Picture of TATA Steel logo

TATASTEEL — TATA Steel News Story

0.000.00%
in flag iconLast trade - 00:00
Basic MaterialsBalancedLarge CapNeutral

Markets are slow to grasp depths of Tata mess

    (The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist.  The
opinions expressed are her own.)
    By Ujjaini  Dutta
       BENGALURU, Sept 18 (Reuters Breakingviews) - The market
signals on the turmoil at India’s Tata group are misleading. An
extraordinary power struggle has erupted between the holding
company, Tata Sons, and its 65% owner, Tata Trusts. So far, the
share-price moves at the $260 billion of listed operating
companies have been relatively minor. Investors are
underestimating how the corporate drama can reverberate through
the group.
    On Thursday, shares in companies including Tata Steel
 TISC.NS , Tata Chemicals  TTCH.NS  and Tata Motors Passenger
Vehicles  TAMO.NS  rallied before the market closed on news that
Tata Sons awarded its chair N. Chandrasekaran a third five-year
term. By Friday morning, most of the gains were reversed after
Tata Trusts called Chandra’s re-appointment “illegal” and laid
bare the extent of the rift.
    The initial lift made sense for some companies that own
small stakes in Tata Sons, whose enterprise the Trusts now value
at $14.4 billion. Chandra's return looked favourable because he
appears willing to acquiesce to a regulatory push to list Tata
Sons, a move that would crystallise the value of those stakes
but which the Trusts oppose. The Trusts went to pains overnight
to emphasise that any IPO would involve a long and laborious
path. That reality check brought prices back down.
    Yet after two tumultuous days, shares in the conglomerate's
largest company, Tata Consultancy Services  TCS.NS , are down
barely 3.3%, equivalent to about $2.7 billion in market value
since Wednesday’s close. On its 12-month forward price-earnings
multiple of 13.9, per LSEG, that’s equivalent to $195 million or
3% of full-year 2026 earnings, according to Breakingviews
calculations. The pain could be worse.
    Investors are underpricing some key risks. The first is how
a forced listing of Tata Sons could hurt the operating
companies. True, most of its publicly traded entities are
self-sufficient, but Tata Sons acts as a lender or financier of
last resort when problems arise. Case in point: an infusion of
26 billion rupees, roughly $271 million at current exchange
rates, by Tata Sons in debt-laden Tata Power in 2020. That gives
support to credit ratings. A publicly traded holding company
might not be able to be so generous, and downgrades could come
faster in difficult times.
    The second is how a power struggle could make Tata’s
customers wary. Take Tata Consultancy again. It is already
struggling to fend off client demands for discounts as AI erodes
the value of the IT services it provides. The group turmoil
could lead customers to drive a harder bargain or take business
to rivals with fewer distractions in the boardroom, and where
legal challenges are less likely to delay major decision making.
    External partners could be put off too. Private equity group
TPG has invested in Tata Consultancy's data centre business and
Tata Motors' electric-vehicle unit; Starbucks  SBUX.O  has a
tie-up with Tata Consumer Products  TACN.NS , and Singapore
Airlines  SIAL.SI  is an investor in Air India. The saga, marred
by official overreach, may leave them wondering if they are
partnered with a private enterprise with deep pockets or one
where the state is increasingly calling the shots.
    The drama is just beginning to unfold. Markets will
eventually catch up. 
    Follow Ujjaini Dutta on LinkedIn and X.
     
    CONTEXT NEWS
    Shares of Tata group companies fell on September 18, with
Tata Chemicals down 9.7% in intraday trading, Tata Motors 3.3%
and Tata Consultancy 3%. The declines reversed some gains made
the previous day.
    Shares moved ⁠after Tata Sons, the group's holding company,
said it had reappointed N. Chandrasekaran as executive chairman
for another five years and would initiate steps to comply with a
regulatory order to list itself. 
     Tata Sons is the privately held holding company for India's
Tata conglomerate. The development reverses Chandrasekaran's
decision on August 12 to not seek reappointment citing the
absence of the board's unanimous support.
    Tata Sons' ​65% shareholders, Tata Trusts, dismissed the
appointment as "illegal". The Trusts, ​which oppose a listing,
said Tata Sons' articles of association require both of the
Trusts' nominee directors to the Tata Sons board to vote in
favour of the chair. Noel Tata, one of the nominees ​and chair
of Tata Trusts, voted against the proposal and that makes the
reappointment void, the statement added.
    On Friday, Shapoorji Pallonji Group, a minority shareholder
of Tata Sons, expressed support for a potential listing.

    <^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^>
    (Editing by Una Galani; Production by Aditya Srivastav)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can
click on  DUTTA/ ujjaini.dutta@thomsonreuters.com))

Recent news on TATA Steel

See all news