Picture of Galaxy Digital logo

GLXY — Galaxy Digital News Story

0.000.00%
ca flag iconLast trade - 00:00
FinancialsSpeculativeLarge CapValue Trap

Analysis: In spot bitcoin ETF race, some pioneers stick to the sidelines

By Suzanne McGee
       Nov 28 (Reuters) - Despite growing excitement that spot
bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) will soon win regulatory
approval, some cryptocurrency ETF pioneers plan to sit out what
is expected to be a fierce industry battle for market share. 
    Demand for a bitcoin ETF, which would allow retail and
institutional investors to easily bet on the price of the
world's biggest cryptocurrency, is expected to draw in as much
as $3 billion from investors in the first few days of trading
and pull in billions more thereafter. 
    Yet some established names in the blockchain and
cryptocurrency space - including ProShares, Amplify Investments
and Roundhill - are so far steering clear of launching a bitcoin
ETF. They worry that the field is too crowded, the regulatory
and marketing costs too high, and that demand will not be strong
enough to compensate for that. 
    Though they remain a small minority in a race where both big
and small players are diving in, their skepticism suggests the
hype over a spot bitcoin ETF may be misplaced and that the
products could prove unprofitable for some issuers rushing into
the space.
    "This could be the most successful ETF launch in history,
but it's still going to be intensely competitive, requiring a
lot of investment up front," said Dave Mazza, chief strategy
officer at Roundhill Investments, which hopes to launch
cryptocurrency ETFs but has no plans for a spot bitcoin ETF. 
    "You have to weigh the odds that you'll end up as one of the
winners or an also-ran." 
        The SEC has long rejected spot bitcoin ETF applications
on the grounds they do meet its investor protection
requirements.
    Industry hopes that position would shift surged in June when
BlackRock  BLK.N , which has an almost unbroken record of SEC
ETF approvals, filed for a spot bitcoin ETF. Then in August, a
court ruled that the SEC wrongly rejected Grayscale Investments'
application to convert its Bitcoin Trust  GBTC.PK  into a spot
bitcoin ETF and must review Grayscale's filing. 
    SEC chair Gary Gensler said last month the agency's
commissioners will consider as many as 10 bitcoin ETF filings,
but could not provide guidance on timing. 
    Even so, ProShares CEO Michael Sapir said he is not
convinced the SEC will approve a filing soon. The company's
ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF  BITO.N , based on bitcoin
futures, was one of the most heavily-traded new ETFs when it
first launched in 2021, pulling in $1 billion in its first few
days. 
    ProShares also has a suite of other cryptocurrency ETFs tied
to futures, offering options to clients without the need for a
spot ETF, said Sapir. 
        
    UPFRONT COSTS 
    When it does approve a bitcoin ETF, executives expect the
SEC to approve several at once, so no one has a first-mover
advantage. 
    That would drive up marketing expenses, one of the biggest
costs of an ETF debut. Combined with legal, SEC filing, and
listing costs, the bill for launching even a simple ETF rings in
at about $100,000, according to lawyers. That can climb to
millions of dollars if the product is complex and takes a long
time to secure SEC approval. 
        "Having the resources and expertise to file for
something that doesn't exist yet in the U.S.," is costly, said
Roxanna Islam, associate director of research at VettaFi, a data
firm. 
    The only prospective issuer to disclose proposed investor
fees so far is Ark Investment, which last week announced its
spot bitcoin ETF would charge a fee of 0.8%. 
        "This seems to be strategically priced to attract
assets" rather than to cover upfront costs, said Aisha Hunt, a
fund lawyer at Kelley Hunt LLC. 
    To be sure, issuers hoping to launch spot bitcoin ETFs have
a more bullish outlook than those sticking to the sidelines.
Some of the largest ETF providers, like BlackRock and Invesco,
can cross-subsidize costs, and have the marketing scale to reach
millions of potential customers. 
    But it's unclear to some ETF providers outside of the top
two dozen or so, like Amplify, that they would be able to grab
sufficient market share to make the economics work.  
    "It will be a game-changer in terms of demand and crypto's
evolution into an asset class, but that doesn't mean we'd be
able to benefit directly," said Christian Magoon, founder and
CEO of Amplify ETFs, whose Amplify Transformational Data Sharing
ETF  BLOK.N  invests in bitcoin miners and other crypto firms.
    Both Amplify and Roundhill said they will focus instead on
other cryptocurrency ETF opportunities. 
    Roundhill last month filed an SEC application to issue an
ETF that seeks to generate income and bitcoin exposure through
bitcoin-linked options. Mazza said he is optimistic the product
could debut as early as January.
    Magoon hopes the buzz surrounding a spot bitcoin ETF will
draw more assets to Amplify's BLOK ETF. That $472 million fund
has holdings in crypto companies like Coinbase  COIN.O , as well
as CME Group  CME.O , the exchange where crypto futures trade. 
    Even Tom Staudt, chief operating officer of Ark Investments,
whose spot bitcoin ETF filing is due for an SEC decision in
January, said the excitement has caused some people to lose
sight of the bigger picture.
    "It will solve some real problems for investors. But it
won't solve all problems," Staudt said, noting that is why Ark
recently launched five ETFs offering various cryptocurrency
investing approaches. 
    "The future is about more than just spot bitcoin," he added.

 (Reporting by Suzanne McGee; editing by Michelle Price and
Deepa Babington)
 ((Suzanne.McGee@thomsonreuters.com;))

Recent news on Galaxy Digital

See all news