BT’s vulture M&A dials up a worthwhile connection
BREAKINGVIEWS-BT’s vulture M&A dials up a worthwhile connection The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own. Refiles to add currency symbol in paragraph 3.
By Neil Unmack
LONDON, Oct 5 (Reuters Breakingviews) - Allison Kirkby is looking like Britain’s answer to Jamie Dimon. The BT BT.L CEO has just stepped in to buy up the carcass of indebted telecom group TalkTalk, just as JPMorgan JPM.N boss is known for saving weak US banks. It looks like a risky move: TalkTalk is lossmaking, and the deal could raise antitrust risks, although Kirkby’s shareholders can probably emerge happy.
TalkTalk may create a new motto in European leveraged finance: never lend to UK telco buyouts. The group was already in turnaround mode when Toscafund took it private in 2020: it relied heavily on the BT-owned network Openreach to sell broadband, giving it little pricing power in an increasingly competitive market. In recent years, high debt and dwindling customers has seen its profitability collapse. It had been kept afloat by chief lender Ares Management ARES.N, which has over the years put over £500 million in debt and equity into the group.
TalkTalk’s dire financial status made rescuing it increasingly challenging. Any buyer would have needed to fund operating losses, invest in new customer service, and pay arrears and future network charges to Openreach. That makes BT a logical acquirer, as more than half of TalkTalk’s revenue goes straight to Openreach, which would be lost if the group went bust. The outlay for BT is around £400 million, including the non-receipt of some £100 million of Openreach charges. The remainder will go to Ares, which will recover some £100 million in high-ranking senior lending and more in fees, and asset-backed lender KKR KKR.N. It will also cover costs. But the rest of TalkTalk’s debt, which Fitch Ratings estimates at £1.5 billion in total, will face steep losses. TalkTalk's 8.25% bond, issued in 2025, was trading at just 2 pence in the pound on Monday.
Buying TalkTalk out of administration makes sense, but it’s still risky for Kirkby. BT’s share of the UK retail market may now exceed 35%, raising the risk that the UK Competition and Markets Authority unwinds the deal or forces disposals. Prime Minister Andy Burnham appears to have panicked at the prospect of 1 million customers losing broadband access overnight if TalkTalk went into liquidation, and granted a public interest intervention notice, which should tame the CMA. Still, rival operators will petition for remedies: Virgin Media 02 has called the deal a “ stitch-up ”.
The deal maths looks sound for BT, providing some cushion. It can make savings by slashing costs and selling more products. Assume synergies of perhaps half Talk Talk’s operating costs, equivalent to £150 million pounds, and the savings' present value alone, after tax and capitalised on a multiple of 10, would exceed £1 billion, more than double the initial outlay. And saving TalkTalk avoids the risk of BT's broadband customers vanishing or going to a rival.
The TalkTalk saga may prompt changes. A clearer administration regime should allow ailing broadband providers to avoid the risk of customers being switched off. And broadband companies may need to operate with lower debt. BT may benefit from the deal, but in an ideal world the telecom group should never have needed to step in in the first place.
Follow @Unmack1 on X.
CONTEXT NEWS
BT Group on October 5 announced it had bought the main businesses of the TalkTalk group out of administration.
The transaction, which will see BT take on TalkTalk’s 1.5 million retail customers, will result in a “cash impact” of £400 million, BT said in a statement. That figure includes the “non-receipt” of £100 million owed to BT by TalkTalk.
BT shares rose by 1.7% to 199 pence as of 1046 GMT on October 5.
(Editing by Aimee Donnellan; Production by Varun H K and Streisand Neto)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can click on UNMACK/neil.unmack@thomsonreuters.com))