28

Webinar Discussion: Inside the Portfolios That Beat the Market - Four Strategies You Can Use

In spite of markets being jittery, GTA6 being released and Anthropic stealing the headlines, it was great to see 750 subscribers join us live last night for the webinar. Your questions kept on coming - a few hundred of you were still with me after an hour and fifty minutes. As promised, I'm opening this as a discussion thread this morning so we can carry on the conversation.

Watch the replay and download the slides: Academy webinar link · Slides link

I'd also like to ask for your help.

The NAPS Portfolio has been being published as editorial, webinars and features on the site since 2015, and I know many of you do value it. We are keen to build on this and make model strategies a proper area of the site, to illustrate more ways to put the StockRanks and rules-based investing to work. Last night was a road test of three more strategy angles, and your feedback will help shape what we build. So please do get involved in the discussion.

Which investing trap has cost you the most?

Early in the presentation, I asked which of three traps had cost you the most money. Chasing story stocks late was most cited, with 35% of 380 votes, but I’m sure we’ve all fallen into each of these traps.

3fa57746-0f09-413d-bc39-4635124623d4.png

I went on to describe that these traps map to three archetypes of investors I’ve written about: the Gambler, the Follower, the Researcher and the Craftsman. These aren’t so much stages that we work through, more states which have benefits and traps we need to be mindful of.

The Gambler buys into a bandwagon and a narrative - which I know I’m falling into right now having subscribed for Anthropic shares. The Follower hands the decision to someone else - a guru, a newsletter, broker research recommendations - who can often have very mixed records. The Researcher trap is more subtle - the more information we gather on a share, the more confident we get, which can lead to overattachment but not necessarily more accuracy.

Simple rules are the way out

Ben Graham, who taught Warren Buffett, put it best: "People don't need extraordinary insight or intelligence. What they need most is the character to adopt simple rules and stick to them."

So the frame I shared in the webinar is to simplify investing by taking an evidence based approach - this is the foundation that the NAPS Portfolio, and the three other strategies I shared are based on.

  1. Drivers: what do I buy? Focus on shares with proven characteristics - good quality, undervalued, trending stocks outperform - build a portfolio around the characteristics, not the narrative,
  2. Diversity: how many? Buy enough shares to catch the big winners. Of the 240 NAPS holdings since 2015, only 1 in 14 doubled or more. Take those out, and the average holding made 6.8% instead of 17.5%.
  3. Discipline: when to sell? I explained that the route to outperformance is keeping your exposures to the return drivers high.

Discipline is the principle I'd most like you to take away, because a high average StockRank doesn't last. The NAPS portfolio starts each January with an average StockRank of about 94. By the next January it has typically faded to 79, as cheap shares get re-rated and profit warnings and downgrades start to hit some stocks. So each year the portfolio is replenished with new high-StockRank shares - it’s this active habit that has driven the outperformance.

cdde561f-e4f2-470d-8d52-d1710521cc85.png

Four strategies you can use

I shared three more strategies, each with a NAPS-esque acronym.

  • DIGS: dividend growth. 25 UK shares with a forecast yield of 3% or more, a dividend higher than five years ago and a quality rank of 50 or more, sorted by StockRank rather than yield and held for a year. Simulated total returns: 10.7% a year since January 2017, against 8.0% for the FTSE All-Share, with a yield of about 4.5% today.
  • RIPS: active momentum. 20 shares with the strongest momentum ranks and a quality rank of 50 or more, five from each of the UK, Europe, the US and Australia/NZ, rebalanced twice a year. Simulated: 15.2% a year since March 2016, against 12.0% for an index blend, with a worst fall of 45%.
  • QILS: international quality. 16 smaller companies (£50m to £500m) with quality and growth ranks of 80 or more and earnings up at least 15% a year for three years, four from each of the same markets, rebalanced twice a year. Simulated: 23.4% a year since March 2016, though the 2016-20 growth boom flatters that. Since 2021 it has made 15.6% a year. Worst fall 26%.

94e65037-9866-4583-803f-0e0b6af6b982.png

None of them are a list to copy. I always say the rules are a jazz sheet you can riff on, not a score you should recite. These are a starting point for your research and to develop a process that might fit. If you'd like to view the stocks that qualify, here are the screens. There’s a copy button top right of each screening page if you wish to make your own version.

Questions for you

We put out a poll quite late in the Q&A which asked which of the four you'd be most interested in. Momentum came out ahead with 24% (people seem to be action hungry), but the biggest interest, 29%, was across the whole set.

3a0a9393-1e91-4e29-b8f9-bb95e2dc5dd1.png

A few questions for you:

  • What's missing? Last night people asked about a StockRank Jumps strategy - which in a perfect world I’d probably incorporate into “Active Momentum” in some way, but also questions around blends of factor strategies, and variants for larger portfolios.
  • How would you like to see more model strategies on the site: as portfolios you can track on the site, as rules you run as a screen and adapt, or as backtesting suites you can adapt to your own purposes?

The 2027 NAPS will be published on the 1st January, with a full NAPS webinar at some point that month - I’ll go deeper into the process then. Until then, please do add comments below.

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

9 comments


Avatar for Tom Holley

Eds comments regarding his Fathers poor stock picking resonates with me. I have said many times i can make anyone a fortune in the markets. If i say Buy you Sell and if i Sell you Buy. Absolute guaranteed success. After a couple of years of fighting against the Stockopedia Ranks, i am a convert.

0
Avatar for Tom Holley

Eds comments regarding his Fathers poor stock picking resonates with me. I have said many times i can make anyone a fortune in the markets. If i say Buy you Sell and if i Sell you Buy. Absolute guaranteed success. After a couple of years of fighting against the Stockopedia Ranks, i am a convert.

1
Avatar for Silver Moon

Three new plans, DIGS, RIPS, and QILS were introduced to us in last night's Webinar, thanks Ed, they expand our options immensely. I don't want to go international with all the extra on subscription and bureaucracy at 82 years of age DIGS is the plan that appeals most. I'll be making a comparison between this and NAPS in January. My own version of NAPS has been very sucessful until of late, a sign of the sickness in the FTSE. Seplat Enregy is the best performer, up 297%.


224de71b-7ac6-4dac-bd5d-c59a52f9b461.png

Silver

0
Avatar for Mark Mitchell

Great presentation about using Stock Ranks in different permutations. But most of all; thank you for changing the webinar provider.

2
Avatar for Edward Croft

Thanks Mark - yes we were all delighted to be on the new platform - apologies for all the trouble in previous webinars !

2
Avatar for Richard Leishman

Thanks so much to Ed and the team for another very informative and thought-provoking webinar - I have really enjoyed them this year and many thanks for putting them together for our benefit.

I am currently refining and simplifying my own investment process, so yesterday's webinar was particularly timely for me personally, albeit it has thrown up some more thoughts and questions for me to consider! Which is a good thing.

I would be especially interested in the ability to do backtesting of simulated investment processes / approaches.

Thanks again and keep up the great work.

Richard

4
Avatar for EricD88

I thought about a screen filter for date. Say you were screening for something simple likes ranks or PE. You could insert a historical date for your screen and it would bring up what would have come up on that day. Then you can simply scroll through the names and see how they have done since that date in time on that screen. I would like that.

1
Avatar for Cayman69

I fear that may be too costly on CPU and data architecture

0
Avatar for The Scribe

I thought it was a very insightful and Illuminating presentation Ed, with lots of interesting information to share. As a rule, I don't rigidly follow rules when investing, but as a subscriber I have watched many of your webinars, and rules-based investing is something that you talk about a lot and it's something that I need to look at introducing. Thank you again for last nights prsentation.

7
Get the free newsletter