(The authors are Reuters Breakingviews columnists. The opinions
expressed are their own. Refiles to remove hyperlink in second
paragraph. Updates to add details in graphic.)
By Robyn Mak and Katrina Hamlin
HONG KONG, Feb 7 (Reuters Breakingviews) - Speed may not
be of the essence when it comes to carmaking M&A. Taiwan's Hon
Hai Precision 2317.TW , also known as Foxconn, has an
opportunity to swoop in on Nissan Motor 7201.T now that the
Japanese manufacturer's merger talks with rival Honda Motor
7267.T have stalled. But a closer look suggests troubled
Nissan is not a must-have for boss Young Liu.
True, the $75 billion company's years-long foray into
electric vehicles has underwhelmed so far. It raced into joint
ventures at home and abroad and even bought a factory in the
U.S. from startup Lordstown Motor in 2022. It also inked an
assembly agreement with another EV darling, Fisker, with plans
to open another factory stateside. Liu's ambition was to
replicate Foxconn's success in making iPhones for Apple
AAPL.O , hoping ultimately to make Teslas for Tesla TSLA.O ,
and grab a 5% share in global EV production by 2025.
Fierce competition from Chinese brands, slowing demand and a
raft of bankruptcies among EV startups - including both
Lordstown and Fisker - have derailed most of those plans. Last
year, Foxconn's EV strategy chief, Jun Seki, admitted that it
will probably take another five years for its U.S. factory to
reach full production capacity of 350,000 vehicles a year,
though for which brands remains unclear.
Against this backdrop, Nissan, Seki's former employer, looks
a tempting target. Foxconn founder Terry Gou has long wanted his
firm to compete with consumer brands. Bagging a household name
like Nissan would be a big step up. Moreover, Nissan's annual
production capacity of 4 million vehicles across the U.S., China
and Europe would turbo-charge the Taiwanese group's output.
Yet Nissan is forecast to log a 70%-plus year-on-year fall
in operating profit in the fiscal year to the end of March 2025,
per analyst estimates gathered on LSEG. Moreover, its forecast
operating profit margin is less than 2%, below Foxconn's
already-uninspiring 3% expected for this year. Crucially, Nissan
is a battery laggard: only 16% of its 2024 sales were electric
or hybrid vehicles.
There are other hazards. U.S. President Donald Trump has
threatened tariffs against Canada and Mexico, a key
manufacturing hub for Nissan's U.S. business. And Foxconn's own
M&A track record does not inspire confidence either: in 2016, it
splashed out $3.5 billion for control of Japan's Sharp 6753.T .
The Tokyo-traded stock has since delivered total returns of
negative 16% compared with a near-190% gain for the Nikkei 225
Index .N225 over the same period. Liu has reason to drive
carefully this time around.
Follow @mak_robyn and @KatrinaHamlin on X
CONTEXT NEWS
Nissan Motor is open to working with new partners including
Taiwan's Foxconn after CEO Makoto Uchida met with his Honda
counterpart to say he wanted to end discussions of a merger,
Reuters reported on February 6, citing people familiar with the
matter.
Foxconn approached Nissan about a bid but was rejected by
the carmaker, Reuters reported in December.
Later that month, Honda and Nissan signed a memorandum of
understanding to discuss integrating under a holding company.
Nissan will formalise the decision to withdraw from the MOU at a
board meeting to be held before the company's third-quarter
earnings announcement due on February 13, according to Reuters.
<^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Graphic: Nissan's forecast operating margin is worse than
Foxconn's https://reut.rs/414DOdJ
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^>
(Editing by Antony Currie and Ujjaini Dutta)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can
click on MAK/ HAMLIN/
robyn.mak@thomsonreuters.com katrina.hamlin@thomsonreuters.com))