The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
By Hudson Lockett
HONG KONG, March 2 (Reuters Breakingviews) - The sign of a good compromise is that nobody gets exactly what they want. Case in point: Toyota group insiders on Monday agreed to increase their buyout offer for Toyota Industries 6201.T, valuing it at a less egregious $40 billion. Activist Elliott Investment Management then agreed to tender shares for less than it probably could have squeezed out of the buyers if push came to shove in court. Yet the agreement is nonetheless an inflection point in Japan’s push to raise returns for investors and streamline the country’s corporate behemoths.
Had the bidding consortium of Toyota Motor 7203.T, its Chair Akio Toyoda, and group real estate firm Toyota Fudosan launched the buyout a few years ago, it might have sailed through – despite their initial offer of 16,300 yen per share undervaluing the listed forklift maker by as much as 38%, Breakingviews calculated.
But investors in Japan Inc are growing increasingly accustomed to, and comfortable with, Western-style pushy shareholders. That worked in Elliott's favour. Having revealed in November a roughly 3% stake in the target, it has helped to force the consortium to up its bid not once, but twice.
Now the activist has agreed to cash out at 20,600 yen per share. That's still well below the fair value estimate of 26,134 yen it previously floated for Industries. But while the deal won’t tick every box on both sides, there is still much to recommend it.
First, it diverts more of the juice from the bidders to minority shareholders, few of whom, to their credit, caved under pressure to tender shares to Toyota insiders, even after they raised their offer in January to account for a recent rally in group shares held by the target. Nor do other investors have to worry about Elliott, which now holds a 7.1% stake, challenging Toyota over valuation in court.
Agreeing to go along with the consortium’s offer also marks Elliott out as a foreign activist that prioritises the possible over the perfect, distancing it from earlier generations of barbarians at Japan’s gates who looked willing to tear the whole castle down in pursuit of full value. Instead, the U.S. firm led by Paul Singer has established an early track record of delivering real returns to fellow outsiders that positions it nicely for future campaigns.
Besides, the final price will still net a healthy return for Elliott, which built up a stake of 5% in Industries at about 16,650 yen per share, according to people familiar with the matter. The implied gain of about 24% on that chunk of shares might fall short of perfection, but it's also more than enough.
Follow Hudson Lockett on Bluesky and X.
CONTEXT NEWS
Toyota group insiders on March 2 said they would increase their tender offer for Toyota Industries for the second time, to 20,600 yen per share, up from 18,800 yen per share. It also extended by two weeks to March 16 the deadline for shareholders to accept the offer.
On the same day, Elliott Investment Management, which owns 7.1% of Toyota Industries and had since November led a campaign to push the bidders to increase the price, said it would accept the newly increased offer.
Toyota Industries shares rally despite insiders' refusal to raise offer further https://www.reuters.com/graphics/BRV-BRV/gdpzaybrwvw/chart.png
(Editing by Antony Currie; Production by Ujjaini Dutta)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can click on LOCKETT/ hudson.lockett@thomsonreuters.com))