Small Cap Value Report (Fri 5 Jan 2018) - G4M, CRAW

Friday, Jan 05 2018 by
72

Good morning!

Paul added further sections to yesterday 's report, which now includes:

It's available at this link.

Today, I'm going to start by covering £G4M (Gear4Music) and Crawshaw (LON:CRAW).

Regards,

Graham



£G4M (Gear4Music)

  • Share price: 740p (-4%)
  • No. of shares: 21 million
  • Market cap: £155 million

Trading update

This is a fast-growing online retailer of musical instruments, which is the UK's largest.

Not having purchased a musical instrument in many years, I've just been doing a little bit of googling to see who else is prominent when you search to buy musical instruments online.

It looks like the biggest player in Europe is Thomann (external link), a family-owned German business in Bavaria. It is several times larger than G4M, earning revenues of €525 million back in 2013, according to Wikipedia. By contrast, G4M is forecast to earn £81 million in revenue during the latest financial year.

It's a fragmented marketplace. According to an Edison research note, Thomann's market share in 2016 was 13%, making it by far the largest company in the sector.

So can G4M catch up? The growth rates are certainly encouraging. Today's trading update includes the following table:

5a4f5e8aa4095G4M_20180105.PNG

Christmas is a key buying period for G4M, making this an important update for the company's annual performance.

If I go back and compare this update versus the equivalent one from last year, growth rates last year were as follows: UK + 29%, International +129%, and total + 55%.

We can also compare against the growth rates in the interim results. In those results UK sales were +30%, International sales were +70%, and total sales were +44%. 

It's easier to grow from a smaller base, of course. But perhaps today's slight reduction in the share price reflects that…

Unlock this article instantly by logging into your account

Don’t have an account? Register for free and we’ll get out your way

Disclaimer:  

All my own views. I am not regulated by the FSA. No advice.

Do you like this Post?
Yes
No
72 thumbs up
0 thumbs down
Share this post with friends



Gear4music (Holdings) plc is engaged in the online retailing of musical instruments and equipment. The Company sells its own-brand musical instruments and music equipment alongside with other brands. The Company offers over 1,500 products, which are sold under approximately eight brands, including Gear4music; Archer, which offers string instruments, such as violins, cellos, violas and double bass; Redsub, which offers bass guitar amplifiers and pedals; SubZero, which offers guitars, amplifiers, mixers, speakers and audio electronics; Minster, which offers digital pianos; Rosedale, which offers woodwind instruments, such as clarinets, flutes, oboes and piccolos, and Brass Instruments, which offers trumpets, trombones, tubas and French horns. The Company has developed its own e-commerce platform, with multilingual, multicurrency and responsive design Websites covering approximately 19 countries. more »

LSE Price
565p
Change
 
Mkt Cap (£m)
118.3
P/E (fwd)
40.4
Yield (fwd)
n/a

Crawshaw Group Plc is a United Kingdom-based company, which operates a chain of meat-focused retail food stores. The Company has approximately 40 stores, which are located across Yorkshire, Lincolnshire Nottinghamshire, Derbyshire and the North West. The Company's product range is categorized into approximately two distinct areas, such as Traditional raw meat, and Hot and cold cooked food. Under the Traditional raw meat category, it offers various products sold either loose in a serve over counter for the traditional experience or as multi buy packs on supermarket style multi deck counters, which have all been cut and packaged in store. Under the Hot and cold cooked food category, it offers freshly prepared roast chickens, gammon and pork joints, hot roast sandwiches, shop cooked curries and casseroles, chicken and chips, as well as other traditional deli products. Its stores include Arndale Centre in Arndale; The Arcades in Ashton Under Lyne, and Fresh Meat Factory Shop in Astley. more »

LSE Price
2.75p
Change
 
Mkt Cap (£m)
3.1
P/E (fwd)
n/a
Yield (fwd)
n/a



  Is LON:G4M fundamentally strong or weak? Find out More »


41 Comments on this Article show/hide all

Julianh 5th Jan 22 of 41
2

Re: £G4M
There was some interesting comments on the Matylda I read the news today oh boy thread this morning. The one that most worried me about G4M was the suggestion that (at least some of) the same items are available at lower cost and with better delivery options from Amazon. So the question is what competitive Advantage £G4M can exert that would maintain their position and margins in the face of competition including the obvious competition from The Everything Store

| Link | Share | 1 reply
Graham Ford 5th Jan 23 of 41
11

Forgive me if I more or less repeat some of what I said on Matylda’s thread about £G4M.

Whether any of us on this thread would personally buy musical gear online is pretty much irrelevant as the company’s sales revenues clearly demonstrate there are plenty of people who will. I personally would never buy shoes online as I find it so hard to find shoes that fit but there are plenty of people that do. Boohoo’s business depends on there being plenty of people who will buy before they try. Our own purchasing preferences are a very poor indicator of whether or not a market exists for an alternative.

Some specific products are cheaper on Amazon. Well that may be true but G4M are growing the business at a rapid rate regardless.

So for me it’s all about whether or not the growth will be profitable in the longer term to support the share price. I think we need to wait for the next set of results to get visibility on that. So I will continue to hold a small amount.

| Link | Share
herbie47 5th Jan 24 of 41
2

In reply to post #293373

Swings and roundabouts, some items on Amazon when I have checked have been much more expensive, I'm not talking just about audio gear. You can't get everything cheaper from the same place I have found you have to shop around. Their delivery service is not very good, if you have the free option it can take along time to arrive and you don't when it will turn or not. Last item I ordered never arrived, had to get them to resend it, so it took about 3 weeks. Time before that they sent the wrong product. I have used G4M once and the service was very good and it was no more expensive than anywhere else. I misunderstood G4M as first, thought it was just another low margin pro audio store but it seems much of their sales are from instruments, there is a large EU competitor Thomanns but seems to be a slightly different market, G4M sales are growing rapidly in Europe so they must be doing something to attract customers. Amazon are not so popular in some countries. Anyway I'm not a holder at the moment I sold out a few weeks ago.

| Link | Share
Nick Ray 5th Jan 25 of 41
5

The guitar that Matylda found "on Amazon" was actually in the Amazon Marketplace. It was not sold by or fulfilled by Amazon, but a tiny company based in Wembley. Every other vendor selling the same guitar on Amazon was charging about the same as G4M.

If the tiny company can undercut the rest by 10% good luck to them but I don't think they represent much of a threat to G4M's revenues just yet.

| Link | Share
sharmvr 5th Jan 26 of 41

In reply to post #293123

Thanks Graham - great analysis and very helpful.
Thanks for posting the link and the analysis (today and from December) and all other days - much appreciated

| Link | Share
gus 1065 5th Jan 27 of 41
3

As a user of and shareholder in £G4M I think they have the potential to grow into a role as Wiggle is to cycling for musical instruments/consumables, i.e. a trusted specialist “go to” vendor with a catholic mix of decent quality own brand product together with specialist names at competitive if not necessarily the best price matched to a reliable and timely delivery service.

Having shopped around for cycling gear over the years I’ve tried other online vendors with varying levels of satisfaction and now rarely bother shopping around. Nowadays, if I want/need something online (I still use my local bike shop for specialist service or kit) I use Wiggle in the knowledge that they value their brand name and are unlikely to get greedy on margins for short term gain. Amazon is great for a lot of “commodity” stuff where price is sine qua non but I think that music and bike supplies offer space for a quality specialist. I think G4M have the opportunity to grow into this role.

Gus.

| Link | Share | 1 reply
leoleo73 5th Jan 28 of 41
2

I don't hold £G4M because I see them as a musical AO World (LON:AO.) - an overpriced niche online retailer than makes low margins and ultimately fails to compete with Amazon. The comparison with Wiggle is a very good one - they are in a very similar situation as evidenced by two consecutive years of losses in a mature market: https://www.retail-week.com/sectors/sports-and-leisure/wiggle-losses-widen-despite-climbing-sales/7026367.article?authent=1

What I hadn't realised until today was just how expensive G4M are and how bad their cashflow is. I tried to short them today, but no stock was available.

Musical equipment is clearly a growth area though and I do hold Focusrite (LON:TUNE) because they are much cheaper (though not cheap), are growing too, have good quality characteristics (margin, cashflow) and, perhaps most importantly, actually do something that adds value.

| Link | Share | 1 reply
millen 5th Jan 29 of 41

In reply to post #293528

Interestingly, Gus, the analogy of £G4M to cycling suppliers had also struck me. I suspect musicians are similar to cyclists in making occasional big purchases (eg new bike or wheelset every 2-3 years) but spend a somewhat smaller annual amount on many components, consumables, upgrades. I respect your loyalty to Wiggle but to be honest I haven't used them for many months. I've found Merlin, Chain Reaction, Ribble, Tredz, Planet X etc etc all to be highly reliable and often a few % cheaper for most components especially around sale season. I think most in my club 'shop around', perhaps not as avidly as me. Evidently the far larger (?) cycling market can support several online distributors with strong competition and, presumably, low margins.

So one of my concerns over £G4M is whether they can corner a large proportion of the market in their various sales territories or whether competition will emerge to eat into their sales and margins. If there is competition they will need to develop a strong USP to maintain brand loyalty, perhaps in the way that Focusrite (LON:TUNE) seems to have achieved in digital music devices, albeit a more pro-oriented market. Or it may be that the market is sufficiently niche that other online specialists don't consider it worth attacking, seeing a bigger cake elsewhere. Another example might be the recently-floating fishing tackle chain (sorry, forgotten its name) thought that struck me as a weaker proposition as barriers to entry appear even lower. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.

| Link | Share | 2 replies
lavinit 5th Jan 30 of 41
1

In reply to post #293258

Hi muckshifter

I am interested in your comments on Keller (LON:KLR). Partly as the damage in contractors took me to Babcock International (LON:BAB) just as it got kicked out of the FT100. Different business focus of course but the same sh1tty stick seems to be tarring them in that investors are spooked around accounting for these long and/or sometimes complex contracts and/or joint projects.

Anyway, all I've done is look at the Stocko info on Keller (LON:KLR) at the moment (inc the accounts) and I see relatively significant debt issuance in last few years and negative FCF due to high capital investment. Does this relate to contracts in that they then need to provide the finance up front and then get paid at the back end or is something else going on?

Thank you

| Link | Share | 1 reply
leoleo73 5th Jan 31 of 41
1

In reply to post #293568

millen: Wiggle bought out Chain Reaction Cycles and operate it as a second brand. I agree with you that the other independents are generally cheaper than Wiggle and just as good.

| Link | Share
herbie47 5th Jan 32 of 41

In reply to post #293558

I'm sure Paul Scott won't agree about G4M being like AO World (LON:AO.) Looking on Trustpilot, G4M get 5 stars, Amazon only get 2 stars. I think a lot of pros will be inclined to use a specialist retailer rather than Amazon. A lot of Focusrite (LON:TUNE) products are sold by G4M.

| Link | Share
gus 1065 5th Jan 33 of 41

In reply to post #293568

Hi millen.

Thanks for your comments on the cycling/music parallel. I’ve used Chain Reaction and Ribble in the past with varying results - mostly pretty good. I should probably revisit in light of your comments.

One further thought on Wiggle is the decent loyalty scheme depending on cumulative historic spend. I think it’s something in the order of 12% for Platinum members which makes them (for me at least) very price competitive. Coupled with my general satisfaction with their dhb own brand kit (fine for day to day use), I’ve probably become their ideal “inert” repeat customer. I wonder if £G4M have/will have a similar feature.

FYI, I think the fishing tackle company you had in mind might be Fishing Republic (LON:FISH) . Similar “disruptive” model but issues with large levels of inventory/very slow stock turnover as I recall.

Gus.

| Link | Share
DJCP 5th Jan 34 of 41

In reply to post #293058

For information, G4M have some (nearly 1,400) items listed on Amazon.co.uk
https://www.amazon.co.uk/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=Gear4music&ajr=2

| Link | Share
millen 5th Jan 35 of 41
3

Thanks Gus and leoleo. I wasn't aware of Wiggle's loyalty scheme - I'll look into it. Tredz sends me occasional £10 vouchers and there were other discounts around Xmas. Just for fun I looked at Wiggle's accounts https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/02667809/filing-history I'm wary of reading too much into a private company's filed accounts but it's interesting to see they reported a small loss of -£4m on turnover of £205m, half of which was outside UK. So sales are 3x that of £G4M currently. I think this is after the CRC acquisition. Bridgepoint are a major investor so maybe they'll float one day.

My only real experience of (much smaller) niche on-line distributors was when my cousin set up a model aircraft distributor. Even though he had good distribution deals with premium brand manufacturers, got good traction with the magazine reviewers, and had a gross margin of 50% on many lines, the range of stock that had to be held (spares etc) was ridiculous - much of it became technologically obsolete and had to be flogged on the eBay shop at lower than cost. The whole business was also undermined by customers buying direct from China, under-declaring for customs etc.

Building a successful on-line distribution business is not in any sense easy. The product area ('niche') has to be chosen wisely to offer sustainable margins without attracting competition, profitable distribution agreements negotiated, marketing and social media campaigns developed, infrastructure put in place etc. I have a small holding in £G4M but am surprised at the current high market rating.

| Link | Share
Paul Scott 5th Jan 36 of 41
10

Hi,

I thought the update today from G4M was absolutely fine.

I agree that the valuation is high, but that's because the company is delivering stellar organic growth, across Europe, not just the UK. Plus it has global ambitions, so is developing websites, e.g. for the USA too. We've already seen that it is capable of operating successfully overseas, so it's really now just a roll-out globally. I think this will be a much, much bigger company in say 5-years' time, hence why the shares are attractive, even on this apparently high valuation.

As the company grows, then it achieves economies of scale, not just on purchasing, but also on the biggest overhead - marketing. We've seen with BooHoo how, once critical mass is achieved, then marketing spend becomes a smaller percentage of revenues. In the case of BooHoo, they have decided to recycle those gains into even more aggressive prices, thus driving continued strong growth. They could have instead accepted slower growth, and a higher profit margin.

G4M is also about backing a very entrepreneurial, focused, ambitious management team.

I think this share is fairly priced for now, so it might just flat-line for a while, who knows? It's not liquid enough to be able to move in & out quickly/easily, hence why personally I've banked some profits along the way in real life and in BMUS, and intend just running the balance for ever, or until the facts change for the worse.

With growth companies like this, conventional metrics such as PER and free cashflow are not terribly useful during the rapid growth phase. It's more a question of looking forwards say 5 years+, and seeing what the picture will be then, once margins have risen through economies of scale, etc.

So for me, this is a long-term tuck away and forget type of share, which I'm pretty confident about. For now though, the price looks up with events.

Regards, Paul.

| Link | Share
Laughton 6th Jan 37 of 41
3

For those who are interested in £G4M, here's a bit more reading available -

http://walbrockresearch.com/will-lack-future-profit-harms-gear4music-share-price/

Personally I was a little disappointed in the slight slacking off in growth and have sold nearly half my holding. I think the market still has some way to go but I'm trying to be careful and "in-line" isn't really good enough, especially in supposedly "high growth" distruptors.

| Link | Share | 1 reply
Orangetree 6th Jan 38 of 41

In reply to post #293738

Thanks for promoting my blog Laughton!

Blog: Walbrock Research
| Link | Share | 1 reply
VegPatch 8th Jan 39 of 41

In reply to post #293808

Hi Orangetree - are you Walter Hin from Walbrock?

I like much of your blog. Its good (although I am way more bullish on Provident Financial).

keep up the good work

VegPatch

| Link | Share
muckshifter 9th Jan 40 of 41

In reply to post #293578

Sorry lavinit, just spotted your response, and thanks for that, as I have a habit of posting about unfashionable shares and getting no response at all.

I’ve always read the KLR finance director’s report avidly over the couple of years and a few before I invested. The statistics here on the stock report page are a bit too abbreviated for me in the case of a complicated company like KLR. The actual cashflow details have been interesting if a little dissapointing recently, with lots of aquisitions, opening up of new areas, etc. complicating things, as well as one poorly timed (imho) major buy in Canada. But the thing which I believe has impeded progress most in the last few years has been lack of recovery from the GFC in Europe, and the extreme slow down in investment in commodity based companies, notably the Canadian tar sands.

So, what has kept me in KLR for the last couple of years, apart from a decent dividend, is a patient expectation that both these slowdown causes will abate, and that appears to be happening now.
The “icing on the cake” to me is that the last chance Trump has to survive (imho) might be a massive infrastructure push, where he has a slight chance of cross party support from the Democrats. Badly damaged infrastructure might well give KLR fantastic repair opportunities or ground improvement work to provide a better lifespan for the replacement. But I’m not holding my breath on the US prospects as I do not expect Trump to survive as president. For the best part of a year now I’ve been banging on about the prospect of clause 25 of the US Constitution being invoked to remove him, so I see it as a race between that and Mueller.
Regards.

| Link | Share | 1 reply
lavinit 9th Jan 41 of 41

In reply to post #295333

Thanks

| Link | Share

What's your view on this article? Log In to Comment Now

You can track all @StockoChat comments via Twitter

 Are LON:G4M's fundamentals sound as an investment? Find out More »



About Graham Neary

Graham Neary

Full-time investor and independent analyst. Prior to this, I spent seven years in the financial markets as an analyst and institutional fund manager. I'm CFA-qualified, also holding the Investment Management Certificate and the STA Diploma in Technical Analysis.Away from finance, my main interests are recreational poker and everything to do with China, especially Mandarin Chinese. more »

Follow



Stock Picking Tutorial Centre



Let’s get you setup so you get the most out of our service
Done, Let's add some stocks
Brilliant - You've created a folio! Now let's add some stocks to it.

  • Apple (AAPL)

  • Shell (RDSA)

  • Twitter (TWTR)

  • Volkswagon AG (VOK)

  • McDonalds (MCD)

  • Vodafone (VOD)

  • Barratt Homes (BDEV)

  • Microsoft (MSFT)

  • Tesco (TSCO)
Save and show me my analysis