The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
By Jeffrey Goldfarb
NEW YORK, April 20 (Reuters Breakingviews) - As any construction foreman knows, it's easy to get confused reading blueprints. The latest deal sketched out by billionaire Brad Jacobs for his QXO QXO.N building-products empire is similarly tricky to understand. Although there's clear logic for adding insulation company TopBuild BLD.N to the existing roofing business, a $17 billion price tag, including debt, seems to stretch the expansion budget.
Jacobs brings plenty of experience in merger architecture. His previous roll-ups in equipment rental and logistics generated impressive returns. He is now aiming to do the same for supplying residential, commercial and industrial contractors with materials such as shingles and lumber, with a goal of $50 billion in revenue and $7.5 billion of EBITDA over the next decade.
TopBuild provides a big boost. In addition to the chunky top line and earnings it's buying, QXO expects to reap $300 million from cost savings and cross-selling opportunities by 2030. Once taxed and capitalized, they're worth about $2.4 billion today. The 23% premium QXO is paying, however, will cost more, at $2.7 billion. It is also sharing some of the synergy spoils with TopBuild investors, who are set to own almost a fifth of the combined company if, as planned, they take 55% of their consideration in stock.
Other standard M&A measurements also look off. TopBuild is projected to deliver $820 million of operating profit next year, based on forecasts gathered by LSEG. Add it to the synergies, tax the sum and divide by the deal's enterprise value, and the implied return on capital is only about 5%.
It's possible that QXO is underselling the upside. TopBuild is light on assets, devoting only about 1% of revenue to capital expenditure. Its 18% EBITDA margin, adjusted to incorporate the full impact of acquisitions, is 10 percentage points higher than QXO's, and its after-tax return on invested capital also exceeded 15% last year, according to Visible Alpha. These are promising signs for additional operating leverage as Jacobs continues his shopping spree.
TopBuild shares took a dive in February, however, falling nearly 40% by the end of the following month. With the path of interest rates and the broader economy unclear, QXO's mega-project is occurring at a shaky time for homebuilder sentiment. To keep backing it, investors will have to put more faith in the designer than the model alone warrants. It's a big ask in an industry where estimates so often come up short.
Follow Jeffrey Goldfarb on X and Linkedin.
CONTEXT NEWS
QXO said on April 19 that it had agreed to buy insulation company TopBuild for about $17 billion to expand the building-products distribution conglomerate that it is assembling through acquisitions.
Under the terms of the deal, QXO will pay $505 in cash or 20.2 QXO shares for every TopBuild share, a 23% premium to where they closed on April 17. The cash component is capped at 45% of the purchase price, but the stock component can exceed 55%, depending on which form of payment TopBuild shareholders choose.
QXO expects to generate $300 million of synergies by 2030, including revenue uplifts from cross-selling. It also said it intends to borrow $6 billion to fund the deal.
Morgan Stanley, Barclays and Wells Fargo are advising QXO while Goldman Sachs and RBC Capital Markets are advising TopBuild.
QXO shares were down over 8% to $22.99 at 1030 EDT.
TopBuild's stock hit a ceiling this year https://www.reuters.com/graphics/BRV-BRV/byvrneyqyve/chart.png
(Editing by Jonathan Guilford; Production by Pranav Kiran)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can click on GOLDFARB/jeffrey.goldfarb@thomsonreuters.com))