(The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions
expressed are her own.)
By Una Galani
MUMBAI, March 5 (Reuters Breakingviews) - Big Japanese
companies are well equipped for the end of the country’s
long-standing era of negative interest rates. Yet, when it
arrives, the shift in monetary policy will unearth the dark side
of Japan Inc lurking beneath the surface: its struggling small
businesses.
Japanese stocks are partying like it’s 1989. The benchmark
Nikkei 225 Index this week topped 40,000 for the first time,
surpassing levels previously seen before the country's asset
price bubble burst more than 30 years ago, triggering a
decades-long effort to reflate the economy.
As in the U.S. the rally is concentrated in a few large
companies. SoftBank Group 9984.T is riding the hype
surrounding artificial intelligence. Trading houses including
Mitsui 8031.T , Sumitomo 8053.T and Mitsubishi 8058.T have
rocketed in value after Berkshire Hathaway BRKa.N backed the
companies, spurring what one hedge fund has dubbed the “Warren
Buffett bubble”. Meanwhile, the Tokyo Stock Exchange is
prodding underperforming companies to boost their valuations.
One of the foundations underpinning the soaring market is
optimism that big firms are strong enough to weather a
much-awaited return to positive interest rates. The Bank of
Japan 8301.T set its benchmark rate at minus 0.1% in 2016
after failing to stop the slide in consumer prices over the
previous two decades, and the rate has not moved since. Now core
inflation which excludes fresh food is finally at the central
bank’s 2% key target and a change is on the horizon as early as
April.
BOJ Governor Kazuo Ueda is trying to induce a virtuous cycle
where prices rise, companies pay higher wages, consumers spend
more, and the economy – currently stuck in a recession – starts
growing again. Typically, any sudden rise in interest rates can
upend the corporate world by forcing companies to pay more to
service their debts. The bigger constituents of Japan Inc are
more than ready, however.
"Scant room for improvement" is the telling title of a
credit report by S&P Global Ratings, covering some 58 companies
it studied. The agency reckons the average ratio of debt to
EBITDA was just 2.4 in 2023. Meanwhile at least 90% of
Japanese companies that S&P rates are investment grade. By
contrast, the agency deems 40% of the firms it assesses
worldwide as speculative.
Nor do large Japanese firms face immediate cash calls from
higher borrowing costs. That’s because they used the era of
ultra-low interest rates to take out longer-dated cheap loans.
Borrowing terms are close to three years, at the peak
range since the 2000s, up from around two years, the BOJ notes
in its Financial System Report. Many have excess cash and
liquidity anyway.
And policymakers will go easy on them. Even if the central
bank raises rates next month – a possibility if corporate wage
negotiations confirm that inflation is finally on the rise – it
will probably do so gradually, Deputy Governor Shinichi Uchida
said in a speech last month. Real policy rates, after adjusting
for inflation, will probably remain negative.
The desire to go slowly makes sense. A big hike could spark
a sharp appreciation of the yen JPY= . That would crush
corporate earnings and equity prices: Japan Inc generates 20% of
its revenue overseas, per Goldman Sachs, compared with just 6%
in 1991. To be fair, a sharp appreciation of the yen could also
happen if the U.S. Federal Reserve embarks on a swift series of
rate cuts, pushing investors away from the dollar and towards
currencies with more attractive returns.
THE WALKING DEAD
Yet decades of stagnation have taken a toll on corporate
Japan. The most devastating impact of the end of ultra easy
money will likely be the death of many “zombie” firms. Authors
who have published in the Bank for International Settlements
Quarterly Review define them as businesses whose annual earnings
are lower than their interest bill. Japan had 251,000 of them at
the end of November, accounting for roughly one in six
companies.
Big Japanese banks have long curbed their exposure to such
firms. Most recently, dead-end companies have benefited
from substantial pandemic-related relief, including access
to so-called “zero-zero” loans without immediate interest
or collateral requirements, from government-affiliated lenders.
Signs of pain are starting to appear as those support
measures wind up. Bankruptcies of companies of all sizes rose
30% year-on-year in 2023, the fastest pace since Japan’s
economic bubble burst. For the first time in 15 years,
bankruptcies are rising in all industries and regions. Failures
of restaurants rose by a stunning 70%.
Yet today’s weak firms are primarily small- and medium-sized
enterprises, and not particularly big borrowers: Debt of failed
businesses stood at 0.33% of aggregate bank lending in
mid-January, compared to 2.5% after the global financial crisis,
LSEG data shows.
SMEs may not command the attention of global lenders
and investors, but they do employ some 60% of Japan’s
workforce. Many of these companies will struggle to pay wages
that are growing fast. And they are poorly equipped to
adopt artificial intelligence solutions to get more out of
the country’s shrinking and ageing workforce. Rooting out weaker
companies will help channel capital and labour to more
productive firms. But disruption from a wave
of corporate failures would weigh on consumer confidence in a
country where lifetime employment was once the norm.
Indeed, confidence is so fragile that Prime Minister Fumio
Kishida’s government is vowing to do “everything possible” to
boost household incomes. The government has agreed tax cuts to
offset the pain of price hikes on households. The International
Monetary Fund says stimulus is unnecessary and warns that
Japan’s current policies will raise gross government debt which
is already very high at over 250% of GDP.
These risks help explain why foreign money managers are
holding back from a fuller endorsement of Japanese stocks.
Despite the rally, global equity fund allocations to Japanese
equities stood at 4.93% in December, according to EPFR, a data
provider, below the 5.62% weight Japan commands in the MSCI All
Country World Index .MIWD00000PUS .
Big companies may be as well prepared as possible for the
end of negative interest rates but executives remain highly
cautious and risk averse. Perhaps they too see the many dark
corners Japan Inc must still navigate.
Follow @ugalani on Twitter
<^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Graphic: Debt of failed businesses is fading as a risk https://reut.rs/48wsury
Graphic: Global equity funds remain underweight Japan https://reut.rs/48En4dO
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^>
(Editing by Francesco Guerrera, Peter Thal Larsen and Katrina
Hamlin)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can
click on GALANI/
una.galani@thomsonreuters.com; Reuters Messaging:
una.galani.thomsonreuters.com@reuters.net))