11
Archived articleThis is an archived article from 2015 - please note that any content within the article may be out of date.

Entu - Collection of Tuesday Thoughts put Together.

Entu Plc
Decided to put my two threads yesterday (Tuesday), morning and late evening into one document.

 I note that the Entu share price is still 112p - 115p (Wednesday  approx.  4.p.m.) . 

Good volume also seen today as well.


Completed Tuesday Morning 9:20 a.m

Entu results released yesterday coupled with the recent share price decline, encouraged me to look at their results with a view to purchasing the shares.

Couple of concerns arose however which I may have indeed misread or overestimated their actual significance.

Concern 1 The purchase of Astley Facades Ltd in March 2015 seems to have had major negative adjustments in fair value. The purchase cost of 200K has had to be paid back in full as initial estimates for fair value seem to have fallen by more than a million caused by trade receivables decline and also trade payables needing to be increased.

"The provisional fair value adjustments at the date of acquisition are provisions against recoverability of retentions, potential bad debts and recognition of income £324,000 "

"Adoption of a prudent Group accounting policy for warranty claims £1,343,000" ·

"The initial purchase consideration of £200,000 has been reduced as a result of an adjustment in the level of net assets at the date of acquisition. The initial cash consideration was repaid to the Group post period end."


Revenue and profit contribution
The acquired Astley business contributed revenues of £419,451 and operating profit of £Nil to the Group in the month from the acquisition date to 30 April 2015." It seems that there is a possibility of a multi million loss in this business and further write offs before any meaningful profits can be made.

The purchase price of 200K for a business with such large revenue could have been a clue to the minefield of potential problems.

"The total revenues and operating loss for the 6 months ended 30 April 2015 were £4,552,000 and £490,100 respectively."

On a positive note to provide balance. "The integration of Astley is proceeding well, and the forward order book has risen from £2 million to £14 million, which is in excess of one year's trading activity. "


Concern 2 Sales and Marketing team as a significant group have left either for better job prospects or poor management retention of key staff.

"Energy Generation & Saving remains a key growth area, but has had a challenging six months: due firstly to lower solar photovoltaic product sales as the potential customer base becomes accustomed to lower tariff levels from the sale of surplus energy generation back into the grid, and secondly due to significant departures and disruption in the sales and marketing teams over the period."


Other concerns as noted before by others are the negative cash flow, increased vat issues, and lower first half profits compared to last year.

The Company says it is on target for y/e. Is this for revenue and profits before tax or after once offs?

 I would not dismiss this company altogether as an investment opportunity but will wait until the next trading statement is issued for better clarity.

Any comments or further insight welcome.

Regards


Dearg Doom



Completed Late Tuesday Night 11:30 p.m


Entu rose in price today with good turnover, suggesting the disappointing trading statement expected by some traders in the days before has now been built into the price.

I would have expected a fall in the share price which it did do so early in the morning session. Good turnover in shares dealt later in the day saw the share price rise. I will be watching Entu management closely over next few months for any financial surprises.

Going back in time Entu appears to have been built up by acquiring other companies with different brand names in different regional areas. Entu came to market at €1.00 offering a generous 8% yield because of its good cash flow business. Why the need for such a good yield for a company that would soon be on the acquisition trail?

The acquisition to acquire Astley earlier this year cost nothing since the 200K initially paid was refunded back to company after some negative findings I presume post purchase.

What did the owners of Astley get if not the 200K? What was the point of selling a 12 million turnover business for nothing unless the owners gain is someway? Maybe the Astley directors had given some personal guarantees to Banks. There was the negative net asset value of half a million shown on Astley 2014 accounts to be considered.   I don’t fully get it!  Astley had just begun its own turnaround plan that year.

The 2014 y/e for Astley showed a loss of 3.8 million after an exceptional loss due to the sale of Astley Scotland of 3.5 million approximately . In 2013 Astley lost 1.7 million on 23 million turnover. In 2012 y/e the business seems to have lost half a million on turnover of 10 million. 3.7 million cumulative losses to 31 March 2014 and still rising in 2015. Turnover for the first six months in 2015 have fallen to under 5 million meaning  sales are not being generated as quickly and trading losses of half a million as a result have been incurred so far. 

 I noticed also that three of five directors resigned in December 2013 from Astley.  Entu shareholders must be hoping  that management has wonderful turn around skills for new businesses acquired, and if so they can pick up on many other cheap similar businesses going forward.

I would not be surprised however by a profit warning later in the year. If not this company is a great buy if it can bring back Astley to break even and make Astley make a meaningful contribution to the bottom line next year.

Entu is a company I feel worth watching from the sidelines at this time. If the price moves without news, than any shareholder simply waiting for RNS news is going to be the last to know.

The gyrations in price interest me. Any comments welcome.

Regards



Dearg Doom

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

14 comments


Avatar for Dearg Doom

Entu (UK) (LON:ENTU)

Share Price 19p   (down 31% at 9:35 a.m.)                                                 

Bid/Offer 18p - 19p 


                                                                     5940f24b2f126entu_logo.jpg


 

Trading Update (today)

The operational issues outlined in the last full-year results statement are more complex and extend further into the supply chain than expected.  Further time is necessary to resolve these issues. 

Problems

Their supply chain difficulties meant that fit capacity in late March and April could not be scaled up enough to meet seasonal demand. 

Last year's full-year results statement and the previous year comparators will need to be restated to reflect changes in accounting policies.  

The intense competition in the non-core boilers and energy-switching businesses resulted in a loss of c.£0.2m in H1.   These business units have been closed.


Trading Outlook

 The fit capacity will be held at current levels throughout H2 and sales brought into line.  

To focus resources on the core Home Improvements business, the LED business and other commercial revenue streams will be scaled back in H2.   These actions, along with the closure of the boilers and energy-switching businesses and the loss of previously anticipated contribution, will reduce previously expected EBITDA further by £1.8-2.2m.

The Group now expects a full-yearLBITDA on continuing operations before exceptional items, in the range of £1.2-2.2m.  Loss before tax for the full-year is expected to be in the range £2.5-3.5m after accounting for restructuring and finance costs.

Final Comment

The task left for management will primarily to save their jobs by running the business properly. Unfortunately, any major change in shareholders' fortunes is a far off distant view.


Regards

Dearg Doom



 


 

2
Avatar for janebolacha

My no. 1 rule in reading results and updates RNS's is never to believe outlook statements but instead to do my own research on markets, competitors, trading and industry environments, etc, etc. There are just so many cases where information is withheld or presented in a misleading way that unless one can fairly well corroborate these statements independently, it's better to pass on to other opportunities. I must say that for ENTU the writing has been on the wall for months, particularly as regards solar.

3
Avatar for Boltonreddave

Too many red flags on this one now and the management have lost all credibility for me. The fundamentals may look good but combined with poor communications and what I see as blatant Insider dealing both Pre this Trading update and Pre 20/07 HY results mean that I have bailed out of my holding at 71p this morning for a whopping 39.71% loss.

The poor trading I can deal with, that is a risk we all take, the prior selling is what has done the reputational damage for me, so much so that it has prompted me to write my first ever complaint to the FCA over insider dealing which I did this morning.

It may come back and be bargain of the century but I will not be involved anymore.

3
Avatar for rhomboid1

http://www.investegate.co.uk/entu--uk--plc--entu-/rns/trading-update/201509010704026229X/

Solar division axed and divi cut, shambolic for such a recent listing but dodgy industries tend to contain companies that yield dog egg RNS announcements on occasion in my experience.

Shares off 30 per cent , hope most holders here had bailed

3
Avatar for Rusty2

I see the share price is down 9% today. Only reason I can see is a Non Ex. director has stepped down from the board.

0
Avatar for CMWilliamson

Entu (UK) (LON:ENTU) has certainly taken a beating recently that seems independent of China-related turmoil. I bought in July at 114 - timing rubbish - so the long-term had better be good.

I see that today's announcement re David Grundy says he's leaving with immediate effect and that a new chair of the audit committee is being sought. That could mean nothing. Or ...

2
Avatar for BlueFrew

More insider selling ahead of another profit warning? Certainly looks like it to me.

A reasonably upbeat outlook statement less than a month and a half ago, followed up by yet another significant profit warning.

Very glad I sold at a loss after the first profit warning. A complete bargepole stock now.

3
Avatar for Rusty2

Its possible although a director did leave on Friday. I think 40% fall maybe overdone?

0
Avatar for BlueFrew

Certainly if they report a profit of 8 million for the full year and pay over 5p for the divi, then a market cap in the low 40 million (at circa 65p) would make this a steal. You've got to imagine that they'll be doing everything in their power to meet those figures.

On the other hand that's Astley and now the solar division that have blown up with very little warning. Earnings visibility here seems to be virtually nil. As a short term trade, it possibly makes sense. I wouldn't go near it as a long term trade.

2
Avatar for Boltonreddave

Simon Thompson in the IC has done a bulish write up on ENTU today. I note his comments on the turnover of staff

'However, the unusually high staff churn rate in Entu’s solar panel business, which contributed to a £1.25m profit reversal to turn in a loss of £250,000 on revenues of £8.1m, has proved only short-term. It was caused by a direct rival offering a significantly improved package to staff in the south of England, albeit it was clearly unsustainable as that competitor has since gone out of business'

0
Avatar for Rusty2

The problem with ST and IC their articles tend to be rather one sided. See his Stanley Gibbons and Globo reports.

I have sold my Entu shares, too many concerns for me.

2
Avatar for biddyishere

Would the drop in price have anything to do with Gov's u-turn on zero carbon homes? Just speculating.

0
Avatar for carmensfella

Just posting to offer a couple of places to meet the directors at 2pm tomorrow afternoon for a results presentation near Bank in London. The company is new to me and I only bought when the share price collapsed on Monday. I am sure there will be lots of questions so it should be an interesting meeting....just email me at mellomeeting.co.uk or by replying to this post

David

4
Avatar for Boltonreddave

David,

Did you go and meet management last week? If so it would be great if you could share your views of the conversation.

Thanks
Dave

3
Get the free newsletter