Picture of TATA Steel logo

TATASTEEL — TATA Steel News Story

0.000.00%
in flag iconLast trade - 00:00
Basic MaterialsBalancedLarge CapNeutral

Chandra’s exit is a double-edged sword for Tata

(The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions
expressed are her own. Updates throughout to reflect Chandra's
statement confirming his resignation. )
    By Shritama Bose
    MUMBAI, Aug 12 (Reuters Breakingviews) - India's $290
billion Tata conglomerate has extended its abysmal record on
managing succession. Its leader of nine years, N.
Chandrasekaran, resigned on Wednesday ahead of an annual meeting
next week where shareholders of the unlisted holding company,
Tata Sons, may have ousted him. The exit of the first real
outsider to run the 158-year-old group removes a distraction but
also raises difficult questions about its future.
A row between Chandra and the charitable trusts that control the
salt-to-power conglomerate became public in February over a
mandate by the Reserve Bank of India to list Tata Sons. Chandra
didn't see eye to eye with Tata Trusts Chair Noel Tata who
opposed a listing. That led to a stalemate over his
reappointment which made his position untenable.
    The recent discord overshadowed Chandra's success in turning
around large parts of the group. He deleveraged bloated balance
sheets after inheriting serious problems at Tata Steel  TISC.NS 
and Tata Motors  TATM.NS . Annualised total shareholder returns
from most listed group firms have beaten India's benchmark Nifty
50 stock index  .NSEI  since he took charge in 2017, prior to
news of his departure.
But AI pressures have led to lagging returns at Tata Consultancy
Services  TCS.NS , the group's industry-leading IT outsourcer
where he was previously CEO and which contributes 87% of Tata
Sons' $3.4 billion annual dividend income. That will squeeze
funds available to plough into unlisted businesses like the
group's smartphone making venture with Apple  AAPL.O  and
money-losing Air India, a carrier foisted on Chandra by the late
Ratan Tata, former Tata Sons chair and chair emeritus.
    Infighting also has delayed decision-making on other
leadership issues: it took four months to name a CEO for Air
India after Campbell Wilson stepped down in April, while rival
IndiGo-owner InterGlobe Aviation  INGL.NS  replaced its chief
within weeks in March. And the spat also has jeopardised the
Tatas' philanthropic spending, which relies on dividends paid up
through the holding company.
    Worst of all, Chandra's departure is uncomfortably
reminiscent of the 2016 ouster of his predecessor Cyrus Mistry.
Back then, Ratan Tata swooped in as interim chair for four
months before handing over to Chandra. His passing in 2024 has
left the family's influence over the group in flux and the
trusts under greater scrutiny, a test they are not passing with
flying colours.
    The 5% drop in Tata Consultancy shares on news of Chandra's
departure underscores the ripple effect it will have across the
group where he also chairs many individual companies. And it
signals how the consequences of this second leadership disaster
could force a bigger rethink on how the Tata group, with its
unusual ownership structure, is managed. 
Follow Shritama Bose on LinkedIn and X.
     
    CONTEXT NEWS
 N. Chandrasekaran on August 12 resigned as chair of Tata Sons,
the Indian conglomerate's holding company, citing the absence of
unanimous support from the board for his re-appointment. 
In a personal statement, Chandrasekaran, known as Chandra, said
one board member did not support his re-appointment at a
February board meeting, noting six months have since passed
without a resolution on the matter. Chandra added it is
necessary to have a leader in place to run the group beyond
February 2027, when his current term as chair ends. 
    Earlier in the day, The Economic Times, citing unnamed
sources, reported Chandra had discussed the possibility of
stepping down ahead of an annual general meeting scheduled for
August 18 amid uncertainty over his reappointment as a director
and tensions with Tata Trusts Chair Noel Tata.
    Charitable trusts collectively own nearly two-thirds of Tata
Sons. Two of ​them — Sir Ratan Tata Trust and Sir Dorabji Tata
Trust — hold a 52% stake between them.

    <^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^>
(Editing by Una Galani; Production by Ujjaini Dutta and Aditya
Srivastav)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can
click on  BOSE/ mailto:shritama.bose@thomsonreuters.com))

Recent news on TATA Steel

See all news