  broken down through the cloud and recent price action has closed below the lows in the Spring of 2018. Price close as of Friday was 1614 so the updated chart will be more bearish. For me the is a Strong Bearish chart.

Decision:  Close all Euro stocks that have Q < 80 or M < 80 or having negative EPS upgrade estimates for FY or FY + 1 . Open a super short on the DAX.

US

S&P 500 - Weekly Chart

5bd4486a3560bspx.png

The blue lagging line is still well clear of the cloud despite the fact that Friday's close was 2661. The warning signs are there though. When the chart is updated to reflect Friday's close: the blue lagging line will probably have dropped below the historic price action; the fast moving average (orange line) will have pushed down through the slow moving average (red line) and the closing price on friday of price action in the last column will be sat smack in the middle of a relatively thin cloud (offering little resistance).

However, whilst the price action might well penetrate the cloud there is a chance that the lagging line will bounce off it over the next few weeks as the price rallies under the cloud. I wouldn't be surprised if there is another rally before it turns bearish. Perhaps a head and shoulders pattern or a triple top.

At present I'm neutral on this chart.

S&P 600 Small Cap - Weekly Chart

5bd44b2e3b7e2spxsc.png

The blue lagging line is still well clear of the cloud despite the fact that Friday's close was 934. Again the warning signs are there. When the chart is updated to reflect Friday's close: the blue lagging line will be below the historic price action; the fast moving average (orange line) will have pushed down through the slow moving average (red line); both moving averages are heading south and the closing price on friday of price action in the last column will be sat smack in the middle of the cloud. Again I think there could well be a rally here before, if any fall below the cloud occurs. 

Again I'm neutral on this chart.

Decision:  Close all US stocks that have Q < 80 or M < 80 or having negative EPS upgrade estimates for FY or FY + 1.  No short on the index at this time.

Other things that are making me twitchy.

US midterm elections are currently showing unprecedented early turnout. Historically this tends to indicate that the vote will be stronger for Democrats. This could mean they take the House. This will make things tricky (trickier) for Trump. Greater uncertainty for US business. Trade wars, etc. etc.

UK/Europe - BREXIT chaos. For UK uncertainty over future Labour/Tory/Coalition government and implications for business. 

Currently I'm 30% Cash, 11.5% US stocks, 19% European stocks, 3.5% UK stocks and 28% shorts on DAX on FTSE (but theses super shorts so 2x)

Best of luck everyone
Phil

16
Avatar for Howard Adams

Hi Phil

Excellent post, thank you.

Regards
Howard

2
Avatar for Nursemaid

Excellent post Phil H., thanks for sharing.

2
Avatar for PhilHofGrowYourDough

I've increased my position on my DAX short today by 50% due an increasingly bearish weekly Ichimoku Chart. Things that triggered it for me were the price hitting new recent lows (intraday and daily close) and  also note everything is pointing south, i.e. the slow and fast moving averages, the boundaries of the cloud and the lagging line

5bf47b0d30631dax.png


If the FTSE 100 drops further tomorrow increase my short on that position too. Ideally I'd be looking for new lows (below 6850) and another lower close (below 6984). 

6
Avatar for PhilHofGrowYourDough

Well it took a little longer than I expected but I've increased my short position on the FTSE 100 by 50% today. The way things are heading this week we are looking at the lowest weekly close in 2 years.

I'm still not short on the US markets and personally if they are going to go south I'd be much more comfortable shorting them in a couple of months time. For example to short the DOW as of today I'm looking for a weekly close below 22188 which is currently 2300+ away. So by the time I'm ready to place my short the big moves might have happened. However looking forward in February 2019 I'd be looking for a weekly close below 24148 (442 pts difference) or in March 2019 the price could close around the current level.

Anyway interesting times ahead and whilst Trump is in play there is going to be a lot of volatility so be careful out there.

Best of luck
Phil

2
Avatar for daverawc

The argument that markets are efficient was blown out of the water decades ago by the likes of George Sros probably the best of market timers

3
Avatar for Nick Ray
The argument that markets are efficient was blown out of the water decades ago by the likes of George Sros probably the best of market timers

The Nobel prize for economics in 2013 went to Fama, Hansen and Shiller. Fama and Hansen developed much of the theory behind efficient markets and Shiller did a lot of work on understanding when markets are not efficient. (Shiller's book "Irrational Exuberance" is a great read by the way. Highly recommended.)

But I wouldn't say that Shiller's work invalidates the work of Fama and Hansen. It just takes things forward.

The work by Fernholz on Stochastic Portfolio Theory gives another perspective in how to develop the theory which I think has a few ideas worth following.

2
Avatar for daverawc

Like Jim Rogers has said numerous times in interviews, if the efficient market hypothesis is correct it not have been possible for him or Soros to have made the outsize gains that are on record.
He practices the academics preach.

0
Avatar for underscored

Does the hypothesis have to be totally right or totally wrong? it seems to be a reasonable starting point for thinking about how markets work, if not the final absolute truth.

2
Avatar for timarr

Like Jim Rogers has said numerous times in interviews, if the efficient market hypothesis is correct it not have been possible for him or Soros to have made the outsize gains that are on record.

But Jim Rogers and George Soros are the exceptions, not the rule. I can kick a football but I wouldn't ever compare myself to Lionel Messi. A more interesting question would be, if the EMH isn't correct why can't the average investor beat the index? And the corollary to that is: if the average investor can't beat the index how come there are a small number of people like Soros and Rogers who can?

To understand the answer to that you need to understand a bit about the assumptions behind the EMH - mainly that all information is assimilated by markets and is in the current price. If that's correct then the only way to beat the market would be to have access to inside information.

However, behind that assumption is the key problem in economics - that human beings are perfectly efficient processors of information. But we're not - we have limited processing power and over millions of years of evolution we've developed heuristics - short-cuts - to overcome these. And while these work well in most everyday situations they also mean we don't assimilate all information immediately and make mistakes in processing.

We call these errors biases. For example, we assume tomorrow will be like today (we anchor on prices, we project current market conditions infinitely into the future), we look for information that confirms our understanding rather than that which disconfirms it (confirmation bias), we look for leaders to follow rather than thinking for ourselves (deferral to authority), we try to find things that give us pleasure and avoid things that give us pain (loss aversion where we keep losers and sell winners, and the disposition effect), etc, etc.

What's interesting about Soros and Rodgers and Buffett and the other handful of people who are able to overcome the limitations of the EMH is that they don't suffer from these biases in the way that most of us do. However, they do all suffer from a delusion common to everyone else - that their experiences of the world are equivalent to everyone else's (technically, the introspection illusion) - so they go around telling everyone that their example is something anyone can follow.

But they're wrong. Most people can't. For most people the EMH is real - apart from when the market departs from efficiency (which it does with surprising frequency). But that's another story entirely.

timarr

8
Avatar for gus 1065

Intrigued, I did a bit of internet digging about the phantom Fidelity report into the success or otherwise of active versus “dead” investors. The consensus seems to be that it was an internal report produced in mid 2014 covering the period 2003 to 2013 which found that the best performing investors were either dead or had “forgotten they had an account” with Fidelity and that the report was discussed on Bloomberg Radio by, among others, James O’Shaughnessy in 2016. As such, it doesn’t appear to have been published or in any way scrutinised at anything approaching a scientific level.

On a wider level, there has been quite a lot of empirical work done to investigate the tendency towards “action bias” (ie the belief that doing anything is better than doing nothing) and this does seem to support the view that active traders tend to underperform the buy and hold-ers. Dan Crosby discusses the academic research from the likes of Vanguard, Meir Statman and Odean and Barber among others in his book “The Laws of Wealth”, which also covers and appears to confirm the alleged urban myth that women (both retail and professional fund managers) tend to out perform men. This latter point is attributed/correlated with a tendency among men to be over confident and over trade (and thereby underperform).

In the digging process, I did find quite an interesting piece from Fidelity (US based) suggesting a general strategy for investors. Whether you see it as Funds industry propaganda or useful advice, it’s possibly worth a quick read.

https://www.fidelity.com/viewpoints/investing-ideas/six-habits-successful-investors

Pretty simple stuff, but my take is that their suggestion is to stay invested rather than try and job in and out of the market (“time in” the market is more important than “timing” the market etc.). Presumably they make more money from the platform fee on balances than they do on account trading income!

Personally, I think Winnie the Pooh had some sage financial planning advice when he suggested “Never underestimate the power of doing nothing”.

Gus.

(Sorry - just read Post 14 from Howard Marx which corroborates my own digging).

3
Avatar for David Talbot

Herbie

Your comments about Minervini are somewhat misleading, As he makes clear, he lost money in the first 6 years of his investing career, when he was learning the ropes and making the mistakes that most of us made. Assuming the later figures are not misrepresentations (and they clearly were not when he became US Investing Champion), then his subsequent returns by active trading have been outstanding. For what it is worth, one piece of Minervini wisdom is that the stocks that hold up best in a bear market are generally those that lead out that market, by advancing early and with the greatest gains.

8
Avatar for Rusty2

Yes it was the first 6 years, not meant to be misleading. I think most people would have given up by then. That's probably why most active traders lose money.

0
Avatar for Rusty2

Just to be clear what I meant was it's difficult to beat the market as an active trader, even Minervini took 6 years before he started making money. Most traders are not as good as Minervini.

0
Avatar for Nick Ray

The idea that you can sell near the top of the market and then buy back in near the bottom is a sort of "optical illusion". The market is just the aggregate behaviour of all of its participants. Given the same level of information available to all participants, if one participant can see that the market will fall and chooses to sell, then so can all the others. And in effect that is what happens in a crash. Everyone wants to sell but there are no or very few buyers.

Any argument that you could sell before a share dropped 50% implies that your trading decision is based in part on a knowledge of the future - which is of course impossible. And if you wait for the fall to start to sell, and wait for the rise to start to buy then you find that you will either be too late to make a consistent net gain, or you will be whipsawing in and out because near the decision point the signal keeps changing. Partly this is due to the natural properties of random processes and partly it is due to people trying to second guess where the market is going.

The only method which can work is to rebalance against a cash reserve. So when the portfolio value rises it is top-sliced to maintain the same split of stock:cash and when the portfolio value falls more shares are bought to again maintain the split. In theory this will return a gain of (1/2)sigma^2 (where sigma=volatility). Usually this is a small amount compared with the returns of the stocks in the portfolio. But when the returns are zero or negative and volatility is high, it can be a significant sum.

Here is a simple example of how you can fool yourself that you can "predict" the future. Consider this profit-and-loss graph:

5bd307f5d5decroulette.png

It looks as if you could use momentum to buy in just after the 1000 point and then sell when the momentum runs out just before the 3000 point maybe.

But in fact this is a simulation of 4000 spins of a roulette wheel, with a bet on a single number each time. There is no momentum. The past predicts nothing about the future at all, and in fact we know that if you continue betting you will gradually lose all your money at a mean rate of -1/37 per spin. So we are reading something in this chart which does not exist.

Stocks behave differently, but it is still the case that we read patterns using human intuition which simply do not exist when you try to analyse the data.

With stocks, and especially with an index, the underlying drift is positive. In other words if you just stay in the market then eventually you will emerge with more than you started. However, with stocks the probability distribution has "fat tails" (Taleb) and that means that there are no guarantees of any outcome (positive or negative) in any given time-frame. (So the drift is greater than zero as time tends to infinity, but infinity is a long way away.)

13
Avatar for m096146

Nick,
I think you are mixing a set of random events up with a stock market/share trend. The latter is not random over a short time period ( very short periods yes). Investors take a view on the news flow and if it is predominately bad or thought to be getting bad/worse then some may sell. I would suggest at present that almost all metrics point to an overvalued market , largely driven by QE money whilst the global background is not good viz USA/vs China tariffs, ECB vs Italy budget, Brexit, Fed raising their rates- one could add to this list. Otherwise why the short selling?
You will never get the top nor the bottom but I think there is money to be made by cashing out/re-investing so long as you have a strategy. Several active fund managers I read have increased their cash holding lately with this in mind.

2
Avatar for timarr

Nick, I think you are mixing a set of random events up with a stock market/share trend. The latter is not random over a short time period ( very short periods yes). Investors take a view on the news flow and if it is predominately bad or thought to be getting bad/worse then some may sell.

I'm not sure what Nick is saying: that post is unusually opaque for him. However, it's not necessarily true that movements even in the short term aren't random. There's a lot a work now that suggests that investors can be divided into those that trade on information (aka value investors) and those that trade on the signal that the value investors generate (aka momentum investors).

At the beginning of a bull market value investors predominate and most trading is done on real information, even if it's the only the first or second order signals generated by that information. However, as the bull run builds more and more uninformed people are attracted into the market and eventually the noise they generate starts to swamp out the underlying signal. But because they don't really know what they're doing they're uniformly positive and keep on pushing the market higher.

At this point real information isn't really driving markets, it's the random behaviour of uninformed noise traders. Even experienced investors will follow the trend, reasoning that they know it's insane but figuring they can get out before it blows up. At some point the fake signal they're following starts to break down, usually as confidence is lost due to external events, and you start to see an uptick in volatility as uninformed investors trade in and out, following what is essentially random noise.

Eventually, of course, the whole thing blows up, because prices have become disconnected from reality and external events start to impact valuations. Uninformed investors chase the price down until they give up and, eventually, informed investors start to pick up the pieces again.

At the market peak there's always a reason why stocks are justified in trading at insane multiples - the popular one this time seems to be that the scalability of the internet makes normal valuation methods irrelevant. It's nonsense of course, but people will always retrospectively justify their decisions as logical regardless of their actual decision making processes. And, of course, brokers, investment houses and media will amplify this message because they're all incentivised to have people dealing.

Timing the top and the bottom is never possible: but the general shape of things is usually vaguely discernible.

timarr

5
Avatar for Nick Ray
Nick, I think you are mixing a set of random events up with a stock market/share trend. The latter is not random over a short time period ( very short periods yes). Investors take a view on the news flow and if it is predominately bad or thought to be getting bad/worse then some may sell.




I'm not sure what Nick is saying: that post is unusually opaque for him.

Yes. I joined together two different thoughts and probably messed up my main point.

What I really wanted to focus on is the fact that the market is the aggregate behaviour of all the participants. So treating it as this passive thing which you can outwit by trying to time your interactions with it won't work. In effect every participant is trying to outwit the market and the market itself is what you get when you sum all those behaviours together.

I'm sure there is some kind of proof by contradiction you can create but I can quite work it out in a way which I'm happy with so I fell back on a simpler analogy based on a pure stochastic process. But I fully acknowledge that it is not really the same situation.

It is somewhat related to the idea of "efficiency" - the act of exploiting anomalies causes them to be arbitraged away. If you don't agree that the market is efficient you will try to find ways to exploit the inefficiency - such as by timing your trading. And in a sense you are right: it needs people reacting to possible inefficiency to remove it. On the other hand, if you do accept that the market is efficient (or efficient enough) then you look for ways that work with the market rather than against it. And that approach can work too!

1
Avatar for shipoffrogs

I always thought the 30 days of highest market gains occurred in crashes when the market was whipsawing and that they therefore fell right next to the 30 worst days.

0
Avatar for Rusty2

Timing the market can be difficult, just look at Brexit, some people sold, stop losses were hit but within a short time the market had recovered and since then has performed very well. Some investors don't try to time the market such as Warren Buffett and Terry Smith, others such as momentum traders do.

Re Victrex (LON:VCT), I think the sector across Europe has fallen, there have been reports that the chemical industry could be one of the hardest hit by Brexit.

1
Avatar for m096146

Surely this debate is all about timing a re-entry point. Even if you don't read the bottom and re-enter something near to it then you must be better off than staying in as long as trading costs are covered.
A simple example is selling your £100 holding before the share drops 50% but then recovers to its original value. The holder gains nothing. If the seller went back in with his £100 when the share had dropped 25% then when the share returned to its original price you make 33% gain. What's wrong with that?

2
Avatar for UK Value Investor

I think the key point is to remember that share prices are just someone else's opinion of what a company is worth. And since most people aren't forced buyers or sellers, it's an opinion you are usually free to ignore.

5
Avatar for andrea34

Out of Ben's investor emotions I suppose I fall into the "prepared to sit it out" camps. I also fall into my own "depressed by consistently falling share prices" emotion... I feel a complete idiot that I didn't see this coming and sell out of some of my holdings - I may feel that many of my holdings are good companies, but to see so much wiped off the share price gives me an amount of sadness. I have been investing for quite a long time... and I never seem to learn :-( I do however have about 20% cash in my unit trust account waiting to plough some of it back into the market, which has been sitting there for some time waiting for a correction.

Ben, you say "there’s almost a sense of inevitability that some kind of correction is past due", but considering the markets have given up their entire gains of this year then isn't this a correction in itself?

Anyway, UKValueInvestor, your sentence I think the key point is to remember that share prices are just someone else's opinion of what a company is worth rather struck a cord with me. The blatant blanket sell off that we are witnessing at the moment seems to illustrate this, I have several companies in my portfolio that have issued very positive trading statements, including earnings beats, and this just makes no sense to me when this news is disregarded in the market sentiment driven sell off.

As far as I can see, when the US market falls then the UK market falls, and when the US market rebounds then the UK market falls less - Brexit uncertainty is obviously a factor here.

BTW, does anyone know why Victrex (LON:VCT) is falling so heavily please? Out of the shares in your list Ben, I cannot see any negative news out for this company at all... and alas I hold. They don't seem obviously overvalued... to me.

3
Avatar for Benson212

Hi andrea34l

Regarding Victrex (LON:VCT) , news isn't the only catalyst for share price movements. In market environments like this, human behaviour (emotions) is usually the catalyst for erratically falling prices. If you are a value/ fundamental investor then this is a golden opportunity because price is now disconnected from valuations/outlook.  As you suggest, companies are issuing positive trading statements so it's now your job to see if there is "value" in these stocks. 


"I feel a complete idiot that I didn't see this coming and sell out of some of my holdings - I may feel that many of my holdings are good companies, but to see so much wiped off the share price gives me an amount of sadness. I have been investing for quite a long time... and I never seem to learn :-("


A quality company does not always mean a quality investment. Regardless of what others think, price is king and where you enter and exit a stock will have a significant impact on your portfolio returns.

Furthermore, your statement above suggests you don't sufficiently manage the downside risk in your portfolio. I know stop losses cause much debate here at Stockopedia, but using a trailing stop loss has saved me once again from a market correction! 

I have locked in my gains and I'm now 100% cash, waiting for a reliable market bottom to establish.  The problem most people have now is that they need a bull market just to break even, as where people who used stop losses and now in cash, can enter the next bull market from a relatively unscathed position.

Have you read Mark Minervini's books? Even if you don't wish to trend follow like he does, the chapters on risk management are truly eye opening. It changed my approach and I'm now profitable as a result. The books are only c.£20-£25 on Amazon. Quite possibly the best investment I have ever made haha!

All the best!

BH

5
Avatar for Howard Adams

Hi BH

With reference to your point ....

'Have you read Mark Minervini's books? Even if you don't wish to trend follow like he does, the chapters on risk management are truly eye opening. It changed my approach and I'm now profitable as a result. The books are only c.£20-£25 on Amazon. Quite possibly the best investment I have ever made haha!'

I totally concur with your sentiment. I have employed Minervini's risk management advice pretty rigorously since reading it last November. I can say without question not only has it protected my portfolio very well but it has really helped me to become more confident with my investing.

Regards

Howard

4
Avatar for Hot Socks

"A quality company does not always mean a quality investment. Regardless of what others think, price is king and where you enter and exit a stock will have a significant impact on your portfolio returns."

I agree with this to some extent but I think precisely how far it is true depends on your outlook and what you are trying to achieve. The best analogy I can come up with is buying a house. If you are going to sell it in two years time then the price you pay for it may have a huge impact on whether or not you make any money. If you own the house for 40 years then the interest on the mortgage, 40 years of inflation, the cost of maintenance and repairs etc will all add up to making the price you paid for it pretty much irrelevant. far more important to any returns will be whether it is a nice house in a good location. with the 40 year time horizon the really big risks are buying a bad house or in not buying a house because you are so worried about overpaying you fail to do anything.

The same I think is true with a business. If you are invested long term the risks in buying a bad business or in suffering inferior returns on cash appear to be much greater than the risk of overpaying.

3
Avatar for Hot Socks

Victrex has had similar falls to XP Power and Renishaw (I hold all three ). They are all industrials and very sensitive to growth. In the case of Victrex to smart phones and consumer electronics in particular. They also all have activities in the Far East including manufacturing plants. So news of slowing Chinese growth, friction over trade and tariffs has probably caused a rethink of their valuations. They had all benefitted from currency headwinds due to the fall in the pound following the Brexit referendums and were on pretty racy valuations. I'm not surprised that they have fallen so sharply, the valuations for all three are now at a more rational level.

I don't share your sense of depression at all. I think the question to ask is whether to employ a market timing/trading based strategy. there are perfectly good reasons to decide not to (some referred to in the other comments in this thread) and having made the decision not to you have to stick with that and not lose sleep over it.

2
Avatar for donald pond

"But trading in and out of the market and missing out on the index’s best 30 days would have left you with just £6,878."
I cannot express enough how much I hate this quote, which the asset management industry trot out time and time again. Clearly nobody could be invested for all but the 30 best days. If they use that statistic they could just as well use its corollary, which is if you were invested for all but the 30 worst days. A more meaningless statistic it would be hard to find.
More useful is the evidence taken from brokerage accounts of how most traders underperform the market: recently I say the (perhaps apocryphal) story that accounts of the dead outperform those of the living, simply through a lack of tinkering.

14
Avatar for HumourMe
"But trading in and out of the market and missing out on the index’s best 30 days would have left you with just £6,878."

I also hate the quote as it isn't balanced by the opposite, returns if missing out the worst 30 days.

2
Avatar for Ben Hobson

​I do agree. It's daft (and even the fund manager quoted in the report sounded mildly embarrassed that they'd even gone there). But that said, I think the general point stands.

2
Avatar for timarr

I say the (perhaps apocryphal) story that accounts of the dead outperform those of the living, simply through a lack of tinkering

It's apocryphal: no one has ever been able to find the evidence that backs this, lovely though that would be.

The real question is to what extent the best and worst days are clustered.  I seem to remember reading somewhere that both are clustered together and usually (and unsurprisingly) occur during periods of market volatility. And markets are usually most volatile when falling.

I had a quick look at the list of largest gains on the S&P500 and eyeballing the data 8 out of the 20 largest rises happened in 2008/9, 4 in 2010/11 and most of the rest around 2000/01: i.e. during bear markets. Most of the largest falls happened in the same periods.

That's not evidence, btw, it's just an anecdote.

I'm not a great believer in market timing, but I'm pretty sure if you can avoid bear markets you will make more money. And mostly the very best days occur during bear markets. Go figure.

timarr

5
Avatar for dfs12

Some evidence that the dead tend to outperform can be seen within Stockopedia. Just look at the fantasy fund league table. It amazes me how many of the top performers are people who set up their funds 3 years ago (or more) and then forgot about them. People will say we've been in a massive bull market... but the active fund managers have been in the same market and have commonly not done so well. Not proof but an indication it may well be true. Might be worth Stockopedia using their data to create some proof of their own! i.e. correlation of returns to activity within fantasy funds.

3
Avatar for PhilHofGrowYourDough

Hi dfs12,

The fantasy fund league is interesting but you need to dig a little deeper when looking at the results.
Many of the top funds run by subscribers have erroneous spikes in their value due to incorrect handling of share splits.

That said if you look at the 3 year returns active fund manager shipoffrogs has very good returns.

Best of luck
Phil

0
Avatar for FREng

In the dotcom era I noticed (and benefitted from) small cap shares following major movements in the FTSE 100 but with a day or two lag. I wonder if that will be the case again.

0
Avatar for Rusty2

Actually Fidelity did a study and found it's best performing client accounts were either dead or accounts had been forgotten.

Also "A University of California study of 66,000 investors found that the higher a portfolio's turnover, the lower the average return. Those who traded the most lagged the overall market's performance by 6.5%. As the researchers put it, ‘trading is hazardous to your wealth'."

1
Avatar for timarr

Hi herbie

Actually Fidelity did a study and found it's best performing client accounts were either dead or accounts had been forgotten.

Fidelity says there was no such study.

The original story comes from a transcript of a podcast between Barry Ritholtz and James O'Shaughnessey. But no one can find the podcast.

It's an Internet myth which continues to circulate because no one ever checks their sources.

timarr

5
Avatar for Howard Marx

The podcast is still available on Ritholtz's Big Picture site. The quote arrives after 58minutes, 50seconds:

O'Shaughnessy: "Fidelity had done a study as to which accounts had done the best at Fidelity. And what they found was..."

Ritholtz: "They were dead."

O'Shaughnessy: "...No, that's close though! They were the accounts of people who forgot they had an account at Fidelity."


https://ritholtz.com/2014/09/m...

5
Avatar for timarr

Fair enough ... though, Fidelity still say there was no such study :)

timarr

0
Avatar for Rusty2

Fair enough but there does seem some evidence that active traders are less successful than buy and hold ones. Take Minervini, he lost money for about 6 years.

How about the Fidelity survey that says women are better investors than men. Is that fake as well?

0
Avatar for timarr

How about the Fidelity survey that says women are better investors than men. Is that fake as well?

You mean this one?

https://www.fidelity.com/about...

Probably not ... the clue being that you can find it when you search for it.

Whether or not it's actually robust is hard to tell. Generally the gold standard for research is peer review in a reputable journal. That's not perfect either, but it's the best we've got.

But I'm not quite sure why this is relevant to this thread?

timarr

2
Avatar for Rusty2

To answer your question about relevance how about this "What is it, exactly, that makes women better investors? One factor, Fidelity said, is that men are 35 percent more likely to make trades, which means that trading fees eat away at their portfolios more than they do women’s."

As this post is about investors behaviour I think it has some relevance.

0
Avatar for Rusty2

To answer your question about relevance how about this "What is it, exactly, that makes women better investors? One factor, Fidelity said, is that men are 35 percent more likely to make trades, which means that trading fees eat away at their portfolios more than they do women’s."

As this post is about investors behaviour I think it has some relevance.

0
Avatar for jonesj

1 Fidelity run funds, investment trusts & some kind of platform business.
Now most platform businesses make money from customer activity.
Therefore Fidelity would have a financial incentive to deny there was any internal survey which found the inactive & dead customers outperformed the active ones.

2 As for the market correction, well, as always, the challenge remains to be to decide if this is one of those intra-year declines which provide a buying opportunity, or the start of a more major bear market.     The US market has certainly been on a high valuation and has been many years into the bull market.    Some emerging markets offer more reasonable valuations. 




1
Avatar for Howard Marx

Counintuitively, bull markets rarely feature large up days. 

As timarr suggests, history reveals that the best (& worst) daily returns occur in bear markets, at times of elevated volatility:

5bd2e2fcda0c0volatility_clusters.jpg


https://awealthofcommonsense.c...

5
Avatar for timarr

Counintuitively, bull markets rarely feature large up days. As timarr suggests, history reveals that the best (& worst) daily returns occur in bear markets, at times of elevated volatility.

Yeah, the whole thing about needing to capture the best 25 days in the market to get most of the returns is another myth because you'll probably have to trade through a bear market and lose money overall to capture them. If you can you're better off sitting it out and waiting until calmer times return.

Of course, if we could figure out when bear markets started and finished then it would make that a whole lot simpler ... although if you're looking at large up and down days as a measure then 2018 has seen two of the largest ever point rises and five of the largest ever point falls on the S&P 500. Those are points changes though, most of the really large percentage changes happened in the 1930's, with the largest ever fall on Black Friday in 1987.

timarr

2
Avatar for Frankyboy

Well said!

0
Get the free newsletter