(The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The
opinions expressed are her own.)
By Shritama Bose
MUMBAI, Sept 28 (Reuters Breakingviews) - A power
struggle at India's Tata group may have another victim in
Deutsche Bank. The German lender helped unlisted builder
Shapoorji Pallonji group raise pricey debt which it's now trying
to offload at a premium. That taps into hopes for an imminent
listing of Tata's holding company, Tata Sons. Such an outcome
will shore up the ability of SP group, owner of an 18% stake, to
honour its borrowings in excess of 541 billion rupees ($5.64
billion). But the timing is less promising than it seems.
The 160-year-old construction group behind Mumbai's iconic
Taj Mahal Palace Hotel ran into financial difficulties in 2020,
as Covid disrupted cash flows. Its problems intensified through
the last six years, pushing the SP group towards higher-cost
funding sources.
Deutsche latched onto the lending opportunity as did private
credit funds which have been warming up to India. In July, when
SP group entities issued bonds worth 214 billion rupees, sole
arranger Deutsche scooped up 29% of the offer, according to data
from Tracxn. In May 2025, SP group raised 286 billion rupees,
roughly $3 billion at current exchange rates, from Ares
Management ARES.N , BlackRock BLK.N and others in India's
largest ever onshore private credit transaction. Each of those
notes is backed by shares in Tata Sons.
Now Deutsche is trying to offload three-year zero-coupon
notes issued by Eqyizen Investment, a unit of the SP group, at a
yield of up to 18.75%, down from 18.95% in July, according to a
Reuters report citing unnamed merchant bankers. Yet the spat at
Tata group which spilled into public this month muddies, rather
than improves, SP's group's ability to honour its borrowings and
monetise its Tata Sons holding which might be worth at least 250
billion rupees.
Although Tata Sons' chair, N. Chandrasekaran, supports a
listing for the holding company he leads, the move is being
forced upon the conglomerate by the Reserve Bank of India. And
Noel Tata, chair of the Tata Trusts which owns 65% of Tata Sons,
fiercely opposes both a listing and Chandra's leadership
position at the holding company.
That could entangle the duo in legal battles and delay any
capital markets debut. The power struggle also ought to make SP
group's credit and its Tata Sons stake less attractive to
investors and lenders because of the sheer official meddling in
the Indian conglomerate.
The SP group is already seeking an extension to payments
worth 35 billion rupees ($365 million) due on September 30.
Until now, it has been able to keep deferring and gorging on
increasingly expensive debt to stay afloat. But the struggle at
Tata group could make it harder for SP group to refinance. That
provides a strong incentive for Deutsche and other lenders to
try and monetise their positions.
Follow Shritama Bose on LinkedIn and X.
CONTEXT NEWS
Deutsche Bank and other investors are offering
rupee-denominated bonds of a Shapoorji Pallonji group firm at a
premium, encouraged by the construction group's plans to sell
part of its stake in Tata Sons, Reuters reported on September
21, citing three unnamed merchant bankers.
The SP group is also planning to seek an extension to a
debt repayment worth around 35 billion rupees, which is due on
September 30, the report added.
Tata Trusts on September 17 said the SP group proposed to
sell part of its 18% stake worth 250 billion rupees in Tata
Sons, the unlisted holding company of the wider steel-to-IT Tata
conglomerate.
<^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^>
(Editing by Una Glani; Production by Aditya Srivastav)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can
click on BOSE/ mailto:shritama.bose@thomsonreuters.com))