18
Archived articleThis is an archived article from 2013 - please note that any content within the article may be out of date.

Small Cap Value Report (18 Nov) - VLK, SNTY, FWEB, DQE

Good morning. Regulars here will know that I've been keen on Vislink (LON:VLK) since the Spring, based on a sensible turnaround strategy under new management, a series of positive trading statements, broker upgrades, and a strong Balance Sheet with net cash, and the icing on the cake being a helpful dividend yield too. So from my perspective, this share pretty much defined GARP (growth at reasonable price) when I originally bought in around the 30p level earlier this year. So you might think that with the shares 60% higher now (currently 48p) that they are fully priced? Actually, I don't think they are - because, as is often the case with improving performance, the broker forecasts seem too cautious, lagging behind the company's recovery.

In this case, Vislink has repeatedly stated its target of achieving £80m turnover and £8m operating profit by the end of calendar 2014. There has been slight confusion over whether that means for that financial year, or to have reached an annualised run rate of those levels by Dec 2014. I asked this question directly of management at a meeting myself & other investors had with them earlier this year, and they rather confusingly said that they had used the two terms interchangeably in previous announcements. So I was left somewhat unsure, but they seemed to be saying that the £80m turnover & £8m profit target was for the year-ended 31 Dec 2014.

That target is once again reiterated today, and they say will be achieved by a mixture of organic growth and further bolt-on acquisitions. The company spends a high proportion of turnover on R&D, so that is a big plus (since that tends to drive better performance). Also, it has net cash available for smallish acquisitions, and management with a track record of making large numbers of acquisitions in previous roles - which should lead to the right decisions being made here.

The key paragraph in their IMS this morning says, reassuringly;

 

Since the half year results overall trading has been in line with our expectations and although our order book visibility remains limited, we remain on track to meet the Board's expectations for the full year.

 

The limited visibility comment is just the nature of the business unfortunately. Vislink are trying to build recurring revenue streams, and that is a priority for companies that they acquire, to improve visibility - although easier said than done.

So, overall the broker consensus forecast for 2014 looks far too low to me. It's showing as 3.9p on Stockopedia, which is only £4.4m net profit, and here we are with a trading statement reiterating their target of £8m operating profit (and since there is no debt, that should be the same as profit before tax).

If we take their £8m profit target, and take off say £2m for tax, then that's £6m earnings. Divide by 113.9m shares, and I make that 2014 target EPS of just under 5.3p. Therefore, showing such decent growth would justify a PER of 15 or more, so we're then looking at a realistic share price target of 80p+. I'm not saying it will jump up to that level instantly, but that's the sort of ballpark I've got in mind for the next year, which implies upside of about 67% from the current share price.

It's difficult to find value at the moment, but this seems to me a fairly clear case of a share where, providing things remain on track, then there's decent upside in the next year, without making any racy assumptions over what management have already indicated they think they can achieve.

There can always be bumps in the road, so nothing is guaranteed, but overall I like the products (which are world leaders in high performance video cameras, with c.20% market share), the strategy, and sound finances. Therefore I'm happy to continue holding for the foreseeable future after this morning's positive IMS.

 

 

 

There is an interesting announcement from Synety (LON:SNTY) - this one should come with a particular wealth warning that it is a highly speculative micro cap with negligible historic performance - just tiny turnover & losses. However, in a bull market I am prepared to look at more speculative stocks - on the basis that I'll top slice into strength to get my original stake money back a.s.a.p., and then run the remainder for free.

With this particular company I think they're really onto something, and it could be an exciting roll-out of cloud-based telephony which integrates with all the main CRM software packages. What this means is that customers of e.g. Salesforce, can buy Synety's cloud based telephony as an add-on for their existing Salesforce system, and it then integrates all telephone calls to & from each customer into their CRM software. That removes the need for expensive telephony hardware (ideal for SMEs), as it's all cloud-based, and also means the cost of the phone calls is lower. So if sales take off, then we could be onto a multi-bagger here. If sales don't take off, then the company will just come back for repeated fundraisings, and the share price will collapse. So just to reiterate, this one is very high risk. They have enough cash for about the next year, after a recent fundraising, so in my opinion it's good enough for me to have a small punt on, which I have.

Their announcement this morning concerns the granting of a USA telecoms licence, and this sentence caught my eye in particular;

 

Gaining our US telco licence is the first step in what is an enormous and very exciting opportunity for Synety. Initially, we will be proceeding cautiously whilst we evaluate this market in greater depth.

 

I don't know anything about management at Synety, i.e. whether they are given to hyperbole or not?! Although it strikes me that if you have an enormous and very exciting opportunity, the last thing you should do is proceed cautiously! You should surely absolutely go for it?!

Anyway, hopefully I've plastered this with enough wealth warnings to put off everyone other than people who understand that this share is a real punt. Very interesting product & business model though.

 

 

 

 

Just a quick reminder that it's the monthly "Mello" investor evening in Beckenham tonight, so if you would like to come along then please follow this link to book yourself in with the organiser, David Stredder.

 

 

 

 

Shares in Fiberweb (FWEB) have de-Listed today, as the opportunistic lowball bid from PGI has gone through. This was a pity, as in my view these shares had considerably more upside in an economic recovery, so I held onto them in the hope of a higher competing bid. None came through unfortunately.

Although it was another success for us to chalk up here, as I covered the share in detail on 2 Aug 2013 in my morning report here, and concluded that at 75.5p: "Overall then, as you've probably gathered, I think this looks an attractively-priced share with good value characteristics, of a healthy dividend yield, reasonable PER, and a strong Balance Sheet." Therefore an exit at 102p a few months later, plus a 1.2p dividend along the way, is not a bad outcome!

So it just shows that you don't have to chase after highly speculative tech stocks to get decent returns. Boring companies at low valuations can also provide some excitement too, and they tend to be much lower risk too, providing you spend a bit of time doing that all-important Balance Sheet review to screen out the high risk situations.

 

 

 

 

As regulars will know, I never buy any Chinese or Indian stocks quoted on AIM, and in fact hardly ever buy any overseas companies Listed on AIM - for the simple reason that as Mark Slater says, "there's usually something wrong with them". Why else would relatively small companies from the other side of the world come to a virtually unregulated, anything-goes market like AIM?

I think investors are now wising up to how awful a lot of these companies really are, and I strongly suspect there is likely to be a mass exodus of these companies, as one by one they realise that the game is up, their credibility is zero, and therefore the £150k p.a. UK Listing costs are not worth it. So it's a complete minefield, where risk/reward is terrible, hence why I don't go near these overseas companies on AIM. The only exceptions would be profitable companies consistently paying dividends, with a good track record (say 3 years minimum).

After all, if the plan was to extract money from the UK, then that process going into reverse is not going to appeal is it?!!

I've had a look at interim results issued today from Indian film & animation company, DQ Entertainment (LON:DQE) and I really can't make head nor tail of them. They follow a similar pattern to a lot of Chinese companies - i.e. huge reported profits on the P&L, but instead of turning into cash, the relevant debits just pile up on the Balance Sheet in debtors & intangible assets.

So there's really no way of knowing whether these assets are real or not. Debtors is INR 2,682m. That compares with turnover of INR 2,294m for the previous year! So debtors is around 14 months sales, which is just crazy! In the UK, 2 months is normal, and 3 months I can just about live with, but 14 months is stretched to a point where you really cannot believe the figures at all.

Intangible assets, and intangible assets under construction have both shot up, as have bank borrowings too. I'm just at a complete loss as to how to value this company. Overall, I would say that nil is probably the safest valuation to put on it. If you want to go above a nil valuation for the company, then I would suggest a detailed audit of their assets would be needed, with sight of all documentation, and third party confirmation of the assets, and their valuations being reasonable. Also, I'd want to know exactly what the Directors backgrounds & previous performance has been. To a certain extent we take that for granted when investing in UK companies, as it's so easy to find out if people have a chequered history. But with overseas companies, investors haven't got a clue who they are backing. So why take the risk? It seems to me that hiring private investigators in the local country would be money well spent for groups of people with large shareholdings in overseas companies on AIM, to get to the bottom of whether the figures are real or not.

Cash is king, but even then you have to be suspicious - why is it that so many Chinese companies with apparently huge cash balances don't pay any dividends? What's the point in holding a piece of paper which purports to tell you that you own a share of some assets abroad, if you don't have any control over those assets, and never receive any income from them? All too often the future cashflow from these shares will be zero, hence the only rational value to put on the share is also zero. I'm sure there are some good companies overseas Listed on AIM, but there are enough ones that smell really bad, to make it worth being highly sceptical about the whole lot, in my opinion. After all, why take the risk if you don't have to?

As always, everything is up for debate here, so please feel free to throw in your views too, in the comments section below, especially if you think I'm wrong about overseas stocks on AIM - a lively (but courteous) debate is encouraged here, and I'm always interested in what readers think too - we usually come to better decisions if we consider both the bull and bear cases. Indeed, I find it is essential to think of both the upside and downside cases, in order to properly weigh up the risk inherent in any investment.

 

 

 

 

That's it for today. I shall be back home by tomorrow morning, after spending a few days in London, so will be back to working on my home PC, hence will be able to easily put graphics & charts into my reports from tomorrow, as usual.

Regards, Paul.

(Paul has long positions in VLK & SNTY.

A Small Caps Fund to which Paul provides research, also has a long position in VLK)

Disclaimer

This is not financial advice. Our content is intended to be used and must be used for information and education purposes only. Please read our disclaimer and terms and conditions to understand our obligations.

13 comments


Avatar for Richard Goodwin

I've always liked the story associated with Lifeline Scientific but apart from any valuation issues I've never had the courage to buy because of the low volumes and overseas company issue which you have outlined.

0
Avatar for Richard Goodwin

Would you put HCM into the same category Paul? It is largely speculative anyway but I've always taken comfort from the associate with Hutchison

0
Avatar for Ramridge

Re. Chinese companies. Generally speaking I agree with Paul's sentiment and caution. Last December I bought into Camkids with a view to a long term holding. A month later I chickened out taking a small profit. On the face of it, CAMK looks fantastic: PE = 2.9, Div yld = 6.3%, ROCE = 47%, ops margin = 29%, and a cash pile over 40% of market value. Enough to make a competitive UK retailer salivate with envy. But, but... it is a chinese operation registered in Jersey, trading in the loosely controlled AIM market. It fails my "I'd like to sleep soundly" test. So on balance I got out.

1
Avatar for nevilleaustin

I totally agree with Ramridge.
I bought 10k of NBU not long ago, that same night I just could not sleep. The following morning I sold half my holding and I then slept a bit better. A week later I sold the rest, amazing result, I slept like a log.
These Chinese stocks may have a PE of 1 and cash etc, but they keep you awake at night for two reasons -

1. They are Chinese
2. The figures are too good to be true

Anyway, I am looking forward to Mello tonight.

Neville

4
Avatar for john bradney

good morning Paul

whilst i agree with you about indian and chinese stocks in general i am intrigued by NBU.
they pay a dividend, seem to have cash in hand, debtors seem reasonable, rates highly.
what am i missing ?

john

0
Avatar for madmix

Re: VLK.  It's worth comparing today's IMS with the Interim Results at the end of August, which were well received.

I'll pick out a couple of sections :

Interims : "Economic conditions in our core markets of the US and the UK and Europe remained challenging and we continued to witness relatively long decision making cycles. Nevertheless, against a background of a low opening order book, due to a relatively low order intake in Q4 FY12, we have achieved good levels of business in these regions."

Today's IMS : "Economic conditions in our core markets of the US, UK and Europe remain challenging, however the Group has a well-established international sales force, a strong brand and market-leading products and this has enabled us to secure key business opportunities."


Interims : "Whilst the Group continues to operate against a background of a challenging economic environment and continued limited order visibility, it is confident that it is successfully executing against its medium term plans that will enable it to deliver its strategic targets."

Today's IMS : "Since the half year results overall trading has been in line with our expectations and although our order book visibility remains limited, we remain on track to meet the Board's expectations for the full year.


So the tone remains unchanged. I've topped up at 45p.

4
Avatar for Brokertobroker

Shareholders and brokers like a 3 year plan. It provides easy valuation and a useful gauge to judge the management's success. I'm a fan of VLK, but I was disappointed that it did not display the revenue and orders received figure for the 9 months (like in previous announcements). What's to hide if it is on track? Question is, how much are they relying on acquisitive growth?

Word on Volex: If the new management can bring the group to anywhere near historic levels of profitability the upside is 200p+. I believe the new management will, and sub 100p for a two year hold is very attractive. An interesting turn-around story.....

1
Avatar for Paul Scott

Hi Brokertobroker,

I agree - and wish more companies would set out a clear 3-5 year plan, with financial targets, for the reasons you mention. Although it's unusual practice in the UK, and seems to have caused confusion & uncertainty in the case of Vislink (LON:VLK) - i.e. investors seem to be fretting over whether they will hit target or not, whilst ignoring the fact that even if they come anywhere near, it will represent a huge improvement in performance over historic levels!
Anyway, I've used the dip this morning as an opportunity to top up on VLK.

As regards Volex (LON:VLX), I suspected that the company might have another profit warning in it, but wasn't too concerned about that because its net debt was minimal, and there was a good dividend yield. So my plan was to ride out any further downturn.

However, the results last week were unsatisfactory from my point of view - because net debt has risen so sharply, that I now see debt as a serious threat to the group, where it wasn't before. They say this was part of a strategy to extract keener prices from suppliers by paying faster, but it also makes the shares much higher risk. The dividend was also withdrawn, which pulled another leg of support away. So reluctantly, I decided to throw in the towel on this one. It might well pull off the turnaround strategy, but the outlook statement sounded very uncertain to me - so rather than having confidence in a turnaround, it seems to be more on a wing & a prayer now.
If the facts change, such that risk/reward shifts negatively by a considerable amount, then for me that makes the shares an easy sell. It wasn't really something I agonised over at all, the facts & figures made it clear that, for me, the investing case was no longer strong enough to hold Volex. Good luck to people who remain holders though, but for me risk/reward is no longer attractive there.
I've kept a few personally, but have sold the bulk of them.

Regards, Paul.

5
Avatar for Roger Lawson

Just taken a quick look at Synety. One reason I would not invest in this company is because they did a placing in August to selected institutions at 150p when the day before the share price was 230 - and had been even higher a few days before. As this company seems to be consuming cash at a fair rate, any private investor is taking a big risk of being prejudiced by further placings.
Roger Lawson, ShareSoc

2
Avatar for Paul Scott

Hi Roger,

Good points, and a useful additional wealth warning to add to the copious warnings in my original article piece about Synety (LON:SNTY).

A good example of where this type of high promise, but cash burning company went wrong, was 2Ergo (LON:RGO). I blasted them here for doing a Placing at 10p when the shares were (from memory 42p), but as readers pointed out at the time, they can only get Placings away for whatever price investors are prepared to stump up fresh cash.

So my view is that you have have to treat such blue sky, micro caps as being almost binary bets. I monitor them closely for evidence of the product taking off, and there being sufficient cash remaining. If the newsflow is inadequate, and the projected cash remaining is small, then it's best to just get the hell out of the shares, well before the next cash call - which is likely to be at a steep discount the more desperate they get.

So I escaped from RGO without too severe a loss, I cannot remember the amount, but it was about a 30-50% loss on a small position, from memory. The key thing is not to fall in love with the story & keep averaging down on something that just is not fundamentally going to work.

Also, try out the products! I did that with RGO, and found their App was absolutely terrific, but the trouble was, they had hardly any retailers signed up for it (and I tried it in central London, and the nearest restaurant was about 2 miles away!!). It then dawned on me that they would need a massive marketing spend to get anywhere, and that's what convinced me to sell the shares.

The thing I like about SNTY's model is that they can sell it as an Add-On through existing major CRM software companies. It's a complete no-brainer for the customers, as it has such a rapid payback period. So it's now purely a question of whether they can ramp up sales fast enough to excite investors & have them knocking on the door to buy stock in the next Placing (maybe even at a premium to the share price), or if sales disappoint then the next Placing will be essentially an emergency fundraising at potentially a much lower share price.

So undoubtedly very high risk.

regards, PAul.

0
Avatar for cig

Synety (LON:SNTY) fails the ten minutes google research test for me: world + dog is doing VOIP integration of CRM software, and they're apparently nowhere to be seen when you google "salesforce voip" or browse the salesforce app store, where you can find numerous competitors.

4
Avatar for shanklin100

Hi Paul

Other than VLK incessantly repeating their goal for two years out, can you see any evidence that they are likely to achieve it?

The sentence you highlight seems more likely a warning of a potential warning than a positive statement, but then, as I don't hold VLK, I may be biased to the downside... ...I just have never achieved enough confidence that their stated goal is anything other than hot air.

Best wishes, and well done so far with VLK. I will continue to watch.

Martin

0
Avatar for Paul Scott

Hi Martin,

Well if they keep repeating a target which turns out to be hot air, then management would have zero credibility & would have to resign. So I don't think that is likely at all - why would anybody set an unrealistic target for themselves?

They've always been very open about the fact that their £80m/£8m target would require additional acquisitions, but bear in mind that the last acquisition they did seems to have generated a very high level of EBITDA already - there's something in the most recent Edison note about that, I seem to recall - and management keep reiterating that they think they can achieve it. So unless there is any information or figures which disprove their chance of achieving target, then I would be inclined to think in terms of them hitting target, or at least getting reasonably close.

It looks as if the limited visibility comment has spooked a few people this morning, with the shares currently down 3%, but that's just the nature of the business - they don't have a lot of visibility on the order book. Although putting in a comment like that will always spook some people, who will think that it's leaving the door ajar to a profit warning later. Although with only about 7 weeks to go in the current financial year, they should pretty much know where they stand for the full year.

There's a lot of VERY short term money in small caps at the moment, so people look for any opportunity to bank profits. But to my mind the message from VLK is perfectly clear - that calendar 2013 should be in line with market expectations, and their ambitious target for 2014 is reiterated.

All open to interpretation of course, that's what makes a market!

I would add that their last interims were pretty good - adjusted EPS doubled from 0.9p to 1.8p. So that's a bit more than "hot air"!

Regards, Paul.

2
Get the free newsletter