(The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The
opinions expressed are her own. Refiles to add missing word
"are" in the fourth paragraph.)
By Una Galani
HONG KONG, Oct 21 (Reuters Breakingviews) - The chair of
Tata Sons spent part of his most recent annual letter to
stakeholders reflecting on the importance of building long-term
institutions in India. Now N. Chandrasekaran, or Chandra as he
is widely known, is locked in a power struggle that will test
one of the country's most important institutions: the rights of
shareholders to control a private company. The outcome has
ramifications far beyond the 158-year-old conglomerate.
The crisis has its roots in a botched succession process at
the business empire with sprawling interests from IT services
and steel to cars, and annual revenue equivalent to 4% of Indian
GDP. For decades Ratan Tata served as the group's patriarch and
ultimate arbiter. After his death in 2024, his half-brother Noel
Tata was appointed to the role as chair of Tata Trusts, the
group of charities which owns 66% of Tata Sons, with Chandra
continuing to serve as the holding company's chair, a position
he has held since 2017.
Though Noel inherited Ratan's title, he did not retain the
same power. After Tata Sons last month reappointed Chandra as
chair, Noel publicly slammed the move as "illegal". The dispute
leaves a group which has over a million employees and 26 listed
group companies with a combined market capitalisation of $260
billion at a crossroads.
The feud hinges on a disagreement over Tata’s future.
Chandra and his allies favour complying with a Reserve Bank of
India determination that could require Tata Sons to list its
shares on the stock market. Noel and the Tata Trusts disagree,
arguing that there are ways to avoid a listing. They argue that
an initial public offering would weaken the group's ability to
provide patient capital to strategic industries, rescue group
companies in distress, and maintain the dividend stream that
funds the charities' philanthropic work.
Complicating matters further, actions taken by the Charity
Commissioner in Tata’s home state of Maharashtra following a
complaint from one of Chandra's supporters who is a trustee and
director of Tata Sons has delayed the holding company's annual
general meeting. That matters because the shareholders would
likely oust the chair if given the opportunity to vote.
Tata is vulnerable to a challenge from an emboldened board
of directors because it is not a conventional family business.
Its majority owner is a group of charitable trusts. So while
Noel chairs the trusts he does not own the shares. Even so, the
Tata Trusts have quorum rights and veto powers embedded into
Tata Sons’ Articles of Association. As Mumbai-based corporate
governance research firm IiAS points out, “the board has
violated the basic governance principle of shareholder
supremacy”.
The twin regulatory disputes have fuelled speculation in
Indian financial circles about outside influence. Some observers
see the unusual public silence from the government in New Delhi
as evidence of creeping official involvement in one of India's
most important business groups. Others point the finger at
minority investors in Tata Sons or rival factions in corporate
India. Whatever the explanation, though, the power struggle has
two possible outcomes.
The first is that Noel and the Tata Trusts emerge
victorious. This would come at a considerable cost for the
group. Chandra's exit would not only leave Tata Sons searching
for a new chair but also force a leadership reshuffle affecting
14 of its group companies.
The biggest risk may be at Tata Consultancy Services
TCS.NS . Chandra joined the information technology outsourcer
in 1987 and served as its CEO for eight years before moving up
to the holding company. As the $94 billion giant grapples with
slowing revenue from AI disruption, Chandra has become more
involved in setting its strategy. His hands-on approach is
understandable: the IT company generates most of its parent's
dividend income and is one of India’s important contributors of
foreign exchange through the services it provides to major
multinationals.
The leadership dispute comes as Tata is making some of the
largest capital commitments in its history. It has pledged to
pour investment into semiconductors, the energy transition and
defence manufacturing, as well as turnaround loss-making Air
India, all of which New Delhi considers strategically important.
According to one person close to Chandra, he agreed to stay
on as chair despite Noel’s opposition to avoid leaving the group
in limbo, with action by the Charity Commissioner also
preventing Tata Sons from forming a search committee for a
successor.
There's some logic there. Tata Sons and its partners have
committed over $27 billion of capital to five new industrial
ventures since 2017, according to another person familiar with
the group's finances, an amount similar to total dividends and
buyback proceeds received over the past decade.
The second possible outcome is that Chandra prevails over
the wishes of the company's controlling shareholder. That would
raise far-reaching questions about the rights of owners across
Indian business. If Tata Trusts cannot pick who leads Tata Sons,
other business owners will fret about their authority too. Some
might then think twice about handing day-to-day control to
professional managers, potentially recreating the same
succession planning problems now afflicting Tata. That’s
significant because the country is undergoing a vast
intergenerational transfer of wealth; some $1.5 trillion is
expected by Hurun Research Institute to change hands over the
next decade.
Chandra's position looks untenable without the support of
the company's majority shareholders. And while he would be
difficult to replace, he is replaceable. Other possible leaders
include Indian executives with global experience like Piyush
Gupta, the former CEO of DBS DBSM.SI , Singapore’s largest bank
and now non-executive India chair at sovereign investor Temasek.
Splitting the roles of chair and CEO at Tata Sons could also
allow for the elevation of a veteran insider like T. V.
Narendran, the CEO of Tata Steel TISC.NS .
Tata’s subsidiaries each have their own boards of directors
and can withstand a few months of uncertainty about who is in
charge. Beyond that, the leadership feud will start to impact
decisions about hiring and capital allocation.
The issue will be tested whenever shareholders eventually
get to vote on Chandra’s reappointment. Several group companies
own shares in Tata Sons, including Tata Steel, Tata Motors
Passenger Vehicles TAMO.NS , Tata Chemicals TTCH.NS , Tata
Power TTPW.NS and Indian Hotels IHTL.NS . Those units'
executives will be under pressure to take sides. The battle will
also test the unity of the Tata Trusts. Their boards include not
only Noel and his son, Neville, but also trustees who have
supported Chandra. In time, more Tata Trusts board members may
switch sides.
Chandra wrote in his annual letter that Tata is "building
for the India of 2047" so that, when the country looks back
after 100 years of independence from British rule, it finds
"that the foundations were laid well". It is vital for the
company and for India that Tata's owners should decide who lays
them.
Follow Una Galani on LinkedIn and X.
<^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^>
(Editing by Una Galani; Production by Aditya Srivastav and
Streisand Neto)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can
click on GALANI/ mailto:una.galani@thomsonreuters.com))