Refinitiv Newscasts - Stoltenberg newser ahead of NATO meeting 1
Click the following link to watch video: https://share.newscasts.refinitiv.com/link?entryId=1_4f6wr1d7&referenceId=1_4f6wr1d7&pageId=RefinitivNewscasts Source: Reuters Description: NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg holds a news conference ahead of a meeting of NATO defence ministers in Brussels. Short Link: https://refini.tv/3gL4XdI Video Transcript: >> Morning time at all. So we follow this, but at the same time, we believe there is some ground for cautious optimism based on the science coming from Moscow that they are interested in continuing diplomatic efforts and to sit down with NATO and NATO allies to find a political solution. >> We go to Interfax Ukraine. If Interfax Ukraine even summer Secretary-General. Two questions if I may. First one, can you please give more details about upcoming meetings with these Ukrainian Minister of Defense. In which formal it will be? When it will be? What do you expect from Ukrainian side? And second question is, being under threat of possible war. Don't you think that later might review Bucharest decision regarding the Ukraine? Or in other words, maybe it's easier to give up Ukraine. Thank you. >> All of them is forward to the meeting with the Ukrainian Defense Minister, also, together with the Defense Minister of Georgia. the two defense means decisional meet, all 30 NATO Defense Ministers. This will take place on a Thursday. And it is, you have to know the sign of the very close and highly valued partnership we have with Ukraine, and strong support that allies provide to Ukraine. In the meeting I expect the ministers to once again express their political support to Ukraine, the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Ukraine. And as you know, NATO provides the support with the capacity building, we helped them organize Ukraine's, defense and security institutions. I expect that to be addressed during the meeting and also help with cyber defense. And then of course, on top of what NATO do together, several NATO allies provide all bilateral support to Ukraine. So the political, the practical support to Ukraine will be addressed in the meeting. Then I think also it will be an opportunity for all of us to take stock. Are there any signs that things are moving in the right direction or is the military buildup in and around continue or does it continue? So I think it's a bit early to preempt the exact outcome of that discussion. But it is important that when things are so challenging and when tensions are as high as there are. Now, it is important that we consult closely with close partners with Ukraine, and that's exactly what we do. That knows how are that, we are in regular contact with Ukrainian leadership in different formats almost all the time. I've spoken several times with President Zelensky and we continue to be in close contact with the government of Ukraine. >> We've got to figure it out. >> Sorry hold on, the Bucharest decision stands. NATO strongly believe that all nations have the right to choose their own path, and the NATO door remains open. The enlargement of NATO has been a great success. It that helps to spread democracy freedom and ensure peace and stability circles suited for decades. So that decision stands. >> Will get to Frankfurter [inaudible 00:03:50] gentleman over there with glasses. Thank you. >> Thanks a lot. Secretary general, over the past days, France has indicated that it no longer consider. So what no longer consider the NATO Russia Founding Act valid in case of an invasion? Do you expect a discussion on the NATO of Russia founding act in that respect during the defense ministerial. And do you sense a change among member states, which beside it, after the 2014 annexation of Crimea, that they still be bound by this basic act. Thanks. >> Russian invasion of Ukraine will be a blatant violation of the NATO Russia Founding Act. But that has happened before. But NATO allies are still committed to the Founding Act, we believe in the importance of respecting all our international obligations, including the Founding Act. And we have seen before that that Russia has violated the funding out by invading Ukraine, by using military force against the Ukrainian and illegally annexing Crimea. But we still, I believe in the importance of the Founding Act, and also like to add up, we strongly believe in the dual truck approach. That we need a dialogue, we need to talk to Russia. But at the same time, we need strength, undertones on defense and that remains NATO position. >> Associated Press. >> Long cook from the Associated Press, You spoke before just on the troop movements about the different types of things that Russia has been moving in recent weeks, you've spoken about fighter jets about S-400 and so on. Then more recently about the enablers, about medical centers, logistics, command and control, and so on. When it comes to the things that Russia is talking about, withdrawing today. Do you see any substance in that, anything significant that might impact its ability to invade Ukraine? And if I could also just ask you very briefly, during the last few months, has there ever been a direct and probable security threat to a NATO ally? >> So far we have not seen any de-escalation on the ground from the Russian side. Of the last the weeks and days we have seen the opposite continued military buildup with more troops, more about the groups are more high-end capabilities artillery and defense, missiles, and a lot of support elements that makes it possible for us all to move into Ukraine for a full flagellation or more limited military incursion with hardly any warning time at all. That picture has not changed so far. But we monitor, we follow what they do. And we believe there is some ground for cautious optimism based on seeing those, and signs coming from Moscow, that they're ready continue to engage in a diplomatic effort. And we are ready to continue to engage you in the diplomatic effort. So it's too early to say. But first, since we so strongly believe in the need for a political solution, of course, we will now really look into whether it is a possibility to create a framework for meaningful dialogue with Russia. I welcome the different formats. We need a native Russia console, we need a bilateral talks between different NATO allies, we need a normative format to engage with Russia and also welcome their friends via many NATO ally leaders, meeting with President Putin engaging with Russia. We have a transcript, would've shot him also in Moscow today. Last week, President Bankroll, also, of course, Present the Biden has been in contact with the President Putin, has Prime Minister Boris Johnson and others. So there are many efforts on NATO allies to engage with Russia. We hope that we will receive an answer from Russia soon. An answer to our letter to our proposals, where we invited them to sit down in a series of meeting and I outlined the topics we are ready to discuss. >> So anyway, I think it's too early to say whether we can see anything on the ground. But I will tell you, or at least we may. Let's come back to what we tell you one, but at least we are following very closely what they are doing. >> Lady in red scarf. >> Sorry. >> [inaudible 00:09:25] >> What we see is a serious buildup in and around Ukraine. And I think also the fact that we have increased the NATO presence in the eastern part of the Lions sends a very clear message to end the potential adversary that we are there to defend and protect all allies. And I've seen that myself. The bath groups I have listed them and just before Christmas in Latvia and Lithuania, and then on Friday I was in Romania, and the fact that we have deployed more NATO troops on the ground, more naval assets, more aircrafts, all of that sends a very clear message. So we are there to protect and defend all our lives. And I think there is no room for any miscalculation in Moscow about our commitment to defending allies. So we have to understand that Ukraine is a partner which support Ukraine, but for all NATO allies, we provide 100% security guarantees and then we have demonstrated that commitment also with more North American presence in Europe all the last weeks. >> We'll go to the lady with the red scarf then. >> [inaudible 00:10:41] Address here from Bloomberg. I just had a follow-up to my colleague's question. Could you be a bit more precise about what the start of de-escalation would look like. I mean, how many troops would have to pull back. And to what extent do you see this Russia's new forest posture as a long-term formation there. Thank you. >> So what do you have to see is, of course, a substantial withdrawal of troops, but not only troops, also equipment, because what we saw this spring was that they moved in with troops and heavy equipment. Very often it takes much more time to move the heavy equipment than to move in and out the troops and the soldiers, under what we've seen before is that they go in with heavy equipment and troops take up out some troops, and then they can easily move them back in again after just a few days on very short notice. So what do we need to see is significant and during withdrawal of forces, troops, and not least, the heavy equipment. But I think also we need to understand that what we have seen over in reality last year because this actually started last spring and then they're gone up and down. With upward trend all the time. We'll have a lasting impact on the security situation in the Europe. And that's also why NATO is not only responding to the current crisis in Iran, Ukraine, by increasing our presence in eastern parts of the lines. But we are also going to consider more long-term adjustment or posture in the East, including considering the establishment of bath group. For instance, in Romania and I welcomed it for France to lead that bath group. So I think we need to distinguish between different things. NATO has, since 2014, increased our presence in the eastern part of the lines because of Russia's aggressive actions against Ukraine with the illegal annexation here. And that has taken place over many years with the bath groups with a new command structure with more than able on the air presence. But also then in the last weeks and months, we responded to the current crisis by increasing our presence. And then we are looking at the long-term adjustment but that will be something we will take decisions on later on. >> We'll go to political. >> Thanks very much, David Herzog, with political Secretary-General at the start of the Olympics, we saw quite a striking joint statement from Russia and China against NATO expansion. I wonder if you assess that one outcome of this crisis is stronger unity between Russia and China against the alliance. Would this have happened if leaders hadn't turned to the China issue at last year's summit? I know the strategic concept you've said would address Russia more than I had before and China more than it had before, does it need to address now Russia and China together. >> So first of all, NATO has to respond to reality. And the reality is that China and Russia has come closer and closer over the last years. They're exercising together. They are working more closely together in the diplomatic domain in the UN Security Council. But you'll also see how they conduct more and more exercises that I've done that over the last years, including recently with a joint exercise with your own in the Indian Ocean. So of course, these are realities that have taken place always on time and they impact our security. So then there is no way we can deny or in a way not to take that into account. And that's exactly what NATO has done over the last years, especially since I was submitting last summer where we for the first time had some substantial language on the security consequences of China for our security. But we are ready to also engage with China. We need dialogue, we need to address arms control, big issues like climate change and many other issues. And that's exactly what we are doing. But knowing that, for instance, China is now rapidly developing new nuclear capabilities, long-range missiles, hypersonic missiles, of course, that mapped the missiles that can reach all NATO territory. There's no way we cannot take that into account and not also and not these because we see that China is coming closer to us in cyberspace and the Arctic and Africa and also trying to create, to control critical infrastructure. I think fundamentally what we see is that too authoritarian powers, Russia and China are operating together because they don't like a rules-based international order. They don't share our values, freedom, democracy. That's also the reason why they tried to deny sovereign democratic nations the right to choose their own future. They want a world where big powers can decide what smaller powers and countries can do. So this is about fundamental principles whether free independent countries can choose to be part of an alliance as NATO or you can choose to stay out. We should respect it anyway. And then to respect sovereign democratic decisions by Finland and Sweden to not apply for membership or by Ukraine to apply for membership. This is there certain democratic decisions and we respect them. But Russia and China do not. They have it state that glare in a joint statement that they don't want countries in the world to have that freedom to make their own decisions on their own future. And that just demonstrates a fundamental difference when it comes to values and what world we would like to live in. I would like to live in a world where we have free democratic nations. Living in a world with a world order and where a rule of law is what we have to abide to. Not a sphere of influence would be powers decide what neighbors can do. >> We'll get to imaging. >> Thank you. Mrs. Secretary General, what can you tell us about the meeting with Georgina defense minister, you spoke about Ukraine? Can you tell us more about it? And also last week during the press conference here in this room. President said that they asked for a high-level meeting with Ukraine and Georgia in Madrid. What do you think about these ideas? Thank you so much. >> So first of all, I look very much forward to the meeting with the Georgian defense minister. It reflects very important partnership we have with Georgia. We have just stepped up our cooperation in different ways. We have activities together, we will have also an exercise together. And there are other ways of demonstrating how NATO and Georgia are working closely together. We continue to provide support to the reform efforts and we continue to, of course, support to the territorial integrity and sovereignty of Georgia. So this is part of the regular important close coordination between Georgia and NATO and I will look forward to the meeting. Well, that's too early to say the different formats of the manager's summit. We have to come back to that. >> We'll try to take a couple of questions online before coming back to the press room. So I'll go to Vegas of piano Johnson. >> Thank you. Mrs. Stuart Mill, I would like to ask you about the unprecedented public sharing of intelligence during these months, specifically from the US and latest about the possible innovation tomorrow on Wednesday. Is this open sharing new tool for NATO or for Allied meant for deterrence. And can you tell us whether, in your opinion, if it had any effect on Russia? >> We have systematically shared information about the Russian plans, the Russian capabilities and the Russian attempts to stage a pretext for aggressive actions against the Ukraine. What is often referred to as a false flag operations. We do so because we believe in transparency, but also because we believe that that makes it harder for Russia to conduct aggressive actions against Ukraine. To Libya, everything they do is a way also to increase the threshold for them to invade Ukraine, to send in forces, to try to organize riots, topple the government or all the other things about we are afraid that Russia may try to do. The fact that we do this is a way also to try to counter and to prevent these things from happening. I think we have to understand that intelligence is not always a prediction. Intelligence is information. When we share information, it is actually an effort to try to prevent things from happening which would have otherwise happened. So yes, we do this in an attempt to prevent aggressive actions against the Ukraine. >> Okay. We will go to DPA Ella Joyner. >> Hi there. Thanks for taking my question. Can you hear me okay? >> Yes. >> Great. Thank you. >> Basically, I'm inferring from your comments that you have no plans to step back from building up NATO's presence in the Eastern flank. If you did see, I think you said a significant and enduring withdrawal, would you then consider reversing those plans to increase NATO's presence in Eastern flank. Thank you very much. >> NATO is a defensive alliance. Everything we do is defensive and it's about protecting other founding NATO allies. Second, we have had an increased precedence on NATO in Eastern Port Alliance since 2014. It started in 2014, because of Russia's illegal annexation of Crimea and because of Russia's continued efforts to destabilise Ukraine, including by supporting the separatists in Donbass. This has been there now for many years and that has triggered the defensive response from NATO in the eastern part of the alliance. Then over the last couple of months and weeks, we have seen that some of these persons has been enhanced, boosted because we have seen in a very current challenge in around Ukraine. We will assess and we will judge the need to maintain that depends on what's happening in and around Ukraine. But it's too early to speculate because so far we have not seen any de-escalation by Russia and we speak about well over 100,000 troops, combative troops also close to it. They are close to Ukraine on the Ukrainian borders, but they're also close to NATO territory, not to list Poland and some of the Baltic countries bordering Ukraine and of course bordering Belarus. We will make judgment decisions based on Russia actually do. But I think also that we need to understand that there will most likely be some long-term consequences, some long-term deterration of the security environment in Europe of these significant Russian military buildup, the threat new rhetoric. We are also done assessing whether we should have some more longer-term adjustments, all precedence in Eastern ports of the alliance. >> And we'll take a final question from Zoom, Robert Lupita from [inaudible 00:24:11]. >> Thank you very much, Mr. Secretary General. Today the Romanian Defense Ministry has announced that Romania has competed the necessary operations to declare the initial operational capability of the NATO battle group. I want to ask you, how soon can these battle group be up and running and which troops do you expect it to be installed over there? Thank you. >> I will not preempt any decisions by ministers. I met with the President Clause Johaness on Friday, and we discussed the battle group. I also discussed this with President McClure. I expressed my support and that I welcomed the French offer to lead a battle group in Romania. It will take some time before we have older decisions in place and also sometimes to have command or control on that and all the other issues that has to be decided before about the potentially is stationed in Romania. But then I think it is important to remember that while we are working on this issue over French battle group in Romania, it doesn't mean that we do not do anything. Just over the last few days, the United States has added 1,000 troops to their presence in Romania, to the 1,000 that all they had. That is 2,000. You're not just as an educator, that's not necessarily a permanent presence, but it is a significant reinforcement on NATO presence in Romania, which has already taken place. I saw in older, the striker units coming into Romania, coming into Constanza. There are more US planes, there are more German, Italian, and all their allies have also stepped up. So I think we have to distinguish between them or imminent need for more troops on forces. For instance, in Romania, where olderly deployed more troops and forces to Romania, and I welcome United States and others. Then distinguished that, to separate out from the show more long-term adjustment and the question of a button group is a more long-term adjustment or a precedence in the Romania and the rest of the Eastern Political. >> Okay. We'll come back to your [inaudible 00:26:47]. >> [inaudible 00:26:51] you said is your group that we often tend to hear. Regression rhetorics was accompanied by such quite aggressive decisions by the State Duma, which suggested to President Putin to recognize that the independence of so-called Donetsk and Luhansk Republics. I understand that it is not a purely NATO issue, but NATO is going to intensify the negotiations with Russia. How that move would impact them. And the second question, if I may, have you received from Russian side any response to your proposal to conduct and to hold the next NRC meeting? Thank you. >> To answer the last question first, we have not received any response from Russia on our proposal to both convene a series of meetings in the NATO Russia council. We had one meeting in January. It lasted for four hours. It was challenging but also an important meeting because we were together there, Russia and all NATO allies and discussing and addressing Ukraine. The security implications, all the military buildup by Russia and Ukraine. I think that in itself are also of great importance. But we have not received any response from Russia on our invitation to hold additional meetings on the NATO Russia Council and not received any response from Russia on our written proposals on the different topics, subjects that we are ready to discuss with Russia. We look forward and we welcome a response from Russia. Let's see what response we will get. Then on the question over a Russian recognition of the so-called the Republics, peoples' Republics of Donetsk and Luhansk. Well, if that happens, that will be a blatant violation of Ukraine's territorial integrity and sovereignty once again. Because there is no doubt that Donetsk and Luhansk is part of Ukraine within international recognized borders. Such a recognition will be a violation of International Law and territorial integrity and sovereignty of Ukraine. Not only that, it will also be about a violation of the means agreements. So it will make it even harder to find a political solution based on the mean schemas and NATO and I support the efforts of within the Normandy format of France and Germany to find a political solution within the Normandy format and of course a recognition of these two, also territories as some independent entities will totally undermine these efforts and violating means agreements. >> Thank you very much. This concludes this press conference. We will see you tomorrow. Thank you. >> Thank you so much