Ireland tries penny-pinching, this time with cash
BREAKINGVIEWS-Ireland tries penny-pinching, this time with cash The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are her own.
By Aimee Donnellan
DUBLIN, Nov 17 (Reuters Breakingviews) - In a country where it rains nearly 260 days a year, fixing the roof while the sun shines is tough. Taoiseach Micheál Martin is trying nonetheless: despite Ireland forecasting a €6.7 billion budget surplus this year - a result of a discounted corporate tax rate luring the likes of Microsoft MSFT.O, Apple AAPL.O, Meta Platforms META.O and Salesforce CRM.N to base their European operations there - he is reluctant to splash the cash. Martin wants to avoid the mistakes of past downturns, but needs to be careful not to kill the golden goose either.
Historically, nations with large external wealth injections often suffer a "resource curse," whereby rising domestic costs crowd out productive industries. Consider the 16th-century Spanish Empire after an influx of American silver, or oil-dependent Venezuela and Nigeria. The key question is whether Ireland belongs in this category, given that foreign multinationals use it to book profits from intellectual property transfers, aircraft leasing and manufacturing.
Indeed, traditional metrics only tangentially reflect Ireland's actual domestic output: in the first quarter of last year, GDP expanded 16.6% year-on-year, as pharmaceutical giants front-ran Washington's tariffs. Yet the gauge used by Irish authorities to strip away these distortions, Modified Domestic Demand, rose just 3.2%.
Even under this more cautious approach, though, Ireland still leaves peers in the dust, meaning voters are largely right to view the country's wealth as real. But Martin fears heavy reliance on corporate tax bungs, arguing receipts are volatile and could dry up. He has a point: the top three multinationals paid nearly half of Ireland's corporate tax in 2024. Now, tech is wobbling after an AI selloff, and US efforts to slash drug prices could dent profits for Irish-based giants like Eli Lilly LLY.N, Pfizer PFE.N, and Johnson & Johnson JNJ.N.
This is why Martin resists permanently raising the national cost base, and initially offered public-sector unions a below-inflation pay rise which sparked recent strikes by nurses, doctors, academics and teachers. The government has since sweetened the payment terms.
Dublin also plans to squirrel away some of the windfall cash in the Future Ireland Fund and the Climate and Nature Fund, scheduled to manage €55 billion by 2030. This mirrors how Norway and the Gulf states use gigantic sovereign wealth funds to mitigate resource curses, or how Switzerland built huge central bank reserves to counter massive inflows into its wealth-management industry.
Yet these other pots are in the trillion-dollar range, and serve the crucial function of curbing exchange-rate appreciation in times of bonanza - something euro-member Ireland can't do. If foreign headquarters decide to leave Dublin, rainy-day reserves will hardly cushion the blow. So Martin may be better off by trying harder to preserve the current economic model through investments in infrastructure, as well as in crisis-ridden housing, health and electricity sectors, where Ireland ranks as the most expensive country in the European Union.
To be sure, his caution is explained by memories of the post-2008 crash, in which overbuilding eventually led to harsh austerity measures, including public-sector pay cuts of as much as 13%. But prudence will ultimately be hard to sell to people living under a leaky roof.
Follow Aimee Donnellan on LinkedIn.
CONTEXT NEWS
Ireland is expected to deliver surpluses of €6.7 billion in 2026 and €9.5 billion in 2027, according to government forecasts. On November 11, public-sector unions reached an initial agreement with the government following six weeks of strikes, which would increase workers' wages by 11.27% over 33 months. This would be significantly above inflation if consumer-price indexes followed economists' median forecasts, though would imply a loss in real purchasing power if inflation remains at current levels.
(Editing by Jon Sindreu; Production by Streisand Neto)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can click on DONNELLAN/Aimee.Donnellan@thomsonreuters.com))
Recent news on Apple
See all newsSignal restricts screenshots to block AI agents from reading messages (updated)
Nvidia's share slide knocks it below Alphabet in valuation
Signal restricts screenshots to block AI agents from reading messages
Media: Apple’s executive in charge of the iPhone’s camera app has left - Bloomberg News
UK tribunal confirms government order demanding access to Apple data (updated)