Picture of ASML Holding logo

ASML — ASML Holding News Story

0.000.00%
us flag iconLast trade - 00:00
TechnologyAdventurousLarge CapHigh Flyer

Huang’s fall is a chance for better US AI policies

BREAKINGVIEWS-Huang’s fall is a chance for better US AI policies

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

By Hugo Dixon

- Never waste a good crisis. That motto applies in spades to the downfall of Jensen Huang.

The discredited former Nvidia NVDA.O chief executive advocated a laissez-faire approach to artificial intelligence and lax controls on exports to China. Because of his influence over President Donald Trump, Huang was often able to get his way. But these policies are dangerous and undermine Washington’s lead over Beijing in AI.

Huang’s resignation as CEO following an extra-marital affair with an alleged Chinese spy offers the chance for better policies. It comes hard on the heels of the resounding midterm election success by the Democrats, who are generally much more critical of AI than Trump.

The twin shifts may herald regulation to address AI’s most serious risks as well as tighter restrictions on chip exports to China. There is mounting outrage in Washington - not just among Democrats, but also among Republicans who care about national security - over the way the Taiwanese-born executive was able to influence policy.

Critics have focused on why Trump took the Nvidia boss on a trip to Beijing even after Secretary of State Marco Rubio told the president that Huang was in a relationship with the alleged spy, the New York Times reported, citing people with knowledge of the matter. Senior White House officials are also unhappy that Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick did so little to control chip exports, Reuters reported citing two people familiar with the situation.

There will now be a host of investigations by congressional committees, the administration, the media and Nvidia itself. The China hawks inside and outside government will be emboldened. The power of the “tech bros” in general may also erode if lawmakers decide it is not sensible for largely unaccountable individuals to have so much influence over public policy.

The chip backlash

Huang argued that tight controls on chip exports to China would spur Beijing to do more to develop its own home-grown semiconductor industry. Their impact would therefore paradoxically weaken the United States.

The flaw in this argument is that having an incentive to catch up with the United States is not the same as being able do so. Beijing already has a mission to build a world-beating chip industry. But it has not yet succeeded.

What is more, China has shown by its actions that it wants foreign technology to help it catch up. For example, it has put huge effort into trying to replicate chip-making equipment made by ASML ASML.AS of the Netherlands, including hiring former staff and cobbling together second-hand parts, Reuters has reported.

The Huang scandal, meanwhile, has focussed attention on the smuggling of top-end Nvidia chips into China; and the sale of its semiconductors to companies in South-East Asia which then rent out capacity on their data centres to Chinese companies. The People’s Republic needs to do all this precisely because it does not have enough indigenous computing power. Its own processors are slower than those produced by US companies such as Nvidia.

Congress will want to tighten chip export controls. This could happen even before the Democrats take power in January. One option is to make smuggling harder. Another is to reduce Chinese companies’ capacity to rent space in data centres in other countries.

Another promising policy could be to make it more difficult for Chinese AI companies to train their models on the best US ones. Such “distillation” allows them to save on both the cost of developing the technology and the amount of computing power they need.

Top US AI companies already have a strong incentive to crack down on what Anthropic calls “industrial-scale” distillation. But this is a moving target, involving subterfuge. One way Washington could help is by granting US labs an exemption from anti-trust laws so they can share intelligence and work together to stamp out this practice.

Serious risks

While AI is a powerful tool, it comes with risks. Some stem from the danger that bad actors will misuse it. Others come from the possibility that AI models will themselves run out of control. There are multiple near-term concerns including cyber-attacks and the production of bioweapons - even before addressing the concern that AI agents might eventually eliminate humanity.

Although most Democrats and some Republicans recognise the risk, Trump has been largely opposed to regulating the industry. He has so far opted for a voluntary pact which is “morally” but not legally binding to developing new models. Huang’s influence may well have encouraged this excessively loose approach.

The new Congress may wish to put regulation of the industry onto a formal statutory footing. But Trump will still be able to veto legislation unless legislators get bipartisan support with at least two-thirds majorities in both chambers.

Opponents of regulation will argue that controls will slow down US companies, allowing China to catch up. But it may be possible for Democrats and Republicans to craft a package which involves regulation of US AI companies and tighter chip exports controls for China. That way, the United States should still be able to keep its lead.

Huang's ousting will also revive a debate about whether to regulate so-called “open-weight” models, where Chinese companies enjoy a strong lead. The Nvidia boss was one of the most influential voices supporting such technology, which allow customers to run models on their own hardware. They cannot do this with closed-weight models provided by the likes of Anthropic and OpenAI.

China’s lack of computing power is one of the reasons its companies have focused on open-weight AI models. While open-weight variants are cheaper and more flexible than their closed-weight competitors, they may be more risky, as bad actors can more easily remove safety features.

Any move by Washington to tighten up export controls or regulation of Chinese open-weight models will anger Beijing. It could retaliate in multiple ways, for example by withholding access to critical minerals. This may be a brake on how far US AI policy changes in the wake of Huang’s downfall. But it is unlikely to change the direction of travel - and that is good news.

Follow @Hugodixon on X


(Editing by Peter Thal Larsen; Production by Pranav Kiran)

((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can click on DIXON/hugo.dixon@thomsonreuters.com))

Recent news on ASML Holding

See all news