By Ross Kerber
May 8 (Reuters) - A new study provides some interesting
data around a talking point from U.S. Republican politicians:
why should western banks take steps to limit fossil fuel
financing when China is the biggest source of greenhouse gas
emissions?
You can read about the study on banks' coal lending below. I've
also included links to stories about Berkshire Hathaway's
BRKa.N famed annual meeting, and about new lines of business
for Italy's mafia.
I welcome connections on LinkedIn. If you have a news tip,
potential content, or general thoughts you can also email me at
ross.kerber@thomsonreuters.com
This week's most-read
Buffett says Berkshire in good hands, lauds Apple despite
lowering stake
Italy's mafia turns to white-collar crime as murder,
extortion fall out of favor
Clean energy ETFs start to outperform key oil & gas ETF
Chinese banks finance a lot of coal
Commercial banks provided $470 billion worth of lending and
underwriting activity to the global coal industry over the past
three years, a new report found, with $324 billion of that
coming from Chinese financial institutions.
The report from German activist research organization Urgewald
focuses on banks' financing of coal-related companies, some $136
billion last year. That was 20% less than in 2016, the year the
Paris climate agreement entered into force, reflecting factors
like slowing coal industry growth and stricter lending policies
especially by European banks.
But the decline was hardly near the level of reduction
needed to meet goals like net-zero carbon emissions by 2050. Of
638 banks reviewed only about 140 significantly cut their
lending and underwriting for coal, the report found, and 75
banks increased their support.
The data "shows that banks are still injecting hundreds of
billions of dollars into the industry, which is our climate’s
worst enemy," said Katrin Ganswindt, Urgewald's head of
financial research, in a briefing on the research.
Urgewald's review, issued on May 2, breaks down activity by
region. Some of its findings align with arguments from U.S.
conservative analysts and politicians who say efforts to limit
western banks' fossil fuel activities focus on the wrong
targets.
Criticizing the Paris agreement in a December opinion piece,
for instance, Wyoming Republican Senator John Barrasso wrote
that "this one-sided agreement helped China's economy and hurt
ours" such as by leaving China able to keep building new coal
plants.
Urgewald's research showed the world's largest coal financier
over the past three years was China International Trust
Investment Corp, or CITIC. 0267.HK Its coal financing in 2023
alone was $9.6 billion, up 63% from 2016.
In contrast the largest U.S. coal financier last year was Bank
of America, BAC.N with $2.8 billion, 30% more than in 2016.
Richard Morrison, senior fellow at the free-market Washington
think tank Competitive Enterprise Institute, said the Chinese
banks' state connections set them apart from big Wall Street
banks. But the findings suggest activists need to exert more
pressure outside the U.S. when it comes to emissions financing,
he said.
"At a certain point climate activist organizations are going to
have to stop preaching to the choir in the Western-aligned world
and turn their efforts to the counties that, for them, represent
the worst offenders," Morrison said.
A CITIC representative did not respond to questions.
Asked about the report, a Bank of America representative
referred to its commitment to phase out financing by 2025 to
companies that derive 25% or more of their revenue from thermal
coal mining, a narrower set of companies than Urgewald counted.
Exposure to thermal coal mining has fallen 94% since 2019 to
$9.1 million as of Dec. 31, "less than 0.0008% of our total
committed commercial credit exposure across all industries,"
according to a Bank of America report.
Urgewald says all banks should cut coal financing. Ganswindt
said via e-mail that financing from banks including CITIC has
dropped in recent years, but most U.S banks, including Bank of
America have backed more coal.
"Financing from the U.S. did increase, even though as an
historic emitter the U.S. should do more to avoid new emissions
than China," Ganswindt said.
Company News
Exxon's XOM.N arbitration case that could block Chevron's
CVX.N purchase of Hess HES.N will extend into 2025, Exxon
CEO Darren Woods said in an interview on Monday, ahead of a
coming vote by Hess shareholders on the deal.
Britain's Local Authority Pension Fund Forum, the biggest
collective owners of UK shares, warned the London Stock Exchange
LSEG.L against weakening listing rules and governance
standards to help attract fresh business.
Hedge fund Shah Capital urged Novavax NVAX.O shareholders to
vote against three directors and opposed proposals related to
executive compensation, weeks after pushing for a board shakeup
at the COVID-19 vaccine maker.
New York's DiNapoli opposing most Exxon directors
A spokesman for New York State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, who
oversees the state's Common Retirement Fund, said it will vote
against most directors at Exxon XOM.N over climate concerns,
following the decision to divest some Exxon holdings in
February.
In addition, a suit the company filed against shareholder
activists "is certainly another factor informing our decision,"
the spokesman told me. The fund had about 5 million Exxon shares
as of March 31.
Via e-mail, an Exxon representative said "We’re disappointed
the N.Y. Common Retirement Fund didn’t bring its concerns
directly to us. We welcome dialogue with all of our
shareholders, even those who have restricted their investments
in ExxonMobil."
On my radar
Item #6 at Amazon's AMZN.N annual meeting on May 22 calls
for a review of whether its products contribute to human rights
violations, citing contracts including one with the Israeli
government's Project Nimbus. Debates over corporate exposure to
the war in Gaza so far have played out at U.S. colleges, but the
shareholder resolution will bring the discussion to a new forum.
A planned New York State tax credit would provide $90 million
for local news outlets, which advocates say would help rebuild
an industry decimated by chain ownership and advertising shifts.
In last week's newsletter I wrote about a study finding that
while the term "ESG" has fallen out of favor, many companies
continue to implement ESG-like practices. My followup,
back-of-the-envelope LinkedIn poll found something similar: just
7% of responses reported their company has dropped its ESG
efforts, while 47% said their company uses the term less but has
maintained the effort. Also, 47% clicked on "We still love ESG!"
OK it was just 15 votes but now I feel validated. If you
disagree, you can comment on the poll here.
<^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Coal financing from banks declines slowly https://reut.rs/3UOWvyY
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^>
(Reporting by Ross Kerber in Boston; Editing by David Gregorio)
((ross.kerber@thomsonreuters.com; (617) 412 0093;))