By Blake Brittain
Jan 13 (Reuters) - Video streaming site Vimeo VMEO.O
fended off an appeal on Monday from units of record labels
Universal Music Group UMG.AS and Sony Music 6758.T in a
long-running U.S. copyright dispute over alleged piracy on
Vimeo's platform.
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that Vimeo
was immune from the labels' claims based on federal protections
for internet service providers that remove infringing
user-posted content.
A Vimeo spokesperson said that the decision "ensures Vimeo
can continue empowering innovation and artistic expression while
respecting intellectual property rights." Spokespeople and an
attorney for the labels did not immediately respond to a request
for comment.
The labels -- imprints of former British music conglomerate
EMI -- sued in Manhattan federal court in 2009, alleging that
Vimeo was liable for hundreds of user-posted videos that
included their music without permission.
The case revolves around the Digital Millennium Copyright
Act, or DMCA. The law protects internet service providers from
liability when users upload infringing content but requires ISPs
to remove the material if they receive notice of the
infringement.
The 2nd Circuit ruled for Vimeo based on the DMCA in 2016.
The court said that Vimeo should prevail unless the labels could
prove that Vimeo employees "either knew the video was infringing
or knew facts making that conclusion obvious to an ordinary
person."
The trial court ruled for Vimeo again in 2021. The labels
appealed again later that year, arguing that Vimeo was not
covered by the DMCA because its employees had "red flag
knowledge" of the infringement.
"A jury could find that, based on the employees' knowledge
or expertise, the employees knew that it was extremely unlikely
that individual Vimeo users had somehow secured licenses from
major rightsholders to use well-known hit songs in amateur video
productions," the labels told the 2nd Circuit in a brief.
The 2nd Circuit rejected the labels' argument on Monday.
"Even if a person without specialized knowledge would have
intuited a likelihood that many of the posted videos were not
authorized, that would not make it obvious that a particular
video lacked authorization to use the music," U.S. Circuit Judge
Pierre Leval wrote for a three-judge panel.
The court also rejected the labels' argument that Vimeo
was not covered by the DMCA because it profited from the
infringement while having the "right and ability to control" it.
The case is Capitol Records LLC v. Vimeo Inc, 2nd U.S.
Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 21-2949.
For the labels: Catherine Stetson of Hogan Lovells
For Vimeo: Kathleen Sullivan of Quinn Emanuel Urquhart &
Sullivan
Read more:
Vimeo wins U.S. appeal in music copyright case
U.S. Supreme Court refuses to hear Vimeo music copyright
dispute
(Reporting by Blake Brittain in Washington)
((blake.brittain@tr.com; +1 (202) 938-5713))