Click the following link to watch video: https://share.newscasts.refinitiv.com/link?entryId=1_s8zvui4s&referenceId=1_s8zvui4s&pageId=RefinitivNewscasts
Source: Reuters
Description: The creation of digital currencies by central banks will be a
fraught process, Edward Chancellor tells Rob Cox. While this may be one of the
most important financial innovations since the creation of paper money, it
also threatens the very premise of the modern banking industry.
Short Link: https://refini.tv/2QOIiEj
Video Transcript:
Telecoms companies with landlines and so forth were threatened by the advent
of the internet. In that sense, the digital currencies may be the biggest
shakeup in banking in 300 years.
Welcome to another Breakout with Breakingviews brought to you by PGIM. I'm
here with Edward Chancellor who's written a fascinating column about CBDCs.
That is not some sort of hemp derived oil. It is not a downtown club in New
York City. Eddie, explain to me what a CBDC is.
CBDC is the central bank’s answer to a stable coin. The central
bank’s answer to cryptocurrencies, namely a new electronic digital
currency.
And why are they putting it out? Is this their response to the Bitcoins and
Ethereum? Is this because they feel under threat in some way from cryptos?
Well, yes. But I think general point is that digital currencies are following
the digital economy and people giving up on cash. And in Sweden, half of
retailers no longer accept cash a tool. So, as you get rid of cash, the
central bank’s saying, well, we need a paper notes that are no longer in
sortation, we need our own currencies.
Who is this going to hurt if central banks, if the Federal Reserve, if the
European Central Bank, Bank of Japan, they come out with these digital moneys?
Is it all good? Or is this, I mean, your piece suggests that commercial
banking, as we know it, is doomed.
Yeah, well, I mean, think of it this way. We all have a bit of cash in our
wallet but not that much. Most of our deposits, most of our cash in a budget
commerce is kept in a bag. Now with the central bank offering, if there are no
limits on holding and as it's much safer than putting your money in a bank,
then the possibility is a huge transfer or savings of deposits out of the
banks into the new digital currency. And that creates a problem for commercial
bank. It's not clear to me what a commercial bank, what function of the
commercial bank is going forward. In the same way, let’s say telecoms
companies with landlines and so forth were threatened by the advent of the
internet. In that sense, the digital currencies may be the biggest shakeup in
banking in 300 years.
OK. Well, there are other elements to this. I mean, if it is, if central banks
can sort of monitor and trace where this money goes, there’s security
issues, there’s privacy issues. Doesn’t that sort of go against the
whole notion of a cryptocurrency?
Well it goes against the notion of cryptocurrencies, then one should bear in
mind that the digital currencies are not necessarily distributed ledger
technology like Bitcoin, they may be centralized. And depending on which
country you're living in, the central bank or the intelligence agencies may be
looking in on all your transactions. And that appears to be the case in China.
Now China's --- thoughts with its trials of the digital currency is the
digital yuan. It said that next year at the Beijing Winter Olympics, that the
sports people who arrive there will be given digital yuan instead. Now the
People's Bank of China and the Chinese intelligence agencies have the capacity
to read all those transactions. Now the Americans are not happy with that. And
they’re going to have to find a different type of system. But on the
other hand, they don’t want you to undesirables transferring large sums
of money around the world to fund terrorism or drug dealing or so. The
Americans have yet to come up with a solution to that.
So, I mean, digital yuan in a sense is a huge threat, I suppose, to the
hegemony of the US dollar long-term?
Well, I think so. And so, we have to think of it is as we're moving from one
platform for financial transactions, which is international, which is banks
and bank transfers over the swift settlement system. Now that is really under
the domination of the Americans. The Americans can impose sanctions on Chinese
officials or a North Korean or whoever they wish by dominating the system. Now
the Chinese dislike the hegemony of the US dollar and want their own system.
So, with that digital yuan they’re looking to insert themselves into a
new international monetary system and they want to dominate that system. Which
is another reason why the Americans have got to get cracking and come up with
a viable alternative.
And as far as if you're a stock market investor, what had you think about? Do
you think this is a reason to underweight commercial banks? Is this a reason
to avoid Visa, MasterCard, and payments companies?
Well, I mean, it may take a while for the market to wake up to these
possibilities. But yes, there is a potential that the digital currencies to
undermine the franchises of JPMorgan Chase, to undermine the franchises of the
credit card networks say Visa International and Mastercard. I'm not saying
tomorrow or even next year, but in five, 10 years’ time, what will those
business franchises look like? Will you need huge banks with vast numbers of
staff and countless numbers of regulators and compliance officers. I think
probably not. So, this, if you will, accelerates the fintech fret to
commercial banking. And I think that will probably make them more a prudent
investor, considering that fret and marking down the valuation of those
stocks, if not today, but certainly in the next few years.
All right, fascinating discussion. Thank you, Eddie. We'll be back with
another Breakout from Breakingviews next week.
Thank you