Picture of TATA Steel logo

TATASTEEL — TATA Steel News Story

0.000.00%
in flag iconLast trade - 00:00
Basic MaterialsBalancedLarge CapNeutral

Refile: EXPLAINER-Tata Sons: the rules, the rift and what happens next

    (Refiles to remove repetitive phrase in paragraph 6)
    * Controlling charities and company differ on key
appointment
    * Lawyers of both sides have taken the debate public
    * Any court battle will focus on Tata's internal governance
rules

    By Jayshree P Upadhyay and Arpan  Chaturvedi
       NEW DELHI, Sept 25 (Reuters) - India's Tata Sons, the
owner of marquee brands like Jaguar Land Rover and Tetley tea,
is facing one of its worst boardroom disputes, with its
leadership now openly split with its biggest shareholder over
key decisions.
    Tata Trusts, the charity arm of the group, owns a 66% stake
in Tata Sons, but the company's board has re-appointed its
chairman N. Chandrasekaran and has decided to move ahead with a
possible stock market listing against the wishes of its owner,
putting the power struggle at the centre of the standoff.
    Here's an explainer on the views of both sides, the complex
structures and legal options being considered, according to
people familiar with the matter:
     
    WHAT'S THE LEGAL VIEW OF TATA TRUSTS AND TATA SONS?
    Both sides have appointed some of the nation's top lawyers
to defend them and explain who can call the shots.
    Noel Tata-led Tata Trusts is being represented by lawyer
Abhishek Manu Singhvi, a lawmaker and Congress party leader. He
has said the dispute is about shareholder supremacy and the
conglomerate cannot act like a "runaway board" operating
independently of the controlling shareholder. 
    Tata Group's Chandrasekaran, who has roped in Harish Salve,
a former solicitor general of India who often represented the
government at international forums, disputes that position.
Salve says the board's decision was in line with internal
governing rules, and the charity arm needs to get past "I
control the trusts, I control this group mindset."
     
    WHY CAN'T THE TATA TRUSTS CALL A SHAREHOLDER MEETING AND
OUST THE CHAIRMAN? 
    The Tata Trusts have problems of their own that are
currently sapping their influence.
    The Tata Trusts are made up of several affiliated charities
and they could have used their voting power to call for a
shareholders meeting to effectively oust Chandrasekaran.
    But that is not possible because one of the main charities —
Sir Ratan Tata Trust — has been barred by a regulator from
convening its own meetings in a dispute over internal
appointments. So, as per internal rules, the charities currently
lack the power to call for a Tata Sons shareholder meet.
    The trusts can either wait for the deadlock to lift once the
regulatory inquiry ends, or are considering approaching a court
to lift the restrictions, two people familiar with the matter
said.
     
    WHAT'S THE CONTROVERSY ABOUT "ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION"? 
    At the heart of the dispute is the governance framework
called the "Articles of Association" of Tata Sons. Both sides —
Tata Trusts and Tata Sons — disagree on the reading of those
rules, which are not public.
    The charity arm says if Noel Tata opposed the appointment of
the chairman, it was enough to not move forward on him. It
believes such decisions cannot be taken unless it has the
support of a majority of the trusts' two nominees on the board.
    In this case, "majority amongst two is two and not one," the
charity arm has publicly argued.
    Tata Sons' lawyer Salve disagrees. He says both of the
trusts' nominees voted differently, which prompted a casting
vote that helped reappoint the chairman as per governance
rules. 
     
    IS TATA TRUSTS CONSIDERING GOING TO COURT?
    The charity arm is working on many options to oust
Chandrasekaran and reverse the board's decision, sources say. 
    One option being considered is a challenge in Mumbai's
company tribunal arguing that the board should not have
proceeded as the majority — that is both of the trusts' nominees
— did not vote in favour of the chairman's reappointment. 
    The divide also extends to the issue of stock market listing
of Tata Sons — which the board agrees to, but the charity arm
does not.
    Tata Trusts could approach the High Court in Mumbai to
challenge the Indian regulatory requirement to list the company.
     

    (Editing by Aditya Kalra and Christian Schmollinger)
 ((mailto:Arpan.Chaturvedi@thomsonreuters.com;))

Recent news on TATA Steel

See all news