By Ross Kerber
May 1 (Reuters) - A nagging question as companies move
away from using the term "ESG" is whether they are actually
scaling back on their efforts or just changing the label. It's
more like the latter, according to a recent report from Farient
that I wrote up below.
You'll also find some strong words from Capital Group, the
parent of American Funds, filed in an ongoing review about the
role that index funds have come to play in the U.S. utility
industry.
I welcome connections on LinkedIn. If you have a news tip,
potential content, or general thoughts you can also email me at
ross.kerber@thomsonreuters.com
This week's most-read
Shell earns $1 billion a year from US crude trading, court
filing shows
Citigroup sees loan book hit in climate action ramp-up,
document shows
HSBC Chief Quinn, architect of sweeping overhaul, announces
surprise exit
As solar capacity grows, some of America's most productive
farmland is at risk
Dropping a term but not the mission
Many companies have dialed back use of the term "ESG," a
reference to environmental, social and governance
considerations, in the face of criticism from U.S. conservative
politicians.
But in the weeds of their financial statements many corporations
continue to refine their ESG practices at least for executive
pay, according to a recent study by executive compensation and
corporate governance consulting firm Farient Advisors.
"In short, our analysis reveals there is no evidence that
companies and their boards are turning back—ESG has established
itself as a strategic value driver for companies in all
industries, of all sizes, and around the globe," writes Farient
CEO Robin Ferracone.
The report cites changes like companies substituting the word
"sustainability" in lieu of "ESG," or making environmental goals
more targeted like reducing energy costs.
Among U.S. large-cap companies, 52% tie executive pay to
environmental incentive measures as of their proxies filed last
year, up from 34% in 2022 and 15% in 2021, according to Brian
Bueno, Farient ESG Practice Lead.
In an interview, Bueno said the trend seemed surprising the
given the ferocity of criticism on many ESG matters. He
cautioned that trends could still change with more recent
proxies now being filed.
But so far, he said, "The anti-ESG push hasn't been as strong,
consistent or long-term as the push for companies to consider
climate in their strategies," a common concern from investors.
"It's too hard to put the toothpaste back in the tube," he said.
The report cites the case of materials science company Dow,
DOW.N which Farient said is among the less than 12% of U.S.
companies with ESG measures in a long-term incentive plan. In
last year's proxy the company disclosed more specificity to the
measures and labeled them "carbon emissions reduction" measures
rather than ESG.
At the same time the report noted a sharp decline in the number
of mentions of "ESG" in Dow's proxy statement. I counted just
seven mentions in Dow's latest proxy, ahead of its April 11
shareholder meeting, down from 14 last year and 130 in the 2022
statement.
I shared the report with Dow, where a representative said
its metrics and timelines "are aligned to achieving the
Company’s carbon emissions reduction target goals by positively
influencing leadership behaviors, creating organizational
alignment and accelerating our efforts aligned to our
sustainability commitments."
Farient's review matched the findings of a similar study from
compensation consulting firm Semler Brossy of last year's
proxies. It found 72% of S&P 500 companies used ESG factors in
incentive plans according to their disclosures from April 2022
through March of 2023, up from 70% and 57% in the prior two
12-month periods respectively.
"ESG metric prevalence in incentives continues to increase among
S&P 500 companies but at a slower rate than prior years, as
market focus shifts to refining existing ESG metric types and
structures rather than increasing adoption," Semler Brossy's
report states.
Company News
State Street STT.N settled its lawsuit against the creator of
the "Fearless Girl" statue that promoted gender diversity on
Wall Street, which had sought to stop her from selling replicas.
Terms of the settlement were not disclosed.
Apple's AAPL.O operating system for iPads has been designated
as a gatekeeper by EU antitrust regulators because of its
importance to business users.
Proxy advisor Glass Lewis on April 24 named Bob Mann as its new
chief executive. Mann had led the Sustainalytics business of
Morningstar MORN.O after its purchase of the business in 2020.
Capital Group tells FERC: hands off!
Readers of this newsletter will know about the ongoing review of
investment company holdings by the U.S. Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission, the hardest scrub of fund firms' size by
a federal regulator to date.
Last week brought a new round of comments including one dated
April 25 from American Funds parent Capital Group. The asset
manager voiced concerns about the idea that fund firms could be
limited to owning no more than 10% or 5% of public utilities'
outstanding shares.
Those limits would force the firm to divest from public
utilities at least $12 billion or $39 billion, respectively,
Capital Group said in a filing. Other firms would also be forced
to divest, Capital Group said, adding that "This would deprive
public utilities of a stable source of capital from investors
like Capital Group, which do not invest for control and which
seek to invest for the long-term."
Capital Group also was not impressed with suggestions from
Vanguard Group to limit passive funds' stewardship powers in
return for being able to own big utility stakes. Capital Group
noted it files 13G forms, which means it does not invest to
change or influence the control of portfolio companies, and that
its casting of proxy votes "is fundamental to fulfilling our
obligations to investors."
Chart of the Week
On my radar
Starbucks SBUX.O and the Workers United union held talks in
Atlanta, both sides said, and they plan to talk again in late
May. In a joint statement the parties mentioned talks around "a
foundational framework" to guide union organizing and
bargaining.
In a report on Monday Citi C.N shared that it has financed
$441 billion toward its goal of putting up $1 trillion for
sustainable finance activities by 2030, up from $349 billion
last year. Transactions include things like green buildings,
water conservation and affordable housing, Citi said.
A new survey by ESG software maker Workiva found 81% of
companies not subject to the European Union's sustainability
reporting requirements still intend to comply, likely because of
market expectations.
<^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Say-on-Pay support steady https://reut.rs/44l1QkQ
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^>
(Reporting by Ross Kerber in Boston; Editing by David Gregorio)
((ross.kerber@thomsonreuters.com; (617) 412 0093;))