Corrects quote regarding revised bid in first paragraph from “final price” to “no intention”. The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
By Hudson Lockett
HONG KONG, Feb 6 (Reuters Breakingviews) - The battle lines have been drawn. Toyota Motor 7203.T, its Chair Akio Toyoda and the family's unlisted firm Toyota Fudosan insist they have “no intention” of raising their revised bid of 5.65 trillion yen ($36 billion) to take Toyota Industries private.
That's far too low, Breakingviews calculates, as does Paul Singer's Elliott Investment Management, which is lobbying other independent investors not to sell shares in the tender offer that closes on Thursday. Whatever happens in the next few days, though, this deal will stand as a lesson in how to conduct M&A badly.
If the buyer consortium wins, it - and by extension the Toyota brand - will be marked as shortchanging shareholders. At 18,800 yen-per-share, the new offer put on the table last month merely adjusted for the increase in Industries' holdings in other publicly traded Toyota companies and undervalues the target by 40%, Breakingviews calculates. The bidders have a big advantage in their push to obtain the 67% of shares necessary for a squeeze out: thanks to Toyota group holdings and those of allies, they have 50% already locked up.
But a win would not be the end of the affair. Elliott, which owns 7.1% of Industries, would probably take the new owners to court to have the price reappraised. Japanese judges are typically wary of ruling on matters of valuation, but in October 2024, Tokyo’s high court ruled in favour of activist Oasis Management that the fair value of FamilyMart shares was 13% higher than Itochu's 8001.T successful buyout offer. That case is still under appeal but will embolden shareholders to keep challenging lowball deals.
Comments published on Thursday by the Asian Corporate Governance Association would strengthen Elliott's case. It points out potential red flags in how Industries' board special committee conducted negotiations. It also estimates that the median price for Japanese tender offers launched since fair M&A guidelines were introduced in 2019 is 2.5 times book value; Breakingviews calculates Toyoda and team are dangling a ratio of just 0.9 times book.
Insiders can try to avoid court by meaningfully increasing the price. There's a good reason to do so: with the shares trading above the tender offer, index funds are unlikely to sell, and they hold around 19%. Add on Elliott's stake, and that's not far short of the 33.1% needed to block the deal. Bumping up the bid would help secure more support, but at the cost of a loss of face for the corporate titan.
The other possibility is that they don't raise the price, investors block the buyout and the Toyota trio walk away from the transaction. That would expose them as cynical opportunists only willing to strike a deal at the heavy expense of supine independent shareholders.
All these options would leave a taint on Toyota group. If nothing else, other Japanese corporations considering how to unwind cross-shareholdings may learn how not to do it from its example.
Follow Hudson Lockett on Bluesky and X.
CONTEXT NEWS
A consortium led by Toyota Motor said on February 2 that it has “no intention” of further raising its 5.65 trillion yen ($36 billion) offer to take Toyota Industries private before the tender offer period for the deal closes on February 12.
U.S. activist firm Elliott Investment Management, which has a 7.1% stake in the listed unit, argues insiders’ revised offer of 18,800 yen per share, up from 16,300 yen, still substantially undervalues the listed forklift maker.
Toyota Industries trades at a premium to insiders' take-private offer https://www.reuters.com/graphics/BRV-BRV/byvrbgozrve/chart.png
(Editing by Antony Currie; Production by Aditya Srivastav)
((For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can click on LOCKETT/ hudson.lockett@thomsonreuters.com))