Picture of Elopak ASA logo

ELO — Elopak ASA News Story

0.000.00%
no flag iconLast trade - 00:00
Basic MaterialsAdventurousMid CapSuper Stock

Analysis: Remaining Western firms face tricky Russian exits

By Alexander Marrow
       June 1 (Reuters) - After months of negotiations,
Finland's Nokian Tyres  TYRES.HE  was on the cusp late last year
of finalising a 400-million-euro  ($440.32 million) sale of its
Russian business. Then Moscow changed the rules again.
    The government in December demanded that companies leaving
Russia sell their operations for at least half price and claimed
10% of the sale for the federal budget, termed an "exit tax" by
the U.S. Treasury. 
    Nokian Tyres dropped the agreed sale price to Russian oil
major Tatneft  TATN.MM  to 286 million euros, finally securing
the approval of the government commission that monitors foreign
investment in March, nine months after initiating its
"controlled exit". 
    Nokian Tyres' protracted departure illustrates the growing
headwinds faced by Western companies that have yet to fully
depart the country. Fifteen months after Moscow's invasion of
Ukraine prompted a mass exodus, firms still there face growing
uncertainty.
    "The war changed the operating environment in a rapid and
unpredictable way," Nokian Tyres' Chief Transformation Officer
Johanna Horsma told Reuters. "The new changes in the regulations
in Russia in September and December had a major impact."  
    From telecoms companies to fashion retailers, thousands of
firms halted operations in Russia last year as Western
governments imposed sanctions. 
    Some managed to negotiate swift exits, often selling at huge
discounts or handing the keys to local management. 
    The pace of exits has now slowed substantially but the rules
are even harder to navigate for those remaining.
    Nationalising assets by presidential decree - a constant
threat - was exploited in April with the seizure of assets owned
by Finland's Fortum  FORTUM.HE  and Germany's Uniper  UN01.DE .
        
    THE UNKNOWN
    Gaining government commission approval is very demanding,
time-consuming and difficult, said Dr Peter Wand, a partner at
Baker McKenzie in Frankfurt, who worked on Nokian Tyres' exit.
    The appraisal process, which requires a Russian evaluation
of the business, was particularly lengthy, he said, with the
ever-tightening sanctions regime demanding constant compliance
checks.
    "From a Western perspective, you would expect more flesh to
the bone describing the process and deadlines," said Wand.
Additional valuation requirements published in mid-December came
in the middle of Nokian Tyres' transaction, he added.     
    Thomas Kormendi, CEO of Norwegian packaging firm Elopak
 ELO.OL , which finalised the sale of its Russian business to
local management in March for an undisclosed fee, said "the
unknown" was the overriding problem. 
    "You have much, much less visibility on the external factors
than you would normally have on any other business deal," said
Kormendi, who had the impression that the commission was
overwhelmed with the number of applications to process. 
    "We were grouped with other companies and were given
instructions...probably because they simply did not have the
resources needed to address everyone one by one," he said. 
    Deputy Finance Minister Alexei Moiseev last month said the
one-off nature of each decision explains why the process is not
quick, saying the commission meets three to four times a week
and considers 20 issues each time. 
    "Foreigners should not be let off at full price...it should
be hard for them," Moiseev said, with exceptions made when it
suits Russia. "That is, when it is better for us that foreigners
leave in a civilised way, rather than quitting and just locking
up the business they owned." 
    Russian buyers are seeking to take advantage of the huge
discounts and using well-placed contacts to push deals through,
according to one Western investor still owning Russian assets.  
    The buyer needs to be well selected to avoid scammers, said
Nokian Tyres' Horsma. Many Russian buyers were opportunists
simultaneously involved in other large-scale exits or
negotiations, she said. 
    Companies' relations with the government are crucial, said
Tatiana Stanovaya, founder of the R.Politik analysis firm.
    "It depends a lot on what personal relationship a foreign
company has with the government and whether it has influential
partners in the Russian leadership," she said. 
    Kormendi, who described nationalisation as any company's
"worst nightmare", said Elopak had agreed to a six-year buyback
clause, mirroring deals made by many exiting firms.
    Baker McKenzie's Wand warned that time was running out for
those remaining.
    "If you cannot sell in time there comes a point where you
may not have the cash to continue operations," he said. "The
clock ticks fast for those still in Russia."
        
    ($1 = 0.9084 euros)

 (Reporting by Alexander Marrow; additional reporting by Darya
Korsunskaya; Editing by Matt Scuffham, Kirsten Donovan)
 ((alexander.marrow@thomsonreuters.com;))

Recent news on Elopak ASA

See all news