Stockopedia academy

How to use the StockRank Styles

Using the various combinations of the three factors which drive stock market returns (quality, value and momentum) leaves us with eight different investment archetypes which we call the StockRank Styles.

Falling Stars: How to handle glamour shares that fall from grace

Ben Hobson
Ed Croft image
Ed Croft
CEO of Stockopedia

Through 2020, online fashion retailer Boohoo was a stock market darling. The business was growing fast, its Quality Rank sat between 93 and 97, and the shares peaked at 415p. Relentless growth had pushed the price to a nosebleed valuation, and investors kept paying it on the assumption that the growth would keep coming. When it started to slow, the shares fell out of fashion as fast as the clothes.

Article Series / StockRank Styles / Falling Stars / Case Study Boohoo
Boohoo share price from 2020 to 2024 with its month-end StockRank Style underneath: a High Flyer through 2020, a Falling Star at 337p from March 2021 for seven straight month-ends, then 27p by August 2024

At the March 2021 month-end, with the shares at 337p, Boohoo was reclassified from High Flyer to Falling Star. The business still looked excellent on paper. But the momentum had gone, and without it the valuation had nothing holding it up. It stayed a Falling Star for seven straight month-ends. The shares were 256p by September 2021 and 27p by August 2024.

Here is the striking part. Only a fifth of the fall from the 415p peak came before the reclassification. Four fifths of it came after. The warning arrived early enough to matter.

If that feels familiar, you're in good company. When we asked investors at our webinar Four kinds of share lose money. Do you own one? which sentence sounded most like a share they had lost money on, the most popular answer, chosen by 39%, was the Falling Star's: "I'm not selling, it's an amazing business."

What is a Falling Star?

A Falling Star is good, but expensive and losing momentum. In StockRank terms:

A share is a Falling Star when its Quality Rank is above 50, the top half of the market, and its Value and Momentum ranks are both below. It has one strong factor out of three, which makes it one of the four losing StockRank Styles.

Article Series / StockRank Styles / Falling Stars / Style Explainer Falling Star
The Falling Star explainer, a losing Style: Quality strong (is it good?), Value weak (is it cheap?), Momentum weak (is it improving?) - still a good business, but expensive and the price has turned

In other words, a Falling Star is a High Flyer after the price has turned. Same quality, same valuation, one factor fewer.

What Falling Stars paid

That one missing factor is worth a great deal. Held as a basket, UK Falling Stars returned -0.1% a year from April 2013 to September 2026, against +5.7% for the average UK share. Before dividends, £100 in Falling Stars became £84, while £100 in the average share became £157.

Line them up against the other Styles with a weak Value Rank and the pattern is clear:

Style

Quality

Value

Momentum

Return a year

High Flyer

strong

weak

strong

+8.8%

Momentum Trap

weak

weak

strong

+1.2%

Falling Star

strong

weak

weak

-0.1%

Sucker Stock

weak

weak

weak

-9.0%

UK shares above £10m, held equal-weight and rebalanced once a year, April 2013 to September 2026, price return plus the average ordinary dividend yield measured 2016 to 2026, no dealing costs. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

The quality in a Falling Star is real, and it does help: Falling Stars did far better than Sucker Stocks. But on an expensive share, quality alone did not pay. Losing momentum cost about nine percentage points a year against a High Flyer.

Why quality at any price disappoints

This is an old lesson. In the late 1960s, the "Nifty Fifty" were 50 large, high-quality US blue chips such as General Electric and Polaroid, rated at up to 100 times earnings. Researchers Vitali Kalesnik and Engin Kose[1] describe them as spurring "a shift from value investing to a 'growth at any price' paradigm." It didn't end well. When the S&P 500 fell 39% in 1973-74, the Nifty Fifty fell 47%. It took a decade for their investors to recoup their losses, and they never caught up with the wider market.

In The Moneyball of Quality Investing, the same researchers put it neatly: "Just as hiring great ballplayers at rocket-high salaries may be bad business decisions, buying quality stocks at high prices are likely to be bad investment decisions."

Where Falling Stars go next

Not every Falling Star keeps falling. From here a share takes one of two paths.

Back up: the momentum returns. Games Workshop spent fourteen months as a Falling Star in 2021 and 2022. Its quality never faltered, and when the momentum came back it returned to being a High Flyer and carried on compounding. Diploma, the case study in the High Flyers article, had a single Falling Star month in 2022 and did the same.

Further down: the price keeps sliding. After its Falling Star spell, Boohoo drifted to Neutral and then spent nine month-ends as a Contrarian, cheap at last and still good quality on paper, while the price kept falling.

The Style tells you the momentum has gone. It cannot tell you whether it will come back.

What to do with a Falling Star

Every StockReport shows the StockRank Style at the top, and the Stock Screener can filter for Falling Stars, which is a quick way to check whether any of your holdings have turned. If one has:

  • Treat it as a prompt to re-examine, not a reflex to sell. Ask whether the business has slowed or only the share price has. Games Workshop and Diploma were the second kind. It's the same question every Compounding Quality investor has to answer about a long-term holding.

  • Watch the news for the turn. Richard Driehaus, the "buy high, sell higher" investor from the High Flyers article, would never buy a share while it was falling. What he did watch for was the moment a company with a record of earnings growth surprised the market. That is the signal to look for in a Falling Star. In the UK it often arrives as a trading update that is ahead of expectations, and because the Momentum Rank only moves once the price and analysts' forecasts respond, the news can be a leading indicator that a share is heading back to High Flyer status. Our Ahead of Expectations research shows how these updates drive share price momentum.

  • Or wait for the price. If the good news doesn't come, the other route back is valuation. A falling price can eventually offer growth at a reasonable price, on a lower PEG ratio.

  • Remember the opportunity cost. As a group, Falling Stars have gone nowhere while the market rose. Waiting for a recovery means missing the shares that are rising now.

The rule for the whole series applies: never buy a share with fewer than two strong factors. A Falling Star has one.


Related Content

The No-Admin Portfolio System: A Deep Dive Into Systematic Investing
How to build an investing advantage with the StockRanks
The StockRanks Jump Effect
How to use the StockRank Styles
Get the free newsletter